Assimetria e coletivização - notas sobre chefes e caraíbas na política Kalapalo

8/2/2019 Assimetria e coletivizao - notas sobre chefes e carabas na poltica Kalapalo

1/26

!"#$%&'()*+)$"',(-."/'01.,.)/2,*.)%,*34+,'

!"#$%&%'()**+,#'"%'-#.+

/+0,%$+'()%$1)'"%'2)34+

56789:;8?$#+'@ABA

CONHECIMENTO

E CULTURA

!"#!$!%!&'()*%+!&,&,-%".(!

Livro Conhecimento e Cultura.indd 1 26/4/2011 12:20:42


2/26



3/26

!"#$%&'()*+)$"',(-."/'01.,.)/2,*.)%,*34+,'

CONHECIMENTO

E CULTURA



4/26

!"#$%&'(%#)"*%*&+,)+-./*0-1)'&.2*3%*)-.#24"-(.56"*#"(+#3"*'#378%#.*9*:3',%#%*!"44.&'*3%*;'(."+?."+?."`-%,"a.*A*BFOIQM

ME@LFEOLEE*B-.27,'.*Wb

%O(.',/*3.#c+#`@`-

R-"8-.(.*3%*R\2O]-.3+.56"*%(*C#)-"0","8'.*>"&'.,9^bRY

Y+.*]%#%-.,*!.-#%'-"*QGE*A*G"@*.#3.-

NE@EGEOFPE*!+-')'`.*A*RY

%O(.',/*008.2c+40-@`-

:3')"-./*C)$.,.'.*]-14'&.*%*:3')"-.

Y%S'26"/*;.72.*d"22'#

>%&-%).-'./*=.-'.#.*>"+?.*>',S.

R-"a%)"*]-14'&"*%*W'.8-.(.56"/*!.-).?*!-'.5e%2*%*R-"a%)"2*]-14'&"2

d'-.8%(/*FEEE*%f%(0,.-%2

:2).*0+`,'&.56"*4"'*4'#.#&'.3.*&"(*-%&+-2"2*3"*0-"a%)"*RYg!CW9!CR:>

:)#","8'.*'#378%#.*%*'#3'8%#'2("/*#"S"2*3%2.4'"2*)%\-'&"2*%*%(07-'&"2



5/26

!!"

#$%&'(')'(*%$+*%,-%.*$%./0%)*1*$%2,/%131/-%4'%5/63+*%.*%7(8*%9346,:%,-%

;*-)(/46,/%348/4$'-/48/%'583;,('.*%)*5%;'$'-/48*$:%;*-=5;3*%/%538,'3$%?;@A:%)*5%/


6/26

7$$3-/853'%/%;*(/83130'S+*

!JK

g$)/;3@3;'-/48/%/$8/$%/1/48*$%=%2,/%$+*%*$%@*;*$%.'$%5/('Sh/$%)';>@3;'$%@*5-'(3T

0'.'$%/485/%*$%'(8*T@3;*

&

%.'%5/63+*%?$*O5/8,.*%')\$%'%')5*


7/26

748o43*%L,/55/35*%b5A

!J!

5/63-/%./%)'0%2,/%13'O3(30'53'%'%;53'S+*%.*%_W9%?Q/4/0/$%B'$8*$%!""JRA%_*1*$%

O/(3;*$*$%2,/%4+*%)'583;3)'1'-%)(/4'-/48/%.*%;*-)(/1/(%./%'(./3'$:%@*3%8*-'4.*%)5*)*5Sh/$%2,/%8'(1/0%4,4;'%8/4G'%83.*%'48/$%.*%;*48'8*A$!%i,'4.*%'$%'(./3'$%/5'-%'34.'%-'3$%.3$8'4T

8/$:%'%15D+D)"5&5%4+*%6'5'483'%13'6/4$%(315/$%./%'8'2,/$%./%343-36*$:%*%./$(*;'T-/48*%/5'%(*46*%/%)/4*$*:%/%,-%i,'5,)%.3@3;3(-/48/%5/,43'%k%$/6,4.*%;*48'-%*$%&'(')'(*%k%-'3$%.*%2,/%.,'$%*,%85c$%'(./3'$%;*413.'.'$A%X*-%'%')5*83;*$:%@*8\65'@*$:%)/$2,3$'.*5/$%/%)/5$*4'(3.'./$%1'53'.'$:%2,/%4'2,/('%=)*;'%)'$$'5'-%'%.31,(6'5%,-'%3-'6/-%.*%_W9%3483-'-/48/%(36'.'%n%3-'6/-%.*$%)*1*$%.*%7(8*%9346,%?./3


8/26

7$$3-/853'%/%;*(/83130'S+*

!JJ

*$%/$)>538*$%8/53'-%(G/%)/.3.*%/-%$*4G*%2,/%@30/$$/-%,-'%G*-/4'6/-%'%r*O/58*%

Q'534G*%?@'(/;3.*%/-%JKKDR:%'*%2,/%*%'8,'(%;G/@/%N'-'s,5U:%&*8\N3:%/%*%];';32,/%6/5'(%.*%9346,^$#:%7538'4'%t'p'(')>83:%';/./5'-:%'@35-'4.*%2,/%'%r/./%L(*O*%G'13'%$3.*%@,4.'-/48'(%)'5'%2,/%*$%>4.3*$%.*%9346,%),./$$/-%$/5%4';3*4'(%/%34T8/54';3*4'(-/48/%;*4G/;3.*$%?F,4'3%JKKZRA%F*3%,-'%*;'$3+*%-'5;'.'%)/('%)5/T?F,4'3%JKKZRA%F*3%,-'%*;'$3+*%-'5;'.'%)/('%)5/TA%F*3%,-'%*;'$3+*%-'5;'.'%)/('%)5/T$/4S'%./%34f-/5'$%',8*53.'./$:%./485/%/('$%*%/48+*%Q343$85*%.'%b,$83S'%QU5;3*%mG*-'0%B'$8*$:%2,/%@35-*,%;*-)5*-3$$*$%./%;**)/5'S+*%/485/%*%6*1/54*%e,('%/%*$%)*1*$%.*%7(8*%9346,:%'-)('-/48/%.31,(6'.*$%)/('%->.3'%?;@A:%)*5%/83;'%?538,'(R%34.>6/4'A

