2003 BECTHMK CAHKT-I7ETEPGYPTCKOTO Y H H B E P C N T E T A Cep. 5 . B b l n . 4 (N? 2 9 )

E.A. Epacosa

3 K O J I O T M 3 A ~ ~ lTPOM3BOACTBA KAK YCJIOBME KOHKYPEHTOCIIOCOIGHOCTM HA MMPOBbLX PbIHKAX

K O H K ~ ~ ~ H T O C ~ O C O ~ H O C T ~ npOki3BOfiCTBa B OTAenbHbIX CTpaHaX M HX npOnyKL(MM H a

MMPOBbIX PbIHKaX B HaCTOIIIl(ee B p e M R HaXOnUTCII B np11~0fi 3aBMCMMOCTU OT p a 3 p a 6 0 ~ K k i M

p e m ~ s a u ~ w s ~ o n o r ~ ~ e c ~ o i i c r p a T e r a M K o M n a H u u , OT TOTO, H a c K o n b K o n o c n e n o B a - r e n b H o MMM

PeLLIamTCR n p 0 6 n e M b l 3KOnOrM3aaMtr npOM3BOnCTBa M YMeHblllaIOTCR HeTaTMBHble lIOCneACTBMII

3KOJlOTMYeCKMX PMCKOB.

B M ~ C T ~ C T e M KOHKYPeHTHbIe n p e H M Y U e C T B a T a ~ 0 f i CTPaTerUki Ollpe.4enRK)TCR ki YpOBHeM

O ~ O C H O B ~ H M I I M PeUIeHMR npo6ne~ 3 a w M T b I ~ K p ~ X a l O I l ( e f i C p e A b l B HaUMOHaJlbHblX M

M e m Y H a P O A H b I X 3KOJIOTMYeCKMX OpTaHM3a4MIIX, O p r a H a X 3 a K 0 ~ 0 f l a ~ e n b ~ 0 f i M ~ C ~ ~ n H k i ~ e n b H ~ f i

BJIaCTM O T n e n b H b I X r O C y n a p C T B M B e n y U M X MeHcsyHapOnHbIX 3KOHOMMreCKMX M I'J'MaHMTaPHbIX

opra~a3asa11x. B n a ~ ~ o f i C T a T b e l IpeAnpkiHIITa n 0 n b I T K a KPaTKOrO CkiCTeMaTM3MPOBaHHOTO O ~ O ~ L ~ ~ H H R

M e ~ Y H a p O A H b I X ki HaIJIMOHaJlbHbIX peLLIeHMfi, H a l l p a B n e H H b I X B KOHeYHOM CYeTe H a

3KOnOrM3aUMEO lTpOM3BO.4CTBa.

H e o 6 x o n ~ ~ o c ~ b B HaL(1lOHaJlbHbIX M KOJIJIeKTMBHLlX Me.HCAYHaPOAHblX M e p a x no 3KOJlOTM3aUMM nPOM3BOACTBa M Me>KAYHaPOAHOTO TOBaPHOrO 0 6 ~ e ~ a B ~ o J I H o ~ ~ M e p e OCO3HaHa

CTpaHaMM MMpa C p a B H U T e n b H O H e n a B H O - B K O H u e 60-x - HaYZiJIe 70-x rODOB XX B.

O ~ H ~ K O nOCTaTOYH0 ~ L I C T P O B MMPOBOM C O O ~ U ~ C T B ~ CJIOXMJIaCb U e n a I I CMCTeMa

M e x n y H a p o A H b l x s K o n o r w q e c K M x o p r a ~ ~ 3 a a ~ f i : B C ~ M H ~ H ~ R KOMHCCMII no o~pyxamuek cpene M

Pli3BkiTHIO (WCED), B c e M k i p ~ b l f i ~ P O M ~ I U I ~ ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ COBeT no 0 ~ p y X a K l u e f i C p e A e (WICE), Koanuu~rr B n0JIAepXKy ~ K O J I O ~ M ~ ~ C K O ~ OTBeTCTBeHHOCTki K O M ~ ~ H M ~ ~ (CERES), K O H C ~ ~ ~ T ~ T U B H ~ I ~ ~ KOMMTeT no n p o 6 n e ~ a ~ 6 ~ 3 ~ e c a tr 0 ~ p y x a K l L U e f i C p e n b I (ACBE), rpynna rATT no s K o n o r u r e c K u M M e p a M u ~ e w y ~ a p o n ~ o f i T o p r o m e (EMIT group), KOMHT~T BTO no T o p r o m e w o~pyxamwefi cpene I? np.

