Por que não falaram a verdade para Jó?

7/31/2019 Por que no falaram a verdade para J?

1/24


2/24

82== @MDJKC YMDPNY OX

@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox

NX ][K DN EMCMXMA M UKX@M@K RMXM O>

8

N rxnryjpn `kypk mxpjln jdukypjlmx kypm pkdyn ynh mrkxyrkipjum `n }{k mindpkik{ dm uj`m `k O# nd`krn`kany kdindpxmx `jypjdpmakdpk n kvkarcn pmdpn `nyjdikxn inan `n ynejypjim`makdpk k}{junim`n dnyrkxyndmlka `ny yk{y majlny$ Mcj n m{pnx `n cjuxnrxkrmxn{ i{j`m`nymakdpk ny rmxakpxny rkcny }{mjy nckjpnx `kukxjm mhnx`mx n m}{jcn }{k mindpkik dmdmxxmpjum# rn`kd`n myyja j`kdpjejimx ina icmxkm nmlkdpk `k pmamdfm impypxnek$ N rxnhckam n `k mikjpmxn{ dn m rxnrnypm `n cjuxn7 k m amdkjxm inan {pjcjmanyn yk{ indpk`n `kd{dijm m dnyym rnyp{xm ka xkcmn rxnrnypm `n m{pnx `n cjuxn$

Dn indfkij`n ykxan `my kypp{my &mdn 96


3/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


9

M Indpxjh{jn `k O

M `jeji{c`m`k jdjijmc ka `kejdjx m indpxjh{jn `n cjuxn`k O pmdpn rmxm m pkncnljm inan rmxm m rxpjim ixjyp nxkindfkijakdpn k mikjpmn `m}{jcn }{k n m{pnx kyprxnrnd`n$ M yjarcky j`jm `k }{k @k{y ykom nxkyrndyukc rkcny ynexjakdpny }{k O kvrkxjakdpn{#inan O 8?9 rmxkik jd`jimx# xkikhj`m `k amdkjxmkumyjum rnx mcl{dy pkcnlny# ny }{mjy dklma inaukkadijm }{mc}{kx xkcmijndmakdpn `jxkpn `k @k{y dn

ynexjakdpn `k O$ Dkypm cjdfm `k mxl{akdpmn# inanukxkany# m indpxjh{jn }{k O pka pxmj`n rmxm mpkncnljm k rxpjim ixjyp dn pka yj`n rxnrxjmakdpk {amindpxjh{jn `n cjuxn inan {a pn`n$ a{jpn ina{a ukxrmcmuxmy jyncm`my pmdpn `k O inan `k yk{y majlnyykxka {ym`my ka mrnjn `k `n{pxjdmy k `kejdjkypkncljimy$ Pn`mujm# ykx }{k rn`kany `jkx }{k makdymlka `n cjuxn pka pxmj`n mcl{am indpxjh{jn}{md`n pkcnlny k rmypnxky jdyjypka ka `xjhcmx n

mxl{akdpn pkncljin `kypm nhxm> Mn }{k ak rmxkik# mamdkjxm }{k kcky mifmxma rmxm yk hkdkejijmxka `nindpk`n `n cjuxn `k O enj m `k emkx {a {yn ykckpjun `kkvrxkyyky k indikjpny kdindpxm`n ka `jukxymy rmxpky`n cjuxn$

Nhykxuk# jdjijmcakdpk# m amdkjxm inan Kcjem kdpkd`k n}{k kyp mindpkikd`n$ Kck mhnx`m m yjp{mn rmxpjd`n `nrxkyy{rnypn }{k O kyp ykd`n r{dj`n rnx im{ym `k

mcl{am injym }{k ekz? Ckahxm!pk mlnxm }{mc njdnikdpk }{k omamjy rkxkik{> K nd`k enxma ny yjdikxny`kypx{`ny> Ykl{d`n k{ pkdfn ujypn# ny }{k cmuxmajdj}j`m`k# k ykakjma amc# yklma n akyan &O 07

Kcjem `k }{k my rkyynmy jdnikdpky d{dim rkxkika n{yn `kypx{`my# o ny }{k ykakjma n amc ina ikxpkm n


4/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


0

ikjemxn$ Yk n mxl{akdpn `k Kcjem kypjukx inxxkpn# kdpnm rmyymlka `k empn mrjm n }{k a{jpmy ukky `kejdj`ninan rkdmcj`m`ky dmp{xmjy `n rkim`n$

Amy kypk rxkijymakdpk n rxnhckam }{k rxkijym ykxxkyncuj`n mdpky `k mikyymxany m akdymlka `n cjuxn# mymhkx# rnx }{k O kyp ynexkd`n> Kypm m rkxl{dpm }{kpn`ny ny yk{y pxy majlny pkdpma xkyrnd`kx dn `kinxxkx`n cjuxn$ M `kyrkjpn `k kcky n mi{ymxka `k pn`m ynxpk `kpxmdylxkyyn# O akyan d{dim mikjpn{ }{k n yk{ynexjakdpn pjukyyk mcl{am xkcmn ina yk{y rkim`ny$Akyan myyja# rmxm Kcjem# O kypmum ykd`n r{dj`n rnxmcln }{k kck pkxjm ekjpn k pmc r{djn ynakdpk xky{cpmxjmka hkdkeijny rmxm y{m uj`m ykxujxjm `k inxxkn k`jyijrcjdm &;?=


5/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


;

rmxm andpmx dnyymy rxrxjmy indic{yky yka `uj`m{am jdinkxdijm kvklpjim$ Inan `jyyk dn jdijn# kypmjdinkxdijm rn`k ykx minhkxpm`m pmdpn rkcm ynejypjimn}{mdpn rkcm yjdikxj`m`k$ N minhkxpmakdpn rkcmynejypjimn lkxmcakdpk yk ni{rm ka mdcjykyjdpkxajdukjy ynhxk myrkipny cjpkxxjny# i{cp{xmjy#kvjypkdijmjy# xkpxjiny k n{pxny# kd}{mdpn }{k makdymlka `n pkvpn rkxamdkik ykd`n jldnxm`m$ Nminhkxpmakdpn rkcm yjdikxj`m`k yk {pjcjm `k {am ckjp{xmcjpkxmc `n pkvpn }{k yk pnxdm jl{mcakdpk i{crm`m `k dnjdic{jx {am mhnx`mlka jdpklxmc `ncjuxn# inan enj n imyn `k Pnay `kM}{jdn$ Mifn nrnxp{dn xkckahxmx m`jypjdn rxnrnypm rkcn ak{rxnekyynx Umdfnnkx kdpxk {amckjp{xm pd{k k {am `kdym$ Ykl{d`ny{m `jypjdn# {am ckjp{xm pd{kindykl{k `kyixkukx ka `kpmcfky {a`kpkxajdm`n kukdpn yka indp{`nymhkx n }{k kyp mindpkikd`n$ Ka

