ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" /...

141
ComentÆrios lei de responsabilidade fiscal Elaboraªo: JosØ Rildo de Medeiros Guedes

Transcript of ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" /...

Page 1: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

Comentários à lei de responsabilidade fiscal

Elaboração: José Rildo de Medeiros Guedes

Page 2: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

/HL�GH�5HVSRQVDELOLGDGH�

)LVFDO&$'(5126�,%$0��

&RPHQWiULRV�j/HL�GH�5HVSRQVDELOLGDGH�)LVFDO

$EULO�GH������

!"#$%&'()* !+,-+ -.'/'%0* ,+ "1,+.+ 1* 23/"-* !+ 4*1#51"*

!+ 4**6+.'()* -741"4' 8".3'!* 4*3 *, 9"1",-7."*, !*

:%'1+;'3+1-* + !* <+,+1#*%#"3+1-* + 4*3 ' => :? #",'1!*

'6*"'. ' "36%'1-'()* !' @+" A*36%+3+1-'. 1B CDC?

!+ EFGFHDDD? "14%$,"#+ 6'.' +8+"-* !+ '-+1!"3+1-* !*

!",6*,-* +3 ,+$ '.-F IEF

=,-+ !*4$3+1-* 6*!+ ,+. .+6.*!$J"!*? +3 6'.-+ *$

"1-+&.'%3+1-+? !+,!+ K$+ !+#"!'3+1-+ 4"-'!' ' 8*1-+F

! "#$%$&'! ()*$ '+#,'!!(! !-" .' '+/0*!$1( ,'!#"%!(2$0$.(.'

.' !'* (*3", ' %-" ,'40'3'56 %'/'!!(,$(5'%3'6 ( #"!$7-" ."!

8,9-"! 4'.',($!:

!"#$%& '(

Page 3: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&'() *#&")+&,& -*#) ./01$1!1) 2+&0$#*$+) ,* 3,4$/$01+&'()

5!/$%$-&# 6 .235 0)" ) -&1+)%7/$) ,) 2&/%) 8&%$)/&# ,*

9*0*/:)#:$4*/1) ;%)/<4$%) * =)%$&# 6 289;=

>))+,*/&'() ?*+&#

!"#$ %&''

>))+,*/&'() @A%/$%&

()*!#+$ +! ,$-.! /)&-

>))+,*/&'() ;B*%!1$:&

0#)&-& ()&-#)* 1)2)-

;#&")+&'()

3$-4 /&#+$ +) 5)+)&*$- 0")+)-

>))+,*/&'() ;,$1)+$&#

!"#$! %!&'$

!"#$ %$&$'()*+,!"$

%$&$'()$-.( /$ (/&0 10'$ 2!3'!(&0"$ 4( 5267

!"#"$% &'$( )*+#' #" ,"#"*-'$

.'/"012-*'$ 3 +"* #" -"$4'0$56*+*#5#" 7*$85+ 9 &'$( )*+#' #" ,"#"*-'$ !"#"$:

)*' #" &50"*-'; <=>,% ?@@A:

AB@4:C ?D8/: E FG"* #" -"$4'0$56*+*#5#" 7*$85+% AH

I51-'8J0*'; =KLMN

A: )"$4'0$56*+*#5#" 1-*6!12-*5: <: <0$1*1!1' =-5$*+"*-' #" >#/*0*$1-5OP' ,!0*8*45+

DDQ F.LL AR "#:H

!"#$%& '(

Page 4: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$ %& '! ()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" /º 7879 ')

&$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

2$#,#/)$(, ,&* 34#$/5'$&* ',(, , 6&7)(#$8,1%& 7,* ()*')/+$9,* ,76$#$*:

+(,1;)* +($<4+-($,= 2$#,#/)$(,= ',+($6&#$,> ) '()9$7)#/$-($,= /&6 9$*+,* ,&

/46'($6)#+& 7,* #&(6,* 7)*+, ?)$ @&6'>)6)#+,(AB

B"),*')/#) 2)"/!/'. C)/"*?@) 5!"'.,.9 )6 ,)@ -".D"!6! ') "E'*.

')'*3!'. F ,!/GH. '),,! ()* 4)6 8;$8:$;888< !/@/3*.@ ,@! ')#)"6*/!GH.

-!"! ?@) . I*/*,#J"*. '. B1!/)K!6)/#. ) . LMNOP '),)/=.1=),,)6 .

!"#$%& '()!*!#+$, @6 3./K@/#. ') !GQ), =.1#!'!, ),-)3*!16)/#) -!"!

B")R)*#@"!, ') -)?@)/. -."#) ) '. */#)"*."9 =*,!/'. R!3*1*#!" ! !'6*/*,#"!GH.

') ,@!, 3./#!, )9 !. 6),6. #)6-.9 !,,)D@"!" ! *6-1!/#!GH. ') @6 /.=.

")D*6) R*,3!1 "),-./,E=)1$

S -@01*3!GH. '),#) #"!0!1T. ,) */,)") /),,) ),R."G. D.=)"/!6)/#!1 -!"!

#.6!" 6!*, RE3*1 ) 6!*, )R*3!U !, !'6*/*,#"!GQ), 1.3!*,$ 2!U -!"#) '! ,)D@*/#)

,J"*) ') #"!0!1T., )1!0."!'., -." )/#*'!'), ) #J3/*3., ') /.#V"*! ),W

-)3*!1*U!GH. /! E")!9 )X31@,*=., "),-./,E=)*, -)1!, .-*/*Q),9 6!, 3@K!

'*,#"*0@*GH. J !-.*!'! -)1., V"DH., R)')"!*, -." !K@'!")6 /! 3.6-"))/,H.

'! 1)* ) /! *6-1!/#!GH. ') @6 /.=. ")D*6) R*,3!1A

3,#4,> 7) C($)#+,1%& ',(, @()*/$6)#+& 7, D)/)$+, E(F'($, 34#$/$',>B=

'! O,3.1! ') S'6*/*,#"!GH. ') O6-"),!, ') PH. [email protected] 2@/'!GH.Y)#@1*.

Z!"D!,9 PH. [email protected] ;888

GHI J$/,* K L70$,* ',(, !1%& 34#$/$',>B= '. 1/,#*#@#. ') O,#@'.,9

2."6!GH. ) S,,),,."*! )6 B.1[#*3!, P.3*!*, \ B](1P9 PH. [email protected] ;888

M4$, 7) C($)#+,1%& ',(, ,* E()2)$+4(,*B= '. S6*" S/#^/*. _T!*"9 PH.

[email protected] 6!*. ;888

3,#4,> N-*$/& 7& O($<4#,> 7)@&#+,* 7& P*+,7&7) Q%&E,4>&B=PH. [email protected]

K@/T. ') ;888

3,#4,> 7) E(&/)7$6)#+&* ',(, !'>$/,1%& 7, ?)$ 7) D)*'&#*,<$>$7,7)

R$*/,> 7& O($<4#,> 7) @&#+,* 7& P*+,7& 7& D$& M(,#7) 7& Q4>B=+*. Y"!/')

'. P@19 /.=)60". ') ;888

$�/HL�GH�5HVSRQVDELOLGDGH�)LVFDO��6LPSOHV�0XQLFLSDO

!"#$%& '(

Page 5: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$ %# &#'()*'+,$-$%+%# .$'/+- # + 01#2$%3*/$+ %)' 4#12$%)1#' 05,-$/)'

67*$/$(+$'8 !" #$%&"'( )*$+$ ,-."/0( !" #(%$"- 1*( !" 2$+"*%(

!"3"45%( !" 6777

!' 91+*':1#'';#' < "#$ %# &#'()*'+,$-$%+%# .$'/+- # =)11#'()*%#*>#'

07*$?;#' .$'/+$' # 0#*+$'8 !" 84*% 8+.9+*( :;$*% 1*( !" 2$+"*%(

!"3"45%( !" 6777

<01)()'>+ %# 0+%1)*$@+?A) %)' &#-+>B1$)' %+ C#'>A) .$'/+-= !( >+-.*.?.(

1?@ A$%5(-$ B0( C$?'( !"3"45%( !" 6777

C7$+ %# D1$#*>+?A) (+1+ +' 01#E#$>71+'8F 6ª !"#$%& ' (")*+ +,-."+!+

!" 84*% 8+.9+*( :;$*% B0( C$?'( D"/"%"*%( !" 677E

!"#$%&'" (#$%)*+, '%-$%.+#/+, % '+- 0/1,(!+23%- +!(.+ !($+'+- %-$4 '(-0"#56%, #+ ,#$%*#%$

0+*+ +!%--" )*+$/($" % /#(6%*-+,7 +$*+68- '% !"#-/,$+ "/ '% !"#$!% & #" '()* .+#$('" 0%,"

9:;<= % %-0%!(+,(>+'" %. ?(#+#2+- 0&1,(!+- % ?%'%*+,(-." ?(-!+, #" %#'%*%2"@

AAAB?%'%*+$(6"B1#'%-B)"6B1*

Banco Federativo

Site do

/012341567879590 :71;58

!

59<7471=/5>?3 0:7;704=0

!

;79590 <08@3/

!"#$% &'()& *++& ),-)&. /&01)2)'* 1&34-3.

CD;<E: FG

Page 6: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$#%&'()* +

,"#-./0* 1

!"#$#%&'()* 2* 34 5 66

,'"&# 7 8#0 2# 9#$!*%$':0;02'2# <0$/'; =89<> ? @*A#%&."0*$

B#%C"0/*$ 6D

,'"&# 47 89< ? @*A#%&."0*$ E$!#/F-0/*$ G6

!;0/'()* # @*%/#0&*$ G6

H ,;'%#I'A#%&* GD

9#/#0&' ,J:;0/' DD

K#$!#$' ,J:;0/' D+

L"'%$-#"M%/0'$ N*;O%&."0'$ PQ

K#$&0%'()* 2# 9#/O"$*$ ,J:;0/*$ !'"' * R#&*" ,"0S'2* PT

KFS02' # E%20S02'A#%&* PU

H!#"'(V#$ 2# @"C20&* Q6

B#$&)* ,'&"0A*%0'; TW

L"'%$!'"M%/0'X @*%&"*;# # <0$/';0Y'()* TG

K0$!*$0(V#$ <0%'0$ # L"'%$0&Z"0'$ +G

%#[*$ +1

6\ @';#%2."0* 2'$ ,"*S02M%/0'$ ,"#S0$&'$ %' 89< !'"' *$

5O%0/F!0*$ U6

G\ 8#0 @*A!;#A#%&'" %º 6W6 16

G\ 8#0 %º 6W\WGU 6DQ

6XPiULR

!"#$%& '(

Page 7: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%& '(

Page 8: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

$ !" #! $!%&'(%)*"+"#)#! ,"%-)+ ./)0 12) 21#)(3) "(%.".1-"'()+ !

-1+.1/)+ (' ./).' -'2 ' #"(4!"/' &5*+"-'6 #"(4!"/' #) %'-"!#)#!7 8%.)2'%

9!/)(#' 12) /1&.1/) () 4"%.:/") &'+;."-'<)#2"("%./)."=) #' >);%7 8%.)2'%

"(./'#10"(#' ) /!%./"3?' '/3)2!(.@/") () +!9"%+)3?' */)%"+!"/)7

A %'-"!#)#! (?' .'+!/) 2)"% -'(="=!/ -'2 )#2"("%./)#'/!% "//!%&'(%@=!"%

! 4'B! !%.@ -)#) =!0 2)"% -'(%-"!(.! #! C1! C1!2 &)9) ) -'(.) #' 2)1

1%' #' #"(4!"/' &5*+"-' D ' -"#)#?'6 ' -'(./"*1"(.!7

A "//!%&'(%)*"+"#)#! &/)."-)#) 4'B!6 !2 C1)+C1!/ (;=!+ #! 9'=!/('6 /!%1+<

.)/@ )2)(4? !22)"% "2&'%.'%6 2!('% "(=!%."2!(.'% '1 2)"% "(E+)3?'6 C1!

D ' 2)"% &!/=!/%' #'% "2&'%.'% &'"% "(-"#! %'*/! '% 2)"% &'*/!%7

F 9'=!/(' (?' E)*/"-) #"(4!"/'7

8%.) )E"/2)3?' &'#! &)/!-!/ :*=") &)/) )+91(%6 2)% (?' &)/) )C1!+!% C1!

)#2"("%./)2 -'(.)% &5*+"-)% 9)%.)(#' 2)"% #' C1! )//!-)#)27 G!"H)(#'

#;="#)% &)/) %!1% %1-!%%'/!% ! )%%12"(#' -'2&/'2"%%'% C1! %)*!26 #!

)(.!2?'6 (?' &'#!/?' 4'(/)/7 I !%.! ."&' #! &'%.1/)6 #)('%) &)/) ' >);%6

C1! D -'"*"#) &!+) !" #! $!%&'(%)*"+"#)#! ,"%-)+7 A #!-"%?' #! )12!(.)/

9)%.'%6 "(#!&!(#!(.!2!(.! #! %!1 2D/".'6 &/!-"%) !%.)/ )-'2&)(4)#) #!

12) E'(.! #! E"()(-")2!(.'7

A !" /!E'/3) '% &/"(-;&"'% #) ,!#!/)3?'7 J'=!/()(.!% #! 8%.)#'% ! K1("<

-;&"'% (?' .!/?' C1! &/!%.)/ -'(.)% #! %!1% ).'% )' 9'=!/(' E!#!/)+ 2)% )'

%!1 /!%&!-."=' !9"%+)."='6 '1 %!B)6 L -'21("#)#! C1! '% !+!9!17 M1#' "%%'

%!/@ E!".' #! E'/2) %"2&+"E"-)#) &)/) C1! ) %'-"!#)#! &'%%) !H!/-!/ ' %!1

#"/!".' #! E"%-)+"0)3?'7 F% 9'=!/()(.!% %!/?' B1+9)#'% &!+'% !+!".'/!%6 &!+'

2!/-)#' !6 %! #!%-12&/"/!2 )% /!9/)%6 %!/?' &1("#'%7

N@ !(./)2'% () !/) #) /!%&'(%)*"+"#)#! E"%-)+7 M!/ 12) &'%.1/) /!%&'(%@=!+

D #!=!/ #! -)#) 9'=!/()(.!7

!"#$% &!'!"(%

!"!#$%& '( )#$*'& '& +,*"(-*.("$&/ 0%1*.("$& ( 2(#$3&

$SUHVHQWDomR

!"#$%& '(

Page 9: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%& '(

Page 10: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$#%&'()$ ' *)+#,-) !"#$%&' ()*+. #+'/)"'0' !#+) 1%$&2&3&) 4"'$25

+#2") 0# 0(2%2$&"',-) 63%2*2!'+ 7 14 6 $)/ ) !'&")*8%2) 0) 49:;<.

*)%$&'%0) 0# 3(' *)+#&=%#' *)( $#&# >)+3(#$ 0# ('%3'2$ )"2#%&'0)"#$

!'"' ' 2(!+'%&',-) 0' ?#2 @)(!+#(#%&'" %º ABA 0# ('2) 0# CBBB. *)(

*#"&#D' '/$)+3&' 0# E3# $#"F 0# G"'%0# >'+2' !'"' )"2#%&'" '$ (3%2*2!'5

+20'0#$ #( "#+',-) H$ (#020'$ ' $#"#( '0)&'0'$ !'"' ' '0#E3',-) H$

%)"('$ #$&'/#+#*20'$ !#+' ?#2 0# I#$!)%$'/2+20'0# J2$*'+K L'"#M' 2(!)"5

&'%&# %' G#$&-) #M2*2#%&# # "#$!)%$F>#+ 0' *)2$' !N/+2*'. (#&' !#"M#2&'5

(#%&# '+*'%,F>#+ !)" &)0)$ )$ G)>#"%)$ +)*'2$. # E3# *)%&"2/32 !'"' '

I#M)"(' 0) ;$&'0)K

:# M'&). *)() 3(' 0'$ !"2%*2!'2$ 2%$&2&32,O#$ 0# P)+8&2*' ;*)%Q(2*' 0#

+)%G) !"'D) %) 4"'$2+. ) 49:;< >#( !'"&2*2!'%0) '&2>'(#%&# 0# ',O#$

>)+&'0'$ !'"' ' "#M)"(3+',-) 0) !'!#+ 0) ;$&'0). %)$ 02>#"$)$ %8>#2$ 0'

J#0#"',-) 4"'$2+#2"'K 9#$&# $#%&20). &#( $20) G"'%0# ) $#3 #(!#%R) #(

'!)2'" ' ()0#"%2D',-) 0' '0(2%2$&"',-) &"2/3&F"2' # ' (#+R)"2' 0' E3'+25

0'0# 0) G'$&) !N/+2*). *)( 3(' !#"$!#*&2>' 0# 0#$#%>)+>2(#%&) +)*'+

$3$&#%&'0)K

+S( 0)$ >F"2)$ !")G"'('$ &"'02*2)%'2$ 0# M2%'%*2'(#%&). ) 49:;< 2(!+#5

(#%&)3 ) !"#!$%$ &' ("&'!)*+$,-" &$ .&%*)*/0!$,-" 1!*2304!*$ ' &$

5'/0-" &"/ 6'0"!'/ 6"7*$*/ 84/*7"/ 9 (.1:!'"' !")!)"*2)%'" ')$ (3%25

*8!2)$ /"'$2+#2")$ !)$$2/2+20'0#$ 0# '!#"M#2,)'" $3' *'!'*20'0# 0# '""#*'5

0',-) #. ') (#$() &#(!). 2%*"#(#%&'" ' E3'+20'0# 0)$ $#">2,)$ !"#$&'0)$

H !)!3+',-)K

L'(/S( M)2 *"2'0) 3( ',-# %' 1%&#"%#& 9;00<=>>?'&'!$0*@"A2)&'/A#"@A2!:

!'"' 02>3+G',-) 0# 2%M)"(',O#$ # #$&'&8$&2*'$ $)/"# ) $#&)" !N/+2*). /#(

*)() !'"' ' &")*' 0# #T!#"2U%*2'$ #%&"# '0(2%2$&"'0)"#$ !N/+2*)$. !#$E325

$'0)"#$. )"G'%2D',O#$ %-)5G)>#"%'(#%&'2$ # #>#%&3'2$ 2%&#"#$$'0)$ #(

!)+8&2*'$ !N/+2*'$K @)( #M#2&). ) 8$)7" B'&'!$0*@" &#( !")*3"'0) &"'&'"

0)$ ('2$ >'"2'0)$ &#('$ "#+'*2)%'0)$ H J#0#"',-) 4"'$2+#2"'. *)() '

I#M)"(' L"2/3&F"2' # ' ?#2 0# I#$!)%$'/2+20'0# J2$*'+. '+S( 0# '!"#$#%&'"

3UHIiFLR

!"#$%& '(

Page 11: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$"%&'( )& *+),& %( ' - (#$ (. /()' -0&+1 "' "'*$)'( "'1%#&,) #% ' $*'&)%

#&'(#'+ ' (' " !$1 2%+ $)&$34( "' 3,& $( 5$&#'& $( #%1 %+)&%( 0&67%( '

!() )+)%( "' 5'(8+ ($.

9$ ( !-%&1$:7% ' 1$ ( )&$!(5$&;!# $ (7%< ('1 "=3 "$< $ 6$&$!) $ 5'&'!'

"% '-') 3% #%!)&%>' 5%5+>$& ' "% $5&'!" 2$"% "$ # "$"$! $.

!"#$%&$' (')*!+' ,#-!. /!'&

!"#$%"&'" %( )*+,-

!"#$%& '(

Page 12: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

( !" #$%&'"(!$ ) *+,!" #" &'+ ),-" ".+/$,+#+ *".$ 0( !-!&!$ 1,+ -."-,$

#" 2#'-(- !,+34$ 5&(-%-*+. 6 01257 %$' $ *+!,$%8(-$ #$ 1+(%$ 9+%-$(+.

#" :" "(;$.;-'"(!$ <%$(='-%$ " >$%-+. 6 19:<>7 %&?$ $/?"!-;$ ) *,"*+,+,

$ 5&(-%8*-$ *+,+ -'*.+(!+, + '&#+(3+ !$,(+#+ $/,-@+!A,-+ %$' +

"(!,+#+ "' ;-@$, #+ B"- C$'*."'"(!+, (º DED7 #" F #" '+-$ #" GEEE7 '+-

%$(H"%-#+ %$'$ B"- #" I" *$( +/-.-#+#" J- %+. 6 BIJK L,+!+M " #" &'+

%$(!,-/&-34$ *+,+ #+, %$( "NOP(%-+ +$ #- *$ !$ ($ +,!K QF #" + B"-7 N&"

*,";P*+,+ +R(-4$ &'*+*". " !,+!)@-%$ (+ + - !P(%-+ !)%(-%+ " %$$*",+34$

S-(+(%"-,+ *+,+ + '$#",(-T+34$ #+ 2#'-(- !,+3U" 5&(-%-*+- (+ *,"*+M

,+34$ #$ V$;",($ B$%+- *+,+ + +*.-%+34$ #+ ($;+ ($,'+ ."@+- K

2 -'*$,!W(%-+ #" " *+*". ) -("@X;".7 ?X N&" + BC (º DEDYGEEE -'*U" &'

+.!$ N&+.-!+!-;$ "' !",'$ #+ @" !4$ " N&+.-S-%+34$ #" N&+#,$ *Z/.-%$

.$%+- 7 N&" ",X " *"%-+.'"(!" #-S8%-. *+,+ $ 5&(-%8*-$ '"($ #" "(;$.M

;-#$ K

2 ),-" + N&" " ,"S"," $ -(8%-$ #" !+ 2*," "(!+34$ ",X -(!"@,+#+ *".$

"@&-(!" #$%&'"(!$ [

!"#$%&'(!) * +#( ,# -#).!$)/0(1(,/,# 2()3/14

5"./3%!) ,/ +#( !".1#"#$%/' $º 67689777 )!0'# / +#( $º :;<97= ,# 6>

,# "/'?! ,# 6@A:4

B C1/0!'/?D! ,! E1/$! E1F'(/$F/1 GEEBH4

B C1/0!'/?D! ,/ +#( ,# I('#%'(J#) K'?/"#$%&'(/) G+IKH # ,! K'?/"#$%!

G+KBH4

B3!"./$L/"#$%! ,/ CM#3F?D! K'?/"#$%&'(/4

N#)%D! ,# -#3F')!) OF"/$!) # / -#,F?D! ,/) I#).#)/) ,# E#))!/14

B P"/'/ QF$(3(./1 # / )F/ -#).!$)/0(1(,/,# $/ N#)%D! 2()3/1R E!)(?D!

# E/.#1;

< " #$%&'"(!$ ",4$ #- !,-/&8#$ \ CW'+,+ " ],"S"-!&,+ #" !$#$ $

5&(-%8*-$ /,+ -."-,$ 7 "'/$,+ " !"?+' #-,-@-#$ '+- " *"%-S-%+'"(!" +$

#" '"($ #" ^EKEEE H+/-!+(!" 7 *".+ #-S-%&.#+#" "_*$ !+ K < !" ,"*,"M

"(!+' + " '+@+#$,+ '+-$,-+7 $& "?+7 ^KEG` &(-#+#" #$ &(-;", $ #$

$SUHVHQWDomR�GR�,%$0

!"#$%& '(

Page 13: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "# $%&'($)($' )* +,-'. )* /*/$)(* 0, $1,2*3,45* 0$'($ 0*67/$)(*. *

87$ $9&0$)6&, , &/+*3(:)6&, 0, &)&6&,(&9,!

; <= )º >">?@""" 9&',. ,)($' 0$ (70*. 0&'6&+1&),3 * 6*/+*3(,/$)(* 0*

A$'(*3 +B21&6*. C 17D 0*' +3&)6-+&*' E(&6*' 1&A,0*' C ;0/&)&'(3,45*. 6*/*

+1,)$F,/$)(*. $87&1-23&* G&),)6$&3*. $6*)*/&6&0,0$. +3*07(&9&0,0$. (3,)'H

+,3I)6&,. 6*)(3*1$ $ 3$'+*)',2&1&0,0$! J$7 G*6* E , A$'(5* G&'6,1. 6*)6$&(*

87$ ,/+1&*7 $/ 3$1,45* ,* 7'* 6*33$)($ 0* ($3/*. +*&' &)617&7 )$1$

,'+$6(*' 3$1,(&9*' ,* +1,)$F,/$)(*. ,* *34,/$)(*. C +3*A3,/,45* G&),)H

6$&3, $ ,* G17%* 0$ 6,&%,K C 3$6$&(,. &)617'&9$ C (3&27(,45*. $ C 0$'+$',K C

$%$6745* *34,/$)(L3&, $ G&),)6$&3,K C' (3,)'G$3I)6&,'K ,* $)0&9&0,/$)(*K

,* +,(3&/M)&* +B21&6* $ C +3$9&0I)6&, '*6&,1!

N ,09$)(* 0$ 7/, 1$& 6*/ $'',' +3$*67+,4O$' *2$0$6$ , 7/, ($)0I)6&,

/7)0&,1. 3$G1$%* (,)(* 0, 63&'$. +3&)6&+,1/$)($ G&),)6$&3,. 0*P'(,0*. 6*/*

0* G*3(,1$6&/$)(* $ 63$'6$)($' /*2&1&D,45* $ +3$''5* 0, '*6&$0,0$ 6&9&1.

$/ 27'6, 0* ,+3&/*3,/$)(* $ 0* 6*)(3*1$ '*6&,1 0, A$'(5* +B21&6,!

Q*3 $''$ /*(&9*. +*0$H'$ 6*)'&0$3,3 87$ * $'+-3&(* $ *2F$(&9*' 0$'', <$&

1$9,/ $/ 6*)(, 9,1*3$' $/*9&/$)(*' 7)&9$3',&' $. +*3(,)(*. (I/7/, G*34,

&33$9$3'-9$1! P/ *7(3,' +,1,93,'. /$'/* 87$. 6*/ * ($/+* $ '7, ,+1&6,45*

+3L(&6,. /*'(3$/H'$ )$6$''L3&,' 3$9&'O$' )$'', <$& R+*3 /$&* '$F, 1$A&'1,(&9*.