~ O C K O J I ~ K Y 3KOJIOrW3aUMR 3KOHOMMKH ~ p e 6 y e ~ OrPOMHblX 3 a T p a T , CO3AaH U e J I b ~ f i PIIA

CIIeUkiaJlbHbIX 0 p r a ~ M 3 a u M f i , C ~ O C O ~ C T B ~ ~ O ~ M X npkiBneYeHMW CpeACTB H a UenM 3 a U I I T b I

o~pyXaml.4efi CpeAbI, MOAePHW3aUMM nPOM3BOnCTBeHHbIX T ~ x H o J I o I ' M ~ ~ M pa3BHTUII 6e30nac~ofi TOprOBJIM: f i 0 6 a J I b ~ b 1 f i 3~onor l l r ec~~f i ~ O H A Pa3BMBaKlIl(UXCR PbIHKOB (GEEMF), Ce~epo- A M ~ ~ H K ~ H C K H ~ 3 ~ 0 J I o r M q e c K M f i ~ O H A (NAEF), C K ~ H A M H ~ B C K ~ R 3 K o n o r M Y e c K a H G M H ~ H C O B ~ R K o p n o p a s m (NEFCO) M ,ap.'

EPACOBA E n e ~ a A H ~ T O ~ ~ ~ B H ~ - KaHn. 3KOH. HayK, A O U e H T K a @ e ~ p b l ~upoeoR 3KOHOMUKM C n 6 I - y . B 1982 r . OKOHIIMIIa M H ) ~ ( ~ H ~ P H O -

~ K O H O M M Y ~ C K W ~ ~ YHUBePCHTeT H El 1990 r . - a C n M p a H T y p y 3KOHOMMVeCKOrO 4 a ~ y J I b ~ e ~ a no CfleUManbHOCTM

( ( M w p o ~ o e XO~RL?CTBO U M e X A y H a p O n H b l e 3KOtlOMUVeCKUe OTHOuJeHUR)). C@epa HaYqHbIX MHTepeCOB - f l p 0 6 n e ~ b l

K O H K ~ ~ ~ H T ~ C ~ O C O ~ H O C T M ~ K C ~ O ~ T H O ~ np0A)KUWM ki HaUMOH&lbHO~O nPOM3BOAClBa , MCXAYHaPOAHaR C T a H B a ~ U 3 a U M R

flpOAyKUHH M Y C n y r , ~ e X ~ y H a p 0 a H b l f i M a p K e T U H r . A ~ r o p C B b l W e 50 HaYqHblX n y 6 n w ~ a ~ 1 u t i .

0 E . A . E p a c o e a , 2003

~ ~ Z ~ H M J ~ ~ M M HTO npeAyCMaTpMBaloTCH 3 K 0 ~ 9 O f M r e C K H e MePOnPMRTMR B c@epc IlpOMBBOJCTBa M TlPM 0CJ'UeCTB;leHHM 3 K C n O p T a H MMnOpTa O I l p e A e n e H H b l X TOBapOB. ~ O R B M ~ M C ~ M

GLICTPO PiUBMBatOTCR n p e A n p H R T M R , n p O i 4 3 B O A R u M e C n e I l M W J b H y m 3KOJIOrMYeCKyW TeXHAKY.

OcoGoe 3Hi lqeHMe n p u o 6 p m d m ~ p a 3 p a 6 0 ~ ~ a M n p M M e H e H M e 3KOJIOrH.ieCKMX CTaHAapTOB M

C ~ P T M @ M K ~ ~ U M R nPOAYK4HM H a COOTBeTCTBMe T ~ ~ ~ O B ~ H M H M 3KOnOrMM. B O ~ H M K ~ W T H

COBepLUeHCTByWTCR H a q H O H U b H b I e M M e m Y H a p O f l H b I e CMCTeMbl ~ K O J I O T M Y ~ C K O ~ ~ CTaHAaPTM3allMM

M C ~ P T H @ W K ~ ~ A M . ~ P W O P W T ~ T H ~ I ~ n03MqIIM B 3TOM OTHOUIeHMM 3aHMMaeT IS0 - MeXAj 'HaPOAHaR

OpraHH3aUHR no CTaHnapTM3aUHM, K O T O p m pa3pa6a~b l~ae~ CMCTeMbI MeXAj'HaPOAHblX CTaHAaPTOB

ISO-9000 M ISO- 14000. ISO-14000 H e n o c p e n c T s e H H o o n p e n e n R e T 3 K o n o r M r e c K M e c . ra tmapTHb!e T ~ ~ ~ O B ~ H H R K

npOAyKUHbi, B ~ I X O A X ~ ~ ~ H a MHPOBbIe T O B a P H b I e PbIHKM, I4 T ~ ~ ~ o B ~ H M I ~ K 3KOnOrM.ieCKOMy