yk{ kvkarcn kck `jyi{pk m `kyixjn`n mpn `k rjyimx ny ncfny$ D{am

`kyixjn pd{kn rjyimx `k ncfnyyjldjejim m indpxmn `ny ayi{cny`my rcrkhxmy d{am ukcnij`m`k `k2$0 ykl{d`ny$ D{am `kyixjn`kdym# }{k rxni{xm mdmcjymx {akukdpn `kdpxn `n yk{ mpnina{djimpjun# n mpn `k rjyimx ny

ncfny rn`k ykx kdpkd`j`n inan {aonln `k ina{djimn ka }{k {amrkyynm# m pjp{cn `k `jukxyn# yjdmcjm rmxm {a `nyn{ujdpky }{k my y{my rmcmuxmy dn yn ukx`m`kjxmy$Mahny ny pjrny `k ckjp{xmy mdmcjyma n akyan kukdpny#amy m cpjam imrm `k mhxmdlkx kckakdpnyina{djimpjuny }{k un mca `my rmcmuxmy k inark nmpn ina{djimpjun inarckpn$ Rmxkik!ak }{k n cjuxn `k Opka yj`n upjam `k {am ckjp{xm pd{k }{k yk mxxmypm rnx

`im`my$

Ckahxm!pk mlnxm}{mc n jdnikdpk

}{k omamjyrkxkik{> K nd`k

enxma ny yjdikxny

`kypx{`ny>Ykl{d`n k{ pkdfn

ujypn# ny }{k cmuxmajdj}j`m`k# kykakjma amc#

yklma n akyan&O 0$


6/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


5

]{mc ykxjm# kdpn# m indpxjh{jn }{k n cjuxn `k O inan{a pn`n pxm pmdpn rmxm m pkncnljm inan rmxm m rxpjimixjyp> Kypk n rxnryjpn `kypk mxpjln? enxa{cmx {amckjp{xm `kdym `n cjuxn }{k ykom kvklkpjimakdpk inkxkdpkina y{m kypx{p{xm nxjljdmc$ K o }{k n cjuxn indpxjh{jina jdakxmy xkmy `m pkncnljm# k{ cjajpmxkj ajdfmjdukypjlmn mn rxnhckam `n ynexjakdpn `k O$ \mcpkxGm{eeamdd mhnx`m kypk rxnhckam `k {am amdkjxm }{kdny mo{`m m j`kdpjejimx n dnyyn prjin$

Ka pn`n n pkarn# dkdf{a `ny majlny `k O pkdpmkvrcjimx n rxnhckam `n ynexjakdpn `k O mrndpmd`n rmxmYmpmdy$ M ndjrnpdijm `k @k{y d{dim }{kypjndm`m# kpn`ny ny jdpkxkyym`ny ka mo{`!cn rmxkika kdpkd`kx}{k dn pka inan mrkcmx rmxm Ympmdy yka dklmx n{ mo{ypjm `k @k{y n{ y{m ndjrnpdijm$ Ny majlny `k O ykxki{yma m }{kypjndmx }{mc}{kx {am `kypmy xkmy$ Pn`nyny }{mpxny yk rnyjijndma `k amdkjxm ykakcfmdpk? o }{k@k{y ynhkxmdn k o{ypn# m djim indic{yn rnyyukc `k

}{k O akxkik yk{ ynexjakdpn$ Cnln# yk kck kypynexkd`n# kck `kuk pkx rkim`n$

kvmpmakdpk kypm indic{yn mrmxkdpkakdpk jdkujpukc#`k }{k O `kuk pkx rkim`n# }{k ak anpjum m xk`kyinhxjxm kypx{p{xm nxjljdmc rxkrmxm`m rkcn m{pnx `n cjuxn$ Nynexjakdpn `k O rxkijym rxjakjxn ykx kdpkd`j`n `kdpxn`n mximhn{n `n cjuxn rmxm }{k `krnjy rnyymanykdpkd`kx m akdymlka `n cjuxn$ Mny jdpkxkyym`ny imhk

kdpn rkxl{dpmx? }{mjy yn my xkypxjky kypmhkckij`myrkcn dmxxm`nx }{k dny enxmxjma m kvrcjimx n ynexjakdpn`k O `jekxkdpk `m}{kcm m`npm`m rnx Kcjem>

Xkypxjky jarnypmy rkcn dmxxm`nx

N Cjuxn `k O enj mxpypjim k jdpkdijndmcakdpk rxkrmxm`nrmxm emkx {a rxnd{dijmakdpn m xkyrkjpn `k dm`m

akdny }{k m xkcjljnyj`m`k f{amdm rnx }{k dym`nxmany m @k{y> Rnx }{k jd`ju`{ny inan O pkaka m


7/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


Enj n rxrxjn @k{y}{ka rxjakjxn ckumdpn{ m }{kypn }{md`n indukxymumina Ympmdy# pkd`n ka akdpk m rkyynm `k O$ Ymhkd`n}{k ny `jcnlny jxn pxmpmx `kypm }{kypn e{d`makdpmc# ncjuxn inakm o ina m mejxamn mvjnapjim? O kxm {afnaka o{ypn k xkpn &=?=*$ Ykxjm hna kdpkd`kxany `ky`ko }{k# kahnxm n cjuxn emck a{jpn ynhxk ynexjakdpn# n yk{

pkam rxjdijrmc dn ynexjakdpn# amykypm }{kypn `m anpjumn rmxm mlkd{dm xkcjljnyj`m`k f{amdm n }{kanpjum {am rkyynm pkakx m @k{y k`kyujmx!yk `n amc> Kypm yka `uj`m{am rkxl{dpm a{jpn jdpkxkyymdpk#kyrkijmcakdpk indyj`kxmd`n }{k kcmenj ckumdpm`m rkcn rxrxjn @k{y}{md`n kck jdjijm n `jcnln inaympmdy$ Dn mrkdmy jypn# kck jdjijm n`jcnln kdempjmd`n n imxpkx yjdl{cmx`m}{kck fnaka?rnx}{k djdl{a fdm pkxxm$$$ $ Ka emkd`n jypn# @k{y kyp

kdempjimakdpk mejxamd`n m amdkjxminan O ind`{ m y{m uj`m$ Pmcjdpklxj`m`k mejxam`m dn rxcnln&=?=*# kdempjm`m `{my ukky rnx@k{y &=?67 8?9*# enxpkakdpk}{kypjndm`m rkcny majlny `k O dn

xkypmdpk `n cjuxn# `kekd`j`m rkcn rxrxjn O dny`jcnlny ina yk{y majlny k ejdmcakdpk xkmejxam`m rnx@k{y dn krcnln &08? Ynhxk }{ka `kukxjm xkimjx mxkyrndymhjcj`m`k rnx p{`n n }{k O rm`kik{> Kypmyrkxl{dpmy yk pnxdma ix{ijmjy `kuj`n mn i{xyn }{k n`jcnln kdpxk @k{y k ympmdy pnan{$ Yk @k{y pjukyyk