'$F, F70&6&,1S. *' A$'(*3$' +B21&6*' ($35* 87$ 27'6,3 '$ ,F7'(,3 ,*' '$7'

/,)0,/$)(*' $ 0&3&A&3 '7, ,0/&)&'(3,45* )* '$)(&0* 0* ,($)0&/$)(* 0$''$

$'+-3&(*. +3&)6-+&*' $ *2F$(&9*'!

; &)($)45* 0$'($ 0*67/$)(* E G,6&1&(,3 &''*. ($)(,)0*. &)617'&9$. 63&,3 7/,

,(&(70$ +*'&(&9, $/ 3$1,45* C <$&. $1&/&),)0* +*''-9$&' 3$'&'(I)6&,' ,*

+3*F$(* ,(3,9E' 0* '$7 /,&*3 6*)T$6&/$)(*!

!"! #!"$% &'!(' )*""!"' +',-.

!"#$%&'#&(#&'# )#$*+ (, -./0

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 14: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

$�/5)�²�&20(17É5,26�*(1e5,&26

'LUHWUL]HV

!"# $%&'("&")*+, )- ./.0 +',%1+2+ "& 3 2" &+#% 2" 4/// 5!"# 2" 6"78

'%)7+9#(#2+2" :#7;+( < !6:= " '>9(#;+2+ )% ?#@,#% AB#;#+( 2+ C)#D% 2" E 2"&+#%

2" 4///0 1"#% ',"");F", >& 1@;>% #)7*#*>;#%)+( " 2+, "B#;@;#+ + 1@,#%7 2#7'%7#*#1%7

2+ $%)7*#*>#GD% :"2",+( < $:0 "7'";#+(&")*" +%7 7">7 +,*7H .IJ " .IK

H

!6:0 ;%&% !"# $%&'("&")*+,0 &%2+(#2+2" 2" 2#'(%&+ ("L+( #)7",#2% )%

?#,"#*% M%7#*#1% N,+7#("#,% + '+,*#, 2+ $: 2" .KIO0 2" !"#!$ ',#1#("L#+2%

!

0

*"& + #);>&9P);#+ 2" )%,&+*#Q+, +77>)*%7 R>" + %&#'& (&)*& *,+)7B","

"S'(#;#*+&")*" '+,+ "(+0 ;%&% ")7#)+ ("S+)2," 2" T%,+"7

"

U

+," -!&. &. -/01#1*2&. 1*'#1 31/ 4"$531$1*'&# 1 31/ "#-/*6#/&7 8 5#/$1/#&

9 $&'1#/&3: !$& ;1< !1 ."$1*'1 5"-1 .1# "=>1'" -1 31/ 4"$531$1*'&#

&$&'9#/& '&?&'/;&$1*'15#1;/.'& *&%"*.'/'!/2," @1-1#&3: 1* !&*'" '"-&.

&. -1$&/. $&'9#/&. -1;1#," .1# "=>1'" -1 31/ "#-/*6#/&7 8../$: & %"*.A

'/'!/2," @1-1#&3 #1.1#;& -1'1#$/*&-&. $&'9#/&. 4!>& #1)!3&$1*'&2,":

"=#/)&'"#/&$1*'1: .1#6 #1&3/<&-& 5"#$1/" -1 31/ 4"$531$1*'&#7 8 .1)!*A

-& 9 0"#$&3 1 -/< #1.51/'" &" 5#"41.." 31)/.3&'/;": *& 0&.1 -1 ;"'&2,"7

B* !&*'" "R>%,>&5&#& &5#";&2," -1 31/ "#-/*6#/& 9 -1$&/"#/& ./$531.

C&#'7 DEF: % R>%,>& 5&#& &5#";&2," -& 31/ 4"$531$1*'&# 9 -1 $&/"#/&

&=."3!'& C&#'7 GHF: "! .1>&: " 5#/$1/#" *I$1#" /*'1/#" .!=.1 J1*'1 K

-/;/.," -". $1$=#". -& %&.& L1)/.3&'/;& 5"# -"/.7

3DUWH�$

!"#$%& '(

!

( & )*+, (-. /) 0 /1+1*234) 561 7813 9:2;81214+)* /3<;:*= <:>*1? @ A B34)4C)< ;D>839)<E

@@ A /FG3/) ;D>839) 1H+1*4) 1 34+1*4)I 34986F/) ) /)< )6+)*563)<I B64/)CJ1< 1 /12)3<

14+3/)/1< 9:4+*:8)/)< ;18: K:/1* KD>839:E @@@ A 9:491<<L: /1 M)*)4+3)< ;18)< 14+3/)/1<

;D>839)<E @N A 123<<L: 1 *1<M)+1 /1 +F+68:< /) /FG3/) ;D>839)EO P:< /12)3< 3+14< 4L: <L:

;1*+3414+1<Q, R= : !"#$ /: )*+, (-S 1<+)>18191 561 7) /1<;1<) 9:2 ;1<<:)8 )+3G: 1 34)+3G:

/)T43L:I /:< #<+)/:<I /:"3<+*3+: 01/1*)8 1 /:<U6439F;3:< 4L: ;:/1*= 1H91/1* :< 8323+1<

1<+)>18193/:< 12 813 9:2;81214+)*,O

V :**1<;:4/14+1 ): ;*3213*: 4D21*: 34+13*: <6><15W14+1 ): /) 21+)/1 /: +:+)8 /:<

;)*8)214+)*1<,

. U&$!#XI !81H)4/*1, %&'(&$) *)+,$&$# &)+!-I !+8)<I $3: /1 R)413*:I Yª 1/,I V'''I ;, ZVS,

Page 15: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&' &()*&+$,$ )&-$ (.,/$ "$ ,/01-+$234 ,$% %$"25&% ,$ 678' )$*&9&

:&* ,&%)&*:$,4 1( ;%&":/(&":4< ,& =1& &-$' 94( %1$% ,/%)4%/25&% &

/"%:*1(&":$-/,$,&%' ;$)$*&9&1< ,& *&)&":&' )*4049$",4 1( ;94*:&< &":*&

4 =1& &>/%:/$ $":&% ? ! "#$ % & 4 =1& )$%%41 $ &>/%:/* ,&)4/% ? !&'()$%@ A%

#$:4%' 94":1,4' $)4":$( &( 41:*$ ,/*&234' *&(4":$",4' "4 (."/(4' $

BC@DB@EE' =1$",4 #4/ )*4(1-+$,$ $ F8' 91G4% )*/"9.)/4%' )4* #4*2$ ,4 =1&

,/%)5& 4 $*:@ DD & %&1 )$*H+*$#4 I"/94 ,4 :4 ,$% J/%)4%/25&% F4"%K

:/:19/4"$/% L*$"%/:M*/$% ? JFLN ,$ )*M)*/$ *"+$" ,"-#"' ,&0&( %&* 4O&,&K

9/,4% )&-$% F4"%:/:1/25&% ,& 9$,$ P%:$,4 ?FPN & )&-$% 6&/%A*+Q"/9$% ,& 9$,$

R1"/9.)/4 ?6ARN@

S )*40H0&- =1& $ 6AR ,4 R1"/9.)/4' 4",& 4 -&/:4* &>&*9& %1$% $:/0/,$,&%'

:&"T$ /"94*)4*$,4 0H*/4% ,4% ,/%)4%/:/04% 94"%:/:19/4"$/%' &%)&9/$-(&":& 4%

$*:/+4% DUV $ DUW' /"9-1%/0& 94( $ *&,$234 ,$,$ )&-$% P(&",$% F4"%K

:/:19/4"$/% =1& %& %&+1/*$(@ 7&94(&",$K%&' )4*:$":4' 1($ -&/:1*$ ,&%%&%

$*:/+4% & %1$ 94()$*$234 94( 4% ,$ 6AR@

X$-& -&(O*$*' $/",$' =1& $% F4"%:/:1/25&% $":&*/4*&% Y F8 ,& DWEE' "4:$,$K

(&":& $ ,& DWZU & $ ,& DWU[' 94( %1$% *&%)&9:/0$% $-:&*$25&% & (4,/#/9$K

25&%' :*$:$0$(' $ %&1 (4,4' ,4% $%%1":4% *&-$:/04% Y% #/"$"2$% )IO-/9$%' O4$

)$*:& ,4% =1$/%' $:\ T4G&' &%:34 ,/%9/)-/"$,4% )&-$ 6&/ "º Z@V]B' ,& D[@BV@UZ'

=1& &%:$:1/ "4*($% +&*$/% ,& J/*&/:4 8/"$"9&/*4 )$*$ &-$O4*$234 & 94":*4-&

,4% 4*2$(&":4% & ,4% O$-$"24% ,$ ^"/34' ,4% P%:$,4%' ,4% R1"/9.)/4% & ,4

J/%:*/:4 8&,&*$-

@

_$ *&$-/,$,&' $ 678' $4 &%:$O&-&9&* "4*($% ,& #/"$"2$% )IO-/9$% 04-:$,$% )$*$

$ !"#$%"&'()(*&*! %& +!",-$ .("/&)' &%:H ,&:&*(/"$",4 =1& $ &0-$ +$1! 2

%&3!%,&) %& ,&%&"04-0$ :&",4 94(4 )*&(/%%$% ?$*:@ DºN $% %&+1/":&% ,/*&:*/`&%a

& &0-$ #)&%!4&*& ! , &%"#& !%,!' &( =1& %&a

b # !1(%!3 ("/$"5 &

b /$ (+!3 *!"1($"5

!67()8' ($ ,$% 94":$% )IO-/9$% (&,/$":& 4 /73# (3!%,$ ,& 3!,&" *!

!"7),&*$" &":*& !/!(,&" ! *!"#!"&"c &

& $'!*(9%/(& $ -/(/:&% & 94",/25&% "4 =1& :$"+& $a

b !%:%/(& ,& *&9&/:$c

!"#$%& '(

!

) ! *+, -º )./0' 12, 3+4+54,2-676 4282 9 5+*2 6:;6* <+=:2 2->:,:;4,2-6*? @;6-72 :36:6

7+ 6>>;-:2 61+:2 A *+, 4285*+8+-:63. %+>>+> 46>2>? >28+-:+ 2;:36 9 527+3B 3+C2DBE*6.

<+=:2 +>5+4F1,42 7+>:6 >G3,+ :36:63B 76> 3+5+34;>>H+> 76 9$I +8 3+*6JK2 6 +*6.

Page 16: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%& !" !"#$"#%# &'( $"##'%)* !% #"+,-.!%!" #'&.%) " ',/-%#0

'()*'#+ &'1#').!%!% " ('2.).3-.%* '$"-%45"# !" &-6!./'* .1&),#.7" $'-

%1/"&.$%48' !" -"&"./%* &'1&"##8' !" +%-%1/.%0 "

*,+-"*$%& "( 9"#/'# % :%+%-;

:'-/%1/'* % -"#$'1#%2.).!%!" 1% +"#/8' <.#&%) $-"##,$5" =," % %48' +'7"->

1%("1/%) #"?% $-"&"!.!% !" $-'$'#/%# $)%1"?%!%#* /-%1#&'--% !"1/-' !'#

).(./"# " !%# &'1!.45"# .1#/./,&.'1%.# " -"#,)/"( 1'!./*0(1"*&"1/-" -"&"./%#

" !"#$"#%#; @"1A,( %+"1/" $B2).&'

CD'7"-1%!'-* :-"<"./'* E"-"%!'- "/&;F

', ',/-% %,/'-.!%!" =,%)=,"- $'!" %/,%- %' #", 2") $-%G"-; H'!'# '#

%+"1/"# $B2).&'# /I( !.-"./'# " '2-.+%45"# "#/%2")"&.!'# $")% )".* %1/" '

$-.1&J$.' !% 0! #0*'#'!* !"1/-" ',/-'#* % =," "#/3 #,2("/.!% % K!(.1.#>

/-%48' :B2).&%* 1'# /"-('# !' %-/; LM !% NO;

$�$omR�*RYHUQDPHQWDO�H�D�/5)

P "Q"-&J&.' !% %48' +'7"-1%("1/%) '&'--" #'2 '# $-.#(%# $')J/.&' " %!(.1.#>

/-%/.7'; @' $-.(".-' &%#'* '# -"#$'1#37".# #8' %+"1/"# $')J/.&'# ")"./'# '*"!2#

! '!3&-"#2*-#3!,2! $")% #'&."!%!" C:-"<"./'# " E"-"%!'-"#

!

* 1' &%#' !'#

R,1.&J$.'#F0 1' #"+,1!'* "( 7.-/,!" !' -"+.(" $-"#.!"1&.%).#/% 7.+"1/" 1'

:%J#* ' NA"<" !' SQ"&,/.7' R,1.&.$%) %##,(" ' &%-+' !" +"#/'->('- )'&%);

T"##" ('!'* '# :-"<"./'# "1<".Q%( "( #,%# (8'#* #.(,)/%1"%("1/"* %#

<,145"# .1&'1<,1!J7".#* $'-6( .1#"$%-37".#* !" :')J/.&' " K!(.1.#/-%!'-*

=," )A"# &'1<"-"( (,./'# $'!"-"# " "1'-(" -"#$'1#%2.).!%!"* -")%&.'1%>

!'# &'( !'.# '2?"/.7'# !.#/.1/'#* $'-6( &'17"-+"1/"#U

#2!,'!" V# !"(%1!%# !% #'&."!%!"0

4!0#" $")% -&,2*,/*'#'! !% .1#/./,.48' ' 5/,*-(6*&;

!"#$%& '(

!

) & *+,*-./+ 0- 12-,/- 3456.*+ 1571,2- /+018 18 3-88+18 9:8.*18; .,*<=5.018; -= *17>/-7

/71,8./?7.+ +< 3-7=1,-,/-; 0- 9<,@A-8 -8/1/1.8B C> + *+,*-./+ 0- 12-,/- 3+6:/.*+ -,D+6D-;

16E= 018 1</+7.010-8 -6-./18; 18 0- 37.=-.7+ -8*16F+ G.-7>7H<.*+ ,1 2-8/F+ 2+D-7,1=-,I

/16B %+ J<,.*:3.+; 3+7 -K-=36+; 8F+ 12-,/-8 3+6:/.*+8 -6-./+8 + L7-9-./+ - +8 M-7-10+7-8;

- ,F+I-6-./+8; +8 N-*7-/>7.+8 J<,.*.31.8 - 1</+7.010-8 -H<.D16-,/-8B !8 0-=1.8 1</+7.01I

0-8; 8-7D.0+7-8 3456.*+8 - +</7+8 7-83+,8>D-.8 3+7 9<,@A-8 -8/1/1.8 *+,8/./<-= 12-,/-8

3456.*+8; -=5+71 ,F+ *+,8.0-710+8 0- ,1/<7-O1 3+6:/.*1B

P "+71D1,/-; ,-8/- /71516G+; 3171 -9-./+8 0- 8.=36.9.*1@F+; L7-9-./+ - M-7-10+7 8-7F+

0-,+=.,10+8 *+=+ 12-,/-8 3+6:/.*+8 - J<,.*:3.+ *+=+ -89-71 2+D-7,1=-,/16B

Page 17: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$!%&! ' #%&!(!))! $* +',!&#"#$*$! %* !$#-.' $! %'(/*) 0(!1(*)2 ,#/#&!)2

+'%$#-3!)2 4('+!))')2 +'%&(',!)2 *"*,#*-3!) !&+56 +*4*7!) $! $#)+#4,#%*( *

4')&8(* ! ') 4('+!$#/!%&') $! &'$') ') *1!%&!)49:,#+') !%"',"#$') %* *-.'

1'"!(%*/!%&*,2 ' ;8! &!/ ,!"*$' %'))') ,!1#),*$'(!) * #%)&#&8+#'%*,#7<=,*)

)': * >'(/* $! ,!#)2 * !?!/4,' $* @!# %º A5BCDEFA2 ;8! +'%)&#&8#2 )!/ $9"#$*

*,18/*2 8/ $') /*(+') G#)&H(#+') %* #/4,!/!%&*-.' $*) >8%-3!) $!

!"#$%"&$#'(2 )(#'*(!$ ! '*"#+ "*,#)-" %* 1!)&.' 49:,#+*2 $! >'(/*

+'%&I%8*2 #)&' J2 +'/' 4('+!))'5

K !"#!$!%&!4('/8,1*$* !/LMNN (!>'(-'8 )#1%#>#+*&#"*/!%&! !))! #%&!(!))!

+',!&#"'2 ;8*%$'2 !%&(! '8&(*) $!&!(/#%*-3!)2 &'(%'8 ':(#1*&H(#* * !$#-.'

*%8*,2 !/ +*$* !)>!(* $! 1'"!(%'2 $* @!# $! O#(!&(#7!) P(-*/!%&<(#*) 0@OP65

Q'$!=)! $!/'%)&(*( ;8! * @RS "!#' $*( 8/ +*(<&!( /*#) !?4(!))#"' * !))*)

>8%-3!)2 #%+,8)#"! +(#*%$' /!+*%#)/') $! *+'/4*%G*/!%&' 4!(#H$#+' $!

(!)8,&*$')2 $#)+#4,#%*%$'*) *&#"#$*$!)$!*T8)&!!%&(!4('1(*/*$'!!?!+8&*$'

! (*&#>#+*%$' * 48%#-.' $') #%>(*&'(!) %' !?!(+I+#' $* *-.' 1'"!(%*/!%&*,5

K))#/2 4('+8(* !"#&*( #/4('"#)*-3!)2 $!)4!($I+#')2 ! *&J2 %' ,#/#&!2 /*,"!()*=

-3!) ! $!)"#') %* *$/#%#)&(*-.' $') !)+*))') (!+8()') 49:,#+')2 +'/ 4(!T8I7'

4*(* ' *&!%$#/!%&' $*) #%9/!(*) $!/*%$*) $* )'+#!$*$!5

. /!"#$%"&$#'( 0" 123( 4(5$*#"&$#'"!

P Q(!>!#&'2 %* ;8*,#$*$! $! 6$+'(*7&(* &8#-)- "!2 )'/!%&! 4'$!(< #/4,!=

/!%&*( ;8*,;8!( "23( 6(5$*#"&$#'"!;8! #/4,#;8! * *$"!-9"23( 0$ 0$+ $+"

: +'%)&(8#( 8/* !)+',*2 /*%&!( 8/ 4')&' $! )*9$! !/ >8%+#'%*/!%&' !&+5 U

)! !,* !)&#"!( 4(!"#)&* %') 4,*%') 4,8(#*%8*#) ! %') '(-*/!%&') *%8*#)2 #%+,8)#"!

%') )!8) +(J$#&') *$#+#'%*#)2 +'%>'(/!' +*)'5 K #%+,8).' $!$!&!(/#%*$* *-.'

%!))!) #%)&(8/!%&') J 4(!+!$#$* $! 8/* $!+#).' 4',I&#+* !)4!+I>#+*5

K $!+#).' $! (!*,#7*( 8/* *-.' +!(&*/!%&! (!)8,&'8 $* )!,!-.' $! 8/*

*,&!(%*&#"* $!%&(! *) "<(#*) )81!(#$*) 4!,') 6$+'(*$+ 0$ ;*$"+ U V!+(!&<(#')

W8%#+#4*#)5 X!%$' * !)+',G* $' Q(!>!#&' )#$' (*&#>#+*$* 4!,') Y!(!*$'(!)2

4'$!=)! *>#(/*( ;8! !,*2 *' ,*$' $! '8&(*) *-3!) )!,!+#'%*$*) ! *4('"*$*)

4!,' @!1#),*&#"' W8%#+#4*,2 !?4(#/! * (!<'-)" =-+)"! $' Z'"!(%'2 ;8*%$'

/*&!(#*,#7*$* %') 4,*%') 4,8(#*%8*#)2 %* @OP ! %* ,!# '(-*/!%&<(#*5

K (!<'-)" =-+)"! $! +*$* !)>!(* 1'"!(%*/!%&*, $' Q*I) *4H#*=)! !/ $'#)

/*(+') (!>!(!%+#*#)[ $! 8/ ,*$'2 *' (', $! *&(#:8#-3!) #%)&#&8+#'%*#) $! +*$*

8/* $!,*)2 *&(*"J) $* #%&!("!%-.'2 )!T* %' +*/4' !+'%\/#+' 0>'/!%&*%=

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 18: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"!# $%&'$!()( !"! !* )+*)( ! $%&+),&(+&-# .&/) (! '),0! .!'$)1

20%&.&%3)( ! ) '$ ) )($) &4!* 0%&.+)( !# & 5!%,) $%&+) !* )+%)36. &

+&%'&$%!.# !. .&%3$7!. &,)( ) !. 0&1) .!'$& ) &-8 ! !*+%!# 9. .*). 5!(+&.

& %&'&$+).

:

;. !</&+$3!. ) !"#$%&' (%)&'" &.+)%=! +)(+! ,)$. 0%>?$,!. ). ).0$%)7@&.

& (&'&..$ ) &. .!'$)$. A*)(+!,)$. )0!$) !. (! '!(B&'$,&(+! ) %&)1$ ) &

.!'$!&'!(C,$')# !<+$ ! )+%)36. & $)D(>.+$'!. +&'($'),&(+& )'&$+E3&$.:

F..&. $)D(>.+$'!. &3&, %&51&+$% *,) 3&%+&(+& +6'($')# 0!% &?&,01!# )+%)36.

) )(E1$.& !. %&.*1+) !. ) &?&'*7=! !%7),&(+E%$) & &?&%'G'$!. 0%&'&"

&(+&. & ). %&1)7@&. '*.+!4<&(&5G'$! ). )7@&. &,0%&&( $ ).# &3$ &('$)"

). &, %&1)+>%$!. D&%&('$)$. & !*+%). <).&. & ) !.: H16, $..!# +I, A*&

)<.!%3&% ) .&(.$<$1$ ) & .!'$)1 !. )D&(+&. 0!1G+$'!.# 0%$('$0)1,&(+& !.

)D&(+&. &1&$+!.# '!,! %&0%&.&(+)(+&. ) 0!0*1)7=! 23&%+&(+& 0!1G+$')-:

J! &".& )5$%,)% A*& ) ,)+&%$)1$K)7=! ) !"#$%&' (%)&'" (). 1&$. !%7),&(+E"

%$). %&0%&.&(+)# 0)%) ! L!3&%(! M*($'$0)1# ! E0$'& ! 0%!'&..! & 01)(&"

/),&(+!: N&3&, &?$.+$% +%I. +$0!. & 01)(&/),&(+!O

& 1!(D! 0%)K!# (!%+&)( ! ) +!,) ) ). &'$.@&. A*& +I, &, 3$.+) )

&3!1*7=! & ! 5*+*%! ) &(+$ ) &8

& ,6 $! 0%)K!# <).&) ! (! $,&(.$!(),&(+! ). ,&+). & !. %&'*%.!.

0)%) '!('%&+$KE"1).8

& '*%+! 0%)K!# 3!1+) ! 0)%) ) &?&'*7=! ). +)%&5). (&'&..E%$). )!

)+$(D$,&(+! ). ,&+).:

P) ) *, !. +$0!. & 01)(&/),&(+! D&%) %&.*1+) !. A*& .&%3&, & <).&

0)%) ! !*+%!: F(+%&+)(+!# ! 0%$,&$%! +$0!# A*)( ! %&.*1+) &, "*%# '!(.+$+*$

<).& !<%$D)+>%$) 0)%) !%$&(+)% !. &,)$.:

Q! $K&% ! J%!5: N)*%)'$ & R&() ;1$3&$%)

!

#

!"#$%&#'%$( ) *%+$#'%$(#" ! ,% -%+ ,%./$/, 0 ' !+ 0%--

!%" 12#" -% !+ 02+# ( '#+ #- ,%0/-3%- #,%12#,#- !#+# #(/$)/+ -

4&%(/* - ,# - 0/%,#,%5 6 .#( ,% -%+ 2'# #(/*/,#,% 0 $(7$2# %

!%+'#$%$(% 8 12% ,%./$% !"#$%&#'%$( 0 ' !+ 0%-- 5

!"#$%& '(

!

) "*+* ,*- ./,*-+01. 23* 0 4.567890 7-8/37:-80 ;3<898405 ,* 8<,*-* <0 4.567890 =8,905>

? &@AB#A$!C "03-098 1* D*<0> !"#$%"&$#'( )*#+,+-"!C AE!FC $8. 1* G0<*8-.C (H?HC 4>

(I>

Page 19: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$%&#'( ' '#)*+) #) ,-'.!/'"!.0) 1)") ,2)1!33) 1).30&04& 4" #)3

)5/!0&%)3#'6789:33',2!)14,'*+) ;&1'!%&#!.0!<4'.#)!-' 02'0'#'.!1!33=2&'

1)",'0&5&-&>'*+) !.02! ) ??@( ' 6AB!' 6B@( ,)2 !C!",-)( )4 <4'.#) ,2!%D

' 3!<ED.1&' -FG&1'H ,2)G2'"'2( ").&0)2'2( 1).02)-'2( '/430'2( 2!,2)G2'"'29

!"#$%"&' () *+," -".'%#)/'#$)&

A!,2!!.#!I3! <4! ) -!G&3-'#)2( ') ',2)%'2 ' 678( !30'%' !" 5431' #! 4"'

.)2"' 1','> #! 345)2#&.'2 ' '*+) #' @#"&.&302'*+) ?$5-&1' ')3 ,2&.1J,&)3

#! -!G'-&#'#!( &",!33)'-&#'#!( ")2'-&#'#!( !;&1&D.1&'( !.02! )402)3( !3I

0'5!-!1&#)3 .) '209 KL #' M8( 14/' 1)",2)%'*+) 1).#&1&).'I3! ') !;!0&%)

!C!21J1&) #) 1).02)-!9 @ 2!.)"'#' '#"&.&302'0&%&30' N'2&' O-%&' P'.!--' A&

?&!02)

( 1).1!&04' 34' ;&.'-&#'#! .' 3!G4&.0! ';&2"'0&%'H

!"#$%"&$&' &( )(#*+(%' , $ &' $--'./+$+ 0/' $ &1"#"-*+$23( $*/' '1

)(#-(#4#)"$ )(1 (- 5+"#)65"(- 0/' %7' -3( "15(-*(- 5'%( (+&'#$1'#8

*( 9/+6&")(: )(1( (- &$ %'.$%"&$&': 1(+$%"&$&': !"#$%"&$&' 5;<%")$:

5/<%")"&$&': 1(*"=$23(: "15'--($<"%"&$&'> '1 &'*'+1"#$&$- )"+)/#-8

*4#)"$-: $<+$#.' *$1<,1 ( )7$1$&( )(#*+(%' &( 1,+"*( ' 0/' &"?