MeHeJXMeHTy H ayAMTy. TO ~ ~ ~ C T B M T ~ J I ~ H O CMCTeMa, B KOTOPYIo BXOART PYKOBOARUMe

YCTaHOBKll no O n p e n e J l e H H m YPOBHR ~ K O ~ O T M ~ ~ C K O ~ ~ ~ @ @ ~ K T M B M O C T H ~ ~ ~ A I I ~ M R T M ~ ( c ~ a t ~ 9 a p T b l

ISO- 140 14), no o u e H K e n o ~ a 3 a ~ e n e g s ~ o n o r ~ r e c ~ o i i f i e r r e n L f r o c T M n p e ~ n p n n ~ w i i M

o p r a ~ ~ 3 a u ~ i (ISO-1403 I), orrewe s~onorw~ec~o t i c o c ~ a ~ n ~ m u ~ e i H a B c e x c T a a w R x X M ~ H ~ H H O ~ O

UMKJla llpO,L(yKqHM (ISO- 14040), no CMCTeMe 3KOJIOrHYeCKOrO M e H e f l X h f e H T a (ISO- 1400 1) M ape2 M e > ~ n y ~ a p o ~ t I b l e CTaHAapThI ISO-9000 no CMCTeMaM KOHTPOJIR 3a KaYeCTBOhf DPOAYKUMM

PaCCYMTaHbI H a KOPPeKTMpOBKY HaIJHOHaJIbHblX 3KOnOrMWCKHX CTaHAapTOB M H a

COBepUeHCTBOBaHMe y c n 0 ~ M f i M ~ X A Y H ~ P O A H O ~ ' ~ o ~ ~ ~ o B J I M .

M H O ~ M ~ HaUHOHa-UbHbJe CMCTeMbI O ~ R S ~ T ~ J I ~ H O E H A O ~ P O B O ~ ~ H O ~ c ~ ~ T H $ M K ~ u M M

IIpOAyKUMM M YCJIyr H a COOTBeTCTBMe 3KOJlOrMYeCKMM T ~ ~ ~ O B ~ H M I I M OCHOBbJBaIOTCR IlpeXAe BCerO H a CTaHAapTaX ISO-9000 M ISO- 14000.

C ~ U J ~ C T B ~ ~ T yXe AOBOnbHO MHOI-0 MHOI.OCTOPOHHMX M fiBYCTOPOHHMX M e ~ y H a P O A H b I X

cornarue~ui3 M AOI-OBOPOB no ~ T I I M 11 A P Y ~ H M B o n p o c a M s ~ o n o r ~ ~ e c ~ o i ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ C H O C T M .

T ~ K , K O M M T ~ T BTO no T o p r o s n e M 0 ~ p y X a t 0 U e i i C p e D C 3aHHMaeTCR yCTaHOBneHMeM

COOTHOLUeHMIl MeXiAy npMHqMIlaMM H 3aAaYaMM T O ~ ~ O B O ~ IIOJIMTMKM C T p a H M I I O J ~ O X ~ H M R M M

; M e m y H a p o n H b l x AO~OBOPOB M cornaure~uii no oxpaae o~pyxamruefi c p e n b r . R y c n o B H x x

I - J I O ~ ~ ~ M ~ ~ U M M 3KOHOMMKM 0 6 0 c T p e ~ M 1 1 KOHKYPeHqMM H a BHYTPeHHMX M MMPOBbIX TOBaPHbIX

PblHKaX K O H K Y ~ ~ H T O C I I O C O ~ H O C T ~ nPOflYKqHM l l p e ~ I l p M R ~ ~ 6 BO BCeX C T p a H a X H a Y H H a e T BO

MHOrOM O n p e n e n R T b C R MYeHHO 3KOIIOTUYeCKMMM ee n a p a M e v a M M : C T e n e H b W COOTBeTCTBMfl

MeXRyHapOAHbIM 3KOnOTMqeCKMM C'raHAapTdM ci MCnOJIb30BaHMR 6 e 3 0 n a c ~ b r x lTPOM3BOACTBeHHblX

T ~ x H o J I o ~ M ~ ~ , 3KOJIOrMYeCKMMH M3AepXKaMH, YPOBHeM 3KOnOTMYeCKOTO M e H e A X M e H T a M a y n M T a ,

0 6 ~ 3 a ~ e n b C T ~ a ~ M no MeX,4YHaPOAHblM COr'naLUeHMFlbl 06 O X p a H e 0 ~ p y X a l O U e G n p M p 0 ~ ~ 0 f i

C ~ ~ A ~ I . ~

B TO Xe BpeMH C a b l a TpaKTOBKa 3KOnOrH'ieCKMX HOPMaTMBOB, H 3 A e P X e K M M e p a OC03HaHHR