`kyindyj`kxm`n n inakdpxjn rkonxmpjun `k ympmdy

Rnxmimyn# O`khmc`k

pkak m@k{y>


8/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


6

rnxukdp{xm# O `khmc`k pkak m @k{y> &=?:* dkdf{am`kypmy imcmaj`m`ky pkxjm ynhxkujd`n dm uj`m `m}{kckfnaka$ Amy dn anakdpn }{k @k{y `kij`j{ xkyrnd`kxmn inakdpxjn `k ympmdy# n rxnhckam `n ynexjakdpn `kO yk pnxdm n ikdpxn `my mpkdky dm dmxxmpjum$ jarnxpmdpk nhykxumxany dkypk indpkvpn }{k n mi{ym`nxdn }{kypjndm m jdpklxj`m`k `k O rkx yk# amy yja manpjumn `kck ka rkxamdkikx jdpklxn k xkpn? K uni

mifm }{k O pkak m @k{y m pxnin `k dm`m> &=?: Wajdfmpxm`{nQ*$ Ka n{pxmy rmcmuxmy# n }{k n mi{ym`nx kyp}{kxkd`n mxl{akdpmx m}{j m ukx`m`kjxm anpjumn`m}{kcm xkcjljnyj`m`k kck pkak m @k{y inan {amamdkjxm `k rxnpklkx k m{akdpmx y{my xj}{kmy &ukxejl{xm =*$ Dkypk rxjakjxn jcnln kdpxk @k{y k ympmdy# mkvrxkyyn p{`n n }{k kck pka mrmxkik pxy ukzky &=?=2#

==# =8* dmy rmcmuxmy `n mi{ym`nx# `md`n m kdpkd`kx }{km rxjdijrmc xmn rnx `kpxy `m}{kcm jdpklxj`m`k kxkpj`n kxm n jdpkxkyyk rxrxjn `k rxnpklkx k rkxrkp{mxm y{m xj}{km$ cljin }{k kypm mi{ymn dn `jxjlj`m mO rxjamxjmakdpk# amy m @k{y$ N }{k ympmdy }{kx

anypxmx }{k djdl{a dm ukx`m`k pkak m @k{y k yk`kyujm `n amc rkcn lkd{dn `kykon `k kypmx kaina{dfn ina n yk{ @k{y$ Pn`m kypm jdpklxj`m`k }{k@k{y induj`mum ympmdy m indyj`kxmx kxm ujypm rkcnmi{ym`nx inan {am rnyp{xm hmypmdpk indukdjkdpk rmxmmcl{a ina O$ @m n `kymejn rxnrnypn rkcn mi{ym`nx?kypkd`k# rnxa# m an# k pnim!cfk ka p{`n }{mdpn kckpka# k ukxy yk dn hcmyekam indpxm pj dm p{m emik

&=?==*$ Nhykxuk }{k n mi{ym`nx kyp mrndpmd`n p{`n n}{k kck pka inan m rnyyukc anpjumn rmxm m y{mjdpklxj`m`k k kvmpmakdpk inan xkyrnypm m kypmrxnrnypm `k ympmdy }{k ny mindpkijakdpny `n cjuxnmindpkika$ N Ykdfnx mikjpm n `kymejn rxnrnypn rkcnmi{ym`nx `k kypkd`kx m an ynhxk p{`n n }{k kck pka$Rnxpmdpn# m ykl{d`m xkypxjn jarnypm rkcn m{pnxrxnhk!dny `k mpxjh{jx }{mc}{kx n{pxm xmn mnynexjakdpn `k O ykdn m}{kck rxnrnypn dn rxcnln @k{y kypmx pkypmd`n m jdpklxj`m`k `k O$


9/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


:

Ejl{xm = O =?:!=8

Rkxl{dpm : Kdpn# xkyrnd`k{ ympmdy mn Ykdfnx?

Rnxukdp{xm O pkak mn Ykdfnx m pxnin `kdm`m>

Mi{ymn =2 Mimyn# dn ikximypk ina ykhk#m kck# m y{m imym k m p{`n n }{k kck pka>M nhxm `k y{my any mhkdnmypk#k ny yk{y hkdy yk a{cpjrcjimxma dm pkxxm$

@kymejn == Kypkd`k# rnxa# m an#k pnim!cfk ka p{`n }{mdpn pka#K ukxy yk dn hcmyekam indpxm pj dm p{memik$

Rkxajyyn =8 @jyyk n Ykdfnx m ympmdy?Kjy }{k p{`n }{mdpn kck pka kyp ka pk{rn`kx7Ynakdpk indpxm kck dn kypkd`my m an$K ympmdy ymj{ `m rxkykdm `n Ykdfnx$

M pkxikjxm xkypxjn jarnypm rkcn m{pnx pxmpm `m xkcmnkvjypkdpk kdpxk ympmdy k my imcmaj`m`ky }{kynhxkujkxma m O$ `k empn y{xrxkkd`kdpk# inan oakdijndmany mdpky# }{k dkdf{a `ny majlny `k O kadkdf{a anakdpn dn cjuxn jdpkjxn pkdfm yk }{kxukdpjcm`n m rnyyjhjcj`m`k `k kvrcjimx n ynexjakdpn `k Oka xkcmn m mcl{am jdpkxekxdijm ympdjim$ Dn

nhypmdpk kypk empn# @k{y mimhm ykd`n n djin }{k ykxkyrndymhjcjm rkcmy mecjky `k O &8?9*$ N rxrxjn Odn kdindpxn{ dkdf{am n{pxm kvrcjimn rmxm y{myjp{mn ykdn m mn `jxkpm `k @k{y im{ymd`n m}{jcnka y{m uj`m$ Nhykxuk m amdkjxm indyjypkdpk ka }{k kypminarxkkdyn `k O yk `kykduncuk dn cjuxn?

&8?=2* Pkany xkikhj`n n hka `k @k{y k dn xkikhkxmanypmaha n amc>

&9?89* Rnx }{k yk indik`k c{z mn fnaka i{on imajdfn ni{cpn# k

m }{ka @k{yikxin{ `k pn`ny ny cm`ny>


10/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


=2

&5?0* Rnx}{k my eckifmy n Pn`n Rn`kxnyn kypn ka ajaixmum`my# k n ak{ kyrxjpn ynxuk n ukdkdn `kcmy7 ny pkxxnxky `k

@k{y yk mxxkljakdpma indpxm aja$&:?89* M pkxxm kyp kdpxkl{k dmy any ny rkxukxyny7 k @k{ymjd`m inhxk n xnypn `ny o{ky `kcm7 yk dn kck n im{ym`nx `jypn#kdpn }{ka >&:?90* Pjxk kck W@k{yQ m y{m umxm `k ijam `k aja# k dn ak

mak`xndpk n yk{ pkxxnx$&=2?=9* Kypmy injymy# my ni{cpmypk dn pk{ inxmn7 amy hka ykj n}{k xkyncukypk indpjln akyan$&=8?:* ]{mc kdpxk pn`ny kypky dn ymhk }{k m an `n Ykdfnx ekjypn>&=9?8=* Mcjujm m p{m an `k ynhxk aja# k dn ak kyrmdpk n pk{pkxxnx$&=5?