+'-5'"*( $(- $-5')*(- &"-)+")"(#@+"(- &$ $*/$23( $&1"#"-*+$*"=$A

B Q42&30' R!-O 6),!3 N!&2!--!3

!"

( #&31)22!.#) 3)52! )3 0&,)3 ! '3 ;)2"'3 #!

1).02)-!( '33!%!2'H

B- *"5(- ' !(+1$- &' )(#*+(%' &$ $*"="&$&' $&1"#"-*+$*"=$ =$+"$1

-'./#&( ( C(&'+: D+.3( (/ $/*(+"&$&' 0/' ( 'E'+)"*$ (/ ( !/#8

&$1'#*(: ( 1(&( ' ( 1(1'#*( &' -/$ '!'*"=$23(A --"1: *'1(- $

)(#-"&'+$+ )(1 5+')'&F#)"$ -(<+' (- &'1$"-: 5(+ -/$ 5'+1$#F#)"$ '

$15%"*/&': ( )(#*+(%' &$ 5+D5+"$ &1"#"-*+$23( -(<+' -'/- $*(- '

$.'#*'- G)(#*+(%' $&1"#"-*+$*"=( (/ 'E')/*"=(H ': $ -'./"+: ( &( I'."-8

%$*"=( -(<+' &'*'+1"#$&(- $*(- ' $.'#*'- &( JE')/*"=( G)(#*+(%'

%'."-%$*"=( (/ 5$+%$1'#*$+H ': !"#$%1'#*': $ )(++'23( &(- $*(- "%'.$"-

&' 0/$%0/'+ &(- C(&'+'- 5'%( K/&")"@+"(A

!"#$%& '(

!

) "* +*#,$&- ./01/ 23451/ 6/7844/9 "1081:; !<=171>:0/:15;- !:4/>- $1; <8 ?/7810;- (@ª 8<9 A9

BCB9

(' .#*$#DD#2- E843 D;A8>9 !"#!$% &'(!)!*$"+$!,% -"+*!.#!"%- ./4F810;>- ())'- (Cª 8<9- A9

BG)9

Page 20: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"! #$"%!" $ !"#$!%& &!'( $)*+#',$- ! ./0 1+#+"&'%! $ '%2+%#',$ 3 4!"#'5

2'4!67$ 4$489!" + 3 "+!9':!67$ 1+ !81';%2'!( 4<)9'2!( 18"!%#+ $( 4"$2+(($(

1+ +9!)$"!67$ + 1+ 1'(28((7$ 1$( 49!%$(- .=> + $"6!&+%#$(? >)"'@! !

1'(4$%')'9'1!1+- 18"!%#+ #$1$ $ +A+"2B2'$- 1!( 2$%#!( !4"+(+%#!1!( 4+9$

CD+E+ 1$ $1+" FA+28#',$- %$ "+(4+2#',$ $1+" .+@'(9!#',$ + %$ G"@7$

"+(4$%(H,+9 4+9! (8! +9!)$"!67$- 4!"! 2$%(89#! + !4"+2'!67$ 4+9$( 2'1!17$(

+ 4+9!( '%(#'#8'6I+( 1! ($2'+1!1+?

J +((+ '%2+%#',$ 3 4!"#'2'4!67$ 4$489!"- K+9L .$4+( M+'"+99+(

$ 1+%$&'5

%$8 1+ C$%#"$9+ FA#+"%$ $489!"N

!"#$!%&'"(!) *# +#! #%,#(-.!() %/01# / )%%2"&/ "3/ !4,#*# / (/"&1/+#

52# ,/*#16 %#1 .#!&/ )&1)78% */% 4#!/% ,1/(#%%2)!% (/42"%9 (/4/ /

4)"*)*/ *# %#:21)";) # ) );3/ ,/,2+)1<

J E8%67$ 2$%#"$9+ 1+,+ 4"$4'2'!" ! &+%(8"!67$ + ! !,!9'!67$ 1$( "+(89#!1$(

1! !67$- ! 4!"#'" 1! 2$&4!"!67$ +%#"+ $ 49!%+*!1$ 2$&$O8+ E$' +A+28#!1$-

! E'& 1+ 2$""'@'" $( 1+(,'$( 1+#+2#!1$( $8 "+E!:+" ! 4"$@"!&!67$? C$&$ !

J1&'%'(#"!67$ <)9'2!- (!9,$ "!"!( +A2+6I+(- #+& (+ "+(#"'%@'1$- )!('2!&+%#+-

!$( "+@'(#"$( 2$%#H)+'(- 4!"! $ +A+"2B2'$ 1+((! E8%67$ ! ./0- "+E9+#'%1$ $ (+8

4!4+9 1+ '%(#"8&+%#$ 1+ &81!%6! %! E$"&! 1+ @+"'" ! !67$ @$,+"%!&+%#!9-

'%(#'#82'$%!9':$8- 2$&$ (+ ,+"H !$ 9$%@$ 1+(#+ #+A#$- &+2!%'(&$( O8+ 4+"&'5

#'"7$ 2$&49+&+%#!" $ 4"$2+(($ 1+ 2$%#"$9+ +& #$1! (8! !&49'#81+?

' ($)"*+)$," -) .) '/0! 1!2&$")3&"#)%

J +45%- -.).&- +9+'#! !$ 9!1$ 1! 9+@!9'1!1+- 1! '&4+(($!9'1!1+ + 1! &$"!9'5

1!1+- 2$&$ 8& 1$( &!'( "+9+,!%#+( 4"'%2B4'$( ! O8+ 1+,+ (+" (8)&+#'1! !

J1&'%'(#"!67$ <)9'2!- ,'(! 4"$4$"2'$%!" &!'$" @"!8 1+ #$)"*+)$," -) 3(

!6I+( @$,+"%!&+%#!'(? J ./0 2$%#"')8'- 1+ E$"&! '%2'(',! + 1+2'(',!- 4!"! !

+E+#',!67$ 1+((+ 4"'%2B4'$- !((+%#!1! %! !&49! 1',89@!67$- '%298(',+ !#"!,P( 1+

&+'$( +9+#"Q%'2$( 1+ !2+(($ 4<)9'2$- 1+ #$1$( $( 49!%$(- $"6!&+%#$(- .=>-

4"+(#!6I+( 1+ 2$%#!( + "+(4+2#',$( 4!"+2+"+( 4"P,'$(- "+9!#G"'$( +#2?

M!'( 8&! ,+:- 2$& $ '%#8'#$ 1+ +,'1+%2'!" ! 2$&4!#')'9'1!1+ +%#"+ !%$"&!

R./0S + ! 1$8#"'%!- ($2$""+&$5%$( 1$( +%('%!&+%#$( 1$ M+(#"+ K+9L

!

N

!"#$%& '(

!

(( &)* +,* )* -.(*

(/ &)* +,* )* 0.*

Page 21: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&%'(')* &+,+ !-%.&/!%+ ') (',%.%01-(23+ !4#$%&( 567* (-18 9:*

&(!"1;* (#-(.<) 1+'( (1"(23+ )01(1($* .3+ 0= 0+# + (0!)&1+ ') '%>"$<(23+

+?%&%($ ') 0)"0 (1+0 &+,+* 1(,#@,* ') !-+!%&%(23+ ') &+.A)&%,).1+ '(

&+.'"1( %.1)-.( ') 0)"0 (<).1)08 B00( !"#$%&%'(') (1%.<)* (00%,* +0 (1+0

&+.&$"/'+0 ) ), ?+-,(23+* +0 !-+&)00+0 ), (.'(,).1+* +0 !(-)&)-)0

'+0 =-<3+0 1@&.%&+0 ) C"-/'%&+0* +0 ')0!(&A+0 %.1)-,)'%D-%+0 ) ?%.(%0*

(0 (1(0 ') C"$<(,).1+0 '(0 $%&%1(2E)0 ) +0 &+.1-(1+0 &+, F"(%0F")-

%.1)-)00('+0* #), &+,+ +0 &+,!-+>(.1)0 ') ')0!)0(0 ) (0 !-)01(2E)0

') &+.1(0 0"#,)1%'(0 (+0 =-<3+0 &+,!)1).1)08

!"#!!$%!&'!( ")*'( +,! - ",./*0*%-%! %)' -1)' ! !2!*1)' %- -34) 5)6!#$-&

7!$1-/ $4) 0)$'1*1,* ,7 2*7 !7 '* 7!'7-8 9) 0)$1#:#*)( %!6! #!6!/-#( %!

2)#7- 0/-#-( "#!0*'- ! -0!'';6!/ < ')0*!%-%!( )' #!0,#')' =,7-$)'( 2*$-$0!*&

#)' ! 7-1!#*-*'( !7"#!5-%)' $-' %*6!#'-' -3>!' !7"#!!$%*%-'( 1-$1) !7

'!,' -'"!01)' +,-$1*1-1*6)' +,-$1) +,-/*1-1*6)'8 ?-/6!@ ,7 ",./*0*1:#*)( -

+,!7 2)''! 0)$2*-%- - 1-#!2- %!"#)%,@*# ,7 0$+<(. ').#! ) 1!7-( 0)$0/,;''!

+,! - ABC ).#*5- ) 5!'1)# - "#)6-# +,! -5! !7 "#)/ %- ')0*!%-%! DE"-#-

2)#-FG ! $4) %) "#H"#*) I)6!#$) DE"-#- %!$1#)FG8

J-#- 1-$1)( -' *$2)#7-3>!' - '!#!7 ")'1-' -) 0)$=!0*7!$1) "K./*0)%!6!7

!6*%!$0*-# )' 5-$=)' ).1*%)' $-' #!/-3>!' 0,'1)L.!$!2;0*) %! 0-%- -34)

!7"#!!$%*%-( !7 2,$34) %! ,7 %!'!7"!$=) -''!$1-%) !7 "#*$0;"*)'

#;5*%)' %! 0)$1#)/! %! 0,'1)'( %! -+,*'*3>!' 6-$1-M)'-' %! .!$' ! *$',7)'

! %! -,7!$1) %! "#)%,1*6*%-%!( %!$1#! ),1#)' 2-1)#!'8 N,- -"#!'!$1-34)

%!6!( "#!2!#!$0*-/7!$1!( !$2-1*@-# )' #!',/1-%)' ! $4) '! -1!# < 7!#-

%*6,/5-34) %! %!7)$'1#-1*6)' 1O0$*0)' 0)7 6-/)#!' +,! 'H ")%!7 '!#

!$1!$%*%)' ")# !'"!0*-/*'1-'8

!"#$%&'( ' )'!$*+,$,'(

9 ABC !'1-.!/!0!( $) '!, -#18 PQ( +,! -' +!"#$%&'(-)' '!,' %*'")'*1*6)' '!#4)

",$*%-' 0)7 .-'! !7 6:#*)' %*"/)7-' /!5-*' M: !R*'1!$1!' 0)7) ) SH%*5)

J!$-/( -' A!*' $º T8UPVLWU ! X8YZVLZZ DA!* %! [7"#).*%-%! 9%7*$*'1#-1*6-G(

!0#!1)&A!* $º ZUTL\P ! %!7-*' $)#7-' %- /!5*'/-34) "!#1*$!$1!8 ]) %*-

TVLTULZUUU( 2)* '-$0*)$-%- - A!* $º TU8UZX( +,! -/1!#- ) !0#!1)&A!* $º

ZXY( %! UPLTZLYU ^ SH%*5) J!$-/( - A!* $º T8UPV( %! TULUYLWU( ! )

!0#!1)&A!* $º ZUT( %! ZPLUZL\P( -0#!'0!$1-$%) -)' #!2!#*%)' 1!R1)' /!5-*'

=*"H1!'!' %! *$2#-34) ! #!'"!01*6-' "!$-' %! #!0/,'4)( +,! 6-#*-7 %! '!*'

7!'!' - +,-1#) -$)'8

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 22: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

$�/5)�²�&20(17É5,26�(63(&Ì),&26

!"! #$ %&' ($&%)%*+&, !# *!"$-.'&%!# #$/0%-.$# 1 234 .5" ! 6&%-*%6+7

6&!68#%.! 9$ .&+-#)!&"+& $" 7%-/0+/$" "$-!# )!&"+7 + 7%-/0+/$" :0&;9%*+

0.%7%<+9+ -! .$=.! 9+ 7$%, + )%" )!&-$*$& 0"+ (%#>! "+%# *7+&+ 9$ *!-:0-.!

9+ "$#"+, +##%" *!"! $7$"$-.!# )0-9+"$-.+%# 6+&+ )+*%7%.+& #0+ "$7?!&

*!"6&$$-#>! $ $-.$-9%"$-.!@ A-.&$.+-.!, 9$($ )%*+& $#*7+&$*%9! B0$, -+

+67%*+C>! 9+ 234, D %"6&$#*%-9;($7 + *!-#07.+ +! #$0 .$=.! !&%/%-+7, $"

+-$=!@

E! 9$#$-(!7(%"$-.! 9!# *!"$-.'&%!#, )!&+"+9!.+9!# +7/0-# 6&$##06!#.!#F

&$+7%<+& *!"$-.'&%!# 6!& G$C>!, *!" %-9%*+C>! 9!# 9%#6!#%.%(!# *!&&$#H

6!-9$-.$#I

0#+&, +! "'=%"!, +# 6&86&%+# 6+7+(&+# 9! .$=.! 9+ 7$%I

%.$"%<+& +# ('&%+# +7.$&-+.%(+# !0 9$#9!J&+"$-.!# 9$ +&.%/!#, 6+&'/&+)!#,

%-*%#!# $ +7;-$+#I

9$#.+*+& K$" -$/&%.!LF +CM$#, 6&+<!#, 6&!(%95-*%+#, ($9+CM$#, %"6$9%H

"$-.!# $.*@I

$#*7+&$*$& +# &$)$&5-*%+# + 9%#6!#%.%(!# 9+ 234 !0 9+ 4I

+6&$#$-.+& +7/0-# *!-*$%.!# $ !&%$-.+CM$#, B0+-9! :07/+9!# -$*$##'&%!#@

$3/,&$d®2�(�&21&(,726

4XHP�(VWi�6XEPHWLGR�j�/5)��DUW���º�����º�"

G0+# 9%#6!#%CM$# !J&%/+" + N-%>!, !# A#.+9!#, ! O%#.&%.! 4$9$&+7 $ !#

P0-%*;6%!#, %-*70%-9!F

Q!9$& A=$*0.%(!, ! Q!9$& 2$/%#7+.%(!, -$#.$ +J&+-/%9!# !# R&%J0-+%# 9$

!-.+#, ! Q!9$& S09%*%'&%! $ ! P%-%#.D&%! QTJ7%*!I

+# +9"%-%#.&+CM$# 9%&$.+#, )0-9!#, +0.+&B0%+#, )0-9+CM$# $ $"6&$#+#

$#.+.+%# 9$6$-9$-.$#@

3DUWH�%

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 23: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#"!$%&'( ( )!'*+%(', -" ./%0(, '%&1+' / )!'*+%(1 -" ./%0(, -( 2%'3/4 /

)!'*+%(1 -" ./%0(, -/ 5,0(-/ "4 6+(%-/ 7/+8"!4 / )!'*+%(1 /+ / ./%,"17/

-" ./%0(, -/, 9+%'&:;'/,< =>+(1?"%0"4 ( !"#"!$%&'( ( 5,0(-/, '%&1+' /

@',0!'0/ A"-"!(1<

5? ,:%0","4 ( BCA (*(!&( ( (-?'%',0!(D3/ -'!"0( E,+F"'0( (/ !"#$!%&

'(&$)$*+( !G " (, "%0'-(-", ,+*?"0'-(, (/ !"#$!%& ,("-%./#( !4 &/%&"'0+(H

-/ ;"1/ ?",0!" I"1J &/?/ / K&/%0!/1" 0"1"/1L>'&/

!

-" 8"!'#'&(D3/ -/

"%6+(-!(?"%0/ -( '%,0'0+'D3/ %/ ;!/>!(?( >"!(1 -/ M/8"!%/ " -" ,"+

(&/?;(%7(?"%0/ -/, (0/, -" ,"+, -'!'>"%0", %/ -","?;"%7/ -" ,+(,

#+%DN", ",0(0+0O!'(,4 ;(!( / (0'%>'?"%0/ -(, #'%(1'-(-", -( "%0'-(-" &/%H

0!/1(-(P<

@",," Q10'?/ >!+;/4 #'&(? "R&1+:-(, (, "%0'-(-", 6+" "R"!&"? (0'8'-(-",

"&/%S?'&(, T "?;!",(, ;Q*1'&(, " ,/&'"-(-", -" "&/%/?'( ?',0( T ;/!

",0(!"? ,+F"'0(, (/ !">'?" F+!:-'&/ ;!L;!'/ -(, "?;!",(, ;!'8(-(,4 '%&1+,'8"

6+(%0/ (/, -'!"'0/, " U, /*!'>(DN", &'8',4 &/?"!&'(',4 0!(*(17',0(, " 0!'*+0O!'/,

E(!0<VWX4 Y Vº !! "# $%& '()'*+ #, '-./',#, ',*#*#0, "'.'1"'1*', 2#/*3 4º

!!! "# 56%&3

&RQFHLWRV�(VSHFtILFRV��DUW���º�

7 56% '(.80)0*# +, ,'9:01*', )+1)'0*+,;

!" #$ % # &$'(); # <10=+ )#"# >,*#"+ + ?0,*/0*+ %'"'/#8 ' )#"#

@:10)A.0+B

*+& ,$ -)!"&).$#$

!

; ,+)0'"#"' ):C# -#0+/0# "+ )#.0*#8 ,+)0#8 )+-

"0/'0*+ # D+*+ .'/*'1E# "0/'*# +: 01"0/'*#-'1*' # '1*' "# %'"'/#E=+B

*+& ,$ ,"$"$. # + !# !" ; '-./',# )+1*/+8#"# F:' /')'G# "+ '1*'

)+1*/+8#"+/ /'):/,+, H01#1)'0/+, .#/# .#9#-'1*+ "' "',.',#, )+-

.',,+#8 +: "' ):,*'0+ '- 9'/#8 +: "' )#.0*#8 '()8:A"+, 1+ I8*0-+ )#,+

#F:'8', ./+D'10'1*', "' #:-'1*+ "' .#/*0)0.#E=+ #)0+1J/0#B

& - /"$ -)&& !" .012/#$ 26$5&; ,+-#*K/0+ "#, /')'0*#, */0G:*J/0#, "'

)+1*/0G:0EL', .#*/0-+10#0, 01":,*/0#0, #9/+.'):J/0#, "' ,'/D0E+, */#1,M

!"#$%& '(

() "*+,-. /. 01234.5678 975:.9*4.567 73 .;<=*90>?7 @3. 1.=09*750 34 A067 974 -30 903-0

A*50=8 -.235/7 7 !31B=*7C #4 !/4*5*-610>?7D @3. EF 7- A*5-C

(G #4<1.-0- <HI=*90- . -79*./0/.- /. .97574*0 4*-60C

Page 24: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&'( %)""!$*!( ! )+*"'( "!%!&*'( *',-., %)""!$*!(/ 0) %'() 1)(

!"#$%&#'( 1!2!, (!"3

4 $')&!*+,'( $' 567 )( 2'8)"!( "!%!-&1)( !, 1!%)""#$%&'3

9 1' 7!& 6),:8!,!$*'" $º ;<= 1! >? 1! (!*!,-") 1! >@@A= B+! (C)

:")2!$&!$*!( 1' %),:!$('DC) 1) E6FG= :"!2&(*' !, (!+ '"*/ ?>H

9 1) +$1) :"!2&(*) :!8) '"*/ AI 1) J*) 1'( K&(:)(&DL!( 6)$(9

*&*+%&)$'&( M"'$(&*N"&'(= )+ (!O'= 1) P+$1) 1! F'$+*!$DC) ! K!(!$9

2)82&,!$*) 1) Q$(&$) P+$1',!$*'8 ! 1! R'8)"&S'DC) 1) F'T&(*."&)

UP+$1! V

!

H

4 ,-,!.#,+( 1' 5673

9 ' %)$*"&-+&DC) 1)( (!"2&1)"!( :'"' ) %+(*!&) 1) (!+ (&(*!,' 1!

:"!2&1#$%&' ! '((&(*#$%&' ()%&'8H !

9 '( "!%!&*'( :")2!$&!$*!( 1' %),:!$('DC) &$'$%!&"' %&*'1' $) W @º

1) '"*/ XI> 1' 6P= &(*) .= !2!$*+'&( &$T"!(()( )"&+$1)( 1! )+*")(

(&(*!,'( :"!2&1!$%&Y"&)( :'"' )( B+'&( )( &8&'1)( ! )( ':)(!$*'1)(

:!8) F+$&%Z:&) *!$[', %)$*"&-+Z1)/

J 567 (!"Y ':+"'1' (),'$1)9(! '( "!%!&*'( '""!%'1'1'( $) )/( -)

0-1-0/"$#+ ! $)( '".- '$*!"&)"!(= !\%8+Z1'( '( 1+:8&%&1'1!(= %!"*',!$*!

1!%)""!$*!( 1! *"'$( !"#$%&'( &$*"'T)2!"$',!$*'&(= '8., 1! )+*"'( B+!

:)"2!$*+"' )%)""!"!,/ E(*) (&T$& &%' 1&S!" B+! ' 567 1!2! (!" ':+"'1'

)-"(+2)-"*-= ,!(,) :)"B+! 2Y"&'( 'DL!(= $) 1!%)""!" 1! %'1' !\!"%Z%&)

&(%'8= %),) (! 2!"Y ,'&( '1&'$*!= $!%!((&*', 1) %)$[!%&,!$*) 1) (!+ 2'8)"/

2�3/$1(-$0(172

2�3ODQR�3OXULDQXDO�²�33$��DUW���º�

Q,-)"' !((! '"*/ ?º *!$[' (&1) 2!*'1)= ) :8'$) :8+"&'$+'8= %)$ )",! :"!2&(*)

$) &$%&() E 1) '"*/ >A] 1' 6P ! !\:8&%&*'1) $) (!+ W >º= 1!2!"Y !(*'-!8!%!"=

1! )",' "!T&)$'8&S'1'= '( ,#0-*0#.-(= )( '34-*#5'( ! '()-*+( 1' '1,&$&(9

!"#$%& '(

!

() & *+,-./ .012 3.4+567.,16-8 9.56 :.; *.-.365 ,º <=>?>@ -. ?> -. -.A.7B38 -. (<<C@

D+E80 3.D+3080 0.3F8 695;D6-80 ,6 76,+1.,GF8 . ,8 -.0.,H85H;7.,18 -8 .,0;,8 !"#

$%&'"(%) 9IB5;D8@ . ,6 H6583;A6GF8 -. 0.+ J64;01K3;8= ! -;013;B+;GF8 -80 3.D+3080@ ,8

L7B;18 -. D6-6 #016-8 . -8 ";013;18 *.-.365@ -63M0.M2@ .,13. 8 N8H.3,8 #016-+65 . 80

N8H.3,80 J+,;D;96;0@ ,6 *+,*,+-., -8 ,I7.38 -. 65+,80 7613;D+56-80 6,+657.,1. ,60

.0D8560 D6-60136-60 -60 3.09.D1;H60 3.-.0 -. .,0;,8=

Page 25: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$% &'()*+" &"!" ", !"#!"$" ! %$#&'$( - %. !", !($" !%)**!+'!" -

&"!" ", !-)" */", "%, &!%0!"1", 2- ,*$-.) %)+'&+,$ $3

41" 2", *5%/"#6-, 2% &"#)"&'&/) /!'$ )+%5,*, *" 5" *5, * .*#$% 2%0+!1)

! 2)(3'&%$ 4&"%$(7 %52- 2-/-!*"1 ,-! -, "(-)-+*2%, %, %(8- */%, - ", 1- ",

&).!*"5."*, 2- #)(3'&%$ 5&"%$( " ,-!-1 ")+"5#"2%, 2.!"5 - % &-!9%2% 2-

/*0:5+*" 2% &)"5%7 2-1%5, !"52% " +%1&" *(*)*2"2- 2-)-, +%1 ", &!-1*,,",

- %, %(8- */%, 2", &%)9 *+", -+%5;1*+" 5"+*%5") - 2- 2-,-5/%)/*1-5 %

,%+*")3

<%1% ,- 2-&!--52- 2" )-* .!" 2- ")0.1", 2", !"=6-, "&!-,-5 "2", "%

<%50!-,,% >"+*%5") &-)% ?!-,*2-5 - 2" @-&'()*+"7 % /- % 5$% "+"!!- "

1"*%!-, &!-8.9=%,7 &%!A.- % +%5 -'2% 2% 2*,&%,* */% /- "2% +%5, "!B 2-

%. !%, 2-1%5, !" */%, *5, * .92%, &-)" C@D7 +%1% % E5-F% 2- G- ", D*,+"*,

H CIJ7 +%5 -52%7 2- K%!1" 1"*, &!-+*,"7 1- ", &"!" +*5+% /"!*B/-*, L

!-+-* ",7 2-,&-,",7 !-,.) "2%, 5%1*5") - &!*1B!*% - 29/*2" &'()*+" L &"!"