3HaYeHMR nPMPOAOOXPaHHbIX p e L U e ~ M f i M, COOTBeTCTBeHHO, I IpaKTMKa 3KOJIOTM3aqMM

npOM3BOACTBa B P a 3 H b l X CTPaHaX, H a P a 3 H b I X IIpeAnpMRTMRX YaCTO Aal IeKO H e OnHO3HaYHa. T ~ K , HanpMMep, B ~ ~ T H $ M K ~ U M M KHOTCKOTO npOTOKOJla 3aMHTepeCOBaHbI H e BCe CTpaHb1. CYU~CTBYK)T

MHOrOYHCneHHbIe HapyIUeHMR IlPUHRTblX o ~ I I ~ ~ T ~ J I ~ c T B , OTKa3bI ~ ~ H K O B O T K p e ~ A T O B a H M H

n p e ~ n p M R ~ k i f i no 3KOnOrMYeCKMM C 0 0 6 p a X e ~ M R ~ . H a n ~ r Me C ~ ~ T H @ H K ~ T ~ IS0 1400 1, KaK

IIpaBHJIO, 3 a M C r H O y I l p O q a e T IIOJIyYeHMe KpeAMTa AncI KOMnaHMM M I l O M O r a e T G ~ H K ~ M M 3 6 e ~ a ~ b

M H B ~ C T M U M ~ B KOMIlaHMH C HU3KMM 3KOJIOrMYeCKMM P e f i ~ M ~ ~ ~ ~ . 4 M M ~ ~ T MeCTO ~ K O ~ O ~ M . ~ ~ C K M ~

LIeMnMHr, n p M KOTOPOM M3-3a YMeHbUleHMR PaCXOAOB I l a 3KOnOrMYeCKMe MepOnpHIlTHR

~ ~ ~ O C H O B ~ T ~ ~ ~ H O CHMXatOTCR 3KCiIOPTHble UeHbI. M C ~ O ~ ~ ~ Y ~ T C I I n p a K T H K a ((3eJIeHOrO

npOTeKUMOHH3Ma)) - H03ABMralOTCR AOflOnHMTenbHbIe T a M O X e H H b l e 6 a p b e p b 1 H a n y T M 3 K C n O p T a

IIpOAyKllMM B Pa3RMThle CTPaHbI M3 C T p a H C 6 0 n b L U M ~ j'AenLHblM BeCOM ((rPH3HMX)) IIPOHSBOACTB,

B nePBYtO O g e p e A b M3 pa3BI.iBaK)UIMXCR, B KOTOPble TaKMe nPOM3BOACTBa H I l e p e M e u a H 3 T C R M3

PiUBMTbIX C T ~ ~ H . '

B A ~ H H O ~ ~ CkilryaUMM B03HMKaeT H ~ O ~ X O ~ H M O C T ~ llpeWe BCWO B H a y q H O M O ~ O C H O B ~ H W I I

s K o n o r w i e c K H x ~ s n e p x e ~ u p e f i ~ ~ ~ r a s K o n o r M Y e c K o r o p M c K a n p e ~ n p m ~ ~ i i , B TOM wcne u An%

OnpeAeJIeHMR KOHKPeTHLIX ~pe60~a~k i f i K OTqeTHOCTM 0 B O ~ B ~ ~ ~ C T B H W X O ~ R ~ ~ C T B ~ H H O ~ ~

AeRTeJIbHOCTM H a O K p y X a m U y K l C p e A y .

B K a Y e c T B e O C H O B ~ I am O n p e A e n e H k f R 3 ~ 0 n o r ~ s e c ~ u x ~ s n e p x e ~ uenecoo6pa3~0 MCnOJIb3OBaTb n03EiUMI-0, M ~ ~ P ~ H H Y I O M ~ ~ Y H ~ P O A H O ~ ~ @ e ~ e p a u k i e f i 6yxran~epo~, COrnaCHO

K O T O P O ~ ~ K TaKUM M 3 n e P X K a M OTHOCRTCR:

3KOnOrMYeCKMe KanMTtiJlOBnOXeHI.IR, CBH3aHHbIe C COBePUleHCTBOBaHReM

npOM3BOjlCTBeHHbIX T e ~ H ~ J l ~ r k i f i ;

H e O T n O X H b I e n p M p O n O O X p a H H b l e M e p b I n p M 3aTPR3HeHMM npeAnpMRTMRMM

~ T M O C ~ ~ P ~ I , nOYBb1, BOAbI;

( ( O n e p a ~ M O H H b I e ) ) 3 a T p a T b I H a 0 6 p a 6 0 ~ ~ y OTXOAOB npOH3BOACTBa M H a LUTPa@b1

38 HapYLUeHMR 3KOJIOrHYeCKOrO 3aKOHOAaTenbCTBa;

HMOKP no s a q u ~ e o~pyxamwefi cpenar. 3 m a Y M IT0 3KOnOrM3aUMH npOM3BOACTBa M lIOBbILUeHMH) K O H K Y P ~ H T O C ~ O C O ~ H O C T I I

IIpOAyKUMM H a B H e U H e M P b I H K e MOTYT 6 b l T b YeTKO C @ O P M Y ~ U P O B ~ H ~ I TOnbKO IIpM O n p e n e n e H k i M

p a 3 M e p O B 3KOnOrMYeCKMX M 3 a e p X e K .