11/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


==

dny ynexjakdpny `k O> @k minx`n ina m kypx{p{xm `ncjuxn# n rmrkc `k ympmdy kxm n `k mi{ymx m jdpklxj`m`k `kO k inan xky{cpm`n }{kypjndmx m ckljpjaj`m`k `n yk{pkanx m @k{y$ Ympmdy dn `kuk# rnxpmdpn# ykx ujypninan m nxjlka `n ynexjakdpn# `k minx`n ina m rxnrnypm`n cjuxn$ Dm ejl{xm 0 k{ pkdpn `kandypxmx inan ndmxxm`nx ykl{k indyjypkdpkakdpk {am rmxm`jlam }{kdny mo{`m m rkxikhkx y{m demyk$ Dn rxjakjxn k ykl{d`npkypky &ukx ejl{xm 9# ykpm = k 9*# ympmdy dn kyp rk`jd`n

rkxajyyn rmxm mecjljx m uj`m `k O# mdpky# kck rk`k rmxm}{k @k{y n emm- Rnx indykl{jdpk# dy `kukxmany ckx mykdpkdm Kjy }{k p{`n }{mdpn kck pka kyp ka pk{rn`kx &=?=8* inan {am xkyrnypm mn rk`j`n ekjpn rnx

ympmdy# {am xkyrnypm }{k `kyixkuk n mpn `k kdpxklmx muj`m `k O dmy any `n mi{ym`nx$ Kypm jdpkxrxkpmnrn`k rmxkikx mxpjejijmc }{md`n yk `jyi{pk ny rxjakjxny`njy imrp{cny# amy }{md`n m`kdpxmany dn indpk`n `ny`jcnlny kdpxk O k yk{y majlny# kypm indujin yk pnxdmim`m uk amjy dpj`m$

Ykxjm pmaha jarnxpmdpk jd`mlmxany? `k }{k amdkjxmkypm exmyk &Kjy }{k p{`n }{mdpn kck pka kyp ka pk{

rn`kx* xkrxkykdpm {am xkyrnypm mn rk`j`n k ympmdy

&$$$ kypkd`k# rnxa# m an# k pnim!cfk ka p{`n }{mdpn kckpka*> Rnx }{k @k{y kdpxklmxjm m uj`m `k O dmy any `kympmdy yk n rk`j`n enj rmxm }{k n rxrxjn @k{y nmecjljyyk> Yk n }{k @k{y }{kx rxnumx rmxm ympmdy }{km xkpj`n `k O dn jdpkxkyykjxm# kdpn n pkypk pka }{kykx akyan `m rmxpk `k @k{y$ O rxkijym kvrkxjakdpmx

xkikhkx rkxykl{jn# `kypx{jn k anxpk `my any }{kykarxk cfk indik`kxma emxp{xm k rxnyrkxj`m`k# k mj yjarn`kxkany ymhkx yk kck pkak m @k{y jd`krkd`kdpk `my{m ynxpk$ jypn }{k @k{y `kykom anypxmx m ympmdy inan pkypk7 jypn }{k ympmdy kyp rmlmd`n rmxm ukx$ Mpnd`k rn`kany ckx dm dmxxmpjum# dkypm `jxkn }{k mpxmam umj k `kuk yk kykdxncmx$ Rnxpmdpn# m xkyrnypmrmxm kypm rkxl{dpm &rnx }{k @k{y kdpxklmxjm O dmyany `k ympmdy* kyp `jxkpmakdpk xkcmijndm`m mnrmrkc

}{k ympmdy pka dm pxmam `m dmxxmpjum$


12/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


=8

M lxmd`k amjnxjm `ny kyp{`jnyny rxkekxk myy{ajx }{k@k{y pkdfm `m`n rkxajyyn rmxm ympmdy `kypx{jx p{`n

n }{k O pjdfm &dn imyn `n rxjakjxn pkypk* k mecjljx y{mimxdk k yk{y nyyny &dn imyn `n ykl{d`n pkypk*# ina m

xkypxjn `k dn mpjdljx nrxrxjn O dn rxjakjxn pkypk k my{m mcam dn ykl{d`n pkypk$ F uxjny rxnhckamy inakypm mejxamn$ Rxjakjxn# n rmrkc `kypk rkxyndmlkarmxkik pkx yj`n n `k indyj`kxmx m uj`m `my rkyynmy# n{ykom# md`mx ka h{yim `k `kyujny anxmjy k jdj}j`m`ky }{kr{`kyyka kypmx myynijm`ny ina m}{kcky }{k ykmrxkykdpma `jmdpk `k @k{y inan yk{y ejcfny$ N{ ykom#kypk rkxyndmlka em n rmrkc `k {a m{`jpnx anxmcindpxmpm`n rnx @k{y rmxm mljx dn akjn `ny yk{y ejcfny$Dn enj kypm m rkxl{dpm jdjijmc `k @k{y> Nhykxumypk muj`m `n ak{ ykxun O> Myyja ykd`n# dn imhk mn ckjpnxa{`mx n{ `kyjldmx {a dnun rmrkc rmxm ny rkxyndmlkdy`m dmxxmpjum$ Ykl{d`n# m j`jm `k indyj`kxmxm uj`m `k Ormxpj{ `n rxrxjn @k{y k dn `k ympmdy$

Inan# kdpn# `kukany kdpkd`kx m xkyrnypm `k @k{y mn

rk`j`n `k ympmdy> K{ y{ljxn }{k m xkyrnypm `k @k{y`kuk ykx cj`m c{ `n rxnryjpn `n pkypk }{k# ka mahnyny imyny# rkxamdkik n akyan? nhykxumx yk Ohcmyekamxjm indpxm emik `k @k{y &=?==7 8?;*$ @k {a cm`nkdindpxmany ympmdy mrnypmd`n dm emcyj`m`k rnx `kpxy`m jdpklxj`m`k `k O# `k n{pxn ukany @k{y indejmdpk `mjdpklxj`m`k k lkd{jdj`m`k `k yk{ ykxun$ Yka `{uj`m#kypk nrxjdijrmc rxnryjpn `m fjypxjm k# rnx kypm xmn#`kuk ykx n rxjdirjn kvklpjin }{k `kejdk n enin `k

jdpkxkyyk `k dnyym kvklkyk$ Ujypn `kypm pjim# @k{y m}{kck }{k a{`m indyj`kxmukcakdpk m y{m mpjp{`k kaxkcmn p{`n n }{k O pka$ Kck rmxm `k ikximx inaykhkp{`n n }{k kck pka &=?=2*# mhkdnmx my nhxmy `ky{m an k a{cpjrcjimx yk{y hkdy k inakm m kdpxklmxp{`n n }{k O pka dmy any `k ympmdy$ Ina jypn npkypk inakm$ M anpjumn mp{md`n rnx `kpxy `mjdpklxj`m`k `k O kyp mlnxm ykd`n pkypm`m$