g$8/$%)5*;/$$*$%./%'85'S+*%.*$%O5'4;*$%)/(*$%538,'3$:%;53'4.*%-*-/48*$%./%4/6*;3'S+*%/%)*$$3O3(3.'./$%./%;*4$85,S+*%./%'(3'4S'$:%8c-%$3.*%,-'%3-)*58'48/%@*48/%./%5/;,5$*$%)'5'%*$%&'(')'(*A$%%_*5%-/3*%./%$/,$%;*413.'.*$%/(/$%*O8c-%)'6'-/48*$%/-%.34G/35*:%4/6*;3'-%)5/$/48/$%;'5*$%?jU%;*4$/6,35'-%,-%;'-3T4G+*:%.*3$%-*8*5/$%./%)*)':%6/5'.*5/$%/%)(';'$%$*('5/$:%)*5%/


9/26

748o43*%L,/55/35*%b5A

!JD

O538q43;'%/$8'5%@3(-'4.*%,-%-$53)'G+;@*H%.,5'48/%*%/1/48*:%'%G*-/4'6/-%4+*%

)o./%';*48/;/5A%g-%JKKC%*$%&'(')'(*%4+*%@30/5'-%4/4G,-%i,'5,):%/%/-%JKKH%*$%)('4*$%@*5'-%@5,$85'.*$%)*52,/%/(/$%4+*%;*4$/6,35'-%/485'5%/-%';*5.*%;*-%*$%348/5/$$'.*$%$*O5/%*$%)'6'-/48*$%/%'%;*-)5'%./%5/;,5$*$%)'5'%'%@/$8'%?)534;3T)'(-/48/%;*-O,$8>1/(%/%'(6*.+*%@3'.*RA

a*%@34'(%.'2,/(/%'4*:%)*5=-:%)'5/;3'%/$8'5%8,.*%'55'4j'.*%)'5'%2,/%'%G*T-/4'6/-%*;*55/$$/%/-%JKK":%.,5'48/%,-%i,'5,)%2,/%$/53'%5/'(30'.*%/-%*,85'%'(./3'%N'(')'(*%?'%-'3*5%./)*3$%./%73G'R%/-%G*-/4'6/-%'*%@'(/;3.*%4/8*%?'34.'%O/OcR%./%,-%.*$%;G/@/$%.'2,/('%'(./3'A$(%M'13'%-,38*$%5,-*5/$%$*O5/%/$8'%@/$8':%/%*$%&'(')'(*%/$8'1'-%-'5'13(G'.*$%;*-%'%2,'483.'./%./%)/$$*'$%3-)*58'48/$%2,/%)'583;3)'53'-%.*%/1/48*:%;*-%*%.34G/35*%/%*$%)5/$/48/$%2,/%5/;/O/53'-:%/%

;*-%'%@'-'%2,/%*%.*4*%.*%538,'(%6'4G'53'%/-%8*.*%*%7(8*%9346,A%Y/6,4.*%,-%N'(')'(*%2,/%;*-/48*,%*%'$$,48*%;*-36*:%]#$%&'(')'(*%1+*%@3;'5%-,38*%-'3$%@'-*$*$%.*%2,/%*$%t'p'(')>83:%1'3%8/5%-,38*%45);+5"'*-)656$;%2,/%4*%i,'5,)%.*%#5('4.*%V3(('$%B*'$A%#5('4.*%/5'%;';32,/%)/2,/4*:%/$8/%2,/%4\$%1'-*$%G*-/4'T6/'5%=%2,/%/5'%4.3*$% 4*%9346,%G'13'% $3.*%1/8'.'%)'5'%/138'5%,-'%)*$$>1/(%/)3./-3'%./%653)/%83)*%7:%;',$'.'%)/(*%1>5,$%M!a!A%X*48,.*:%'%)*$$3O3(3.'./%./%2,/%'%G*-/4'6/-%';*48/;/$$/%@/0%;*-%2,/%'%*56'430'S+*%./$8/%538,'(%$/%8*54'$$/%)'(;*%./%.3$),8'$%/41*(1/4.*%*$%;G/@/$%.'$%.,'$%-'3*T5/$%'(./3'$%N'(')'(*%/%*,85'%)/2,/4'%'(./3':%@,4.'.'%4'%135'.'%./%JKKC%)'5'%



10/26

7$$3-/853'%/%;*(/83130'S+*

!JZ

JKKHA%748/$%./%-'3$%4'.':%=%)5/;3$*%/48/4./5%*%;*48/83;*%.'%$/6,4.'%

-'3*5%'(./3'%N'(')'(*A%a'%=)*;':%/('%;*48'1'%;*-%.*3$%;G/@/$%)534;3)'3$:%/%*%])53-/35*%;';32,/^%?@*5-'%)/('%2,'(%*$%&'(')'(*%$/%5/@/5/-%'*%;G/@/%)534;3)'(%./%,-'%'(./3'R%*;,)'1'%8'-O=-%'%)*$3S+*%./%].*4*%.*%O5'4;*^%?!5#5)@5+*'*:%*%5/$)*4$U1/(%)*5%348/5-/.3'5%*%;*48'8*%k%'O*5.'5/3%/$8/%83)*%./%'6/48/%;*-%-'3$%./8'(G/$%'.3'48/R%/%134G'%$/4.*%;*4$8'48/-/48/%';,$'.*%./%$/%')5*)53'5%.*%.34G/35*%./$834'.*%)'5'%'%;*-,43.'./A%g(/%8'-O=-%jU%4+*%5/$3.3'%-'3$%/-%8/-)*%348/65'(%4'%'(./3'%;*-*%$/%/$)/5'%./%,-%;G/@/%3-)*58'48/:%/:%.*%)*48*%./%13$8'%./%'(6,-'$%)/$$*'$:%*%/;3*%.'%;G/@3'%85'.3;3*4'(%G'13'%$/%8*54'.*%3413U1/(%)'5'%/(/A