!:, "5%,7 -,&-+*K*+"2", -1 /")%!-, +%!!-5 -, - +%5, "5 -,3

<%5/M1 -,+)"!-+-! A.- " -F&!-,,$% N2- K%!1" !-0*%5")*="2"O !-)"+*%5"2"

+%1 % &)"5% &).!*"5.")7 . *)*="2" &-)" <D7 5% P Qº 2% "! 3 QRS 2" <D -, B

2*!-+*%5"2" 1"*, &"!" " 45*$%7 ,-1 &!-8.9=% 2- ,." "&)*+"#$% &-)%,T, "2%,

- &-)%, G.5*+9&*%,7 5% +%5 -F % -!!* %!*") 2- +"2" .13 <%1 -K-* %7 1-,1%

5%, G.5*+9&*%,7 2- -!1*5"2% &!%8- % %. " */*2"2- 2*K*+*)1-5 - -!B "(!"5U

0:5+*" -1 %2" " -F -5,$% 2% ,-. -!!* V!*%3 J 1"*, &!%/B/-) M " !-, !*#$%

2%, ,-., -K-* %, " 2- -!1*5"2" !-0*$% W2*, !* %,7 ("*!!%, - +3X3

?%! "5 %7 " *52*+"#$%7 "5 % A."5 % &%,,9/-)7 2" !-0*$% 1.5*+*&") " ,-!

(-5-K*+*"2" %. %(8- % 2- "#6-, *5+).92", 5" &!%&%, " 2% &)"5% &).!*"5.")7

+%5, * .* /")*%,% ".F9)*% -1 &!%) 2% +%5 !%)- - 2" !"5,&"!:5+*"3 J ??E 2-/-

,-! -5+"1*5Y"2% "% ?%2-! C-0*,)" */% &!*5+*&")1-5 -5% &!*1-*!% "5% 2-+"2"

Z%/-!5%7 2"2" " ,." "&)*+"(*)*2"2- "%, &!%0!"1", 2- ,*$-.) %)+'&+,$ $7

*, % M7 +%1 "(!"50:5+*" -1&%!") " M ,.&-!*%! H 2% 1"52" % WA." !% "5%,X3

/HL�GH�'LUHWUL]HV�2UoDPHQWiULDV��DUW���º�

<%1&- - H CIJ7 2- "+%!2% +%1 % P [º 2% "! 3 QRS 2" <D\

!5&+&* ", 1- ", - ", &!*%!*2"2-, 2" E21*5*, !"#$% ?'()*+"]

)*&!+'$* " -)"(%!"#$% 2" )-* %!#"1-5 B!*" "5.")]

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 26: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$% !"#$ % %&'$#%()$ *% &$+, &%(-! '#,".'/#,%0

&"'()&*&+&% % 1!&2',3% 4$ %1&,3%(-! 4% %+5*3,% 6,*%*3$,#% !6,3,%, 4$

6!7$*'!0

!"#$% !"#$ %.'!#,8%()$ 1%#% %.7$*'! 4! +% '! !. 3!*'#%'%(-! 4$

1$ !%& 4% %47,*, '#%(-! 4,#$'% $ ,*4,#$'% 9:;< %#'= >?@< A >º< BBC=

D EFG 6!, ,+*,6,3%',H%7$*'$ 6!#'%&$3,4% 1!#I.$< %&J74$ % ,*3.7"5*3,% <

% EK;< $7 1#!& 4! &,-!*.)%!$ 6,*%*3$,#! $*'#$ #$3$,'% $ 4$ 1$ % < '%7"J7

&L$ %'#,".,.< $7 4,H$# ! 4, 1! ,',H! < 3!71$'5*3,% 1%#% !"+!#*!/(% H/#,%

7%'J#,% = :!7 , !< ,*4$1$*4$*'$7$*'$4% 6!#7% $4! $. 3!*'$M4! %'.%, <

% 1%#',# 4! 1#NO,7! $O$#323,!< 4$H$#-! $# !/+$%#$%( $" %! '$O'! 4% EFG

*!#7% I.$ ,#-! 4, 3,1&,*%# !. '#%'%# 4! $+.,*'$ % .*'! P

0!1(% 3#,'J#,! 1%#% $&%"!#%(-! 4% EGD0

&0!/!% % 6!#7% 4$ .',&,8%(-! $ ! 7!*'%*'$ 4% #$ $#H% 4$ 3!*',*+5*3,%0

0!1(% 2*4,3$ 4$ 1#$(! 1%#% %'.%&,8%(-! 7!*$'/#,% 4! 1#,*3,1%& 4% 42H,4%

7!",&,/#,% #$6,*%*3,%4%0

!"+!#*!/(% % 1#!+#%7%(-! 6,*%*3$,#% $ ! 3#!*!+#%7% 4$ $O$3.(-!

7$* %& 4$ 4$ $7"!& !0

0!1(% 3#,'J#,! 1%#% &,7,'%(-! 4$ $71$*L! $ 4$ 7!H,7$*'%(-! 6,*%*3$,#%<

3% ! ! 3.71#,7$*'! 4% 7$'% 4$ #$ .&'%4! 1#,7/#,! !. *!7,*%& *-!

1! % $# 3!71!#'%4! 1$&% #$%&,8%(-! 4% #$3$,'% 1#$H, '%0

!/ !+(% % 4$ 1$ % *-! .Q$,'% R &,7,'%(-! 4$ $71$*L! $ 4$ 7!H,7$*S

'%(-! 6,*%*3$,#%0

!"#$% !"#$ % +$/+&""2$ $- % (3#*!(42$ 4$ ,*3$*',H! !. "$*$623,! 4$

*%'.#$8% '#,".'/#,% 4% I.%& 4$3!##% #$*M*3,% 4$ #$3$,'%0

!"#$% !"#$ % &+*(%(42$ 4! !#4$*%4!# 4% 4$ 1$ %< *! 3% ! 4$

%.7$*'!< I.%*'! R .% %4$I.%(-! $ R 3!71%',",&,4%4$ !#(%7$*'/#,% $

6,*%*3$,#%< "$7 3!7! I.%*'! R ,*4,3%(-! 4% 3!* ,4$#%4% ,##$&$H%*'$ 0

!"#$% !"#$ % +$3#%$5(42$< % $# %1#$ $*'%4% 1$&! 1#!1!*$*'$< *!

3% ! 4$ 3#,%(-! 4$ 4$ 1$ % !"#,+%'N#,% 4$ 3%#/'$# 3!*',*.%4!< I.%*'!

R .% %4$I.%(-! $ 3!71%',",&,4%4$ !#(%7$*'/#,% $ 6,*%*3$,#%0

0!1(% ! 7$*!#< $ 6!# ! 3% !< 4! 1$#3$*'.%, 4% 4$ 1$ % '!'%& 3!7

1$ !%&< 1!# T!4$# $ N#+-!0

&0!/!% 7$3%*, 7! 1%#% % '#%* 6$#5*3,% H!&.*'/#,% 4$ #$3.# ! 1%#%

!.'#! $*'$< !. 1%#% 3!"#,# *$3$ ,4%4$ 4$ 1$ !% 62 ,3% !. Q.#24,3% 0

&0!/!% 7$3%*, 7! 1%#% ,*3&. -! 4$ *!H! 1#!Q$'! < ! I.%, 4$H$#-!

3!* '%# 4$ #$&%'N#,!< % $# $*3%7,*L%4! %! E$+, &%',H!0

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 27: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$% !"#$ %!#&' ('#' )!%*#!+$ ,$ )- *! $ ,$ '.'+/'01! ,$ #$ -+*'2

,! 3

4+5& ,$ ' /%)-&"6%)/' & !'!$(&!"7 ' 89: ')#$ )$%*!- ; )"*%+*+%& ,'

8<= ! ,$%!&/%',! ,()-$" ) .)*&" /!"'&!" $ ,$ 0!"'$" /!"'&!"7 )!&

' $>-/%*$ )!%?/>-#'01!@

,()-$ ) .)*&" /!"'&!" 1 ,./7 ! A-'+ )!%*$#B@

C 2)*&" &(+&!"7 ('#' ! )-)%'3'!$ ' A-$ $ #$?$#/#$& $ ('#' ! $!"

")4+!(*)"5 $& .'+!#$ )!##$%*$ $ )!% *'%*$

!

7 #$+'*/.' '@

2 #$)$/*' D

2 ,$ ($ ' D

2 #$ -+*',! %!&/%'+ $ (#/&B#/!

"

D $

2 &!%*'%*$ ,' ,E./,' (F"+/)'D

C &6&7!&89$ ,! )-&(#/&$%*! ,' &$*' #$+'*/.' '! '%! '%*$#/!#D

C )2$("*%&*!6$ ,' &$*' '%-'/ 7 /% *#-E,! )!& &$&G#/' $ &$*!,!2

+!>/' ,$ )B+)-+! A-$ H- */?/A-$& ! #$ -+*',! (#$*$%,/,! 7 )!&('#'%2

,!2' )!& ' ?/I',' %! *#6 $I$#)E)/! '%*$#/!#$ 7 $ $./,$%)/'%,! '

)!% / *6%)/' ,$+' )!& ' (#$&/ ' $ ! !"H$*/.! ,' (!+E*/)' $)!%J2

&/)' %')/!%'+D

C )6$7+89$ ,! ('*#/&J%/! +EA-/,!7 *'&"5& %! F+*/&! *#6 $I$#)E)/! 7

,$ *')'%,! ' !#/>$& $ ' '(+/)'01! ,! #$)-# ! !"*/,! )!& '

&7!)(&89$ ,$ '*/.! D

C &6&7!&89$ ,' /*-'01! ?/%'%)$/#' $ '*-'#/'+@

2 ,! #$>/&$ >$#'+ ,$ (#$./,6%)/' !)/'+ $ (#G(#/! ,! $#./,!#$

(F"+/)! $ ,! :-%,! ,$ 4&('#! '! K#'"'+L',!#D

2 ,! ,$&'/ ?-%,! (F"+/)! $ (#!>#'&' $ *'*'/ ,$ %'*-#$M'

'*-'#/'+D

C )2$("*%&*!6$ ,' $ */&'*/.' $ )!&($% '01! ,'@

!"#$%& '(

!

() *+,-./0 1-203+23/0 04- +56.+7-0 86+27- 0/ /956.:+; -0 /</=3-0 =2<,+1=-2>.=-0 7-0 ?+,-./0

1-../23/0@ ;/7=+23/ + +5,=1+A4- 7/ BC27=1/0D 86/ ;/7/; + ?+.=+A4- 7- 5-7/. +86=0=3=?-

7+ ;-/7+ 26; 7/3/.;=2+7- 3.+2016.0- 7/ 3/;5-E %- F.+0=,@ 7=?/.0+0 =203=36=AG/0

5HI,=1+0 / 5.=?+7+0 1+,16,+; / 7=?6,:+;@ ;/20+,;/23/@ ?+.=+7-0 BJ27=1/0D /; 0/60 !"#

2+ !$"#%$#" / /; 56I,=1+AG/0 /05/1=+,=K+7+0@ + /9/;5,- 7- J27=1/ %+1=-2+, 7/ L./A-0

+- -206;=7-. M NL ! 7- NFO# / 7- J27=1/ O/.+, 7/ L./A-0 M "=05-2=I=,=7+7/ N23/.2+

M NOLP"N / 7/ Q/.1+7- M NOLQ@ +;I-0 7+ R627+A4- O/36,=- *+.:+0 M RO*E

(S &# '(")*+ $+,!$)(T 7=</./2A+ /23./ -0 3-3+=0 7+0 ./1/=3+0 / 7+0 7/05/0+0E &# '(")*+

-%!,.%!+T ./06,3+7- 2-;=2+, /91,6C7- 7-0 ?+,-./0 1-../05-27/23/0 U0 ./1/=3+0 7/ -5/.+P

AG/0 7/ 1.V7=3- / 1-; + 1-,-1+A4- 7/ 3C36,-0 ;-I=,=>.=-0 / U0 7/05/0+0 1-; - 0/.?=A- 7+

7C?=7+ WX6.-0@ /21+.:-0 / +;-.3=K+AG/0YE

Page 28: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#"$%& !" #"$"%&'( "

'& (!' )! !*+&",-. !') !")*")') +,#%-'&.#%') !" $'#/&"# $+0&%

01'!+2

/"!*. )! 0%,$., 1%,$&%, 2 /013 +0!" )"#4+ '5'6%'!+)3 %07+#8'0!+ ')

*#+5%!90$%') ' )"#"8 &+8'!') $')+ 5"0:'8 ' )" $+0$#"&%;'#<

= +) +&,,%3., $."4%"(!"4!,( "

= +) .54 ., %,$., $'*';") !" '7"&'# ') $+0&') *>,6%$')2

!"#$ %" &"'() *+),(+) - &*

? /61

!

$+0)&%&1% 18' !') %".3&78!, !' @AB2 C' )1' "6',+#'D4+ !"5" )"

$+0)%!"#'# 18' !%8"0)4+ &"8*+#'6 8E0%8' !" )"%) '0+)3 F1" ',#'0-"3

*+#&'0&+3 + "G"#$E$%+ "8 $1#)+3 +) &#9) *#"$"!"0&") " +) !+%) )1,)"FH"0&")2

I1%&+) I10%$E*%+) J/ &#','6:'5'8 $+8 %0)&#18"0&+ )"8"6:'0&" 0' *#+-#'

8'D4+ !" &#','6:+ ' )"# %0$61E!' 0+ )"1 *#+J"&+ !" 6"% +#D'8"0&/#%' '01'62

K !%7"#"0D' L F1"3 !+#'5'0&"3 "6" )"#/ +,#%-'&.#%+3 &'0&+ 0' 7+#8' F1'0&+

0+ $+0&">!+3 #"))'65'!' ' 7'$16!'!" *#"5%)&' *'#' I10%$E*%+) !" 8"0+#

*+#&" *"6' *#.*#%' @AB M%0$%)+ NNN3 '#&2 OPQ2 ? KIB )"#5%#/ !" ,')" *'#' '

"6',+#'D4+ !' @"% ?#D'8"0&/#%' K01'6 = @?K3 ,"8 $+8+ *'#' + K$+8*'

0:'8"0&+ !' RG"$1D4+ ?#D'8"0&/#%' = KR?3 *'#' + *#+$"))+ !" *#")&'D4+

!" $+0&') " *'#' " 7+#8'&'D4+ !' @S? !+ "G"#$E$%+ )"-1%0&"2

!"#$ %" .+),$) *+),(+) - .*

?1&#+ %0)&#18"0&+ &+#0'!+ +,#%-'&.#%+ *"6' @AB3 &'8,L8 #"))'65'!' '

7'$16!'!" *#"5%)&' 0+ %0$%)+ NNN !' @AB L3 *+))%5"68"0&"3 + 8"0+) 1&%6%;'!+

'&L "0&4+ *"6+) .#-4+) !" *6'0"J'8"0&+ !" +#D'8"0&'D4+ !+) I10%$E*%+)2

T#'&' )" !+ KAB3 '0"G+ F1" !"5"#/ !")$#"5"# +) *+&"0$%'%) "5"0&+) $'*';")

!" *"#&1#,'# + !95%:;< %. !') $+0&')3 $')+ +$+##'8 +&,,%3., $."4%"(!"4!,

" .54 ., %,$.,= %)&+ L3 ' +$+##90$%' !" 7'&+) $%#$10)&'0$%'%) F1" *#+5+F1"8

-"#'D4+ !" !")*")') %8*#"5%)E5"%)3 #"!1D4+ !" #"$"%&') +1 *"#!') !" ,"0)

*'&#%8+0%'%)3 !"0&#" +) F1'%) )4+ $%&'!+) $+8+ "G"8*6+<

!"#$%& '(

!

() *+,-. ./0.12341+ 5./-. 6,+7+89: 5.-+89+ 0,:1.54;.<-:/ 0+,+ /=+ .8+7:,+>?:@

Page 29: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! " #$%&'() *$(!+, #$%&'( $&-.) /0$ 1'(( # 12'3'- 2 +%$(1$2 *'( *$4

($#5'!('( 6+% %-$+2'() 1$2* *$ 5$%( #73$+( '0 +#73$+( $ &8

%$-$((+* *$ *$ -'%-$*$2 2$#+((9' :1$2*9'; *$ -28*+&'( &2+50&<2+'(=

>0!" #$%&' *$6+%+&+3' *$ *$# %* ( >0*+-+ +( /0$*$&$2#+%$) +"0 !#$%&$)

*$($#5'!('( 6+% %-$+2'(.

? 2 /0$ ($0( 3 !'2$( %9' ($ &2 %(6'2#$# %0# @-A0&B#$&2'C) #$(#'

1'2/0$ $!$( *$3$# ($2 +%($2+*'( % DEF -'#' 0# 1 2-$! * @2$($23 *$

-'%&+%"G%-+ C) '( 2$(1'%(<3$+( 1$! 3 !+ H9' *'( $3$%&'( -+# #$%-+'4

% *'( *$3$29' $6$&0 2 !"0# ( +%3$(&+" HI$( $ !$3 %& #$%&'( >0%&' '(

2$"+(&2'( -'%&<5$+() 6+# *$ +*$%&+6+- 2) ' #$%'( %' J!&+#' !"#$"%)

'-'22G%-+ *$ -+2-0%(&K%-+ ( *' "G%$2'.

L$ 1'(($ *$(($( !$3 %& #$%&'( $ *'( -'%($/M$%&$( *$($#5'!('() '( /0 +(

-'%(&+&0+29' 0# 5 ($ 1 2 '( 3 !'2$( ($2$# +%($2+*'( % 12'1'(&

'2H #$%&<2+ *' 127N+#' $N$2-O-+') *$3$# ($2 -'%(0!& * ( '0&2 ( 0&'2+4

* *$(. F( 2$(1'%(<3$+( 1$! 62'& *$ 3$O-0!'( $ *$# +( 5$%( 1 &2+#'%+ +(

1'*$# 6'2%$-$2) 1'2 $N$#1!') +%6'2# HI$( ('52$ -+*$%&$( /0$ &$%A #

12'3'- *' 1$2* ( $ ' 2$(1$-&+3' 3 !'2 * /0$!$( %9' (($"02 *'() $ & #58#

( * <2$ >02O*+- . L$(& ( *$3$# ($2 '5&+*'( '( 3 !'2$( 1'&$%-+ !#$%&$

*$($#5'!(<3$+() *$-'22$%&$( *$ *$# %* ( >0*+-+ +( $# -02('.

P$ !+, * $(( & 2$6 ) -'# ' -0+* *' *$ 2$! -+'% 2) $#/0 *2'( $(1$-O6+-'()

( *+3$2( ( '-'22G%-+ () (0 ( - 0( ( $ '( @12$>0O,'(C -'22$(1'%*$%&$()

$(& 24($4< $# -'%*+HI$( *$ $! 5'2 2 ' FPQ $# 5 ($( # +( -'%*+,$%&$( -'#

2$ !+* *$ A+(&72+- . F!8# *$ ($23+2 *$ 5 ($ 1 2 $! 5'2 H9' *$ '0&2'(

*$#'%(&2 &+3'() ' %$N' *$3$ ($2 '5>$&' *$ $(&0*' /0$ +%*+/0$) ($ 6'2 '

- (') %$-$((+* *$ *$ -'%&2 & 2 -'5$2&02 *$ ($"02'( >0%&' $#12$( ( *'

2 #'.

!"#$%&'#( )*+') ,)-)#+./ ) 0)/1)/./

E 1! %$> #$%&') ' -'%&2'!$ $ &2 %(1 2G%-+ * H9' "'3$2% #$%& !

-'(&0# # !$3 2 ' #$!A'2 12'3$+& #$%&' *'( 2$-02('( 1J5!+-'() $N12$(('

% '5&$%H9' *$ 0# 2$! H9' -0(&'R5$%$6O-+' # +( 1'(+&+3 . F!8# *$ $%6 &+4

,<4!'() DPQ $N1!+-+& ) % ( %'3 ( &2+50+HI$( * DLE) %$-$((+* *$ *$

'5&$%H9' *' &'(")*+!"% $%&2$ 2$-$+& ( $ *$(1$( (. S ! $/0+!O52+' *$3$ ($2

-'#12$$%*+*' -'#' ' &'(")*+!"% ,"$-$.&"!% %( /& .-"0-1

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 30: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%$& #!'(& )!( *$(%!+$( ,'-)-.$'+!(& )/!%)+ )( #+!0'/1-.')( -$.$((2+')(

$ (3,'.'$-%$( 4 ")-3%$-56! /$(($ $73'89:+'!; <( )=3(%$( +$(#$.%'0!( #!/$+6!

!.!++$+ %)-%! /! 8)/! /) +$.$'%)& 73)-%! /) /$(#$()& !3 /$ )":!(& $":!+)

-6! ($ /$(.!->$5) 73$ ? "3'%! ")'( $,'.)@ +$/3@'+ /$(#$() A0') .!-%$-56!

/$ $"#$->!(& #!+ $B$"#8!C /! 73$"$8>!+)+ ! ,83B! /$ '-*+$((! /$ +$.$'%)&

#+!0'/1-.') 73$& '-.83('0$& /$#$-/$ /$ %$+.$'+!( A.!-%+':3'-%$( !3 .+$/!D

+$(C;

E)'( *$(%!+$( /$0$+6! $(%)+ )%$-%!( )! $(%+'%! .3"#+'"$-%! /$ %!/)( )(

-!+")( 8$*)'(& #$8)( )3%!+'/)/$( "3-'.'#)'( 73$& /$ 73)873$+ ,!+")&

.!-.!++)" #)+) )5F$( 73$ '"#).%$" !( ,83B!( /$ +$.$'%) $ /$ /$(#$(); G3)

#+$"'(() :2('.) (6! )( 0$/)5F$( /! )+%; HIJ /) K A73$ /$0$" $(%)+

+$#+!/3@'/)( -) L<MC& $(#$.')8"$-%$ )( $(%)%39/)( -!( ($3( '-.'(!( N& NN& O&

$ PN& 73$ .!-(%'%3$" /'(#!('5F$( .8)+)( $ #+$.'()( #)+) ! )%'-*'"$-%! /$(($

!"#$%&'#(;

Q ,).%90$8 (3#!+ 73$ ) )#8'.)56! /) LR<& )#S( ) 0'*1-.') /) LTK& '+2

"!/','.)+ ! )(#$.%! '++$)8 /$ "3'%!( !+5)"$-%!(& #!'( ($ $(#$+) 73$

+$,8'%)"& /!+)0)-%$& 73)-%'%)%'0) $ 73)8'%)%'0)"$-%$& )( 8'->)( /$ )56!

"'-'")"$-%$ #8)-$=)/)( /) U/"'-'(%+)56! VW:8'.)& )*!+) ")'( .$+.$)/)(

.!" ) '"#!('56! /$ +$(%+'5F$( $ 8'"'%)5F$( )! ($3 .)"#! /$ )56!; U:!+/)-D

/! ! %$")& 8$.'!-)" X$+)8/! /) !(%) T$'( $ Y; E$'B$'+) M).>)/! Y+;

!

Z

!"#$%&'#%(# ! !$)&'#%(! * '&+, -.# .'& /!%,!0+"&)1! "# 20&%!,

34,+/!, # "# $#/.$,!, "&, '&+, 5&$+&"&, %&(.$#6&,7 * .' +%,($.'#%(! "#

($&8&09!: ;#,(# ,#%(+"!< * 2!,,45#0 .(+0+6&$ ! !$)&'#%(! /!'!'#+! "#

"#,/#%($&0+6&)1! &"'+%+,($&(+5&< "# "#0#=&)1! "# /!'2#(>%/+& # "#

&2.$&)1! "# $#,2!%,&8+0+"&"#,< %1! ,? "& !$=&%+6&)1!< '&, (&'8*'

"!, =#,(!$#,< "# '!"! -.# & ,.& &2$!5&)1! ,+=%+3+-.# & &.(!$+6&)1!

2&$& & &)1! #< /!%/!'+(&%(#'#%(#< ! +%4/+! "! 2$!/#,,! "# /!%($!0#:

/HL�2UoDPHQWiULD�$QXDO�²�/2$��DUWV���º�D��º�

!"! #!$%&'()$#*+ ,+% $!-"+% &"+$+,+% ,+ . & ,+ /0. & 1&$,! &"

"&$1& ! 2-!#&%%! ,& 23+$&4+"&$1!5 ! 2-!4&1! ,+ 3&* !-6+"&$17-*+ +$8+35

2-&9*%1! $! *$#*%! ::: ,! +-1; <=> ,+ .5 ,&9&-7 %&- &3+?!-+,! ,& @!-"+

!"#$%& '(

!

() $#*+, -./0123 20 3450, 6! -!"& 7/8, !"# $%&'( )*+",-./.8 *9!6, $:3 2. 70;.:/3,

<=0 .28, ())>, ?8 (<8

Page 31: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&'() !" ! #)$*! #)+,-$*+$) ( !" $ ./0 (1 2(" #,(3+&4! 5!2

5("!*2%,$%-'!2 (2%$%+&5!2 #()$ .(- *º 6789:;<6=

!"#$%&1 (" $*(>!1 5("!*2%,$%-'! 5$ !"#$%-?-)-5$5( 5$ #,!@,$"$AB!

5!2 !,A$"(*%!2 !" !2 !?3(%-'!2 ( $2 "(%$2 !*2%$*%(2 5! C*(>! 5(

D(%$2 E-2 $-2

!