13/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


=9

@m}{j rmxm exkdpk# imhk!dny `kejdjx n dl{cn rkcn }{mc`kukany nhykxumx n }{k pxmdyinxxkx$ N pxmhmcfn `kmindykcfmakdpn acpjrcn indik`j`n rkcny majlny `k Ormxkik pkx yk indypjp{`n d{am pkxikjxm k amjy ykukxmmecjn$ Ncfmd`n `m rkxyrkipjum `k O# n rxnhckam dn dka }{ka `kypx{j{ &yk ympmdy# ny Ymhk{y n{ n ukdpn `k@k{y* dka n }{k enj `kypx{`n# amy yja n anpjun }{kckun{ @k{y a{`mx `k xkrkdpk$ Inan `kandypxmanymdpkxjnxakdpk# O rmxkik kypmx amjy rkxp{xhm`n ina npkxxnx `k @k{y }{k dn yk memypm `kck `jm k dnjpk &5?0* `n}{k rxnrxjmakdpk ina m rkx`m `k y{m emacjm k `k yk{yhkdy$

Rxjakjxn dl{cn? N Rkxjln `my Ykakcfmdmy

N `jcnln pxmum`n kdpxk O k yk{y majlny jc{ypxm hka n`jckam `k {am lkxmn `k rmypnxky k c`kxky }{k dnindykl{ka amjy xkyrnd`kx mny `kymejny `k {am dnumkxm ina my ekxxmakdpmy }{k ymhka amd{ykmx$ Ny majlny

`k O mrxkd`kxma m mhnx`mx m mecjn f{amdm mrkdmy `k{am djim pjim n imypjln `k @k{y ynhxk n rkim`nf{amdn$ Yk m yjp{mn ina m }{mc kcky kypn cj`md`n ymjenxm `m}{kck rkxejc n{ yk pnxdm amjy kcmhnxm`m `n }{k nrmxm`jlam ina n }{mc mrxkd`kxma pxmhmcfmx# m xkmn ykarxk m akyam kcky xkinxxka m{pnxj`m`k `k y{myxkyrnypmy m `kyrkjpn `k ykxka n{ dn mrcjiukjy yjp{mn ka }{kypn$

@k minx`n ina n rmxm`jlam `ny majlny `k O# n o{ypnd{dim rkxkik dka {a jdnikdpk kypx{`n$ Cnln# ykkvjypk `kypx{jn `kuk fmukx i{crm$ K ka fmukd`n i{crm#n ynexjakdpn xky{cpmdpk `m `kypx{jn ykxuk inan m`jyijrcjdm `n Pn`n Rn`kxnyn$ Pkcnlny k c`kxky `nimcjhxk `k Kcjem kypn indukdij`ny }{k y{my xkyrnypmyyn inxxkpmy# rnjy kcky o xkyrnd`kxma a{jpmy ukky myjp{mky ykakcfmdpky nd`k kypmy akyamy rmcmuxmy ykanypxmxma ukx`m`kjxmy k mrcjiukjy$ Myyja ykd`n# mync{n }{k kcky pa m nekxkikx m O yjarcky k nhokpjum?Kjy }{k jypn o n fmukany jd}{jxj`n# k myyja 7 n{uk!n k


14/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


=0

ak`jpm djypn rmxm n pk{ hka &O ;?8 M rxnrnypm `k Kcjem jc{ypxm hkam pkdpmn `k pkcnlny k c`kxky ka mrxkykdpmxxkyrnypmy xk}{kdpm`my rmxm rxnhckamy ykakcfmdpky$

Dn imyn `k O# rkcn akdny# kypm mrmxkdpk ykakcfmdm ykpnxdn{ d{am lxmd`k mxam`jcfm rmxm yk{y majlny$ Pn`mm inyanujyn kypx{p{xmd`n m ync{n `k Kcjem kdpxm ka

incmryn yk kcky myy{ajxka }{k O rn`k kypmx ikxpn7 nindenxpn }{k kck pka m nekxkikx `krkd`k `m indejyyn `ki{crm `m rmxpk `k O$ Myyja# m mxam`jcfm kyp andpm`m kO yk kdindpxm kdi{xxmcm`n `jmdpk {am djim mcpkxdmpjum$

Rmxm n ckjpnx# kypm mxam`jcfm rn`k ykx emijcakdpk`kymxam`m# yk m rxnrnypm nxjljdmc `n m{pnx `n cjuxn enxckum`m ka indyj`kxmn$ Inan ujany mdpkxjnxakdpk# nynexjakdpn `k O yk `kuk kvic{yjumakdpk mn pkypk

rxnrnypn rnx ympmdy k mikjpn rkcn Ykdfnx$ Mjd`m }{k Oykom {a rkim`nx k pkdfm inakpj`n }{mc}{kx cmryn ka

Kjy }{k jypn o n fmukanyjd}{jxj`n# k myyja 7 n{uk!n kak`jpm djypn rmxm n pk{ hka$

&O ;$8


15/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


=;

y{m uj`m# m xmn rnx `kpxy `n ynexjakdpn }{k n cjuxn`kyixkuk pka }{k ykx kdpkd`j`m ina nxj{d`m `n pkypkrxnrnypn dn jdijn `m dmxxmpjum$ N ckjpnx dn pka n`jxkjpn `k mcpkxmx n{ rxnrnx {a `kyekifn mcpkxdmpjunrmxm n cjuxn$ {am }{kypn akpn`ncljim k anxmc `kmikjpmx n{ dn m}{jcn }{k n dmxxm`nx hhcjin kypina{djimd`n-

Onfd Lnc`jdlmz ujy{mcjm kypk ikdxjn ixjm`n rkcnymajlny `k O k mckxpm pkcnlny k cj`kxky rmxm m`jeji{c`m`k ikdpkdxjm `k rxnikyymx mejxamky `jypjdpmyrxnik`kdpky `my Kyixjp{xmy$ ak`j`m }{k kypm`jeji{c`m`k rkxamdkik yka {am ync{n ympjyempxjm# nyckjpnxky `n cjuxn `k O un yk ukd`n dn `jxkjpn `k ckljycmxka im{ym rxrxjm# `kij`jd`n mhmd`ndmx kypmrxkni{rmn ina {am ckjp{xm jdpklxmc `n cjuxn# {amckjp{xm }{k indyjlm rxnikyymx pmdpn my jdenxamkyindpj`my dn rxcnln k krcnln inan my jdenxamkyindpj`my dny `jcnlny$

Ka y{am# m rkxl{dpm rxjdijrmc dkypk myy{dpn mykl{jdpk? m inkxdijm akdijndm`m rnx Lnc`jdlmz dkikyyxjm n{ nrijndmc> Yk enx nrijndmc# n `jckam ixjm`nrnx Kcjem dn kvjypk# k O rxnumukcakdpk kypmxjm kxxm`nka xki{ymx m `jyijrcjdm `n Ykdfnx$ Yk m inkxdijm enxdkikyyxjm# kdpn n ckjpnx pka m nhxjlmn anxmc `kxkyrkjpmx m jdpkdn m{pnxmc `n cjuxn$ M yjp{mn `k O kxmykakcfmdpk mny imyny }{k Kcjem rnyyjukcakdpk pjdfmpxmpm`n mdpkxjnxakdpk# amy dn kxm j`dpjim$ Fmujm

dnumy umxjukjy# dnuny kckakdpny inarnd`n n }{m`xn`n ynexjakdpn `k O$ Amjy jarnxpmdpk `n }{k mikjpmx n{dn m rxnrnypm `n m{pnx `n cjuxn mikjpmx mrxkd`kx

ina kck m xkyrkjpn `k {am yjp{mn }{k n ckjpnx dninarxkkd`k dka mikjpm rnx inarckpn$ ]{ka ymhk# dnejdmc `n cjuxn ifklmxkany akyam indic{yn `n rxrxjnO# n }{mc `jyyk pkx emcm`n `k injymy }{k dn indfkijm rnxinarckpn$