a/$$/%;*48/4.3;/%./%;G/@3'A%7)5/$/48'5T$/%;*-*%;G/@/T.*4*%./%$#)';A%=%;*(*;'5T$/%4*%(,6'5%.*$%;G/@/$%.*%)'$$'.*:%;,j'$%5/('Sh/$%5/;,'-%'*%)'$$'.*%->83;*A%a*$%.3$;,5$*$%;/53-*43'3$%./%5/;/)S+*%./%-/4$'6/35*$:%*%;G/@/%.30:%/-%8*-%',8*./55*6'8\53*:%2,/%/(/$%4+*%-'3$%]5/$$,$;38'-%$/,$% ;G/@/$%.*%)'$$'.*^:%*%2,/%=%348/5)5/8'.*%)*5%'(6,-'$%)/$$*'$%;*-*%$/4.*%,-'%@*5-'%)*=T83;'%./%.30/5%2,/%*$%;G/@/$%131*$%4+*%-'3$%$,O$838,/-%*$%;G/@/$%-*58*$%;*-%8*8'(%.3643.'./%k%-'$%2,/%=:%./%@'8*:%,-'%@*5-'%./%'@35-'5%'%)*$3S+*%./%./$;/4./48/%./%3-)*58'48/$%;G/@/$A

#%@'8*%./%/$8/%;G/@/%@'0/5%2,/$8+*%./%5/'(30'5%'%@/$8'%/-%$,'%'(./3':%/%4+*%/-%73G':%@*3%,-%)*48*%3-)*58'48>$$3-*%.'$%.3$),8'$A%7%65'4./%-'3*53'%.*$%i,'5,)%

N'(')'(*%';*48/;/%/-%73G':%;*4$3./5'.'%'%)534;3)'(%'(./3'%N'(')'(*:%/%'8=%/48+*%')/4'$%,-%*,%.*3$%i,'5,)%N'(')'(*%G'13'-%*;*553.*%@*5'%?$/6,4.*%-/%.3$$/5'-%/-%73G'RA%w%-,38*%3-)*58'48/%)'5'%,-%65,)*%'(8*T


11/26

748o43*%L,/55/35*%b5A

!J[

i,'5,)%)'5'%/(/E%2,'(%4+*%@*3%$,'%$,5)5/$'%'*%$'O/5/-%2,/%*$%Q'83),%G'13'-%3.*%

'*$%t'p'(')>83%/%5/;('-'.*%*%;*5)*%?)*3$%'%'1\%-'8/54'%.*%-*58*%/5'%Q'83),RA%#$%&'(')'(*%@3;'5'-%-,38*%34;*-*.'.*$%;*-%*%';*48/;3.*:%/%;*4$3./5'5'-%3$$*%,-'%65'4./%*@/4$'A

#$%-*5'.*5/$%./%73G'%/$8'1'-%'O$*(,8'-/48/%34;*4@*5-'.*$%;*-%'%5/'(3T0'S+*%./%,-'%@/$8'%./%8'(%-'6438,./%/-%,-'%'(./3'%;*4$3./5'.'%])/53@=53;'^A%r/'(30'4.*%,-%i,'5,)%./%@*5-'%',8o4*-':%*%;G/@/%/-%'$;/4$+*%4+*%$\%.'1'%,-%)'$$*%3-)*58'48/%)'5'%(/6383-'5%$,'%)*$3S+*%;*-*%'@35-'1'%'%8*8'(%34./)/4T.c4;3'%538,'(%./%$,'%'(./3'%k%/%73G'%n$%1/0/$%=%;*4$3./5'.'%;*-*%'%]-+/ %.'$%./-'3$:%2,/%$+*%)/4$'.'$%;*-*%$/,$%]5'-*$%./%-'4.3*;'^:%/13./4;3'4.*%;/58'%8/4.c4;3'%n%G3/5'52,30'S+*%.'$%5/('Sh/$%5/63*4'3$A%g('%8'-O=-%=%;G'-'.'%./%)@*:%

)'('15'%2,/%$3643@3;'%])*$8/%*4./%$/%'-'55'%,-'%5/./^:%];G/@/^:%])5*8/8*5^:%/%'$%5/('Sh/$%/485/%'(./3'$%./%,-%-/$-*%)*1*%$+*%$/-)5/%./$;538'$%8*-'4.*%,-'%./('$%;*-*%)@*:%]'(./3'%)534;3)'(^A

734.'%2,/%/-%65'4./%-/.3.'%8*.'%'(./3'%$/j'%',8o4*-':%/('$%./)/4./-%,-'$%.'$%*,85'$%)'5'%*$%538,'3$:%/%'%$38,'S+*%N'(')'(*%'8,'(%/13./4;3'%;*-*%,-%$3$8/-'%./%'(./3'$%]$'8=(38/$^%=% ('8/48/% ?,-'% $38,'S+*%)*$$31/(-/48/%-'3$%;*T-,-%4*%)'$$'.*R$)A%_/5-3835%2,/%*,85'%'(./3'%5/'(30'$$/%,-%538,'(%./%8'-'4G'%65'4./0'%$/53'%5/;*4G/;/5%$,'%8*8'(%',8*4*-3'%538,'(%/-%5/('S+*%n%73G'%k%*%2,/%'8,'(30'%,-'%8/4$+*%/485/%.,'$%65'4./$%)'5/48/('$%2,/%1/-*$%./$./%'%/84*65'T

@3'%./%B'$$*%?!"CDR:%jU%2,/%'%'(./3'%/-%2,/$8+*%5/$,(8'%.'%$'>.'%./%)'58/%./%,-'%./$8'$%)'5/48/('$A%Y/5%',8o4*-'%=%./383-*$%/-%.3$),8'%;*-%'%'(./3'%]-+/^%)*5%;*413.'.*$%34.>6/4'$%/%4+*T34.>6/4'$A