F

'$%& ( !)*("+(,! 5( 5("!*2%,$%-'! 5! $-$.#! %$/.!"(0.1(,!1 5( !,G

,(*%( 5( -2(*AH(21 $*-2%-$21 ,("-22H(21 2+?2&5-!2 ( ?(*(I& -!2 5( *$%+,(4$

I-*$* (-,$1 %,-?+%J,-$ ( ,(5-%& -$ KL <º 5! $,%7 M<N 5$ OEP 2!?,( $2=

Q %$ $.#(' $ ,$'*$'('F

Q %$'*$ #.2('"(5-5$2 5( !"#(*2$AB! #$,$=

G %$"3" .(' 5( ,( (-%$F (

G (4)$"#! 5( 5(2#(2$2 !?,-@$%R,-$2 5( $,J%(, !*%-*+$5!F

!"#$%& %$'$%2( ,$ !"#."/5" .(1 +3$ I!,"$ 5( +%-)-4$AB! ( "!*%$*%(1

5(I-*-5! !" ?$2( *$ SO.1 2(,B! (2%$?()( -5!2 *$ ./01 5(2%-*$5$ $!

$%(*5-"(*%! 5(=

Q *(''.2!' !*%-*@(*%(2F

Q %.' !' $ $2$"#!' I-2 $-2 -"#,('-2%!27

"6! !"'./"(%&7

Q %8,.#! !"=

G -."(0.,(,$ .)*%$ .'(9 !4

G ,!#(:6! .0.).#(,(F (

Q ,!#(:6! #$,$ -*'(2%-"(*%! !" 5+,$AB! 2+#(,-!, $ +" (>(, & -!

I-*$* (-,! T+( *B! (2%(3$ #,('-2%! *! #)$*! #)+,-$*+$) !+ (" )(- T+(

$+%!,-4( $ 2+$ -* )+2B! K5(%(,"-*$AB! !*%-5$ *! L Mº1 $,%7 M<U 5$ OEPF

$"/0!;( %!5$2 $2 5(2#(2$2 ,()$%-'$2 V 5&'-5$ #W?)- $1 "!?-)-J,-$ !+

!*%,$%+$)1 ( $2 ,( (-%$2 T+( $2 $%(*5(,B!7

O!*%+5!1 ! ,(I-*$* -$"(*%! 5$ 5&'-5$ #W?)- $ !*2%$,J1 2(#$,$5$"(*%(1 *$

)(- !,A$"(*%J,-$ ( *$2 5( ,X5-%! $5- -!*$)1 +3$ $%+$)-4$AB! "!*(%J,-$ 5!

#,-* -#$) 5$ 5&'-5$ "!?-)-J,-$ ,(I-*$* -$5$ *B! #!5(,J 2+#(,$, $ '$,-$AB!

5! &*5- ( 5( #,(A!2 #,('-2%! *$ ./01 !+ (" )(@-2)$AB! (2#( &I- $7 Y*%,(G

%$*%!1 ! L 6º 5! $,%7 9Z 5$ .SE $5"-%( T+( ! %!%$) 5! ,(I-*$* -$"(*%!1 $!

I-*$) 5( $5$ (>(, & -!1 %$"?X" 2(3$ $ ,(2 -5! 5$2 !#(,$AH(2 5( ,X5-%!

$+%!,-4$5$2 *! !,A$"(*%! ( #$,$ (2%( (I(-%! ,($)-4$5$27

!"#$%& '(

!

)' !* +*,-* ./ 0*.1 1 2$34 56 7/,89* 1 :6;<*= 1,/>*= / ./7*,=0;10<:*=? & ./01+517/,0*

.*= ;/=@/A0<:*= A*,0/B.*= <,.<A1 CD/ 7D<0*= A*7D,-17 1 7/=71 <,E*;7189* *D *=

@*=0/;<*;/= D0<+<F17 <,E*;718G/= *D :1+*;/= ;/=D+01,0/= .*= 1,0/;<*;/=? !==<74 1 /+1H*;1I

89* ./ CD1+CD/; D7 ./+/= !" ./:/ =/; /,0/,.<.1 A*7* D71 01;/E1 <=*+1.1?

Page 32: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$ %$&$ $#'($)$* '($ + ,-. $#/0 %1#)12314+4%"5 $4/*$ "(/*"#5 " 6 7º5

+*/8 9:75 %+ ;.5 #$<(4%" " '(+3 " "*=+>$4/" ?1#)+3 +@*+4<$*0 "# A"%$*$#

%+ B41!"5 #$(# ?(4%"#5 C*<!"# $ $4/1%+%$# %+ +%>141#/*+=!" %1*$/+ $

14%1*$/+5 14)3(#1&$ ?(4%+=D$# 14#/1/(E%+# $ >+4/1%+# 2$3" A"%$* AF@31)"8 G

2*"2C#1/"5 "# A*"?$##"*$# H$*+3%" %+ ;"#/+ -$1# $ I8 J$1K$1*+ L+)M+%" I*

!

/$)$> "# #$<(14/$# )">$4/0*1"#N

!!"#$ % %&'(#)*+% ,) ,)+)&#"*(,( )*+",(,) ,) ,"&)"+% -./0"1%

"*+)&*% ,)2) !)& !"$ "!+% 3$ ( )*+",(,) ,)2) -%!!4"& (-)*(! 4#

%&'(#)*+% ) *5% #("! 64) 4# -(&( ,(,% )7)&181"% 9"*(*1)"&%$ % 64(0

1%*+)&: +%,(! (! !4(! &)1)"+(! ) ,)!-)!(! ) %4+&%! &)14&!%!; <(! !)

)!!( )*+",(,) -%!!4"& 4#( (4+(&64"( -./0"1($ ("*,( 64) "*+)=&) %

%&'(#)*+% 1%*!%0",(,% )$ -%&+(*+%$ !)>( (-&%2(,% -)0( 0)"$ 1%*9%&#)

,"!-?) % (&+; @AB$ C Bº ,( DE$ % %&'(#)*+% ,)!!( )*+",(,) (4+F*%#(

,4&(*+) ( !4( )7)14'5% )!+(&: ,)!0"=(,% (,#"*"!+&(+"2(#)*+) ,%

%&'(#)*+% ,( )*+",(,)$ +)*,% !4( -&G-&"( !#$%$&$ !4( !#'&()%*#+

$%$& ) !)&: %! %* H%! *%!!%! =&"9%! ,)!+(1(# %! -&"*18-"%! %&'(#)*I

+:&"%! "#-081"+%! *% +)7+%J;

([HFXomR�2UoDPHQWiULD�H�&XPSULPHQWR�GDV�0HWDV��DUWV���º�D����

O A"%$* PK$)(/1&" !"#$ % & '( + 2*"<*+>+=!" ?14+4)$1*+ $ " )*"4"<*+>+

%$ $K$)(=!" >$4#+3 %$ %$#$>@"3#" #") "'*+"# ,*#! +2C# + 2(@31)+=!" %"#

"*=+>$4/"#5 4"# /$*>"# $>'($%1#2(#$* $K)3(#1&+>$4/$ + ,QO5 2"*'(+4/"

+ +3E4$+ 1 %" 14)1#" R %" +*/8 Sº ?"1 *$&"<+%+8 J+3 2*0/1)+5 T0 U +>23+>$4/$

+%"/+%+5 )"4?"*>$ #$ &V 4" +*/8 SW %+ ,$1 4º S8XYZ[:S8

+ $K$)(=!" "*=+>$4/0*1+5 "# *$)(*#"# 3$<+3>$4/$ -*+&.%#,/! \ ?14+31%+%$

$#2$)E?1)+ #$*!" (/131]+%"# $K)3(#1&+>$4/$ 2+*+ +/$4%$* +" "@T$/" %$ #(+

&14)(3+=!"5 +14%+ '($ $> $K$*)E)1" %1&$*#" %+'($3$ $> '($ ")"**$* "

14<*$##"8 P##+ %$/$*>14+=!" 1>2D$ + +%"=!" %$ 2*")$%1>$4/"# $#2$)1+1#

2+*+ <$*1* "# *$)(*#"# &14)(3+%"# $ #(+# +231)+=D$# )">" >"&1>$4/+=!"

?14+4)$1*+ $> )"4/+# $#2$)E?1)+#8

G $K$)(=!" "*=+>$4/0*1+ $ ?14+4)$1*+ 1%$4/1?1)+*0 "# @$4$?1)10*1"# %$

2+<+>$4/" %$ #$4/$4=+# T(%1)1+1# ^2*$)+/C*1"#_5 2"* >$1" %$ #1#/$>+ %$

!"#$%& '(

!

)( $#*+, -./0123 20 3450, 6! -!"& 7/8 398 :;58 98(<8

Page 33: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&'&($() ) $(*&"&+#,$-.! /&"$" )&,$0 1$,$ /&"+ ()!%+),23" &$ ($ !,()*

,!"!'45& $ 1$,$ )/)&#!+ () 1,&!,&($() () 1$5$*)"#!0 ()#),*&"$($ "! $,#6

788 ($ 9:6

;#,$2<+ (! $ !*1$"=$*)"#! !"#$!%& ($ )>) ?-.! !,-$*)"#@,&$ ) (!

?*1,&*)"#! ($+ *)#$+ +&+#)*$#& $*)"#) $! #<,*&"! () '()*&+ (,-! &+0

()2)* +), $(!#$($+ $+ +)5?&"#)+ '(&.! /"%!)+ A$,#6 BºCD

).)0!)12& 3!$4+5()06 )& 7!")0 4 %) ) 3!$4+5(40 $+! $ ,)$'&E$-.! ($

,) )&#$ 1,)2&+#$ ".! 1!++$ !*1!,#$, ! ?*1,&*)"#! ($+ *)#$+ ()

,)+?'#$(! 1,&*@,&! !? "!*&"$' )+#$%)') &($+ "! ;")>! ()845)+ 9!+%)!+0

+),@ '(&$&.! )0 "!+ 5(!"5) !)+ +?%+)FG)"#)+0 '&*&#$-.! () )*1)"=! )

() *!2&*)"#$-.! /&"$" )&,$0 "!+ *!"#$"#)+ ") )++@,&!+0 +)5?"(! !+

,&#<,&!+ /&>$(!+ 1)'$ HIJK

).)0!)12& :;) (!$4+5()06 )5< & 7!")0 &+ $4+4+ 4 $)!&= +454$3(& 4

74.4(4!(&0 ! L!(), M>) ?#&2! ()*!"+#,$,@ ) ).)0!)(> ! ?*1,&*)"#! ($+

*)#$+ /&+ $&+ () $($ :;) (!$4+5(40 )* $?(&N" &$ 1O%'& $ "$ 9!*&++.!

)+1) P/& $ ($ 93*$,$ Q?"& &1$'6

; '&*&#$-.! () )*1)"=! ) () *!2&*)"#$-.! /&"$" )&,$ ".! +) $1'& $ R+

()+1)+$+ F?) !"+#&#?$* !%,&5$-S)+ !"+#&#? &!"$&+ ) ')5$&+

(! 4"540

&" '?+&2) $F?)'$+ ()+#&"$($+ $! 1$5$*)"#! (! +),2&-! ($ (P2&($0 ) $+

,)++$'2$($+ 1)'$ HIJ6 T! $+! () ,)+#$%)') &*)"#! ($ ,) )&#$ 1,)2&+#$0

$&"($ F?) 1$, &$'0 $ ,) !*1!+&-.! ($+ (!#$-S)+0 ?U!+ )*1)"=!+ /!,$*

'&*&#$(!+0 ($,V+)V@ () /!,*$ 1,!1!, &!"$' R+ ,)(?-S)+ )/)#&2$($+6

W) !+ L!(),)+ H)5&+'$#&2! ) X?(& &@,&! ) ! Q&"&+#<,&! LO%'& ! ".! 1,!*!2)V

,)* $ '&*&#$-.! "! 1,$E! )+#$%)') &(!0 ! L!(), M>) ?#&2! /& $ $?#!,&E$(! $

'&*&#$, !+ 2$'!,)+ /&"$" )&,!+ +)5?"(! !+ ,&#<,&!+ /&>$(!+ 1)'$ HIJ6 M+#)

(&+1!+&#&2! +) U?"#$ $ !?#,!+ F?) #N* +&(! !%U)#! () ,P#& $+ /!,*?'$($+ 1!,

U?,&+#$+ ) )+1) &$'&+#$+ )* 2@,&!+ +)*&"@,&!+ ) 1?%'& $-S)+ )+1) &$'&E$($+6

T! $+! 1,)+)"#)0 1!,F?) !'&() !* $ ()#),*&"$-.! )>1,)++$ (! $,#6 7YZ

($ 9: )0 *$&+ (! F?) &++!0 !* $ &"()1)"(N" &$ ) $ =$,*!"&$ )"#,) !+

L!(),)+0 !"+$5,$($+ "! $,#6 [º ($ 9:6

!"#$%& '(

!

)) ! *+,-*../0 12*.,*.3. 45* 607.89853: 0;-9<3=>*. 607.8985690739. * ?*<39.@ *.8A :3?

*:,-*<323 73 B$CD E*F 45* ,02*-A 23- 3 *78*72*- 45* *+9.8*: 2*.,*.3. 19?*<39.@G %3

-*3?9232*D 2*E*H.* *78*72*- 60:0 2*.,*.3.D ,3-3 65I3 -*3?9F3=/0 JA 5:3 -*6*983

E9765?323 05 5:3 2*8*-:973=/0 ?*<3? *+,-*..3D 45* 9:,*=3: 0 32:979.8-320- 2*

,0.8*-<3- 3 .53 *K*89E3=/0G

Page 34: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$%&'()*&+! + !,#,- .$-+'+! +./ !"# $ %"$& +"0! $ ,)*,##+-,).$ ',

*+'+ '"()& !) , ', *+'+ *+$%!"()& !) '1$ + .2)&*+ '+ %"#,("-$ '$

+*$-"+)3+-,).$ '+ ,4,*561$ $#6+-,).7#&+8 9$.,:!, ;5,< +",!+# '$

#,=+.0#&$ >&-,!.#+= ,!.+# "#,%&!.$ )$ ? @º< +#.8 ABC '+ DE< +! !,F5&).,!

"#$%&'()*&+! &-"$!.+! *$)!.&.5,- "#./$01)& $",#+*&$)+&!< +.5+)'$ ,-

>5!*+ '$ )*+"23'!". ,).#, #,*,&.+! , ',!",!+!G

+ $%.04. '+! -,'&'+! #,=+.&%+! H =&-&.+61$ ', ,-",)3$ , ', -$%&-,):

.+61$ I&)+)*,&#+J

+ %)(.#& !$04., + $/$2"$04.'$ *5-"#&-,).$ '+!-,.+! I&!*+&! ', *+'+

*+$%!"()& !)< ,- $+%"5#-"$ 67'2"-$)+ D$-&!!1$ ,!",*KI&*+ '+ DL-+#+

M5)&*&"+=8

! ',.,#-&)+6N,! '+ OPE< *$).&'+! )$! +#.!8 Qº + AR< "$!!5,- 5- $>S,.&%$

&-"=K*&.$ T "#$"&*&+# 5- +*$-"+)3+-,).$ %"#,("-. , "#$!",*.&%$ '+

,4,*561$ $#6+-,).7#&+ , '$ *5-"#&-,).$ '+! -,.+!< 5-+ '+! "#,-&!!+!

&)$%+'$#+! '+ OPE )+ >5!*+ '$ )*+"23'!". I&)+)*,&#$8 =/- '&!!$< .'!"8$(

+ 5.&=&U+61$ ', )$%$! &)!.#5-,).$! ', F,!.1$ I&)+)*,&#+ ,< *$)!,;V,).,:

-,).,< 2"')!$( $! F,!.$#,! ', "$!!K%,&! *#K.&*+! ', $#',)+'$#,! '+ ',!",!+

;5+)'$ +'$.+- +! "#$%&'()*&+! *+>K%,&! "+#+ .+).$< ', ,!.+#,- +F&)'$ ',

I$#-+ '&!*#&*&$)7#&+8

5(&(,7$�3Ô%/,&$

3UHYLVmR�H�$UUHFDGDomR��DUWV�����H����

D$)!.&.5,- #,;5&!&.$! ,!!,)*&+&! '+ #,!"$)!+>&=&'+', )+ F,!.1$ I&!*+= $

"#& " +"04.9 $ 6!)/"&4. ) $ ):) "/$ $!!)-$%$04.', .%.& .& !"'+ .& '+

*$-",.()*&+ *$)!.&.5*&$)+= ', *+'+ ,)., '+ E,',#+61$8 W M5)&*K"&$ ;5,

)1$ *5-"#&# ,!!+ )$#-+ ',!$>,',*, +$ -+)'+-,).$ *$)!.&.5*&$)+= ,4:

"#,!!$ )$ &)*&!$ XXX< +#.8 @R '+ DE< , I&*+#7 &-",'&'$ ', #,*,>,# .#+)!I,#():

*&+! %$=5).7#&+! '$ Y!.+'$ $5 '+ Z)&1$ $5 ', ;5+=;5,# $5.#$ M5)&*K"&$8

[,F5)'$ + OPE< +! 6!)/"&1)& ', #,*,&.+G

.'&)!/$!4. +! )$#-+! ./*)&*+! , =,F+&!J

-.#&"%)!$!4. .& ):)" .&G

T '+! +=.,#+6N,! )+ =,F&!=+61$J

!"#$%& '(

Page 35: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #"$%"&'( !( )*!%+, !, -$,&(./

!( +$,.+%0,*1( ,+(*20%+(/

!, 34"534,$ (41$( 6"1($ $,5,#"*1,/

!"#$ %&$'(%)*%+% 7

!, !,0(*.1$"1%#( !, .4" ,#(54&'( *(. 851%0(. 1$9. "*(./

!" -$(:,&'( -"$" (. !(%. ,;,$+)+%(. .,<4%*1,. =34,5, " 34, ., $,6,$%>

$,0/

!" 0,1(!(5(<%" !, +?5+45( , -$,0%..". 41%5%@"!".A

B C(!,$ D,<%.5"1%#( .(0,*1, ,6,14"$? "!! ,-'%,-.% !, $,+,%1" ., +(0-$(>

#"!( ,$$( (4 (0%..'( !, ($!,0 1E+*%+" (4 5,<"5A F!,0"%.G ( '$),%),!

-$,#%.1( -"$" ". $,+,%1". !, $(!"%/0! +! &"1+-,$ *'( -(!,$? .,$ .4-,$%($

"( !". +! (! % +! &%(-,%2G +(*.1"*1,. !( -$(:,1( !, 5,% ($&"0,*1?$%"

!

A

B C(!,$ H;,+41%#( I4*%+%-"5 +(5(+"$? = !%.-(.%&'( !( C(!,$ D,<%.5"1%#(G

*( 0)*%0( ,"-),% +-% "*1,. !( -$"@( 6%*"5 -"$" ,*+"0%*J"0,*1( !, .4".

-$(-(.1". ($&"0,*1?$%".G (. ,.14!(. , ". ,.1%0"1%#". !". $,+,%1". -"$" (

,;,$+)+%( .4K.,3L,*1,G %*+54.%#, !" $,+,%1" +($$,*1, 5)34%!"G , ". $,.-,+1%#".

0,0M$%". !, +?5+45(A

F. $,+,%1". -$,#%.1". .,$'( !,.!(K$"!".G -,5( C(!,$ H;,+41%#(G ,0 '!,%

3-'! ,"%- !, "$$,+"!"&'(G +(0 " ,.-,+%6%+"&'(G ,0 .,-"$"!(G 34"*!(

+"K)#,5G !". 0,!%!".7

!, &$'3%,! = ,#".'(

"

, = .(*,<"&'(

#

/

!" 45%),-+%+! , !(. #"5($,. !, "&N,. ":4%@"!". -"$" +(K$"*&" !" !)#%!"

"1%#"G

!, !.$25/#$ !( 0(*1"*1, !(. +$E!%1(. 1$%K41?$%(. -"..)#,%. !, +(K$"*&"

"!0%*%.1$"1%#" O%*.+$%1(. (4 *'( ,0 !)#%!" "1%#"PA

F ,;-5%+%1"&'( $,5"1%#" = (K$%<"1($%,!"!, !, %*.1%14%$ , "$$,+"!"$ .,4. 1$%K41(.

!,$$4K" " 1,., !, "5<4*. 6%*"*+%.1".G 34, +(*.%!,$"0 #(54*1?$%" ,.." +(0>

-,19*+%" %*.1%14+%(*"5 !(. I4*%+)-%(. O%.1( EG "!0%1,0 " -(..%K%5%!"!, !,

!,%;"$,0 !, +(K$"$ ( QCRSG -($ ,;,0-5(PA B !,.!(K$"0,*1(G ,0 '!,%

3-'! ,"%- !, "$$,+"!"&'(G +(0 " ,.-,+%6%+"&'( !". 0,!%!". "+%0"G

$,6($&" ( ,*1,*!%0,*1( !, 34, *'( K".1" .(0,*1, ,6,14"$ ( 2%)/%'!),$

!"#$%& '(

!

)* #++, -.+/-0123 4.-05, 43 40+63+/3 73 ,-/8 (9:; <<< 4, =8

)> =3-?, 4. .50/,- 3 6,@,?.7/3 4. /-0AB/3+ C3? A,+. 7,+ DA-.CE,+F G.@,0+8

)H =3-?, 4. .50/,- 3 6,@,?.7/3 4. /-0AB/3+ 4. ?343 I-,B4BG.7/3 3B 4. ?JKIL8

Page 36: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$%&'#!"( )*" +,-% *$ #! !" !" +".!$/!" 0*$* 1'+ ! 2$3 %#! #$%&'#4$%!

!"#$%%$( "!& * .!$)* + ,')+$4$%!( ,!" 2!.$+" )',%2%0*%"5

6" */7+" ,+2+""4$%*" 8 0$+-%"9! * $+2+%#* #*)&3) +:%;+)( *<3) !

2!,=+2%)+,#! !" -*<!$+" *$$+2* * !" ,!" ><#%)!" #$?" *,!" + + !'#$*"

%,.!$)*/7+" 0$! '@% *" 0+<!" -4$%!" A$;9!" ! B!-+$,! C',%2%0*< DE%"2!(

* )%,%"#$* !$+" + )+$2* !" 0>&<%2!" +#25F( !'#$*"( $+<*2%!,* *" 2!) *

-*$%*/9! !" G, %2+" + 0$+/! + + 2$+"2%)+,#! +2!,H)%2!( 0*$* I'"#%.%2*$

* )+#! !<!;%* + 24<2'<! + 0$+)%""*" '#%<%@* *"( +"0+2%*<)+,#+ ,! 2*"! *"

#$*,".+$?,2%*" %,"#%#'2%!,*%" DJKCL( EMC+#25F5 N+-+) "+$ 2!,"'<#* !"( +,#$+

!'#$!"( ! 6,'4$%! O"#*#G"#%2! ! O"#* !( !2')+,#!" D0+"1'%"*"F ! JPBO(

&+) 2!)! ! *,+:! +"0+2G.%2! 8 )+,"*;+) 1'+ +,2*)%,=*$ ! 0$!I+#! *

QNR *S,%9!( ,! 1'*< "+$9! +"0+2%.%2* !" DT Uº( *$#5 Uº * QVEF !" !&I+#%-!"

*" 0!<G#%2*" )!,+#4$%*( 2$+ %#G2%* + 2*)&%*<( &+) 2!)! !" 0*$W)+#$!" + *"

0$!I+/7+" 0*$* "+'" 0$%,2%0*%" *;$+;* !" + -*$%4-+%"( + *%, * *" )+#*" +

%,.<*/9!( 0*$* ! +:+$2G2%! "'&"+1X+,#+

!

5

'D�5HQ~QFLD�GH�5HFHLWD��DUW�����

6 &'!&$%%(' ') * *+,- *.(' + %,2+,#%-! !' &+,+.G2%! + ,*#'$+@*

#$%&'#4$%*( * 1'*< +2!$$* #$!/!& * + $+2+%#*( +-+$4 +"#*$ *2!)0*,=* *

+ +"#%)*#%-* ! +,*&0' !$/*)+,#4$%!Y.%,*,2+%$! D#*,#! ,! $1$#&2& ' +)

1'+ +-* %,%2%*$ "'* -%;?,2%*( 2!)! ,!" 3' % %$") !0$%4( *#+, +$ *!

%"0!"#! ,* QNR + * 0+<! )+,!" )+* *" "+;'%,#+" 2!, %/7+"Z

3$+'!%0#*.('( 0+<! 0$!0!,+,#+( + 1'+ * $+,>,2%* .!% 2!,"% +$* * ,*

+"#%)*#%-* + $+2+%#* * <+% !$/*)+,#4$%*( + + 1'+ ,9! *.+#*$4 *" )+#*"

+ $+"'<#* !" .%"2*%" 0$+-%"#*" ,! *,+:! 0$A0$%! * QNR[

*&'+,*!5*+$!0' +)+ % *" + 2!)0+,"*/9!( ,! 0+$G! !)+,2%!,*Y

! ,! !"#$( 0!$ )+%! ! *')+,#! + $+2+%#*( 0$!-+,%+,#+ * +<+-*/9!

+ *<G1'!#*"( * *)0<%*/9! * &*"+ + 24<2'<!( * )*I!$*/9! !' 2$%*/9!

+ #$%&'#! !' 2!,#$%&'%/9!5

6 #$!/!& * + $+2+%#* 2!)0$++, +Z *,%"#%*( $+)%""9!( "'&"G %!( 2$3 %#!

0$+"')% !( 2!,2+""9! + %"+,/9! +) 2*$4#+$ ,9! ;+$*<( *<#+$*/9! +

!"#$%& '(

!

)* ! +,-./-, 012212 0.34+156.2 1267 0-28.59:1; 5, !"#$!#"< ,64,;+1561 =.561 :,;-.2, 01

812>4-2,? ! 1>4-81 @.:1/5,+156,; -534+A-0, 01 1;,A./,/ 1261< 3.+. .2 01+,-2 01+.52B

6/,6-:.2< ,51C.2 163?< /1=1/-0.2 5, D$E< 01:1 =-3,/ ,86, 8,/, 46-;-F7B;,?