16/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


=5

Ykl{d`n dl{cn? N Rkxjln `my @jekxkdmy

N cjuxn `k O dn nekxkik {am mcpkxdmpjum ykdn mikjpmx mamdkjxm inan n m{pnx andpn{ n mxl{akdpn `n cjuxn$ Rnxamjy kypxmdfn }{k rnyym rmxkikx# O kyp ynexkd`nkvmpmakdpk rnx ykx {a fnaka o{ypn# }{k pkak m @k{y kyk `kyujm `n amc$ Eijc n{ `jeijc `k kdpkd`kx n{ mikjpmx#kypm m ukx`m`k cjpkxxjm mrxkykdpm`m rmxm n ckjpnx dnjdijn `n cjuxn$ cljin }{k kypm dn m amdkjxm }{k@k{y cj`m ina yk{y ejcfny indypmdpkakdpk# k dka m

rxnrnypm `n cjuxn `k kypmhkckikx n imyn `k O inan {armxm`jlam$ Inan `jyyk mijam# n ynexjakdpn `k O `kukykx mhnx`m`n mrkdmy inan m rxnrnypm nekxkij`m dnjdijn `m dmxxmpjum# m ymhkx# pkypmx m anpjumn rnx`kpxy `m jdpklxj`m`k `k O$ Dm`m amjy dm`m akdny$ K{xkindfkn }{k n kdpkd`jakdpn }{k n m{pnx pka `k @k{ykyp# mp ikxpn rndpn# ka `jyynddijm ina rkxejc }{ka{jpny pkcnlny k c`kxky mpxjh{ka m @k{y$ Pn`mujm# kypmmrmxkdpk `jyynddijm `kuk ykx kdpkd`j`m inan emkd`n

rmxpk `m kypxmpljim xkpxjim nxjljdmc `n cjuxn$ InanRncjd mejxam#

M indexndpmn `kypmy jdindyjypdijmy rmxpk `mkypx{p{xm k akdymlka `n cjuxn$ My pkdpmpjumy `k xkanu!cmy rn`ka ykx imxmipkxjzm`my inan {a mpm}{k `kdkxuny mim`ajin `m akyam amdkjxm }{k m mhnx`mlka{djcmpkxmc `ny majlny `k O ka emik mn yk{ ynexjakdpnpmaha {a mpm}{k `k dkxuny$ Dn jdp{jpn `k xkanukxkypmy jdindyjypdijmy# mcl{dy pkcnlny mimhmxmaxkanukd`n m rxrxjm akdymlka `n cjuxn$

Inakdpmd`n m mejxamn `k Rncjd# Hmxpfncnak|mixkyikdpm mjd`m }{k n lxmd`k emyidjn `kypm rxnrnypmincnim`m rkcn m{pnx `n cjuxn `k O }{k m anxmc `m

fjypxjm umj ykx myyjajcm`m dn rnx m}{kcky }{k kujpma

indpxm`jky k jdindyjypdijmy# amy yja rnx m}{kcky }{kmikjpma n `kymejn `k jdpklxmx indpxm`jn ina xkync{n$


17/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


=


18/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


=6

rxnrnxn k jdo{ypjejiukc mny ncfny `k O$ ]{md`n akxkejxn m fnypjcj`m`k m}{j# m xkekxdijm dn mrkdmy mny

rxjakjxny `njy pkypky dn rxcnln `ncjuxn# amy kyrkijmcakdpk mn pkxxnx `k@k{y }{k dn yk memypn{ `k O rnx pn`nn cjuxn$ O dn imrp{cn ykpk `n cjuxn Ormxkik dn mlkdpmx amjy m mecjnkyrjxjp{mc rxnunim`m dn rkcnyjarxnrxjny `k yk{y majlny n{ rkcmrkx`m `k p{`n n }{k kck pjdfm# amy rkcmfnypjcj`m`k }{k kck ixjm ujx `n rxrxjn@k{y$

&


19/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


=:

inakm m rkxikhkx }{k n rxrxjn @k{y a{`n{ my xklxmy

`n onln dm amdkjxm inan yk{y ejcfny `kuka yk

xkcmijndmx ina kck$ Kypm mejxamn `k O dkypk rndpnindejxam ajdfm pkyk `k }{k n pkypk rxnrnypn rnx @k{yy e{dijndmxjm yk O rkxikhkyyk }{k m akyam an }{kykarxk mhkdnn{ mlnxm yk pxmdyenxan{ dm rxjdijrmcendpk `k fnypjcj`m`k$ Kypk ikdxjn incnim O hkjxm `m pnkyrkxm`m indejyyn rnx rmxpk `k ympmdy? hcmyekamxindpxm m emik `k @k{y$ M hcmyeajm }{k ympmdy pjdfm kaakdpk kxm {am mpjp{`k }{k kvrxkyymyyk n xkukxyn `npkanx m @k{y# n{ ykom# m mi{ymn minarmdfm`m `kxkixjajdmn$

Rnxpmdpn# m dyjm `k j`kdpjejimx {a i{crm`n dm dmxxmpjumyk pnxdm jl{mcakdpk d{am mxam`jcfm# rnjy kcm dny pjxm`n ukx`m`kjxn enin `n cjuxn k mxxkakpk!dny dmindp{xhm`m xkcmn kdpxk ny rkxyndmlkdy$ J`kdpjejimx ni{crm`n rkcn ynexjakdpn `k O dn n rxjdijrmcrxnryjpn `n cjuxn k# rnx im{ym `jypn# dn `kuk ykx {aprjin }{k pnak indpm `m `jyi{yyn$ Kypm enj m

rxkni{rmn hyjim `ny majlny `k O? kvrcjimx nynexjakdpn rkcm j`kdpjejimn `n i{crm`n$ Kypm akyamrxkni{rmn rnyyjukcakdpk ckun{ pkcnlny ina \mzdkLx{`ka dklmx }{mc}{kx kduncujakdpn `jxkpn `k @k{yina n ynexjakdpn `k O `jzkd`n }{k xkyrndymhjcjzmx

@k{y rkcn amc }{k Kck ek xkimjx ynhxk O ujm mlkdpkyyki{d`xjny ykxjm {a rkim`n$ O dn ek jypn# myKyixjp{xmy d{dim emka jypn k dka dy `kukxmanyemzkx$ N akyan `kyujn `k jdpkxkyyk rxmpjim`n rnx