B M W T ~ C T e M KOHKYPeHTHbIe ITOSMUMI? I T p e ~ l I p M ~ ~ k i f i AOJIXHbI OUeHMBaTbCR no n p e n n a r a e M o M y M e m y H a p o n H b I M u o p r a ~ u 3 a u w x ~ u n p M H s M n y PPP - ( < s a r p ~ . j ~ ~ ~ e n b n n a T M n ) - M

( ~ o @ M ~ M ~ J I ~ H o M ~ OTYeTy 0 KOJIMYeCTBe 3 a ~ p R 3 ~ e H k i f i H a eAMHMUY IIPOAYKUMH)) (PIOR). 3 ~ o n o r u s e c ~ ~ f i PMCK n p e n n p m ~ ~ f i B KoHKypeHsMM A o c T a T o Y H o n o n H o O n p e A e n R e T c R no

n B y M ~ ~ G T H H ~ ~ M , MClTOJIb3yeMbIM B M ~ X C A Y H ~ P O ~ H O ~ IlpaKTMKe: SYBERR - CMCTeMHOMY

p e f i T M H ~ 3 K o n o r M Y e c K o r o PMCKa M ERMR - pefi~ki~Q' y n p a B n e H H I I 3KOnOrMYeCKMM PMCKOM

(Environmental Risk Management Rating). C H C T ~ M I I ~ I ~ ~ p e i i ~ ~ l ~ r 3 K o n o r M Y e c K o r o p t r c K a 6 b 1 n

ppa3pa60~a~ B B e n u ~ o 6 p w ~ a ~ ~ u H yXe B 1990-e rOAb1 XX B. nO3BOJIHJl YCTaHOBATb TaKMe

p e f i ~ k i ~ r k i nIIR 6onee YeM 330 TblC. ~ P M T ~ H C K H X K O M ~ ~ H H ~ ~ . C H C T ~ M ~ ERMR ( C O ~ ~ ~ H H ~ R T a m e B

B ~ ~ M K O ~ ~ M T ~ H M M ) nO3BOnReT O n p e A e J I R T b 3KOnOrMYeCKMe ~ c ~ ~ T M H I X I H TpaHCHaUMOHaJIbHbIX

K O M ~ ~ H M ~ ~ . '

~ P M OCYUleCTBJIeHMM 3KOJIOTU3aUMM nPOH3BOACTBa ~ e 0 6 ~ 0 ~ 1 . 1 ~ M 6onee o6w~fi P ~ ~ T H H ~ - P ~ ~ ~ T M H T 3KOJ'IOrMYeCKOTO COCTORHWR IlpeAnpARTMR. ,&I% er0 COCTaBJleHMR n O n X e H YYMTbIBaTbCR

IJenblii PRA (P~KTOPOB: Y P O B e H b OC03HaHMR 3HaYeHHR 3KOnOTMqeCKMX n p o 6 n e ~ (B TOM YHCne nJ'IR

ycneU~0fi KOHKYP~HUMII) PYKOBOACTBOM npeAIIpHRTMR M B er0 CTPYKTYPHbIX nOAPa3AeneHWRX;

C T e n e H b O~OCHOB~HHOCTM ~ K O ~ O ~ A Y ~ C K O ~ ~ C T p a T e r M t l M HOnMTMKM IIpennpMRTMR; @ U H ~ H C O B O ~

nonoxeeue npennpumarr, no3~on~1owee e M y 6 p a ~ b H a c e 6 ~ T e anti u H b r e s~onorwsec~ue 0 6 ~ 3 a T e n b c ~ ~ a ; 3KOnOrMYeCKaR P e I I y T a U u R npOAyKUMM; C T e n e H b HCIIOJlb30BaHMR 3KOJIOrMYeCKOrO

aynI4Ta; 0614~ii Y p O B e H b 3 K O n O r H s e C K O r O M e H e A X M e H T a .