Q,38*$%.*$%'56,-/48*$%;*485U53*$%n%@/$8'%/1*;'.*$%/-%)fO(3;*%)/(*$%-*T5'.*5/$%./%73G'%$/%5/@/53'-%n%.3$8q4;3'%.'2,/('%'(./3':%2,/%)*./53'%.3@3;,(8'5%*,%3-)/.35%'%13'6/-%.*$%;*413.'.*$%34.>6/4'$:%'*%$/,%8'-'4G*%?=%,-'%'(./3'%

)/2,/4':%2,/%/-%JKKC%4+*%834G'%!KK%)/$$*'$:%;*485'%2,'$/%DKK%/-%73G'R:%/%n%$,'%]@'(8'%./%O/(/0'^%?.*%)*48*%./%13$8'%./%'(6,4$RA%Q'$:%/-%)'583;,('5:%4+*%@*5'-%)*,;'$%'$%1/0/$%2,/%*,13%2,/343*%./%@/$8'$%4*%@,8,5*A%7$%)/$$*'$%/-%6/5'(%'@35-'1'-%1//-/48/-/48/%2,/%4+*%353'-:%./%@*5-'%'(6,-':%;*-)'5/;/5%'*%538,'(%k%*%2,/%;*4$838,3%,-'%65'4./%./$@/38':%/%*%



12/26

7$$3-/853'%/%;*(/83130'S+*

!JI

;G/@/%)534;3)'(%./%73G'%./,%34>;3*%'%,-'%1/5.'./35'%;'-)'4G'%)'5'%;*41/4;/5%

*$%;G/@/$%./%*,85*$%)*1*$%'%4+*%35/-%4'%@/$8'%;'$*%/('%4+*%@*$$/%@/38'%/-%73G'A7*%-/$-*%8/-)*:%*%;G/@/%./%,-'%'(./3'%;53'.'%5/;/48/-/48/%)'583;3)*,%.,T

)('-/48/%.'%.3$),8':%$/%)*$3;3*4'4.*%;*485'%73G'%?./%*4./%G'13'%$3.*%/83;*RA%g(/%$/%)*$3;3*4*,%;*485'%73G'%'%@3-%./%(/1'5%$/,$%'(3'.*$%4.3*$%2,/%*%';*-)'4G'T53'-%$/%8*54'5'-%65'4./%*Oj/8*%./%.3$),8':%/41*(1/4.*%*%@';;3*4'(3$-*%/485/%*$%;G/@/$:%'$%)*$$3O3(3.'./$%./%.3$853O,3S+*%./%'(3'.*$%/%$/,$%5/;,5$*$%/%*%)5/$T8>63*%5/63*4'(%.'$%'(./3'$A%7$%)*$$3O3(3.'./$%./%'(3'4S'%;*-%5"'*-)656$;%/%$/,$%O/4/@>;3*$% )*8/4;3'3$% ?8'48*% -'8/53'3$% 2,'48*% )*(>83;*$% /% $3-O\(3;*$R% ;*(*;'T5'-%/-%j*6*%'%G3/5'52,3'%/485/%*$%;G/@/$%.'%'(./3'%'4@3853+%$+ $&'-$+5;+1-?1-)5;+

536$)5;:%5/1/('4.*%2,/%)*5%85U$%.*%538,'(:%2,/%-,38'$%1/0/$%)*./%$/5%(3.*%4'%;G'T1/%.'%]/6/4'A%_'5'%*$%z',j':%'$%-U$;'5'$%4+*%)*./T53'-%$/5%@/38'$%]n%8*'^:%)*3$%@'0/5%,-'%-U$;'5'%4+*%=%]5/)5/$/48'5^%,-%515155'5):%-'$%$3-%8*54UT(*%)5/$/48/%k%/%@'0cT(*%$/-%'(3-/48UT(*%/%'(/65UT(*%=%;/58'-/48/%-,38*%)/536*$*A!*%_*5%3$$*%'(6,=-%./1/53'%)'85*;34'5%,-%538,'(%)'5'%*%2,'(%'$%-U$;'5'$%$/53'-%./13.'-/48/%@'O53;'.'$:%/4@/38'.'$:%'(3-/48'.'$%/%'(/65'.'$:%/%$\%./)*3$%1/4.3.'$%)'5'%'%(*j'%.'%F,4'3A



13/26

748o43*%L,/55/35*%b5A

!JC

X*-*%*%$/,%.*4*%.*$%O5'4;*$%G'13'%$/%8*54'.*%.*4*%./%-,38*$% 515155'5)%/%

/$8'1'%-/.3'4.*%'$%5/('Sh/$%;*-%'%(*j':%/(/%)'85*;34*,%,-%/4*5-/%538,'(%.*%2,'(%)'583;3)'5'-%-'3$%./%DK%515155'5)%?,-%/1/48*%;*4$3./5'1/(-/48/%5'5*R:%;,j'$%-U$;'5'$%@*5'-%1/4.3.'$%n%F,4'3A%m/4.*%$/%8*54'.*%.*4*%./%8'48*$%/$)>538*$:%3$8*%@/0%;*-%2,/%1U53'$%)/$$*'$%$/%-*O3(30'$$/-%)'5'%)('48'5%5*S'$%/%@'0/5%*Oj/T8*$%)'5'%?/(/%/R%$/,$%515155'5):%/%*%)'85*;>43*%./$8/%65'4./%538,'(%(G/%5/4./,%,-%)5/$8>63*%/4*5-/%/%,-'%5U)3.'%'$;/4$+*%'*%])53-/35*%(,6'5^%.'%;G/@3'%p',j'A%#%$/,%;'$*%=%/1/3$%/485'.'$%.*$%O5'4;*$%4'%/;*T4*-3'%./%)5/$8>63*%'(8*T"$+;=*+ $3$;+4$;4*;+"45+F5-)$656$+6$+)';$!$A