`jukxyny n{pxny inakdpmxjypmy$ Pn`m pkdpmpjum `k pkdpmxmo{`mx @k{y yk `kekd`kx `my jdyjd{mky `k O `k }{kKck kypmum rnx `kpxy `k p{`n yk indypjp{j d{am rkx`m `kenin# rnjy dka @k{y rxkijym `k mo{`m rmxm `kekd`kx m yjakyan dka m dmxxmpjum `kypk pjrn `k rxkni{rmn$

N lxmd`k ajypxjn m ykx `kyukd`m`n dn yk @k{ykypmum n{ dn kduncuj`n dm}{kck ynexjakdpn# amy yja `kinan O amdpkuk y{m jdpklxj`m`k ka akjn pmamdfm

mlndjm$ Inan n pkxxnx `n Pn`n Rn`kxnyn mimhn{


20/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


82

rxn`{jd`n dkck {a `kykon mjd`m amjnx `k kdindpxmxina @k{y> Mf- Yk k{ yn{hkyyk nd`k n rn`kxjm mifmx-&89?9!5*$ Inan {am r{djn pn `kyrxnrnxijndmcmimhn{ rxn`{zjd`n dkck m kyrkxmdm `k }{k yk{

Xk`kdpnx ujuk k rnx eja yk ckumdpmx ynhxk m pkxxm

&=:?8;*> Inan kck indykl{j{ mimcamx m mlndjm `m y{mmcam yka pkx xkikhj`n }{mc}{kx kvrcjimn `m rmxpk `k@k{y }{k o{ypjejimyyk p{`n n }{k kck rmyyn{> &02?9!;* Nempn `k @k{y dn pkx kvrcjim`n ka dkdf{a anakdpn mukx`m`kjxm xmn rnx `kpxy `n ynexjakdpn `k O ykindypjp{j d{a indecjpn m`jijndmc lkxm`n rkcm rxnrnypm `nm{pnx# amy }{k dn rxko{`jim ka dm`m m akdymlka }{kkck `kykom ina{djimx? m ukx`m`kjxm anpjumn `k O$

]{mxpn dl{cn? N Rxnryjpn `n Ynexjakdpn

N }{mxpn `kymejn mrxkykdpm`n rkcn m{pnx `n cjuxn pka mukx ina n rxnryjpn `n ynexjakdpn kvrkxjakdpm`n rnxO$ Ykl{d`n m rxnrnypm `n cjuxn# n m{pnx rmxkik `kymejmx!

dny ina m j`jm `k }{k dka ykarxk n ynexjakdpn pkx {aimxpkx `jyijrcjdmx$ @kxkg Gj`dkx kyp inxxkpn kaykrmxmx ynexjakdpn `k `jyijrcjdm `kdpxn `n indpkvpncjpkxxjn `n cjuxn$

@k {am uk rnx pn`my# my ikdmy `k mhkxp{xm W`n cjuxnQ`kjvma icmxn }{k n ynexjakdpn dn jarcjimdkikyymxjmakdpk ka }{mc}{kx i{crm dm ujpjam# emcfmy kay{my rxkim{ky n{ mp akyan ka y{m e$ Ykom c}{mc}{kx rmcmuxm yrkxm }{k O ukdfm `jkx krnypkxjnxakdpk xkpxmpmx# k ykom c }{mc rkim`n kck pkdfminakpj`n inan n xkypn `k dy# n rxcnln `kjvm icmxn }{kyk{ ynexjakdpn dn pka dkdf{am xkcmn ina }{mc}{kx{am `kypmy injymy$ Rnxpmdpn# cndlk `k pkx mcln m ukx inai{crm# enj kvmpmakdpk m y{m jdnidijm }{k n kvry m pn`nkypk amxpxjn# n }{k @k{y ek }{kypn `k xkjpkxmx rnx`{my ukky &=?67 8?9*$

Ynexjakdpn k `jyijrcjdm dn kypn xkcmijndm`ny {a inan n{pxn dkypk cjuxn$ Kypm m cjdfm `jujyxjm kdpxk O k


21/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


8=

yk{y majlny$ ukx`m`k }{k kypm `jypjdn dn yk mrcjimm pn`ny ny imyny `k ynexjakdpn# amy kypm rnyyjhjcj`m`k`kukxjm rkcn akdny emkx rmxpk dn akd{ `my kvrcjimkyrmxm n ynexjakdpn f{amdn$ Xnhjdynd kypmrmxkdpkakdpk emkd`n m rkxl{dpm ikxpm dkypk indpkvpn#n }{k dny mo{`m m enxa{cmx {am indpxjh{jn lkd{dm `ncjuxn `k O dkypk myy{dpn$

Yk rkxl{dpmxany `k }{k umck{ pn`n n ynexjakdpn `k O#dy ynany mxxkakpj`ny jak`jmpmakdpk rmxm my ikdmy `kmhkxp{xm `n cjuxn# m inxpk dny i{y nd`k Omu mpxjh{j mim{ym `m jdpklxj`m`k `m xkcjljn `k O y{m ej`kcj`m`k$ Mlxmd`k cjn `n cjuxn xkyj`k dn ajypxjn `kypk pkypk7 nynexjakdpn rxkijym ykx amdpj`n ynh m rxkyyn `kypkindpd{n rnx }{k> n }{mc rnx eja rkxamdkik yka

xkyrnypm$ Dka dn inakn dka dn eja `n cjuxn O jdenxam`n `kypm inxpk dny i{y# n }{k ykxjm {amkvrcjimn y{ejijkdpk rmxm yk{ ynexjakdpn$

M `jyrnyjn `n ckjpnx ka amdpkx kypk lxmd`k rnx }{k>

ka y{yrkdyn rnx pn`n n cjuxn k `krnjy u!cn rmyymx ykadkdf{am xkyrnypm xkmcakdpk mlndjmdpk$ N }{kjark`jm @k{y `k emkx n yk{ ykxun ymhkx m xmn rnx