Page 37: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%& %$ '%()*)+ ,-% (. / 0. (. +1!+$!%2 #$. )'3!)#$. 4.($,-% ()0+4)5

')6 ( (. &4)/$&%0 %$ +%6&4)/$),7.0 . %$&4%0 /.6.*"+)%0 #$. +%44.03%6( '

&4 & '.6&% ()*.4.6+) (%

!

8

9%4& 6&%2 3 4&)4 ( :);<6+) ( =>?2 #$ !#$.4 34%3%0& 2 (% @A.+$&):% %$

(% =.;)0! &):%2 :.40 6(% 0%/4. +%6+.00-% (. )6+.6&):%0 *)0+ )02 0%'.6&.

(.:.41 &.4 34%00.;$)'.6&% + 0% 0.B +%'3 6C ( (%0 0.;$)6&.0 (.'%605

&4 &):%0D

! "#$%&!$%'!(% )'3 +&% %4, '.6&14)%5*)6 6+.)4% 6% .A.4+"+)% .' #$.

(.: )6)+) 4 0$ :);<6+) . 6%0 (%)0 0.;$)6&.0E

" ()" !$"* " % ()03%0&% 6 =FGE

" ()" ! +"*,*-%! &.6( 3.!% '.6%0 $' ( 0 0.;$)6&.0 +%6(),7.0D

H "#$".! -/*#% "+! !6 .0&)' &): (. 4.+.)& ( !.) %4, '.6&14) 2 . 6-%

*.&. 0 '.& 0 (. 4.0$!& (%0 *)0+ )0 34.:)0& 0 6% 6.A% 34I34)% (

=FGE %$

H #".! -/&0"*#! ! 3%4 '.)% (% $'.6&% (. 4.+.)& 34%:.6).6&. (

.!.: ,-% (. !"#$%& 02 ( '3!) ,-% ( / 0. (. +1!+$!%2 ( ' B%4 ,-%

%$ +4) ,-% (. &4)/$&% %$ +%6&4)/$),-%

"

8

J-% / 0& #$. %0 %/B.&):%0 (% 34%B.&% (. !.)2 +%6+.(.6(% /.6.*"+)% *)0+ !2

0.B ' %0 ' )0 6%/4.08 K L?2 )60&4$'.6& !)M ( +%' %0 ' 6( '.6&%0

)'3%0&%0 3.! =>?2 .A);. #$. 0.B ' ()!*$%1%-! /# . &" % /# %0 0.$0

)'3 +&%0 6 0 *)6 6, 0 '$6)+)3 )02 3 4 3.4')&)4 : !) ,-% ( 4.! ,-%

+$0&%N/.6.*"+)% . * +)!)& 4 & 4.* (%0 '.'/4%0 (% 9%(.4 =.;)0! &):% (.

4. !)M 4 : !) ,-% (% 'O4)&%8 @' %$&4 0 3 ! :4 02 * +)!)& 4 P LQ' 4

R$6)+)3 !2 6.0&. + 0%2 6 !)0 4 0 4.3.4+$007.0 ( '.()( 6 34%;4 ' ,-%

(%0 )6:.0&)'.6&%0 . 6 34.0& ,-% (%0 0.4:),%0 3S/!)+%0 + 4;% (% R$6)+"5

!"#$%& '(

!

)* & + ,º !"#$ %&' (! )* +, ",-,", ! .+/0+1(23 3/ 2+,4563 ",(/563 (, 0!+, (, 7897/93

7347,++63 (, 7":(2#3 ;",+/<2(3 !42+#2! 3/ ",<2++63 ",9!#2=3+ ! 2<;3+#3+ #!>!+ 3/

734#"20/25?,+@$

AB C!+27!<,4#, +3<,4#, ! ,9,=!563 (, !91D/3#!+ ;!"! 7897/93 (, 2<;3+#3+ ;3(, +/"#2" 3+

,-,2#3+ (,+,E!(3+ ;3"D/, #!4#3 ! 24+#2#/2563 (, #!>!+ D/!4#3 ! (, 734#"20/2563 (,

<,9F3"2! ",+/9#!< ,< ",7,2#!+ ",7/;,"!#G"2!+ (3+ 7/+#3+ 2473""2(3+ 4! ;",+#!563 (3+

+,"=253+ 3/ 4!+ !#2=2(!(,+ D/, H,"!",< ,=,4#/!2+ #!>!+ 3/ 43 7/+#3 (! 30"! D/, ,4+,E!

! 730"!45! (! 734#"20/2563 (, <,9F3"2!$ I3" 3/#"3 9!(3 !+ 0!+,+ (, 7897/93 (3+ 2<;3+#3+

;3" (,#,"<24!563 ,>;",++! (3 !"#$ %JK LLL ! (! )* E8 ,+#63 (,#,"<24!(!+ 43 )G(2H3

M"20/#8"23 N!7234!9 ",7,;7234!(3 73<3 O,2 )3<;9,<,4#!" , 463 ;3(,< +," !9#,"!(!+

;3" 9,2 </4272;!9$ P ,=,4#/!9 !#/!92Q!563 (3+ =!93",+ =,4!2+ (3+ 2<G=,2+ ;3" ,>,<;93

D/!4(3 </2#3 73""2H, /<! -!9F! H"3++,2"! (3 *2+73 R/4272;!9 ;3"D/, ,9,+ (,=,< ",-9,#2"

+,<;", 3+ =!93",+ (, <,"7!(3$

Page 38: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"# $%& "'&()" *"+(&( *",%-)" '& ."/0!/%!'1'& "% &('1 '& $%1,!'1'&#

&2 '&."((3/.!1 '1 (&'%-)" '"* (&.%(*"* +!/1/.&!("*# .1%*1/'" (&4%56" 7

."2%/!'1'&8 9**& (&4%56" "'& *&(# ."2 1(10!:12&/0&# *% &(!"( 1" ;&/&<

+5.!" 1 *&( ."/.&'!'"# 1* &.0" $%& 2&(&.& 1 21!"( 10&/-)"8

'(63(6$�3Ô%/,&$

*HUDomR�GD�'HVSHVD��DUWV�����H����

=* 10"* :",01'"* 1(1 1 .(!1-)"# 1 &> 1/*)" "% " 1 &(+&!-"12&/0" '& !"#

$#%&'( )&(* +# $%& 1.1((&0&2 1%2&/0" '1 '&* &*1# *&()" 1."2 1/?1'"* '&@

&,*-) *-% '" !2 1.0" "(-12&/0A(!"<+!/1/.&!(" /" &.&'/0/-# &2 $%&

'&:1 &/0(1( &2 :!B"( & (#, 1#-, ,23,&45&(*&,# 1."2 1/?1'1 '1*

(&2!**1* & '1 2&0"'","B!1 '& .A,.%," %0!,!61'1*C

1&/+ ' !"# '" "('&/1'"( '1 '&* &*1 '& $%& " 1%2&/0" 0&2 1'&$%1-)"

"(-12&/0A(!1 & +!/1/.&!(1 ."2 1 ,&! "(-12&/0A(!1 1/%1, & ."2 10!;!,!'1<

'& ."2 " ,1/" ,%(!1/%1, & ."2 1 DE=8

F1(1 "* +!/* '1 DGH# ."/*!'&(1<*&@

1&42 1 7 ,&! "(-12&/0A(!1 1/%1, 1 '&* &*1 ";4&0" '& '"01-)" &*<

&.5+!.1 & *%+!.!&/0&# "% $%& &*0&41 1;(1/B!'1 "( .(I'!0" B&/I(!."# '&

+"(21 $%&# *"21'1* 0"'1* 1* '&* &*1* '1 2&*21 &* I.!&# (&1,!61'1* & 1

(&1,!61(# (&:!*01* /" ("B(121 '& 0(1;1,?"# /)" *&412 %,0(1 1**1'"* "*

,!2!0&* &*01;&,&.!'"* 1(1 " &>&(.5.!"C

/#)6 *0%&+ ."2 " ,1/" ,%(!1/%1, & 1 DE= 1 '&* &*1 $%& *& ."/+"(2&

."2 1* '!(&0(!6&*# "* ";4&0!:"*# 1* (!"(!'1'&* & 1* 2&01* (&:!*01* /&**&*

!/*0(%2&/0"* & /)" !/+(!/41 $%1,$%&( '& *%1* '!* "*!-J&*8

K&()" ."/*!'&(1'1* ("# 2*#'-7 1 ,8 -''&$2+ '&, & +&,-% , 1" 10(!2L/!"

M;,!." 1 $&' !"# '& '&* &*1 & 1 ,,2(!"# '& ";(!B1-)" $%& /)" 10&/'12

"* (&$%!*!0"* 1.!218 N'&21!*# &**1* /"(21* ."/*0!0%&2 ."/'!-)" (I:!1 1(1@

&)6&(9# & +-/-* !"# '& *&(:!-"*# +"(/&.!2&/0" '& ;&/* "% &>&.%-)" '&

";(1*C

1&, 6'#6'- !"# '& !2O:&!* %(;1/"*# 1 $%& *& (&+&(& " P Qº '" 1(08 RST

'1 UH8

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 39: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!!"! #$%&%"!' ()#*&+"%"! ()# "! ,$!-,&./$! 0 ()+($!!1) %$ *$+$23(&)!

2&!("&!' !$# 4,$5637) %"! %$#"&! "./$! &+&*&%),"! %$ $8$+-6"&! %$!8&)!

),."#$+-9,&)! )6 2&+"+($&,)!' *6!("# ) -1) ":#$5"%) !"#$%&'#( 2&!(": $'

#"&! 6#" 8$7' &+!-,6#$+-":&7"# )! ;$!-),$! 2&+"+($&,)!<

!"#!"$ %&'()$*+'($ ,! -$'.*!' -/0*(01$,/ 2$'*3 456

=$,9 ()+!&%$,"%" (&'#)*+,'#* - .*'/+ ' .(0+#0"*-( " %$!4$!" .('' 0+

%$,&8"%" %$ :$& )6 "-) "%#&+&!-,"-&8) +),#"-&8)' >6$ 2&?$ " )*,&;".1) :$;":

%$ !6" $?$(6.1) 4), 6# 4$,3)%) !64$,&), "-(#1 2 '.%.#(1< @ "-) >6$ (,&",

)6 "6#$+-", %$!4$!" %$!!" $!4A(&$ %$8$,9 !$,B

#01+'"%-( ()# " $!-&#"-&8" 4,$8&!-" %) #34*.+( ),."#$+-9,&)C2&+"+($&,)

+) 2 '.%.#( $# >6$ %$8" $+-,", $# 8&;), $ +)! -(#1 1"&1 !5 0+ 1 $

()# " %$#)+!-,".1) %" ),&;$# %)! ,$(6,!)! 4"," !$6 (6!-$&)D

*.(34*06*-(%$ %$(:",".1) %) ),%$+"%), %" %$!4$!" %$ >6$ ) "6#$+-)

-$# "%$>6".1) ),."#$+-9,&" $ 2&+"+($&," ()# " :$& ),."#$+-9,&" "+6": $

()#4"-&*&:&%"%$ ()# ) 4:"+) 4:6,&"+6": $ ()# " EF@ $ >6$ !$6! $2$&-)!

2&+"+($&,)!' +)! 4 '%(-(1 1 )"#0+ 1' !$,1) ()#4$+!"%)!' $# (",9-$, 4$,C

#"+$+-$' 4$:) *"3 0+( %$ ,$($&-" )6 4$:" ' -"78( %$ %$!4$!"<

G"!) " H&4I-$!$ 4"," ,$":&7".1) %$!!" %$!4$!" &#4:&>6$ *"3 0+( 4$,#"C

+$+-$ %$ ,$($&-"' $:" 08( 1 '/ 2 ."+*-* "+-$! %" &#4:$#$+-".1) %"!

#$%&%"! >6$ 8&!$# ":("+.", $!!$ )*5$-&8)<

J EKL ()+!&%$," "6#$+-) 4$,#"+$+-$ %" ,$($&-$ ) ),&6+%) %$B

$ 9*78( %$ ":3>6)-"!D

*34$#*78( %" *"!$ %$ (9:(6:)D

3*:('*78( )6 .'#*78( %$ -,&*6-) )6 ()+-,&*6&.1)<

J .(34'(9*78(' " !$, "4,$!$+-"%" 4$:) 4,)4)+$+-$' ()+-$,9 "! 4,$#&!!"!

$ " #$-)%):);&" %$ (9:(6:) 6-&:&7"%"!' !$# 4,$5637) %) $?"#$ %$ ()#4"-&C

*&:&%"%$ %" %$!4$!" ()# "! %$#"&! +),#"! %) 4:"+) 4:6,&"+6": $ %" EF@<

M)-$C!$ >6$ !$ ()+!&%$," *"3 0+( %$ %$!4$!" " 4'(''()*78( %">6$:"

(,&"%" 4), 4,"7) %$-$,#&+"%)<

N;6":#$+-$' !$,1) ()+!&%$,"%"! +1) "6-),&7"%"!' &,,$;6:",$! $ :$!&8"! ")

4"-,&#O+&) 4P*:&() " ) '*78( %$ %$!4$!" )6 " *11"078( %$ )*,&;".1) >6$

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 40: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$% &#' "( )%*+,(,$"( #-,'#. /((#( ")'#( !" (% #01,-#' 2( &%(0%(#(

&%($, #&#( #" (%)3,4" &# &53,&#6 %' #" )%#7+($#'% $" &% )%'+ %)#4!" &%

0%(("#16 &% *+% $)#$# " , -,(" 8 &" #)$. 9: &# ;<.

=")$# $"6 >,-# 3%&#&# # )%#1,?#4!" &% *+#1*+%) "3# !"#!"$ %&''!()! !

%$'*)!' %&()+(,$ &-

(#13" (% -"'0% (#&# -"' '! ,./& &% "+$)# &%(0%(#@ "+

% *+# $" !" 0+1&'$' " &,(0"(,$,3" 1%A#1 *+% $,2!()$'* # )%-%,$#

$),B+$C),# 0)D0),# %' 3#1") (+>,-,% $% 0#)# >, # -,#) %((# &%(0%(#.

;"'" # EF< !" #&',$% (+# -"'0% (#4!" -"' " , -)%'% $" &# )%-%,$#

0)"3% ,% $%&" -)%(-,'% $" %-" G',-""+&%*+#1*+%)"+$)" >#$") )%1%3# $%

!

H-"'" # &%(-"B%)$# &% +' 0"4" &% 0%$)D1%" " $%)),$D)," &" I+ ,-50,"6 0")

%J%'01"K6 -" ($#$#L(% +'# -" $)#&,4!" % $)% %((# ")'# )%($),$,3# % "( 0)%(L

(+0"($"( %($#B%1%-,&"( 0#)# #( 0)%3,(M%( &# )%-%,$# " #)$. NO.

P )%A)# -" $,&# %($% #)$,A" #((+'% +'# ,'0")$Q -,# 3,$#1 # 0)"A)#'#4!"

&#( "B)#( % &% "+$)"( , 3%($,'% $"(. ;"'" (% (#B%6 0)#$,-#'% $% $"&"(

%((%( , 3%($,'% $"( H-1#((,>,-C3%,( -"'" &%(0%(#( &% -#0,$#1K (!" A%)#&")%(

&% >+$+)#( &%(0%(#( -"))% $%( &% -#)C$%) -" $, +#&" H-1#((,>,-C3%,( -"'"

&%(0%(#( &% -+($%,"K % #$R &% "+$)#( &%(0%(#( &% -#0,$#1 H%*+,0#'% $"( &"

0"($" &% (#S&% "+ &# %(-"1#6 0") %J%'01"K6 (%' *+%6 # '#,"),# &#( 3%?%(6

T#7# 0)%3,(!" &"( (%+( ,'0#-$"( "( ")4#'% $"( >+$+)"(.

'DV�'HVSHVDV�FRP�3HVVRDO

'HILQLo}HV�H�/LPLWHV��DUWV�����D����

/ $% &%L(% -"'" &%(0%(# $"$#1 -"'0%(("#1 ""&2$)3'+&&"( A#($"( &" !()!

&# <%&%)#4!" -"' "(U

#$,3"(6 , #$,3"( % 0% (," ,($#(6 )%1#$,3"( # '# &#$"( %1%$,3"(6 -#)A"(6

>+ 4M%( "+ %'0)%A"(6 -,3,(6 ',1,$#)%( % '%'B)"( &% ="&%)6 -"' *+#,(L

*+%) %(0R-,%( )%'+ %)#$D),#(6 $#,( -"'" 3% -,'% $"( % 3# $#A% (6 >,J#(

!"#$%& '(

!

)* +,-, )''( , ."& /010-,2 0345 ,16747819 , :96;083,<=9 :96 9 78:-060849 1, -0:074,

;-9>0870840 19 :-03:760849 0:98?67:9@

Page 41: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%! $&' &()&*+$,&' -#,! ./,& +" "-,& ./"+,#$"' # 0,#1"& - .&2 &'

$.34(&$! "+$3$,."$&' 5#"/$0$3"62 &' 7,#"& 8/#"& !"./"5 .& - &&,"$& +

9("49( # ."/(# :";

.3"#5,& &,3$"$& 3,./#$)($62 & # 3,47$+"& - 4, !" <& ./$+"+ & +

-# !$+=.3$";

3,./#"/,& + / #3 $#$:"6>, + 1>,?+ ?,)#"' 9( & # 0 # 1 < &()&/$/($6>,

+ & #!$+,# & 1-# 5"+,& -@)4$3,&' ,& 9("$& & #>, 3,./")$4$:"+,& 3,1,

AB(/#"& C &- &"& + D &&,"4EF

G + &- &" "#"$% 3,1 - &&,"4' 1 &$'$ ( )*#'# ' $(+)$,-#' & #% 3"43(4"+"

&,1".+,?& " # "4$:"+" ., 1=& 1 # 0 #=.3$" 3,1 "& +,& ,.: $1 +$"/"?

1 ./ "./ #$,# &' "+,/".+,?& , # 5$1 + 3,1- /=.3$"

!

' ' ., 3"&, +,&

H(.$3*-$,&' .>, -,+ #% 83 + # IJK L& && ./" -,# 3 ./,M +" NOPF

Q" ! #$0$3"6>, +, "/ .+$1 ./, +,& 4$1$/ & + 0$.$+,& . &/ "#/$5,' .>, & #>,

3,1-(/"+"& "& + &- &"&R

' .!' !./$,-# -,# + 1$&&>, + & #!$+,# & ,( 1-# 5"+,&;

) %$".0$1 " $.3 ./$!,& < + 1$&&>, !,4(./%#$";

' ).0$'$1 +" "-4$3"6>, +, +$&-,&/, ., $.3$&, SS +, T Iº +, "#/F UV +" OW'

,( & X"' "& + 3,## ./ & + 3,.!,3"6>, 8/#",#+$.%#$" +, D,+ # P 5$&4"?

/$!,' 1 3"&, + (#5=.3$" ,( $./ # && -@)4$3, # 4 !"./ ;

' &#)) !" 1 + + 3$&>, X(+$3$"4 +" 3,1- /=.3$" + - #*,+, "./ #$,#

", +" "-(#"6>, " 9( & # 0 # , T Yº +, "#/F Z[;

&#2 .!$".0#1' "$.+" 9( ' -,# $./ #1\+$, + 0(.+, &- 3*0$3,' 3(&/ "+"&

-,# # 3(#&,& -#,! .$ ./ &R

] +" "## 3"+"6>, + 3,./#$)($62 & +,& & 5(#"+,&;

] +" 3,1- .&"6>, 0$.".3 $#" L ./# ,& +$! #&,& # 5$1 & + -# !$+=.3$"

&,3$"4M + 9( /#"/" , T ^º +, "#/F YJZ +" OW;

] +"& + 1"$& # 3 $/"& +$# /"1 ./ "## 3"+"+"& -,# 0(.+, !$.3(4"+, "

/"4 0$."4$+"+ ' $.34(&$! , -#,+(/, +" "4$ ."6>, + ) .&' +$# $/,&

"/$!,&' ) 1 3,1, & ( &(- #%!$/ 0$.".3 $#,F

G ) ($)".,-# +,& 4$1$/ & 54,)"$& .>, -,+ #% 83 + # ,& & 5($./ & - #3 .?

/("$&R

!"#$%& '(

!

)' *+,-./- 0 012-+34/0 50 +67 40 89-: ;0< 13-:<=-5-> <453,34534/3+34/3 53 /31 7<50 ,-?-

09 4@0A

Page 42: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! !"#! $%& '"()%* $+&+ % ,"-#!.+)#/%0 #('.123% % 4&#51(+. 3" 6%()+! 3%

71(#'2$#%0 81+(3% 9%1/"&:

"#! '#(8;"()+ " 81+)&% $%& '"()%* $+&+ % <="'1)#/% 71(#'#$+.>

?!)% !#-(#@#'+ 3#A"& 81" (B% $%3"&C 9+/"& $%&'()*+,-% "()&" %! D%3"&"!>

E!!#F0 $%& "="F$.%0 !" % D%3"& ,"-#!.+)#/% '%(!1F#& !%F"()" GH0 % @+)%

(B% +1)%&#A+ % <="'1)#/% 71(#'#$+. + 3"!$"(3"& GGH> < /#'"I/"&!+

!

>

J% D%3"& ,"-#!.+)#/%0 %! .#F#)"! !"&B% &"$+&)#3%! "()&" !"1! K&-B%! 3" @%&F+

$&%$%&'#%(+. L FM3#+ 3+! 3"!$"!+! '%F $"!!%+.0 "F $"&'"()1+. 3+ &"'"#)+

'%&&"()" .281#3+0 /"&#@#'+3+! (%! )&N! "="&'2'#%! @#(+('"#&%! #F"3#+)+F"()"

+()"&#%&"! +% 3+ $15.#'+OB% 3+ ,PQ )&#N(#% RSTRR*0 %1 !"U+0 + 6VF+&+ 3"

W"&"+3%&"! " % 4&#51(+. 3" 6%()+! 3% 71(#'2$#%0 81+(3% 9%1/"&>

D+&+ %! &"$+!!"! $&"/#!)%! (% +&)> XYZ 3+ 6Q0 + "()&"-+0 +)M %./+ 01 .( $+.+

&2*0 3%! &"'1&!%! @#(+('"#&%! '%&&"!$%(3"()"! L 3"!$"!+ )%)+. '%F $"!!%+.

$%& D%3"& " K&-B%0 !"&C + &"!1.)+()" 3+ +$.#'+OB% 3%! $"&'"()1+#! 3"@#(#3%!

+'#F+0 %1 +81"."! @#=+3%! + F"(%&0 !" @%& % '+!%0 (+ ,[\

"

>

!"#$%& '(

!

)( #* (+,'-,-'''. /01 230*456787 7 #*9:87 0:;<1<4=10:75 :> -?. @49 /1A7 51*1<9; 2737 0;

;4B;C810; 80; D93978039; 9 0; <9<0; 87; 89;29;7; 80 E0893 F961;57<1G0 H4:1=1275. 9*

/4:IJ0 87 /71A7 89 202457IJ0 80 H4:1=C210K 0*0 9;;7 9*9:87 ;L 9:<37 9* G1603 :0

817 '(,'(,-''(. 0; 1*27=<0; 89=0339:<9; 80; ;4B;C810; ;0*9:<9 ;9 /73J0 ;9:<13 7 273<13

89 -''?. 203@49 =7B93M 70; D93978039;. @49 <0*739* 20;;9 :0 1:C=10 80 23LA1*0 7:0.

/1A73 0; ;4B;C810; 80; @49 0; ;4B;<1<413J0 :7 5961;57<437 ;4B;9@N9:<9K & *9;*0 :J0 ;9

2089 81O93 80; 293=9:<471; =0339;20:89:<9; 70; <9<0; =0* 7; 89;29;7; ! "#$ 87 P*737

89 D93978039; Q DK ! B7;9 89 =M5=450 89;<7; R5<1*7;. ;0B39 7 @475 ;93J0 7251=780; 0;

293=9:<471; @49 39;45<73J0 :0; 51*1<9;. ;93M =0:;<1<4C87 9A=54;1G7*9:<9 87; 39=91<7;

<31B4<M317; 23L2317; Q $SE 9 87; <37:;/93T:=17; =0:;<1<4=10:71; US VWEH. =0<7;U273<9; 80

X HY. XED! 9<=KZ. ;9:80. 203<7:<0. 1:/93103 [ 87 $ FK X;;0 203@49 7 B7;9 89 =M5=450 87

$ F 9:650B7 04<37; 39=91<7;. 729;73 89 7; <37:;/93T:=17; =0:;<1<4C39* 273=957; ;16:1/1=7U

<1G7; 89;<7K !;;1*. 7 273<13 89 '(,'(,-''(. =787 P*737 89G93M 9/9<473 0; =M5=450;

39;29=<1G0;. ;9:80 %&' ! @49 7; D 89 H4:1=C210; =0* 202457IJ0 $()&'#!' 7 <39O9:<0;

*15 \7B1<7:<9; 89G93J0 7251=73 *9:0; @49 0; ]^ 87 $ F 9* 89;29;7; 89 29;;075.