MU%/(/-/48*$%8'48*%4'%-38*(*63'%2,'48*%4*%.3$;,5$*%;*83.3'4*%2,/%/4@'83T0'-%/$$'%;*4.3S+*%.*$%!5#5)@5A%g-%$,'$%)53-/35'$%')'53Sh/$:%/(/$%/5'-%13$8*$%/83-'$%.*$%$/2,/$85*$%.*$%!5#5)@5A%a'%G3$8\53'%./%Y'6'4'@':%,-%j*1/-%&'(')'(*%5*,O'.*%)/(*$%!5#5)@5%?$/6,4.*%$/%)*./%/$)/;,('5:%)*5%,-'%O'4./35'%./%748o43*%_35/$%./%X'-)*$%/-%-/'.*$%.*%$=;,(*%9VWWWR!$:%*%71oT.*$TB5'4;*$%=%./$;538*%;*-*%,-%)';$!$%;'43O'(%/%,-%'$T$'$$34*%;5,/(%2,/%)5*.,0%*Oj/8*$%./%-/8'(%'%)'5835%./%$'46,/%;*'6,('.*A%g-%,-'%1/5$+*%.*%-38*%./%*536/-%.'%G,-'43.'./%)3;':%'%;')';3.'./%./%85'4$@*5-'5%$'46,/%;*'6,('.*%/-%

-/8'(% *53634'.'% ./% $/,$% '4;/$85'3$% /% $/,% .,)(*%)*8/4;3'(%./$85,831*T;53'831*:%.30T$/% 2,/% *$%!5#5)@5% $+*% )/$$*'$% .*8'.'$% ./%)';$!$'":% *%-/$-*% ;*4j,48*%./%;')';3.'./$%./%'65/$$+*%/%85'4$@*5-'S+*{;53'S+*%2,/%;'5';8/530'%*$%$/5/$%4+*TTG,-'4*$A%MU%;/5;'%./%,-%'4*:%,-%G*-/-%4'G,N,U%2,/%$/%8*54*,%./*A%7$$3-:%-/$-*%$/4.*%



14/26

7$$3-/853'%/%;*(/83130'S+*

!JH

F);)F$34$&'$%6/48/:%!"#$!":%*$%!5#5)@5%4+*%./3538*A%g$8/%)5*;/$$*%4+*%$\%./1/%$/5%348/55*-)3.*%)/(*%4T.3*$:%'$$3-%;*-*%/(/$%@'0/-%;*-%*$%)';$!$A%74U(*6*$%.*$%)';$!$:%*$%!5#5)@5%8'-TO=-%)5/;3$'-%$/5%];,3.'.*$^:%]@'-3(3'530'.*$^:%/%)*5%3$$*%)5/;3$'-%./%,-%6*&*A

a*%7(8*%9346,%)5'83;'-/48/%$/%34$838,;3*4'(30*,%'%/8,(*%./%];G/@/^:%-'$%2,/%4*5-'(-/48/%4+*%$+*%*$%)53-*6c438*$%.*$%65'4./$%5&$'5J:%*,%G/5.'5'-%'%;G/@3'%)/('%13'%-'8/54'!&%

/:%/1/48,'(-/48/:%4,4;'%@*5'-%)5/)'5'.*$

!'

%)'5'%/$8/%;'56*A%g485/8'48*:%/$8'$%)/$$*'$%')5/$/48'-%*%.3@/5/4;3'(%./%@'('5/-%,-%)*58,6,c$%';3-'%.'%-=.3'%.*$%-'3$%1/(G*$%?.*$%2,'3$%'(6,4$%$/2,/5%/48/4./-%)*58,6,c$R%/%8/5/-%/6/4':%$/%;*-)5*-/8/5%'%;*-)5'5%65'4./$%2,'483.'./$%./%]'58/$'4'8*^:%*,%/48+*%)'6'5%/-%.34G/35*%)/('%/$8'.3'R:%=%*%$/,%85'O'(G*A

l/$./%'%;G/6'.'%.*$%35-+*$%V3(('$%B*'$%n%5/63+*:%'6/48/$%./$$/%83)*%8c-%$3.*%348/4;3*4'(-/48/%)5/)'5'.*$:%)*5%>4.3*$%/%O5'4;*$:%)'5'%./$/-)/4G'5/-%)')=3$%./%-/.3'S+*A%V/j'T$/:%)*5%/


15/26

748o43*%L,/55/35*%b5A

!J"

(/1'1'%@3(G*$%j*1/4$%./%;G/@/$%3-)*58'48/$%)'5'%)'$$'5/-%8/-)*5'.'$%j,48*%'%/(/%

?./485*%/%@*5'%.*%_'52,/R%')5/4./4.*%'%/48/4./5%*$%;*$8,-/$%.*$%O5'4;*$:%$/,$%348/5/$$/$%/%@*5-'$%./%4/6*;3'5A%g42,'48*%*$%)53-*6c438*$%.*$%65'4./$%;G/@/$%;*4834,'5'-%$/4.*%)5/)'5'.*$%)*5%/$8/$%)'5'% ')5/4./5/-%*$%;*4G/;3-/48*$%2,/%$+*%$,'$%)5/55*6'831'$%/%'$$,-35/-%$,'$%5/$)*4$'O3(3.'./$%538,'3$:%$/,$%@3T(G*$%-'3$%4*1*$%@*5'-%)5*65/$$31'-/48/%*;,)'4.*%*%)')/(%./%-/.3'.*5/$%;*-%*%-,4.*%83;'%./%*O8/4S+*%./%5/;,5$*$%-,38*%;/485'.'%4'%@36,5'%.*%!5#5)@5+*'*%/%$/,$%'(3'.*$%)/$$*'3$A%l/%@'8*:%7A!(:%*%;G/@/%2,/%'8=%*%@34'(%./%JKKC%./$/-)/4G'1'%/$8/%)')/(%@*5'%8'-O=-%*%/$;*(G3.*%)'5'%)5/$3.35%'%7$$*;3'S+*%7,(,N,-+:%*%2,/%/-%)'58/%@/0%;*-%2,/%'$%'8313.'./$%./$8'%'$$*;3'S+*%@3;'$$/-%-,38*%'85/('.'$%n$%'8313.'./$%./$8/%;G/@/A%7%'$$*;3'S+*%)'$$*,%'%@,4;3*4'5%-'3$%;*-*%,-'%/$)=;3/%./%;*48'%;*4j,48'%.'%