Rnx }{k n lxmd`k rnx}{k dn enj

xkyrnd`j`n dn krcnln>


22/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


88

`kpxy `k pn`n n ninxxj`n> ]{k rxko{n jyyn pxmxjm rmxm@k{y# O n{ }{ka }{kx enyyk> Mp akyan rmxm nyckjpnxky }{k amdpjukxma n enin inxxkpn `n cjuxn# dn yk`kjvmd`n ckumx rkcmy rxkyyky incnim`my rkcny majlny`k O# dka imxma ka dkdf{am `my mxam`jcfmyakdijndm`my mdpkxjnxakdpk# mp kypky yk uka y ukkyex{ypxm`ny ina n `kyekifn `n cjuxn$ Rnx }{k n lxmd`krnx }{k> dn enj xkyrnd`j`n dn krcnln> Kypmyrkxl{dpmy mpkypma jdindyijkdpkakdpk {a `kyujn `nrxnryjpn jdjijmc `n cjuxn$ N rxnryjpn `n pkypk kxm n `kxkukcmx m ympmdy m ukx`m`kjxm anpjumn `k O k dn n`k kvrcjimx m xmn `n ynexjakdpn f{amdn$ Mjd`m }{k mfjypxjm pkdfm i{cajdm`n dkypm jdpkdym kvrkipmpjum `k{am xkyrnypm mn rnx }{k># {am xkyrnypm kvrcjimpjumindpkd`n my jdenxamky }{k kdlkd`xmxma pn`n namxpxjn `k O mn ak{ ukx pjxmxjm m demyk ejdmc k`kejdjpjum ina xkyrkjpn m anpjumn `m}{kck fnaka$ Mnpkxajdmx n cjuxn `kypm amdkjxm# n m{pnx induj`m!dny mindikhkx m j`jm `k {a ynexjakdpn }{k ujym amdjekypmn `m amjy rxne{d`m rjk`m`k$ Rmxm Xnhjdynd#

kypk pjrn `k rjk`m`k dn rn`k d{dim ykx mpkypm`m ykdnrkcm rxnum# rnjy m }{kypn umj a{jpn mca `n fnxjndpk`m rkyynm }{k kyp ykd`n pkypm`m$ M anpjumn `m}{kck}{k `kij`k pkak!cn pka {a umcnx jdpxdykin rmxm @k{y# n}{mc indyj`kxm yk{ kduncujakdpn ina rkyynmy inan Od{a dukc a{jpn amjy mcpn `n }{k {am yjarckynhykxumn `k rxkikjpny k amd`makdpny$

Indic{ynInan ujany# m ckjp{xm jdpklxmc `n cjuxn `k O {ammxxnom`m amxmpndm kvklpjim imrm `k xkukcmxxmrj`makdpk dnyyn `kyrxkrmxn k m dkikyyj`m`k `k {amcndlmakdpn amjy inarckpn$ Ekcjzakdpk m nhxm enj

ajd{ijnymakdpk nxlmdjm`m &{a pxmhmcfn `jujdn-* rmxmcj`mx ina a{jpmy jarcjimky k inarcjimky `n myy{dpn

ka }{kypn$ My rmcmuxmy }{k ml{ma dnyymindypkxdmn d{a imrp{cn yn ykarxk ykl{j`my `k rnx


23/24


@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


89

rnd`kxmky }{k mimhma xkukcmd`n dnyyn `kykon ukcm`nrnx o{ypjm$ M akdymlka ikdpxmc `n cjuxn &m anpjumn `mxkcjljn `k O* rn`kxjm ykx `jpm `k a{jpmy n{pxmyamdkjxmy# amy n m{pnx xkyncuk{ mhnx`mx n pkam ujm kypkypkypky rxkrmxm`ny rnx @k{y$ Inan o `jyi{pjany mdpky# mjdpxn`{n enxm n ckjpnx d{am `jxkn kyrkiejim#mckxpmd`n!dny ykarxk `n rkxjln `k pnamx my `nxky `k Oa{jpn ik`n dm dmxxmpjum$

Mixk`jpn }{k m akdymlka `kypk cjuxn dny kdyjdm#ynhxkp{`n# m ckx ny rn`kxnyny mpny `jujdny ina ny ncfny}{k kck akyan dny indik`k ka y{m rmcmuxm$ Dn imyn `ncjuxn `k O# m rkxyrkipjum `kejdj`m dn rxcnln yn nyncfny nekxkij`ny rkcn rxrxjn @k{y k rnx jyyn# akyan}{md`n incj`jd`n ina n jdpkxkyyk `n ckjpnx# kcm `kukl{jmx m `jxkn `k dnyymy indic{yky$ M ajdfm rxnrnypm }{k kypkomany mpkdpny rmxm ny dukjy indic{yjuny dmdmxxmpjum$ N{ ykom# n ckjpnx rxkijym ykx imrm `kj`kdpjejimx ny rndpny ix{ijmjy dm dmxxmpjum ka }{kindic{yky k nrjdjkyejdmjy kypn ykd`n xkukcm`my# mn

jduy `k `kpkx!yk ka myrkipny jyncm`ny n{ nrjdjky }{kykxn rnypkxjnxakdpk indpkypm`my rkcn rxrxjndmxxm`nx$ Dkypk ykdpj`n# y{ljxn }{k ncfkany rmxm myukx`m`ky `n pkvpn `k minx`n ina ny dukjy indic{yjunyka }{k kcmy yk kdindpxma$

Dukc 9? dmxxm`nxDukc 8? dmxxmpjum

Dukc =? rkxyndmlka

Ykl{jd`n kypk rmxm`jlam# rn`kany mejxamx# rnxkvkarcn# }{k n dukc `k indfkijakdpn amdjekypm`n rkcnrkxyndmlka# m}{jcn }{k kck emcm n{ indic{j# dn rn`komamjy ykx incnim`n mijam `m}{jcn }{k enj mejxam`n dndukc 9# }{md`n n dmxxm`nx ejdmcjm m y{m indic{ynynhxk n pkam mhnx`m`n$ Ykxjm kypxjpmakdpk emcmijnynpjxmx indic{yky }{k indyj`kxka mrkdmy ny dukjy = k 8#


24/24

@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox


mjd`m }{k n dukc 9 yk xkypxjdom m {a ukxyn `kdpxn `kpn`n n cjuxn$ Yk dm}{kck djin ukxyn m nrjdjn `ndmxxm`nx enj amdjekypm`m# kcm pka rxkekxdijm ynhxk nyn{pxny dukjy `k indfkijakdpn# kyrkijmcakdpk yk kypmdjim amdjekypmn kypmhkckik {a x{an `jekxkdpk rmxm mjdpkxrxkpmn$

Ynhxk n m{pnx

@mdjkc Ymdpny Ox rxnekyynx `k Mdpjln Pkypmakdpn dn Ikdpxn `kRy!lxm`{mn Md`xk| O{arkx ka Yn Rm{cn$`ymdpnyBamigkdjk$hx

Indfkm nEmikhnng `n Md`xk| O{arkxIndfkm nYjpk nejijmc `n Md`xk| O{arkx
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.facebook.com/pages/Centro-Presbiteriano-de-P%C3%B3s-Gradua%C3%A7%C3%A3o-Andrew-Jumper/149305211760418http://www.facebook.com/pages/Centro-Presbiteriano-de-P%C3%B3s-Gradua%C3%A7%C3%A3o-Andrew-Jumper/149305211760418http://www.facebook.com/pages/Centro-Presbiteriano-de-P%C3%B3s-Gradua%C3%A7%C3%A3o-Andrew-Jumper/149305211760418http://www.mackenzie.br/cpajhttp://www.mackenzie.br/cpajhttp://www.mackenzie.br/cpajhttp://www.mackenzie.br/cpajhttp://www.facebook.com/pages/Centro-Presbiteriano-de-P%C3%B3s-Gradua%C3%A7%C3%A3o-Andrew-Jumper/149305211760418mailto:[email protected]

Por que não falaram a verdade para Jó?

Documents

Transcript of Por que não falaram a verdade para Jó?