203@47:<0 7 # -? 78*1<9 0 *MA1*0 89 ]^ 80 ;0*7<L310 87 $SE =0* 7 S 2737 0 ! "*

87 89;29;7 80 E0893 F961;57<1G0 H4:1=1275. 9A=54C80; 0; 67;<0; =0* 1:7<1G0;K _ )'!+,+&*

@49 0 *9;*0 0=0337 9* 7564*7; D 89 H4:1=C210; =0* 202457IJ0 #-.&'#!' 7 <39O9:<0;

*15 \7B1<7:<9;K #* @475@493 =7;0. 23980*1:7* 7; 89<93*1:7I`9; 87 # . 203 ;93

89<9:<037 89 \19373@417 ;4293103 [ 87 F$WK

)- & a ?º 80 73<K -' 78*1<9 @49 7 F"& 20893M /1A73 51*1<9; 81;<1:<0; 80; 9;<7B959=180; =0*0

<9<0 2950 !"#$% #;<9 b *71; 4* 20:<0 89 81;=L3817 :7 1:<93239<7IJ0 87 F$WK E39/931*0;

0; G75039; 9;29=1/1=780; :0; 1:=1;0; X. XX 9 XXX 80 73<K -'K !8*1<1*0;. =0:<480. @49 7 F"&

89 89<93*1:780H4:1=C210 20893M 3984O13 2737 ?-^. 203 9A9*250. 0 <9<0 80; 67;<0; =0*

29;;075 80 ;94 E0893 #A9=4<1G0. 9*B037 :J0 20;;7 959G73 2737 *71; 89 ]^ 0 80 ;94

E0893 F961;57<1G0K

Page 43: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$% # &'(%"&)&*+!&,(# -&''&' .&$*&,(/%+' 0&,1% '&,-#2 % &3&!.)# -&

#/($#' -+'.#'+(+0#'2 #"4&(# -& *$5(+*%' & -& -&!%,-%' 4/-+*+%+'2 ,% .$6(+*%2

&! (&$!#' 7+,%,*&+$#'2 ,8# -&0& .$#0#*%$ !%+#$&' +!.%*(#'2 .#$9/&2 ,#

$&:+!& %,(&$+#$ ;<&+ =+(% >%!%(%?2 %.&'%$ -& ,8# 1%0&$ &''% -+'*$+!+,%@8#2

&)% 46 #*#$$+%2 .#$9/& #' -#+' A#-&$&' '#!&,(& -&0&$+%! %.)+*%$ #' .&$*&,B

(/%+' $&'.&*(+0#' '#"$& #' 0%)#$&' -% =>< &7&(+0%!&,(& -+'.#,50&+' .%$% *%-%

/!2 '#" .&,% -& +,*#$$&$B'& &! -/.)% *#,(%:&!C

D%)& $&''%)(%$ 9/& ,8# 'E % F-!+,+'($%@8# G,-+$&(% &'(6 '/"!&(+-% %# (&(#

&'(%"&)&*+-# .&)# H Iº -# %$(C IJK2 -% >L ;*#! % $&-%@8# -% > IKMKN? .%$%

# A#-&$ %# 9/%) '& 0+,*/)%2 *#!# 9/& *#,($+"/+ .%$% # *O!./(# -& '/%'

-&'.&'%' -& .&''#%)C F-&!%+'2 '8# +,*#,*&"50&+' +,(&$&''&' -+0&$:&,(&' #/

#.#'(#' &,($& % F-!+,+'($%@8# P+$&(% & '&/' 7/,-#'

2 %/(%$9/+%'2 7/,B

-%@Q&'2 &!.$&'%' &'(%(%+' -&.&,-&,(&' & #/($%' &,(+-%-&' *#,'(+(/5-%' .&)#

A#-&$ AR")+*#C

,(&,-+!&,(# *#,($6$+# .&$!+(+$+% 9/& /!% &,(+-%-& .&$(&,*&,(& %# A#-&$

AR")+*# -&'#"&-&*&''& /! !%,-%!&,(# %# 9/%) # &,(& 9/& % *$+#/ &'(6

'/"!&(+-# .#$ -&(&$!+,%@8# &3.$&''% -% >L ;%$(C IJK?2 !%(&$+%)+S%-% .&)%

<=LC F)T! -+''#2 &''% -&(&$!+,%@8# *#,'(+(/*+#,%) .&$-&$+% '&/ '+:,+7+*%-#

& &7&+(# '& *%-% &,(&2 .%$% 7/:+$ %# )+!+(&2 ./-&''& *$+%$ /!% &,(+-%-& 9/&2

.#$ 1+.E(&'& $%-+*%)+S%-%2 7#''& +,*/!"+-% -& $&%)+S%$ (#-%' %' '/%' %@Q&'2

!&'!# 9/& '#" % 7#$!% -& *#,($%(# -& :&'(8#2 '&! 7+*%$ 0+,*/)%-% %# (&(#

-%' -&'.&'%' -& .&''#%)C

P&-/SB'& -% %''&$(+0% %*+!% 9/& # (&(# '&4% *#!./(%-# ,# %:$&:%-# -%'

*#,(%' -& *%-% A#-&$ & $&'.&*(+0%' &,(+-%-&' -% %-!+,+'($%@8# +,-+$&(%2

-&0&,-# # '+'(&!% -& $&:+'($# *#,(6"+) &'(%$ .$&.%$%-# .%$% .$#*&-&$ U'

%:$&:%@Q&'2 *#! &3*)/'8# -%' -/.)+*+-%-&' & -%' #.&$%@Q&' +,($%:#0&$,%B

!&,(%+'2 & +,-+*%$ &0&,(/%+' $&'.#,'60&+' .#$ .#''50&+' &3*&''#'C

&RQWUROH�GD�'HVSHVD�7RWDO�FRP�3HVVRDO��DUWV�����D����

V !"#

!

-& .)&,# -+$&+(# # %(#W

!"#$%& '(

!

)) ! *+,-./01 21/ 3.+21/ ,141 5+6*2725 ,1+/6*6.* 47*/ .47 27/ 37-87/ 25 9527:01 27 ;$<=

>19?.5= ,141 /5 /7@5= 1/ 3.+21/ +727 47*/ /01 21 ?.5 95/59A7/ 3*+7+,5*97/ 5/>5,B3*,7/=

25/6*+727/ 7 .47 256594*+727 7>-*,7:01C %01 6D4 >59/1+7-*2725 E.9B2*,7= 1/ ?.5 1

*4>5254 25 >976*,79 761/ ,141 7 724*//01 25 >5//17-C

)F G79*7 HI-A*7 J7+5--7 "* K*5691= 1>C,*6C= >C LLM= 73*947 ?.5 /01 +.-1/ 1/ 761/ ?.5 +01

>1254 /59 ,1+A7-*2721/= ,141 1/ ?.5 7 -5* 7//*4 25,-795C

Page 44: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$%&% !" !"#$%& ' '#()#( *&" )#((& + # $,& %#$' -

. /( #0123$*1 ( 4#+ %15 ( /( '#()#( ( '# * 46%#4 *&$%1$! '& # & '1()&(%&

$& 1$*1(& 7888 '& 4%9 :; <51$*!+ =,& # #>!1) 4 =,& '# 5 $% 2#$(

)#((& 1(? # $& @ Aº '& 4%9 ABC ' DE <4#(%41$2# 5 $% 2#$( # '"1((,&

# *&$%4 % =,& '# )#((& +?F

. & +1"1%# +#2 + '# *&")4&"#%1"#$%& )+1* '& /( '#()#( ( *&")#((& +

1$ %15&

!

9

'" !" $"(!)*" !"#$%& ' '#()#( *&" )#((& +G #0)#'1'& $&( *#$%& #

&1%#$% '1 ( $%#41&4#( & H1$ + '&" $' %& '& %1%!+ 4 '& 4#()#*%15& I&'#49

J& H1$ + '# +,', !,'$-."(*$"G (#46 #H#%! ' 5#41H1* =,& '& *!")41"#$%&

'&( +1"1%#( #(% K#+#*1'&(9 L# '#()#( #0*#'#4 CMN <$&5#$% # *1$*& )&4

*#$%&? '& +1"1%#G & >!# *&44#()&$'# !" O2 %1+P&Q

"

G H1* " 5#' '&(-

+%/+"((0% '# 5 $% 2#"G !"#$%&G 4# R!(%# &! '#>! =,& '# 4#"!$#S

4 =,& >! +>!#4 %T%!+&G ( +5& &( '#415 '&( '# (#$%#$= R!'1*1 + &! '#

'#%#4"1$ =,& +#2 + &! *&$%4 %! +G 4#(( +5 ' 4#51(,& 2#4 + $! +G (#"S

)4# $ "#(" ' % # (#" '1(%1$=,& '# T$'1*#( <1$*1(& 7G 4%9 :; ' DE?F

+$-,10% '# * 42&G #")4#2& &! H!$=,&F

,)*"$,10% '# #(%4!%!4 '# * 44#14 >!# 1")+1>!# !"#$%& '# '#()#( F

#$%&-."/*% '# * 42& )UK+1*&G '"1((,& &! *&$%4 % =,& '# )#((& +

>! +>!#4 %T%!+&G 4#(( +5 ' 4#)&(1=,& '#*&44#$%# '# )&(#$% '&41 &!

H +#*1"#$%& '# (#451'&4#( ' ( 64# ( '# #'!* =,&G ( U'# # (#2!4 $= F

+%/*$,*,10% '# P&4 #0%4 G ( +5& $& * (& '# *&$5&* =,& #0%4 &4'1$641

'& D&$24#((& V *1&$ + <1$*1(& 88G @ Bº '& 4%9 M; ' DE? # ( (1%! =W#(

)4#51(% ( $ XYZ9

L# &( +1"1%#( '#H1$1'&( H&4#" !)*$,#,((,'%(G (#" )4#R!T[& ' ( 5#' =W#(

*1" G & )#4*#$%! + #0*#'#$%# %#46 >!# (#4 #+1"1$ '&G $&('%-( !,'$-."(2

*$"( (#2!1$%#(G (#$'& )#+&"#$&( !" %#4=& $&#$-."-$%G '&% $'&S(#G #$%4#

&!%4 ( "#'1' (G *&"& H *!+% ' 4#'!=,& %#")&4641 ' R&4$ ' '#

!"#$%& '(

!

)* &+ ,-.-/0+ 10 (23 14 $ 5 0+/67 0+/480,09-17+ :4 50- :º ;<=(=> 10 2= 10 :7?0.8@7 10

(;;A> BC0 1-+DE0 +78@0 @0F@4+ F0@4-+ D4@4 4 7@F4:-G4H67 0 7 IC:9-7:4.0:/7 17+ @0F-.0+

D@JD@-7+ 10 D@0?-1K:9-4 +79-4, 17+ +0@?-17@0+ DL8,-97+ 14 M:-67> 17+ #+/417+> 17 "-+/@-/7

N010@4, 0 17+ OC:-9PD-7+> 17+ .-,-/4@0+ 17+ #+/417+ 0 17 "-+/@-/7 N010@4, 0 1Q 7C/@4+

D@7?-1K:9-4+<

)R #++0 SF4/-,T7U> 97.7 V .4-+ 97.C.0:/0 97:T09-17> D7@ +0 /@4/4@ 10 C. +-:4, 10 4,0@/4

D4@4 7 49-7:4.0:/7 10 D@7?-1K:9-4+> BC0 0?-/0. 4 C,/@4D4++4F0.17 ,-.-/0 /7/4,> /4.8V.

V 10:7.-:417> :7+ .0-7+ /V9:-97+> 10 S,-.-/0 D@C10:9-4,U<

Page 45: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#"$%& '&( " ")*+,"-.& )&/ 0*1'2(*1 &/ 3 1&0" '"!4" %&!5!2"6 "/

7!&02)81'2"/ "#"29& :;; <º * =º )& "! > ?@A )" BCDE

!"#$%& *( 7*$& (*1&/ 021 * 7&! '*1 & )"/ )*/7*/"/ '&( '"!4&/ *(

'&(2//.& * F,1-.& )* '&1F2"1-"G

!'&(! )$%& )&/ /*!02)&!*/ 1.& */ 50*2/G

!'&(! )$%& )* /*!02)&!*/ */ 50*2/6 '"/& "/ (*)2)"/ "1 *!2&!*/ 1.& /*H"(

/,F2'2*1 */6 /*( 7!*H,IJ& )" 21)*12J"-.& '&!!*/7&1)*1 *>

K.& )*+)($)") ) !"#$%& 1& 7!"J& */ "#*$*'2)&6 * *1+,"1 & 7*!),!"! &

*9'*//&6 & L,12'I72& 1.& 7&)*!5E

!+!,! !"1/F*!81'2"/ 0&$,1 5!2"/G

&,-! 4"!"1 2"6 )2!* " &, 21)2!* "6 )* &, !& *1 *G

+&(- )-) &7*!"-M*/ )* '!N)2 &6 !*//"$0")"/ "/ )*/ 21")"/ "& !*F21"1'2"O

(*1 & )" )I02)" (&#2$25!2" * "/ +,* 02/*( 3 !*),-.& )"/ )*/7*/"/ '&(

7*//&"$>

P*6 1& . /0!/ & 1#)" /0!2- ! "& 3*-/0& )(& "& 0)(")-&)&/ 2 ,$"!*/ )*

Q&)*!6 *//" )*/7*/" *9'*)*! &/ $2(2 */6 *//"/ !*/ !2-M*/ /.& "7$2'")"/

2(*)2" "(*1 *> R "! > Sº )" T*2 1º ?U>USVWSUUU ("1)" "'!*/'*1 "! & "! >

<XAOY "& BZ)24& Q*1"$6 & +,"$ */ "#*$*'* " 7*1" )* !*'$,/.&6 )* ? :,(D "

= :+," !&D "1&/6 " +,*( &!)*1"!6 ", &!2J"! &, *9*', "! " & +,* "'"!!* *

",(*1 & )* )*/7*/" & "$ '&( 7*//&"$6 1&/ '*1 & * &2 *1 " )2"/ "1 *!2&!*/

"& F21"$ )& ("1)" & &, )" $*42/$" ,!">

'HVSHVDV�FRP�D�6HJXULGDGH�6RFLDO��DUW�����

K*1%,( #*1*FI'2& &, /*!02-& !*$" 20& 3 /*4,!2)")* /&'2"$ 7&)*!5 /*! '!2")&6

("H&!")& &, */ *1)2)& /*( " 21)2'"-.& )" F&1 * )* ',/ *2& & "$6 1&/ *!(&/

)& ; Xº )& "! > ?AX )" BC> [*0*( /*! " *1)2)"/6 "21)"6 "/ *92481'2"/

2(7&/ "/ 3 '!2"-.& )"/ [*/7*/"/ R#!24" Z!2"/ )* B"!5 *! B&1 21,")&6 2/ &

N6 " '&(7*1/"-.& )& 4"/ & 7*$& ",(*1 & )" !*'*2 " !2#, 5!2" &, 7*$"

!*),-.& 7*!("1*1 * )" )*/7*/"> \ "/2.!(2)") )" '&(7*1/"-.& *9242)"

7"!" " '!2"-.& )* )*/7*/" )* '"!5 *! '&1 21,")& :"! > ?]D6 & ",(*1 & )*

)*/7*/" )*'&!!*1 * )*E

+&(+!22%& )* #*1*FI'2& " +,*( /" 2/F"-" "/ '&1)2-M*/ )* %"#2$2 "-.&6

7!*02/ "/ 1" $*42/$"-.& 7*! 21*1 *G

!"#$%& '(

Page 46: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&' ()#$*+*#*+,# ! "#$% &'$%#! $ !( ($)*&+!( ,)$(#" !(-

- #.)%*#/ $*' $ *".!) ! /$%$012&! !3 ($)*&+!4 " 0&' $ ,)$($)*") ! ($3

*".!) )$".5

6(($ %!)'"#&*! ",.&2"7($ "!( /$%$012&!( !3 "!( ($)*&+!( $ ("8 $4 ,)$*& 9%7

2&" $ "((&(#9%2&" (!2&".4 &%2.3(&*$ "!( $(#&%" !( "!( ($)*& !)$( ,8/.&2!( $

'&.&#")$(4 "#&*!( $ &%"#&*!(4 $ "!( ,$%(&!%&(#"(5

7UDQVIHUrQFLDV�9ROXQWiULDV��DUW�����

: '$2"%&('! $ #)"%(0$)9%2&" *!.3%#;)&" < 2!%2$&#3" ! 2!'! " $*- 0#

$ )$23)(!( 2!))$%#$( !3 $ 2",&#". " !3#)! $* " =$ $)"+>!4 " #1#3.! $

2!!,$)"+>!4 "3?1.&! !3 "((&(#9%2&" 0&%"%2$&)"4 @3$ %>! $2!))" $ $#$)'&7

%"+>! 2!%(#&#32&!%".4 .$A". !3 !( $(#&%" !( "! B&(#$'" C%&2! $ B"8 $5 D

#)"%(0$)9%2&" *!.3%#;)&"4 ".<' "( %!)'"( $(#"/$.$2& "( %" EF: " $(0$)"

A!*$)%"'$%#". @3$ 0"G ! )$,"(($4 0&2" 2!% &2&!%" " HI

!+%*1$2+# $ !#"+>! $(,$210&2"-

$&' 3 %*+$#4&' " ,"A"'$%#! $ $(,$("( 2!' ,$((!". "#&*!4 &%"#&*! $

,$%(&!%&(#" J&%2&(! K4 ")#5 LMN " O=P-

2'/"-',#4&'4 ,!) ,")#$ ! /$%$0&2&;)&!4 $I

Q @3$ ($ "2R" $' &" @3"%#! "! ,"A"'$%#! $ #)&/3#!(4 $',)<(#&'!( $

0&%"%2&"'$%#!( $*& !( "! $%#$ #)"%(0$)& !)4 /$' 2!'! @3"%#! H

,)$(#"+>! $ 2!%#"( $ )$23)(!( "%#$)&!)'$%#$ $.$ )$2$/& !(-

Q 23',)&'$%#! !( .&'&#$( 2!%(#&#32&!%"&( )$."#&*!( H $ 32"+>! $ H

("8 $-

Q !/($)*S%2&" !( .&'&#$( "( 1*& "( 2!%(!.& " " $ '!/&.&;)&"4 $

!,$)"+T$( $ 2)< &#!4 &%2.3(&*$ ,!) "%#$2&,"+>! $ )$2$&#"4 $ &%(2)&7

+>! $' U$(#!( " V"A") $ $ $(,$(" #!#". 2!' ,$((!".-

Q ,)$*&(>! !)+"'$%#;)&" $ 2!%#)",")#& "5

W , 3#3# " 3#&.&G"+>! $ )$23)(!( #)"%(0$)& !( $' 0&%".& " $ &*$)(" "

,"2#3" "5

V")" 0&%( " ",.&2"+>! "( ("%+T$( $ (3(,$%(>! $ #)"%(0$)9%2&"( *!.3%#;7

)&"(4 2!%(#"%#$( " EU=4 $?2$#3"'7($ "@3$."( )$."#&*"( " "+T$( $ $ 32"+>!4

("8 $ $ "((&(#9%2&" (!2&".5

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 47: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&'! ($)%$ (&)*!)&%&'! + ,-./.0$1%$ /$)%/&12&/ .) ,3.0.(.) 4/.1)5$6

/71,&.) 81%$/2!'$/1.0$1%.&) ,-.))&5&,.(.)9 /$)*$,%&'.0$1%$9 )!" !) :;(&2!)

<=>=>=? $ @=<=>=?9 ,!0! %/.1)5$/71,&.) ,!//$1%$) !A %/.1)5$/71,&.) ($

,.*&%.-9 1! B($1(! 8 C D!/%./&. E F 1º ! "# $%&$'& (! )*# +,*+-./+ +

".012.3.4+567 "+ "#08#0+! + )*# 0# 2#9#2# 7 +2,& :; "+ <#. 4º %&;'$=>%&

?737 +3+.72.+ "#00+0 ,2+409#2@41.+0 71722# #4,2# + A4.67 # 70B*4.1C8.70!

+ <DE *,.-./+ *3+ 3+4#.2+ 82F,.1+ "# .4"*/.2 +0 3*4.1.8+-."+"#0 + G*01+2 7

,67 +-3#H+"7 #)*.-CG2.7 9.01+- 173 0#*0 82I82.70 #0972570&

J"#3+.0! 70 [email protected] 2#-+,.K70 L0 ,2+409#2@41.+0 K7-*4,F2.+0 073#4,# 87M

"#267 0#2 9.23+"70 0#! +-N3 "# +,#4"."+0 +0 "#3+.0 174".5O#0 +1.3+! 7 #4,#

G#4#9.1.F2.7 ,.K#2 9#.,7 1740,+2! #3 0#* 725+3#4,7! + 82#K.067 "+ !"#$%&

'%$#()%& P0,+ 2#0,2.567 .38#"#! "72+K+4,#! + ,2+409#2@41.+ .4,#2Q7K#24+3#4M

,+-! + R9*4"7 8#2"."7S! 0#3 + 174K#4.#4,# .4".1+567 82#1.0+ "# 0*+ +8-.1+M

567! 872)*# + 3#03+ ,#2F! 0#382#! 7 1+2F,#2 1738-#3#4,+2 "# *3 827H#,7

7* "# *3+ +,.K."+"#&

'HVWLQDomR�GH�5HFXUVRV�3~EOLFRV�SDUD�R�6HWRU�3ULYDGR�DUWV�����D����

J "#0,.4+567 "# 2#1*2070 8+2+! ".2#,+ 7* .4".2#,+3#4,#! 17G2.2T

"* *++()%)*+ "# 8#007+0 9C0.1+0U 7*

),-( (#+ "# 8#007+0 H*2C".1+0U

V "#K#2FT

M +*$ +*,72./+"+ 872 -#. #08#1C9.1+U

M %#*")*$ L0 174".5O#0 #0,+G#-#1."+0 4+ <WXU #

M *+#%$ 82#K.0,+ 47 725+3#4,7 7* #3 0#*0 12N".,70 +".1.74+.0&

P00+ 2#Q2+ %'.( %&+* + ,7"+ + +"3.4.0,2+567 .4".2#,+! .41-*0.K# 9*4"+5O#0

8YG-.1+0 # #382#0+0 #0,+,+.0! #Z1#,7! 47 #Z#21C1.7 "# 0*+0 +,2.G*.5O#0

82#1C8*+0! L0 .40,.,*.5O#0 9.4+41#.2+0 # +7 [+417 ?#4,2+- "7 [2+0.- # 4#-+ 0#

17382##4"#3 (" ./0)%+T

+ !" *++1! "# #382N0,.370! 9.4+41.+3#4,70 # 2#9.4+41.+3#4,70! .41-*M

0.K# +0 2#08#1,.K+0 827227Q+5O#0 # + 173870.567 "# "CK."+0U

+ !" *++1! "# 0*GK#45O#0U #

+ '%$#( ('%21! #3 1740,.,*.567 7* +*3#4,7 "# 1+8.,+-&

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 48: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&'()* !*# +",-+#*# ."&,%*&'!*# #" "&/-'!+'. &'# 0+'&#1"+2&,%'#

' 3"##*'# " &'# 0+'&#1"+2&,%'# ' 4&#$%$-%(5"# 3+%6'!'#7 %8-'9."&$" ,*!%1%,':

!'# &* !"&!* 4 ; 3*+$'+%' <=> &º ?7 !" @AB@CB?D7 /-" '$-'9%E' ' !%#,+%.%:

&'()* *- ' "#F",%1%,'()* !' !"#F"#'7 ' /-" #" +"1"+" * '+$B GH !' I"% &º

ABHC@JKA7 ,*.* HBCBDB@ L!"#F"#'# !" $+'&#1"+2&,%'# ,*++"&$"#M " HBCBHB@

L!"#F"#'# !" $+'&#1"+2&,%'# ,*++"&$"#M " ABHBHB@ L!"#F"#'# !" $+'&#1"+2&,%'#

!" ,'F%$'9MB

# F+%."%+'#7 '9N. !" +"8%#$+'+". *# 8'#$*# ,*. %&'$%6*#7 F"&#%*&%#$'#7

"&,'+8*# F'$+*&'%# "$,B !* "&$"7 %&,9-". *# 8'#$*# ,*. F*%* >%&'&,"%+* '

O#$-!'&$"# " =-$+'# 0+'&#1"+2&,%'# ' 3"##*'#7 "&/-'&$* '# #"8-&!'# "&89*:

P'. '# <-P6"&(5"# <*,%'%# LHBCBHBG Q ,*++"&$"M " O,*&R.%,'# LHBCBHBC Q

,*++"&$"M " -ST9%*# F'+' U"#F"#'# !" V'F%$'9 LABHBHBGM " V*&$+%P-%(5"# F'+'

U"#F"#'# !" V'F%$'9 LABHBHBCMB

=# '+$#B GK " GW !' I"% &º ABHHC@JKA "#$'P"9",". '# ,*&!%(5"# " *# ,+%$N+%*#

F'+' ' ,*&,"##)* !'# #-P6"&(5"# #*,%'%#7 "&/-'&$* * '+$B G?!"$"+.%&' /-"

'# #-P6"&(5"# ",*&R.%,'# #)* -$%9%E'!'# F'+' ,*P"+$-+' !" !"#$#%& !"

.'&-$"&()* !'# ".F+"#'# "#$'$'%#7 P". ,*.* !' !%1"+"&(' "&$+" *# F+"(*#

!" ."+,'!* " *# !" +"6"&!'7 F"9* X*6"+&*7 !" 82&"+*# '9%."&$T,%*# *-

*-$+*# .'$"+%'%# "7 '%&!'7 F'+' F'8'."&$* !" P*&%1%,'(5"# ' F+*!-$*+"# !"

!"$"+.%&'!*# 82&"+*# *- .'$"+%'%#B YZ *# -ST9%*# F'+' U"#F"#'# !" V'F%$'9

#" ,'+',$"+%E'. ,*.* $+'&#1"+2&,%'# !",*++"&$"# !' 9"% !* *+('."&$*7 '*

F'##* /-" '# V*&$+%P-%(5"# F'+' U"#F"#'# !" V'F%$'9 !",*++". !" $+'&#1":

+2&,%'# "#$'P"9",%!'# ". 9"% "#F",T1%,'7 /-" &)* ' !* *+('."&$*B

,*&[-8'()* !*# '+$%8*# CK ' C? !' I\> ,*. *# ."&,%*&'!*# ',%.'7 !'