'(./3'%;,j'%5/4.'%134G'%/6,'%-'5;'.'%)/('%'2,3$3S+*%./%-,38*%)5/$8>63*%$/6,3.'%./%,-%)/5>*.*%./%@*58/$%./$;*4@3'4S'$:%2,/%(/1'5'-%n%$,'%/'%;*-%;*4138/$%)'5'%)'$$'5/-%8/-)*5'.'$%/-%73G'A%Q'$:%;G/6'4.*%(U:%/$8/$%'-36*$%6/5'(-/48/%@3;'1'-%G*$)/.'.*$%4'%;'$'%.*%.*4*%.'%'(T./3':%2,/%/$)/5'1'%)5/$/48/$%;'5*$%8'-O=-%)'5'%$3:%*%2,/%4/-%$/-)5/%';*48/;3':%jU%2,/%/$8'$%)/$$*'$%jU%/$8'1'-%./.3;'4.*%)5/$/48/$%'%7A%Q,38*$%.*$%)5/$/48/$%



16/26

7$$3-/853'%/%;*(/83130'S+*

!DK

2,/%/$8/$%13$38'48/$%(/1'1'-%]15-5+5+O'^%=%3-)*58'48/%)'5'%/48/4./5%*$%;*4@(38*$%/-%j*6*A%#$%4+*T>4.3*$%;*-%*$%2,'3$%/(/$%-'48c-%'(3'4S'$%-'3$%*,%-/4*$%.,5'.*,5'$%$+*%;G'-'.*$%./%]&'(')'(*%!5#5)@5#A^:%$/4.*%M#A%,-%$,@3


17/26

748o43*%L,/55/35*%b5A

!D!

/$8/$%4+*T>4.3*$:%./%'(6,-'%-'4/35':%])*$$,>.*$^%)/(*$%&'(')'(*%/42,'48*%65,T

)*%*,%)/(*$%;G/@/$%5/$)*4$U1/3$%)/('%;53'S+*%./%'(3'4S'$%;*-%/(/$|%l/%@'8*:%/$8'%=%,-'%953;5+>"$;'=*:%.3'48/%.'%@*5-'%;*-*%;G/@/$%/%65,)*$%/$8+*%5/(';3*4'.*$%4*%)/4$'-/48*%N'(')'(*A%7%)5*.,S+*%.'%,43.'./:%.*%;*(/831*:%)'$$'%4/;/$$'53'-/4T8/%)/('%'6c4;3'%./%,-%5&$'A+k%4*%;'$*%.*%i,'5,):%)/('%'6c4;3'%.*%;G/@/{.*4*%.'%@/$8':%/-%*,85*$%;'$*$:%)/(*%].*4*%.*$%O5'4;*$^A%#$%&'(')'(*%$\%$/%5/(';3*4'-%/42,'48*%65,)*%k%$/j'%;*-%*,85*$%>4.3*$%4*%538,'(:%$/j'%;*-%*$%O5'4;*$%k%)*5%-/3*%./%$/,$%;G/@/$:%2,/%'*%$/%;*(*;'5/-%4'%)*$3S+*%.'2,/(/$%2,/%];,3.'-%./%$/,%)/$$*'(^%/485'-%/-%,-'%5/('S+*%'$$3-=853;'%2,/%@'0%;*-%2,/%*%65,)*%$\%/


18/26

#%$'O*4/8/%.'%.3$;\5.3'

!DJ

;G/@/%./3$$3-*%2,/%'%)5*.,S+*%G'13'%(/1'.*A%l/)*3$%./%-,38'%4/6*;3'S+*:%'%/2,3)/%;*4;*5.*,%/-%./3


19/26

748o43*%L,/55/35*%b5A

!DD

#%.*4*%'56,-/48'1'%2,/%/$8'$%;*3$'$%/5'-%./13.'$%'%/(/%)*52,/%$/53'-%15B

#54$&'*+1*-+'*6*+*+1$)D$+1$;


20/26

7$$3-/853'%/%;*(/83130'S+*

!DZ

)534;3)'(%)o./%;*4834,'5%/-%$/,%(,6'5:%4'%)*$3S+*%./%$/5%'%)/$$*'%5/$)*4$U1/(%

)*5%)/5$*43@3;'5%*%;*(/831*%N'(')'(*A%v-%;G/@/%)*./%*O8/5%/$8'%)*$3S+*%.3$853TO,34.*%;*-3.'%/%*Oj/8*$:%*,%)'6'-/48*$%k%'%(\63;'%./%)5*.,S+*%./%'$$3-/853'%)/('%.U.31'%=%'%-/$-':%/%*%;*4@(38*%/485/%*$%.*3$%;G/@/$%)/(*$%)'6'-/48*$%'$$,-/%'$%@/3Sh/$%8>)3;'$%.*%@';;3*4'(3$-*%83;'%(*;'(%2,/%=%$3-,(8'4/'-/48/%)5/$$,)*$8'%/%?;*485'R)5*.,T03.'%4*$%538,'3$A