B CMCTeMy YnPaBJIeHMR KPYnHbIM n p e n n p k i R T M e M pa3BHTbIX M MHOrkiX Pa3BABafOUMXCR

C l p a H , O C O ~ ~ H H O B H ~ ( P T H H O ~ ~ M X M M M ' ~ ~ C K O ~ ~ IIPOMbIUlJIeHHOCTM, ~ K o J I o ~ w Y ~ c K R ~ ~ M e H e A X M e H T

B o w e n yxe KaK ee o p r a H M q e c K a R c o c T a s r j a R Y a c T b . B TOG n o n c u c T e M e y n p a s n e l r w x M e H e n x e p b r

p a 3 p a 6 a T b i ~ a ~ 3 ~ s K o n o r k i s e c K y m c ~ p a ~ e l - w m M nonwrarcy npennpwrr~uii, peruam-r B o n p o c b l

COrJIaCOBaHMR AX AeRTenbHOCTM C H a U M O H ~ b H b I M M A MeXJQ'HaPOAHblMM 3KOJlOTMYeCKMMM

CTaHAapTaMM, H e C y T OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 38 COCTaBlIeHUe COOTBeTCTBYKlUMX OTYeTOB M

o c y u e c T B n e a M e s ~ o n o r ~ r e c ~ o r o ay.nMTa.

B MTOre pa3BMBaeTCR K O ~ ~ O ~ ~ T M B H ~ I ~ ~ ' ~ K O ~ O ~ H Y ~ C K M ~ ~ M e H e D X M e H T KaK CMCTeMa

y n p a s n e H u x p e ~ y p ~ 0 ~ 6 e p e X e ~ M e ~ M o 6 e c n e ~ e ~ ~ e ~ s~onor~. rec~of i 6e30nac~oc~u n p o u 3 ~ o n c ~ ~ a M n o ~ p e 6 n e ~ u x ~03,LlaHHofi npOAyKUMki. K B ~ X H ~ ~ ~ U H M er0 IIpMHUMnaM MOrYT 6b1Tb OTHeCeHb1:

nOBbIUeHJ4e ~ K o J ~ o ~ M Y ~ c K O ~ ~@C&KTMBHOCTA I lpeAlIpMRTUR C YYeTOM HaYYHO-TeXHMYeCKMX

A O C T M X ~ H M ~ ~ , T p e 6 0 ~ a H M f i M 0 X M f i a ~ M f i n o ~ p e 6 ~ ~ e n e ~ Pi KOHTpaTeHTOB; 0 6 y q e ~ M e n e p C O H W l a C

UeJIbfO ITOBbIUleHMH er0 OTBCrCTBeHHOCTH 3a ~ 0 3 n e f i c T ~ M e npOM3BOaCTBa H a OKpyXaWLL(yf0 C p e n y ;

n p e ~ y n p e ~ ~ ~ e n b ~ b l i i IlOAXOA U I l IIPeAOTBpalJJeHMR 3HaYHTenbHOI'O U O C O ~ ~ H H O H ~ O ~ P ~ T H M O I ' C

YXyAUIeHAIl KaVeCTBa O K ~ Y X ~ I O ~ ~ ~ I CpeAbI ; MOHMTOPWHr M 0 n e p a T M B ~ b 1 f i KOHTPOnt

n n a H u p y e M b r x s K o n o r b j s e c K w x ~ e p o n p ~ x ~ ~ f i ; n p o s e n e H u e a y n t i T o p c K M x n p o B e p o B

~ @ @ ~ K T W B H O C T M TaKMX ~ e p 0 l l p M R T U f i ; ~0~efiC'r~kie I IepeAas t? 3KOJlOrMWCKki 4MCTbIX T ~ x H o J I o ~ M ~ ~ ~

OTKPbITOCTb AMiUOrY no I - I ~ O ~ J I ~ M ~ M 3KOnOTHM.

B E s p o n e f i c ~ o ~ Come A n x p e a n ~ 3 a u ~ ~ ~ T M X n p M H u M n o B p a 3 p a 6 0 T a ~ a C x e ~ a ~ K O -

M e H e n x M e w T a 1.1 a y n u T a - EMAS (Eco-Management and Audit Scheme EU). Ta xe B ~ ~ M K O ~ ~ M T ~ H M R CO3AaJJa n e p ~ b l f i B M M p e C T a H n a p T C a M O r O 3KOnOrM.leCKOrO M e H e A X M e H T a - BS 7750, H a OCHOBe KOTOpOrO IlpOMCXOAMT aKKpeAHTaL[HR K O M ~ ~ H M ~ ~ H a COOTBeTCTBMe

3KOIIOrMVeCKMM T ~ ~ ~ o B ~ ~ H M R M . ~

K HepeLUeHHbIM MnM T p y A H O p e U a e M b l M n p 0 6 J I e ~ a ~ 3KOJlOTH3aUMM llPOM3BOACTBa I4

YCHneHMR KOHKYPeHTHblX l l 0 3 ~ 4 M f i I T ~ ~ A ~ ~ M R T M ~ ~ H a MMPOBblX PbIHKaX OTIIOCHTCH I I p e X A e BCerO

c n e A y m u l w e :