_/(*$%;'$*$%.3$;,83.*$%';3-':%1/-*$%2,/%4+*%GU%,-'%$38,'S+*%].,'(^%;*-T)*$8'%)/('%348/5'S+*%.*$%!5#5)@5+;*-%]*%538,'(^:%3-'634'.*%;*-*%,-%*Oj/8*%)'$T$>1/(%./%$/5%$3-)(/$-/48/%13$8*:%-'$%,-'%34;*5)*5'S+*%.*$%4+*T>4.3*$%/%$/,$%5/;,5$*$%4*$%/$2,/-'$%348/54*$%./%*56'430'S+*%.*%538,'(:%34.3$$*;3U1/3$%.'%/;*T4*-3'%)*(>83;'%./%)5/$8>63*%'(8*T4.3*$%*,%*$%O5'4;*$A%a+*%$/53'%)*$$>1/(%3-'634'5%$/-/(G'48/%-*13T-/48*%4*%-,4.*%'-/5>4.3*:%4/-%/-%(,6'5%'(6,-A%72,3:%'6*5':%;*-*%/-%*,85*$%(,6'5/$%/%8/-)*$%?L/((%!""HR:%8*.'%*Oj/83@3;'S+*%=%'*%-/$-*%8/-)*%>4.3;/%/%;',$'%./%5/('Sh/$%/485/%$,j/38*$%?e'65*,%JKKCE%B'5;/(*$%a/8*%JKKH`DZR`%8*.'%*Oj/83@3T?e'65*,%JKKCE%B'5;/(*$%a/8*%JKKH`DZR`%8*.'%*Oj/83@3T`%8*.'%*Oj/83@3T;'S+*%/


21/26

748o43*%L,/55/35*%b5A

!D[

'@/8'%*,85'$%5/('Sh/$%?)*3$%$\%$/%*Oj/83@3;'%'(6*%'%@3-%./%/


22/26

7$$3-/853'%/%;*(/83130'S+*

!DI

B340,

!g$/$AJ%7(6,-'$:%n$%1/0/$:%)*./-%8/5%@'$/$%348/5'(./3'$AD%g$8/%-/%)'5/;/%,-%)*48*%3-)*58'48/:%-'$%2,/:%)*5%'(6,-'%5'0+*:%4+*%=%./$/41*(13.*%4'$%

/84*65'@3'$%.3$)*4>1/3$A%#$%538,'3$%5/63*4'3$%?n%/4.3*$A

I%w%3-)*58'48/%4*8'5%2,/%*%])';3@3$-*%'(8*T83%;*-%*%_*$8*%e/T*4'5.*:%)*5%/


23/26

748o43*%L,/55/35*%b5A

!DC

M/;N/4O/56/5%JKK[`C!:%!JZT!DDR%.'%*;,)'S+*%.*%7(8*%9346,:%2,'4.*%1U53'$%'(./3'$%65'138'1'-%

/-%8*54*%./%'(./3'$%-'3*5/$%/%538,'(-/48/%-'3$%3-)*58'48/$%?*,%-/$-*%./%(,6'5/$%$'65'.*${;/4T85*$%538,'3$%4+*%G'O38'.*$:%;*-*%)'5/;/%8/5%$3.*%*%;'$*%.*%$>83*%N,3N,5*%M/,(,63Gd8d%x`"KT"DyRA!D%l/%@'8*:%,-%-*./(*%./%34.36/43$-*%O'$8'48/%)'583;,('5:%2,/%4,4;'%$/%8*54*,:%/@/831'-/48/:%

-*./(*%)'5'%*,85*$%)*1*$%/%5/63h/$A!Z%l/$./%-,38*%j*1/-%7538'4'%@*3%)5/)'5'.*%)*5%$/,%)'3%/%)*5%#5('4.*%V3(('$%B*'$%)'5'%$/%

8*54'5%*%)534;3)'(%348/5-/.3U53*%/485/%*$%)*1*$%.*%7(8*%9346,%?2,/%/(/%5/)5/$/48'53'%;*-*%,-'%f43;'%]$*;3/.'./^R%/%*%-,4.*%.*$%O5'4;*$A%g(/%./%@'8*%'$$,-3,%/$8'%)*$3S+*%/%)*5%3$$*%=%;G'-'.*%./%];';32,/%6/5'( :%-'$%3$8*%4+*%3-)(3;'%2,/%/(/%8/4G'%2,'(2,/5%',8*53.'./%$*O5/%*,85'$%'(./3'$%*,%)5/55*6'831'$%$*O5/%*,85*$%;G/@/$:%4+*%8/4.*%4'.'%'%1/5%;*-%,-%])'5'-*,48%;G3/@^%*,%'(6*%.*%6c4/5*A

![%v-%)*1*%./%(>46,'%N'53O%.*%7(8*%9346,:%;*-%*$%2,'3$%85'O'(G*%./$./%JKK[%/%'8,'(-/48/%5/T'(30*%-34G'%)/$2,3$'%./%.*,8*5'.*:%j,48*%'*%_5*65'-'%./%_\$TL5'.,'S+*%/-%7485*)*(*63'%Y*;3'(%.'%v431/5$3.'./%./%B5'$>(3'%?L,/55/35*%bf43*5%JK!KRA

!I%W$8*%@*3%*%2,/%-/%.3$$/%,-%G*-/-%N'(')'(*%2,/%/$8'1'%/-%B5'$>(3'%-/.3'4.*%'$%5/('Sh/$%;*-%*$%348/5/$$'.*$:%2,/%8'-O=-%4+*%-/%./,%4*-/$A%X/58'-/48/%./%$/,%)*48*%./%13$8'%$\%,-%)'5/48/%)*./53'%./$/j'5%'%G*-/4'6/-:%-'$%2,/-%/@/831'-/48/%/$8'1'%)5*65'-'4.*%'%@/$8'%/,%4+*%$'O/53'%.30/5%k%$\%3-'634'5A

!C%7%-'3*5%'(./3'%&'(')'(*:%;*4$3./5'.'%)*5%-,38*$%;*-*%$/4.*%'%])534;3)'(^%?3$8*%=:%'%'(./3'%)'5'%'%2,'(%./1/53'-%$/%.353635%*$%-/4$'6/35*$%./%*,85*$%)*1*$%/%*4./%8*.*$%*$%538,'3$%5/63*4'3$%./1/53'-%$/5%5/'(30'.*$%k%*%2,/%';'O'%4+*%';*48/;/4.*%4'%)5U83;'RA

!H%734.':%,-%.*$%G*-/4$%5/$)*4$U1/3$%)*5%-/.3'5%'$%4/6*;3'Sh/$%;*-%'%@'->(3'%.*%G*-/4'6/T'.*%/$8'1'%.35/8'-/48/%348/5/$$'.*%4'%)*$$3O3(3.'./%./%*O8/5%'j,.'%.*$%)'5/48/$%.*%/


24/26

7$$3-/853'%/%;*(/83130'S+*

!DH

$/%348/5/$$'4.*%/-%5/8*-'5%*%,$*%./%/4@/38/$%]85'.3;3*4'3$^%4*%.3'%'%.3'%/% 5/63$85'5:%./%8*.'$%'$%

@*5-'$%)*$$>1/3$:%$,'$%@/$8'$:%;'48*$%/%-f$3;'$AJI%v-'%@*5-'%;*4$3./5'.'%]-/4*$%(/6>83-'^%./%85'4$-3$$+*%.'%;G/@3'A%X*48,.*:%3$$*%4+*%$3643@3;'%2,/%4+*%G'j'%65'4./$%;G/@/$%2,/%G/5.'5'-%*%;'56*%./%$,'$%-+/$A%_/(*%;*485U53*:%'$%)534;3T)'3$%-,(G/5/$%4*O5/$%N'(')'(*%)'5/;/-%')5/$/48'5%,-'%8/4.c4;3'%n%G3)*6'-3':%*%2,/%@'0%;*-%2,/%$/,$%@3(G*$%G*-/4$%G/5./-%*%$8'8,$%./%$/,$%'1o$%-'8/54*$:%65'4./$%;G/@/$:%6/5'(-/48/%)*./4.*%5/2,3$38'5%*%8>8,(*%./%@*5-'%O'$8'48/%(/6>83-'A%w%*%;'$*%./%.*3$%;G/@/$%/-%73G'%G*j/:%*%'8,'(%]$/6,4T.*%;';32,/^%/%*%j*1/-%2,/%@*3%/$;*(G3.*%)'5'%'$$,-35%'%)*$3S+*%./%;G/@/%)534;3)'(A

JC%W$8*%=:%2,/%)*./-%4+*%8/5%)'$$'.*%)*5%,-'%5/;(,$+*%3./'(%/%')5/4.3.*%*$%;*4G/;3-/48*$%'$$*;3'.*$%n%;G/@3'%?.*$%2,'3$:%,-%.*$%)534;3)'3$%$+*%*$%.3$;,5$*$%;/53-*43'3$RA%7%5/('831'%]@'(8'%./%)5/)'5*^%?)'5'%'%;G/@3'%85'.3;3*4'(R%./%'(6,4$%G/5./35*$%./$8/%83)*%4+*%$/%./1/%$*-/48/%n%@'(8'%./%,-%)'3%;G/@/:%)*3$%'%-'3*53'%.'$%)'5&!#*%8/-%8*8'(%;*4G/;3-/48*%.*$%'853O,8*$%.*$%;G/@/$%G*-/4$%/:%-,38'$%1/0/$:%j*1/4$%5&$'5J%$+*%)5/)'5'.*$%)*5%$/,$%QF%/{*,%QBA

JH%_'5'%8/48'5%)5/$/51'5%'%3./483.'./%.'$%)/$$*'$:%,83(30'5/3%'$%343;3'3$%./%$/,$%4*-/$%-/4*$%

;*4G/;3.*$AJ"%#%'-36*%?5'*R%=%'2,/(/%;*-%2,/-%$/%85*;'%-,38*:%;*-*%$/%@'0%;*-%*$%'@34$:%-'$%8'-O=-%=%'2,/(/%./%2,/-%4+*%$/%8/-%1/56*4G':%;*-*%*$%)'5/48/$%1/5.'./35*$:%)*./4.*%$/5%)/4$'.*%;*-*%,-'%;'8/6*53'%348/5-/.3U53'%/485/%'-O*$A%m5*;'T$/%-,38*:%;*-*%/485/%'@34$:%-'$%;*-%)/$$*'$%;,j'$%5/('Sh/$%$+*%8*8'(-/48/%(315/$%/%./$)5*13.'$%./%1/56*4G'A



25/26

748o43*%L,/55/35*%b5A

!D"

C8D8/E1290,

B7rXge#Y%agm#:%753$8\8/(/$A%JKKDA%]F/$8'$%)'5'%,-%4*O5/`%538,'(%/%?5/R)5*.,S+*%$*;3*)*(>83;'%4*%7(8*%9346,^A%R;'"6)*;+S5')&*+%4$-)"$;+$&+'$--$;+548-)&6)$&&$;A%a'48/55/`%Y*;3=8=%./8G4*(*63/A%))A%ZH!T

[K"AFva7WA%JKKZA%4.3*$%.*%9346,%@'0/-%&,'5,)%)'5'%l5A%r*O/58*%Q'534G*A%G88)`{{pppA

@,4'3A6*1AO5{,(83-'${4*83;3'${J$/-/$85/JKKZ{76*$8*{,4KI!CKK!AG8-A%7;/$$*%/-`%!I%./%j,4G*%./%JK!KA

Lgee:%7(@5/.A%!""HA%%-'+5&6+5#$&


26/26

7$$3-/853'%/%;*(/83130'S+*

!ZK

6*+%3'*+7)"T+@);'?-)5+$+83;'%4*%7(8*%9346,`%#O$/51'Sh/$%'%)'5835%.*$%&'T-'s,5U%/%.*%g$8,.*%.'%F/$8'%.'%b'6,'8353;'%?b'p'53R^A%W4`%BA%F5'4;G/88*%P%QAbA%M/;N/4O/56/5%?*56$AR:%0;+1*F*;+6*+%3'*+7)"T+@);'?-)5+$+

Assimetria e coletivização - notas sobre chefes e caraíbas na política Kalapalo

Documents

Transcript of Assimetria e coletivização - notas sobre chefes e caraíbas na política Kalapalo