H e c o s e p w e H c - r B o M e w y H a p o A t i o r o 3 K o n o r M q e c K o r o npasa, 3 a ~ p y ~ ~ ~ m u e e s a w r m r e ~ ~ e ~ C ~ ~ @ ~ K T U B H ~ I X MHOI'OCTOPOHHMX ~ 0 r H a ~ l e ~ k l f i 06 O X p a H e 0 K p y ~ a ~ l J J e f i C p e A b l ;

HeAOCTaTOrHO O ~ T ~ H M ~ O B ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ U nOTOMY M ~ J ~ o ~ @ @ ~ K T M B H ~ I ~ ~ O ~ M ~ H ~ K O J I O T M Y ~ C K O ~

k f H @ o p ~ a q M e f i M COOTBeTCTBYK3uMM IIpaBOBbIM OnblTOM (B qaCTHOCTU, MMeeTCH B BMAY

BO3MOXHOCTb MCllOHb30BaHMR B HaUKOHaJIbHOM 3aKOHOAaTeJlbCTBe I I p O ~ e C C M B H b l X

l lpaBOBbIX aKTOB APYrMX CTpaH, H a n p M M e p CERCLA - % K O H ~ C w A 0 ~ceo6qefi ~ K o J ~ o T M Y ~ c K O ~ ~ OTBeTCTBeHHOCTM, KOMlleHCaUURX U o ~ R ~ ~ T ~ J I ~ c T B ~ x ) ;

OTCYTCTBUe O ~ O C H O B ~ H H O ~ O KOMllneKCHOrO M e X a H H 3 M a ITPMHHTMR KOMllPOMWCCHblX

p e m e ~ ~ f i B O ~ J I ~ C T M 3 ~ o n o r ~ ~ e c ~ 1 . 1 O n a c H o r o 3 ~ c n o p ~ a u M M n o p T a (~ccne~o~ar-[we T A n ((06 3KOnOTMYeCKOM KOHTpOJIe M M ~ X J ~ H ~ ~ O A H O ~ ~ T O p r O B n e ) ) HBnReTCR nMIUb

nepBbnM m a r o M B TOM ~ a n p a ~ n e ~ ~ w ) ; o r l p e A e n e H H o e t r r H o p w p o B a H M e UnM H e n o o q e H K a npo6ne~ vr~onorusec~oii ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ C H O C T H BO MHOrUX M e X A y H a P O A H b I X 3KOHOMU9eCKMX COrJIal lIeHMRX (name l l p M M e p H 0 B 180 M e m y H a p O n H b I X C O ~ n a U I e H M H X IIO B O n p O C a M 3KOnOrMM T O n b K O B 10% 133 HUX c o A e p x a r c R e K o M e H n a q u M o T ~ M O X ~ H H O ~ s a w ~ i ~ e OT 3 ~ o n o r ~ q e c ~ u o n a c H o r o

T O p r O B O r O 0 6 M e H a ) ; !!'

r u ~ p o ~ o ucnonbsye~arr n p a r c r u K a cy6crwvrii 3 ~ c n o p ~ o r o ~ ~ ~ O M ~ B O A C T B ~ B q a c n m c ( ( ~ R 3 H b I M I I ) ) TeXHOJJOTHRMM, O C O ~ ~ H H O B 3HepTeTMqeCKOM, TPaHCll0I)THOM M a I p a p H O M

C e f l O p a X 3KOHOMMKM (TOII~KO B BOCbMM CTpaHaX, O~CJI~?AOB~HH~JX M ~ ~ H ~ ~ o , ~ . ( H ~ I M

3HePTeTMYeCKMM XCHTCTBOM, B 1Y)M YtrCne ~ ~ A M M , bT%, POCCHW, YMeHbLSIeHMe

cy6cly1~ii M o r n 0 6 b 1 rlpMBecTM K C o K p a W e H U m B p e m b D L B ~ I ~ P O C O B B a T M o c @ e p y H a 4,6%);1° HeAOCTaTOrIHO CKOOPAUHMPOBatIO B ~ ~ H M O A ~ ~ ~ C T B M ~ BTO, IOH3I3, WHKTAA no I ~ P o ~ ~ ~ M ~ M ~ K o J I o T w M M ~ ~ B ~ M R H B I ~ H ~ M ~ W Y H ~ P O A H Y K ) T O P T O B J I ~ ;

HeCOBePLUCHCTBO HaUMOHCUlbHblX CMCTeM ~ K o J I o ~ M ~ ~ c K O ~ ~ CTaHAaPTM3aUMM M

c ~ ~ T M @ U K ~ ~ M H H MX B ~ ~ U M O A ~ ~ ~ C T B M H C C0OTBeTCTBYIO~AMI. i MeX&yH8POAHbIMM

CACTeMaMH.

B n o c n e n H e M cnyqae 06 TOM MOXHO C Y A M T ~ IIO wcny H a u M o H a n b H b r x opra~~saqwfi, C ~ ~ T M @ U ~ M ~ O B ~ H H ~ I X H a COOTBCTCTRMe C T a H A a p T a M ISO-1400 1 M EMAS ( ~ a 6 n ~ u a ) .

Hauuo~a.rlbnb~e o p r a ~ u ~ a s n u , c e p ~ u + a s n p o ~ a ~ ~ a r e aa cooTseTcTBue cTaHnapTaM ISO-14001 n EiMAS (no nanHblM Ha n e ~ a 6 p b 2002 r.)

B M T O X G o n h w a x YaCTb n p o 6 n e ~ 3KOnOTMH M KOHKYPeHUMM ( ( T P R ~ H o ~ ~ ) ) M ((YMcTo~~))

IlpOnyKL(MM CBH3aHa C TeM, YTO MHOrMe CTPaHbl 3KOHOMMYeCKW, WAeOJTOTMYeCK11, IlOJlMTMSeCKM H e

TO'TOBbI K IlPOBeAeHMIO M ~ C L I J T ~ ~ H O ~ ~ 3KOJlOrM3aUMM llPOM3BOACTBa. ~ J ~ ~ B H ~ I M M nPenRTCTBMRMH

npM p e m e H n M c T p a T e r u q e c K H x s a ~ a r no s a l u ~ ~ e o~pyxamqei i cpenar u ~ ~ ~ B H T M I - O C B O ~ O A H O ~ ~

KOHKYPeHUWU B M ~ > K A Y H ~ P O ~ H O ~ ~ TOPI'OBJIe RBIIRIOTCR COXP~HRIOLIJW~CR PaCKOSl M M p a H a 6ora~bre kl 6 e a ~ b l e CTpaHbI, nPOTMBOpeYMR M e m Y HMMM T O B O n p O C a M T O ~ ~ O B O ~ ~ M I I ~ O M ~ I L L I ~ ~ H H O ~ ~

llOJIMTMKM, c J ~ ~ ~ o c T ~ M e W y H a p O f l H b l X 0 p r a ~ M 3 a i J M f i . Oco6e1r~o HCTaTMBHYm P O n b MI'PaWT

nOIIbITKM ~ a ~ 6 o n e e MOUJHblX I3 3KOHOMMqeCKOM OTHOLUeHMM rOCYAapCTB, npewe B C e r O CWA, MCllOJlb30BaTb < < n p a B O C11nbHOrO)), MX OTKa3 O T P R A a 06113aTe.Jlbc~~ IlO MHOrOCTOPOHHMM

COTdlUIIeHHRM, H a n p M M e p , I10 KMOTCKOM~ nPOTOKOnY; C T p e M n e H M e JJJ'IR YCMneHMR C O ~ C T B ~ H H ~ I X

KOIiKYPeHTHbIX II03MUMfi H e AOnYCTMTb H a CBOM PblHKH ITPOAYKUMIO A p y n l X , B n e p B y f 0 O Y e p e A b

pasnw~amuluxc~ c-rpae, B H a p y r u e H M e npasm BTO o nu6epana3asu~ T o p r o s n w .

' U1 M H A x e k H H C., 3 o p a K R u H O. Q ) U H ~ H C M ~ ~ R ~ H M ~ rlepeMeH / nep. c awn. M., 1998. C. 200. n a x o M o B a H., 3 H R p e c A., P H x T e p K. 3 ~ 0 n o r u q e c ~ n t i MetieaxMeHT. M.; Cll6., 2003. C. 350-35 1. ' T r o g e A. Umweltschutz im globalcn Wettbewerb: neue Spielregeln fuer das grenzlose Unternehmen. Berlin;

tieidelberg; New York; Barcelona; Hongkong; London; Mailand; Paris; Singapur; Tokio, 2000; L a x h 11 b e r D., K e I n h o f e r E., S c h I e m m i n g e r H. Abgeschneiderte Umweltmanagementsysteme. Heidelberg, 1998.

http:/Iwww. 1400I.r~ ' T u r n e r R., 0 p s c h o o r H. Environmental economics and environmlntal policy instruments: introduction and

overview. Dordrecht. 1994. " I I M W R X ~ F ~ H H C . , ~ O ~ ~ K B U ~ ! @.YKa3.COq.C. 139-141. ' B e r n b e c k K. Business in the Environment. Personal communication. London, 1995.

W a s k o w S. Betrieblicches Umweltmanagement - Anforderungen nach der Audit Verordnung der EG. Heidelberg, 1994.

N e u m e i e r E. Trade Measures in Multilateral Environmental Agreements and WTO Rules: Potential for Conflict, Scope for Reconciliation; Aussenwirtschaf?, (2000), Nc 55. H 111. Zurich; Ruegger. S. 404.

' O ht~~:/:www.ecolouia.ru