I"% &º ABHC@JKA7 F"+.%$" %&1"+%+ /-" '# ,*&!%(5"# !"$"+.%&'!'# F"9*#

F+%."%+*# #*."&$" #" 'F9%,'. ;# 0+'&#1"+2&,%'# ' 3"##*'# !"#$%&'!'# ;

,*&,"##)* !" F*%* >%&'&,"%+* ' O#$-!'&$"# " =-$+'# /-" 6%"+". ' #"+

"#$'P"9",%!'# F*+ '(# (&)($*"#$+, #"8-&!* '# ,*&!%(5"# !' IU=7 " ;#

#-P6"&(5"# ",*&R.%,'# -$%9%E'!'# F'+' ,*P"+$-+' !" !"#$#%& !" .'&-$"&:

()* !'# ".F+"#'# "#$'$'%#B

O. ,*&#"/]2&,%'7 '# $+'&#1"+2&,%'# $+'$'!'# &*# '+$#B GK ' G? !' I"% &º

ABHC@JKA7 &)* "S,"F,%*&'9%E'!'# F"9*# CK ' C? !' I\>7 " ,*&$%&-'+)* #"&!*

,*&,"!%!'# &' 1*+.' -#-'9B V*&6N. &*$'+ /-" ' I\> '.F9%*- ' ,*&,"##)*

!'# #-P6"&(5"# ",*&R.%,'# -$%9%E'!'# F'+' ,*P"+$-+' !" !"#$#%& ' /-'%#:

/-"+ *-$+'# F"##*'# [-+T!%,'#7 %8-'9."&$" !" ',*+!* ,*. * /-" 6%"+ ' #"+

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 49: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$ % &'() * !" !#$!%&'"%()! +,-() #! &)-('./ ! (# 0123 ( !( 3 &%#4)3

5, 64 7'!"#! -) )4.#* -") ), * ! ,! &48('")! #('&')-#'!9

1 7 ! 4 ( !"#&#()3 "#*$8*3 5, # 0:; <#4"9 =>? 6 4*'" # %*+%!##,* (

&48('") 6)4 !+-! (# ; ( 4#.@) # 6 !!)#3 AB!'&# ), C,4B('&#3 5, -@) !" C#

!)$ ! , &)-"4)% ('4 ") ), '-('4 ")3 &,C)! -&#4+)! A'-#-& '4)!3 &)*'!!/ !

( !6 !#! &)-+D- 4 ! -@) ( 7 4@) ! 4 '-A 4')4 ! #)! ( A'-'()! * % '

<*,-'&'6#%3 !"#(,#% ), A ( 4#%? ), #) &,!") ( &#6"#.@)9 E#-") #! 64)4F

4)+#./ ! #! &)*6)!'./ ! ( (B7'(#! ( &)44 -" ! ( !!#! )6 4#./ ! (

&48('")3 $ * &)*) # &)-& !!@) ( *648!"'*)! ), A'-#-&'#* -")! *

( !#&)4() &)* !!# 4 +4#3 ( 6 -( * ( #,")4'G#.@) * % ' !6 &BA'&#3

! -() ) #./#&0"* &)44 !6)-( -" &)-!'+-#() -# !" *12(3!+-41"(9 H)*

'!!)3 &)-"'-,#* ! -() 6 4*'"'(#! #! )6 4#./ ! 4 #%'G#(#! * #%+,-!I!"#()!

J,-'&B6')! !)$ # ( -)*'-#.@) ( KL#-&) () M)7)K9

;'-#%* -" 3 6#4 & N'!"'4 ,*# &)-"4#('.@) -"4 ) #4"9 => (# 0:; ! ,

6#4O+4#A) P-'&) ) H#6B",%) QR (# H)-!"'",'.@) (# : 6P$%'&#3 5, "4#"# ()

!'!" *# A'-#-& '4) -#&')-#%3 5, !"#",' 4 +4#! 6#4# ) A,-&')-#* -") (#!

-"'(#( ! ( &48('")3 5, !@) A'!&#%'G#(#! 6 %) L#-&) H -"4#% () L4#!'%9

'Ì9,'$�(�(1',9,'$0(172

'HILQLo}HV�%iVLFDV��DUW�����

S 0:; #()"# #! ! +,'-" ! ( A'-'./ !T

0&5"0( $6/ "%( %*+#* "0(0( *. '.+0(0(T *)-"#-" ")"#%3 #6,4#() ! *

(,6%'&'(#( T

U (#! */1"7(28!# '"+(+%!"1(# () -" (# ; ( 4#.@)3 #!!,*'(#! *

7'4",( ( % '!3 &)-"4#")!3 &)-7D-')! ), "4#"#()!V

U (# 1!( "9(2,* 0! *$!1(28!# 0! %1:0"-*3 6#4# #*)4"'G#.@) * 64#G)T

F #.$!1"*1 # 0*9! 3!#!#V

F "+'!1"*1 ( 0*9! 3!#!#) &,C#! 4 & '"#! " -W#* &)-!"#() () )4.#F

* -")9

0&5"0( $6/ "%( 3*/" "41"(T (B7'(# 6P$%'&# 4 64 ! -"#(# 6)4 "B",%)! *'F

"'()! 6 %# X-'@)3 '-&%,!'7 )! () L#-&) H -"4#% () L4#!'%3 6 %)! I!"#()!

6 %)! J,-'&B6')!V

*$!1(2,* 0! %1:0"-*T &)*64)*'!!) A'-#-& '4) #!!,*'() * 4#G@) ( T

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 50: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%& '()*#$*' +) ,*-+.#%& )!.//0% ) ',).#) +) #1#$2%3

'4$./.50% 6.7'7,.'+' +) ()7/ %$ '**)7+'!)7#% !)*,'7#.23

*),)(.!)7#% '7#),.8'+% +) 9'2%*)/ 8*%9)7.)7#)/ +' 9)7+' ' #)*!% +)

()7/ ) /)*9.5%/3

%$#*'/ %8)*'5:)/ '//)!)2;'+'/& .7,2$/.9) ,%! % $/% +) +)*.9'#.9%/

6.7'7,).*%/3

'//$750%& *),%7;),.!)7#% %$ ,%76.//0% +) +19.+'/ 8)2% !" +'

<)+)*'50%& /)! 8*)=$1>% +% ,$!8*.!)7#% +'/ )?.@A7,.'/ .!8%/#'/ 7%/

,'/%/ +) B)*'50% +) C)/8)/'/ +) 4$) #*'#'! %/ '*#/D EF ) EG3

#$!# %%&$ ' ()*)!"+)H ,%!8*%!.//% +) '+.!82A7,.' +) %(*.@'50%

6.7'7,).*' %$ ,%7#*'#$'2 '//$!.+' 8%* )7#) +' <)+)*'50% %$ )7#.+'+) '

)2) 9.7,$2'+'3

* ,+!)!#+)- !"$ ') './+') -$0+1+2*+)H )!.//0% +) #1#$2%/ 8'*' 8'@'I

!)7#% +% 8*.7,.8'2& ',*)/,.+% +' '#$'2.>'50% !%7)#J*.'D

K * ,+!)!#+)- !"$ +% 8*.7,.8'2 +' +19.+' !%(.2.J*.' 70% )?,)+)*J& '%

#-*!.7% +) ,'+' )?)*,1,.% 6.7'7,).*%& % !%7#'7#) +% 6.7'2 +% )?)*,1,.%

'7#)*.%*& /%!'+% '% +'/ %8)*'5:)/ +) ,*-+.#% '$#%*.>'+'/ 7% %*5'!)7#%

8'*' )/#) )6).#% ) )6)#.9'!)7#) *)'2.>'+'/& ',*)/,.+% +) '#$'2.>'50% !%7)I

#J*.'D L//) 7%*!'#.9% +-3 ' 4$) %/ M$7.,18.%/ 4$) * ,+!)!#+)*)- /$'

+19.+' ,%! ' N7.0% )!.#'! #1#$2%/ '#- ' 4$.#'50% +' +19.+' *)6.7'7,.'+'D

'RV�/LPLWHV�GD�'tYLGD�3~EOLFD�H�GDV�2SHUDo}HV�GH�&UpGLWR�DUW�����

O% 8*'>% +) !$/ !") '+)%4 '8P/ ' 8$(2.,'50% +' QR<& % S*)/.+)7#) +'

R)8"(2.,' +)9)*.' /$(!)#)* '%H

5 !)'$ 6 ' *)1H 8*%8%/#' +) 2.!.#)/ @2%('./ 8'*' % !%7#'7#) +' +19.+'

,%7/%2.+'+' +' N7.0%& +%/ L/#'+%/ ) +%/ M$7.,18.%/& ,$!8*.7+% % 4$)

)/#'()2),) % .7,./% TU +% '*#D FV +' W%7/#.#$.50%& ()! ,%!% +) 2.!.#)/

) ,%7+.5:)/ *)2'#.9%/ '%/ .7,./%/ TUU& TUUU ) UX +% !)/!% '*#.@%

!

3

7$!(* %%$ 8)#+$!)1H 8*%=)#% +) 2). 4$) )/#'()2)5' 2.!.#)/ 8'*' %

!%7#'7#) +' +19.+'!%(.2.J*.' 6)+)*'2 Y.7,./% XUT& '*#D Z[ +' W<\& ',%!8'I

7;'+% +' +)!%7/#*'50% +) /$' '+)4$'50% '%/ #)#%/ 6.?'+%/ 8'*' ' +19.+'

!"#$%& '(

!

)* !+,-./0 1-2340-5367,30813498-: 4º (';<=>'''? - @,A@A0+- BA8 349-684C-1- -A D34-1A

E313,-:? A413 ,393F3G A 4º (HI=>'''J

Page 51: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#!$%&'&' &' ("%)!* '+,"&%&! ! &%#-!#+! "! %" %#! . &! / 0º &,#+,

'1+%2!

!

3

4# -1!-!#+'# 1,5,1%&'# ' %6' , #7'# '$+,1'89,# &,:,1)! !"+,1;

!"#$%&'()*#&, <7, !# $%6%+,# , '# !"&%89,# 27'1&'6 !,1=" %' !6

'# "!16'# ,#+'>,$, %&'# "' ?@A , !6 !# !>B,+%:!# &' -!$C+% ' 5%# '$D

!%&+"(&+,(% &! %6-' +! &' '-$% '8)! &!# $%6%+,# ' '&' 76' &'# +1=#

,#5,1'# &, 2!:,1"!D

'(-.!% &, ,:,"+7'$ -1!-!#%8)! &, $%6%+,# &%5,1," %'&!# -!1 ,#5,1' &,

2!:,1"!D

"!&# #/#0+( &, '-71'8)! &!# 1,#7$+'&!# -1%6E1%! , "!6%"'$3

4# -1!-!#+'# 6," %!"'&'# +'6>F6 -!&,1)! #,1 '-1,#,"+'&'# ,6 +,16!#

&, &C:%&' $C<7%&'* ,:%&," %'"&! ' 5!16' , ' 6,+!&!$!2%' &, #7' '-71'8)!3

G# $%6%+,# #,1)! 5%H'&!# ,6 -,1 ,"+7'$ &' 1, ,%+' !11,"+, $C<7%&' -'1' '&'

,#5,1' &, 2!:,1"! , '-$% '&!# %27'$6,"+, ' +!&!# !# ,"+,# &' A,&,1'8)!

!"#+%+7%"&!* -'1' '&' 76 &,$,#* $%6%+,# 6EH%6!#3 I,6-1, <7, '$+,1'&!#

!# 57"&'6,"+!# &'# -1!-!#+'#* ,6 1'J)! &, %"#+'>%$%&'&, , !"K6% ' !7 &,

'$+,1'89,# "'# -!$C+% '# 6!",+E1%' !7 '6>%'$* ! L1,#%&,"+, &' @,-M>$% '

-!&,1E ," '6%"N'1 '! I,"'&! A,&,1'$ !7 '! O!"21,##! P' %!"'$ #!$% %+'Q

8)! &, 1,:%#)! &!# $%6%+,#3

G# 2,#+!1,# &,:,1)! ,#+'1 '+,"+!# -'1';

,!'+1+2('3 (# 1+$(/&, 2( ( 45( '+"!%&'!* #, ' &C:%&' !"#!$%&'&' '+,"&,

'! $%6%+,D

+$2/5+' !# 6'!2(&7'+#% B7&% %'%# ")! -'2!# &71'"+, ' ,H, 78)! &! !18'Q

6,"+! "!# $%6%+,# &' &C:%&' !"#!$%&'&'3

5HFRQGXomR�GD�'tYLGD�DRV�/LPLWHV��DUW�����

I, ' &C:%&' !"#!$%&'&' &, 76 !$&! &' A,&,1'8)! 7$+1'-'##'1 ! 1,#-, +%:!

$%6%+,* '! 5%"'$ &, 76 45( '+"!%&'!* &,:,1E #,1 ' ,$, 1, !"&7J%&' '+F !

+F16%"! &!# &'8% %59%!4:!$&!%* 1,&7J%"&! ! ,H ,&,"+, ,6 -,$! 6,"!#

!"#$%& '(

!

)* +,-./012314 5 6758135 91 /1: 8; <1 12=5237. 10 37.0:3.>?5 25 52,71<<5 %.=:52./@ %5

=.<5 95< A-2:=B6:5<4 1<3; 671C:<35 -0 3135 91 9BC:9. =52<5/:9.9. 1D-:C./1231 . (E'F 9.

$ G 1 -0 9:<6H29:5 0;I:054 10 =.9. (E 01<1<4 91 .3J ((4KF 9. $ G@

Page 52: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$%&'( ( )%&)* +*, )(&'*- &* +,%.(%,*/ 0&123&'* +(,42,3, * (5)(66*7

* (&'( 12( &(8( 9*2$(, %&)*,,%4*:

!"#$% +,*%;%4* 4( ,(38%<3, *+(,3=>* 4( ),?4%'* %&'(,&3 *2 (5'(,&37

%&)826%$( +*, 3&'()%+3=>* 4( ,()(%'37 ,(6638$34* * ,(@%&3&)%3.(&'* 4*

+,%&)%+38 3'238%<34* 43 4A$%43 .*;%8%B,%3C

&'" $% ,(628'34* +,%.B,%* &()(66B,%* D ,()*&42=>* 43 4A$%43 3* 8%.%'(7

+,*.*$(&4*7 (&',( *2',36.(4%4367 8%.%'3=>* 4( (.+(&9*7 &3 @*,.3 4*

3,'/ Eº/

F6 ,(6',%=G(6 3)%.3 #()*+#,-! %.(4%3'3.(&'(7 6( * .*&'3&'( 43 4A$%43

(5)(4(, * 8%.%'( &*($*, *$& ./#0$*, !"$ 12#3 *$& # #'$*)4 0& 5)"*,& #3&

0& ,#30#"& 4* H9(@( 4* I*4(, 05()2'%$*/

J(&)%4* * +,3<* +3,3 ,('*,&* 43 4A$%43 3* 8%.%'(7 ( (&123&'* +(,42,3, *

(5)(66*7 * (&'( @%)3,B '3.;?. %.+(4%4* 4( ,()(;(, ',3&6@(,K&)%36 $*82&L

'B,%36 43 M&%>* *2 4* 06'34*/ N O%&%6'?,%* 43 P3<(&43 4%$28Q3,B7 .(&638L

.(&'(7 3 ,(83=>* 4*6 (&'(6 12( '(&93. 28',3+36634* *6 8%.%'(6 436 4A$%436

)*&6*8%4343 ( .*;%8%B,%3

!

/

23(5$d¯(6�'(�&5e',72

&RQWUDWDomR�GH�2SHUDo}HV�GH�&UpGLWR��DUWV�����H����

H3;(,B 3* O%&%6'?,%* 43 P3<(&43 $(,%@%)3, * )2.+,%.(&'* 4*6 8%.%'(6 ( 436

)*&4%=G(6 ,(83'%$*6 D ,(38%<3=>* 4( *+(,3=G(6 4( ),?4%'* (. +8(%'* 4( )343

(&'( 43 P(4(,3=>*7 %&)826%$( 436 (.+,(636 +*, (8(6 )*&',*834367 4%,('3 *2

%&4%,('3.(&'(/ N (&'( %&'(,(6634* @*,.38%<3,B 6(2 +8(%'* @2&43.(&'34* (.

+3,()(, 4( 6(26 6$78&! "9+3*+&! 2/$:0*+&!7 4(.*&6',3&4*:

3 $ )#;8& )26'*L;(&(@A)%*7

*3" $ !! ()*&R.%)* ( 6*)%38 43 *+(,3=>*C

( * #" 30*, 3"& 436 6(Q2%&'(6 )*&4%=G(6:

S <*!"=3+*# 4( +,?$%3 ( (5+,(663 32'*,%<3=>* +3,3 3 )*&',3'3=>*7 &*

'(5'* 43 8(% *,=3.(&'B,%37 (. ),?4%'*6 34%)%*&3%6 *2 8(% (6+()A@%)3C

!"#$%& '(

!

)* #++,+ -./012,345+ 6075180 +51 09:-7,+ .0 !"# 70 ;-.-+:<1-0 7, =,>5.7,?

Page 53: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&' !" "#$%&'!(" ") '& *#+,-(". %,-*-"!%-. ,". #'*)#.". /#"0'1

!-'!('. ,% "/'#%$2"3 '4*'(" !" *%." ,' "/'#%$5'. /"# %!('*-/%$2"

,' #'*'-(%6

'(%)*+,!" - ,". 7-&-('. ' ,%. *"!,-$5'. 8-4%,". /'7" 9'!%," :','#%76

-$.'* /-0&' './'*;8-*% ," 9'!%," :','#%73 <)%!," .' (#%(%# ,' "/'1

#%$2" ,' *#+,-(" '4('#!"6

+)1-0&' 1-% '2)*-03)% 1) "*41 .' 5$) )6")1-7 " &"!(%!(' ,%.

,'./'.%. ,' *%/-(%73 #'..%70%,%. %. %)("#-=%,%. &',-%!(' *#+,-(".

.)/7'&'!(%#'. ") './'*-%-.3 *"& 8-!%7-,%,' /#'*-.% >-!*-." ???3 %#(@ ABC

,% D:E3 *"!.-,'#%!,"1.'3 '& *%,% '4'#*;*-" 8-!%!*'-#"3 " ("(%7 ,".

#'*)#.". ,' "/'#%$5'. ,' *#+,-(" !'7' -!F#'..%,". ' " ,%. ,'./'.%. ,'

*%/-(%7 '4'*)(%,%.@ G4*'()%&1.' ," *H&/)(" ,%. ,'./'.%. ,' *%/-(%7

%. #'%7-=%,%. ."I % 8"#&% ,' '&/#+.(-&" ") 8-!%!*-%&'!(" % *"!(#-1

I)-!('3 *"& " -!()-(" ,' /#"&"0'# -!*'!(-0" 8-.*%73 ('!," /"# I%.'

(#-I)("3 .' #'.)7(%# % ,-&-!)-$2"3 ,-#'(% ") -!,-#'(%3 ," H!). ,'.('6

'(%)*+,!" - ,%. ,'&%-. #'.(#-$5'. '.(%I'7'*-,%. !% JK:@

L M-!-.(+#-" ,% :%='!,%3 .'& /#'N);=" ,%. %(#-I)-$5'. /#O/#-%. ," 9'!%,"

:','#%7 ' ," P%!*" D'!(#%7 ," P#%.-73 '8'()%#Q " #'F-.(#" '7'(#H!-*" *'!(#%1

7-=%," ' %()%7-=%," ,%. ,;0-,%. /RI7-*%. -!('#!% ' '4('#!%3 F%#%!(-," " %*'.."

/RI7-*" S. -!8"#&%$5'.3 <)' -!*7)-#2"T

)!"-*8'% ' *"!,-$5'. ,' *"!(#%(%$2"6

%-#1'% %()%7-=%,". ' 7-&-('. #'7%(-0". S. ,;0-,%. *"!."7-,%,% ' &"I-7-Q#-%3

"/'#%$5'. ,' *#+,-(" ' *"!*'..2" ,' F%#%!(-%.@

U -!.(-()-$2" 8-!%!*'-#% >%#(@ VVE <)' *"!(#%(%# "/'#%$2" ,' *#+,-(" *"& )!.)

,% :','#%$2"3 '4*'(" <)%!," #'7%(-0% S ,;0-,% &"I-7-Q#-% ") S '4('#!%3

,'0'#Q '4-F-# *"&/#"0%$2" ,' <)' '..% "/'#%$2" %('!,' S. *"!,-$5'. '

%". 7-&-('. '.(%I'7'*-,".@ D%." *"!(#Q#-"3 % &'.&% .'#Q *"!.-,'#%,% !$#-3

/#"*','!,"1.' %" .') *%!*'7%&'!("3 &',-%!(' % ,'0"7)$2" ," /#-!*-/%73

0',%,". " /%F%&'!(" ,' N)#". ' ,'&%-. '!*%#F". 8-!%!*'-#".@ 9' % ,'0"1

7)$2" !2" 8"# '8'()%,% !" '4'#*;*-" ,' -!F#'.." ,". #'*)#.".3 .'#Q *"!.-F1

!%,% *)%)*+- )%2)"9: "-3 !% 7'- "#$%&'!(Q#-%3 /%#% " '4'#*;*-" .'F)-!('@

G..% ,-./".-$2" /#%(-*%&'!(' -&/',' % *"!(#%(%$2" ,' "/'#%$2" ,' *#+,-("3

'./'*-%7&'!(' /%#% ". M)!-*;/-". ,' /'<)'!" /"#('3 /"#<)' ,-8-*-7&'!('

%. -!.(-()-$5'. 8-!%!*'-#%. -!*"##'#2" !" #-.*" ,' #'*'I'#'& " 0%7"# ,'.'&1

I"7.%,"3 '&,%(% -!*'#(%3 ,'.%*"&/%!W%,",". N)#". ',". ,'&%-. '!*%#F".

8-!%!*'-#".@

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 54: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

'DV�9HGDo}HV��DUWV�����D����

!"# !"#"# # $%#&!'#()* +#, ,%-.!/0%, $%!&#'(!) "! *&+",-$1

%/0$% .2 !.-! +# %+%$#()*3 +!$%0#2%/0% *. 4*$ !/0%$25+!* +% 6./+*3

#.0#$7.!#3 6./+#()* *. %24$%,# %,0#0#& +%4%/+%/0%3 %$/-&$3 !/"&.,!8% ,.#,

%/0!+#+%, +# #+2!/!,0$#()* !/+!$%0#3 #!/+# 7.% ,*9 # 6*$2# +% /*8#()*3

$%6!/#/"!#2%/0* *. 4*,0%$-#()* +% +:8!+# "*/0$#:+# #/0%$!*$2%/0%;

#, !0/,%#&#"#) <, ,%-.!/0%,1

= *#%-#'1$ +% $%".$,*, # 0:0.&* +% #/0%"!4#()* +% $%"%!0# +% 0$!9.0* *.

"*/0$!9.!()*3 ".>* 6#0* -%$#+*$ #!/+# /)* 0%/?# *"*$$!+*@

= &!*!2,3!.-$ #/0%"!4#+* +% 8#&*$%, +% %24$%,# %2 7.% * A*+%$

AB9&!"* +%0%/?#3 +!$%0# *. !/+!$%0#2%/0%3 # 2#!*$!# +* "#4!0#& ,*"!#&3

"*2 +!$%!0* # 8*0*3 ,#&8* &."$*, % +!8!+%/+*,3 /# 6*$2# +# &%-!,&#()*@

= #))/.'1$ +!$%0# +% "*24$*2!,,*3 "*/6!,,)* +% +:8!+# *. *4%$#()*

#,,%2%&?#+#3 "*2 6*$/%"%+*$ +% 9%/,3 2%$"#+*$!#, *. ,%$8!(*,3

2%+!#/0% %2!,,)*3 #"%!0% *. #8#& +% 0:0.&* +% "$5+!0*3 /)* ,% #4&!"#/+*

%,0# 8%+#()* # %24$%,#, %,0#0#!, +%4%/+%/0%,@

= #))/.'1$ +% *9$!-#()*3 ,%2 #.0*$!'#()* *$(#2%/0C$!#3 "*2 6*$/%"%D

+*$%, 4#$# 4#-#2%/0* # !"#$%&!%& +% 9%/, % ,%$8!(*,;

E,,#, +%0%$2!/#(F%, 2%$%"%2 .2 "*2%/0C$!* #+!"!*/#&3 %,4%"!#&2%/0%

#/0% * +!,4*,0* /* ,%. #$0; GH3 7.% #,,%8%$#1

'%#( )*( + ,$-.-. . %$./&0.12! -$ ! $%.12! -$ 3%4-&#! $5#%$ 67 $5#$

-. 8$-$%.12!9 -&%$#.7$5#$ !6 !% &5#$%74-&! -$ :65-!9 .6#.%;6&.9

:65-.12! !6 $7 %$". $"#.#./ -$ $5-$5#$9 $ !6#%!9 &53/6"&,$ "6."

$5#&-.-$" -. .-7&5&"#%.12! &5-&%$#.9 .&5-. ;6$ "!< . :!%7. -$ 5!,.=

12!

!

9 %$:&5.53&.7$5#! !6 !"#$%>.12! -$ -?,&-. 3!5#%.?-. .5#$%&!%=

7$5#$(@

A Bº CD3$#6.7="$ -. ,$-.12! . ;6$ "$ %$:$%$ ! 3. 6#9 ." ! $%.1E$"

$5#%$ &5"#&#6&12! :&5.53$&%. $"#.#./ $ !"# $%"$-. 8$-$%.12!9 &53/6"&,$

"6." $5#&-.-$" -. .-7&5&"#%.12! &5-&%$#.9 ;6$ %& "$ -$"#&5$7 .F

G H '(%)%*()#9 -&%$#. !6 &5-&%$#.7$5#$9 -$" $"." 3!%%$5#$"I

!"#$%& '(

!

)' "*+,- . /01.230 45./60 0 6-1-607 80/97.: 80; 0 87-607 5;. /01. 0<7:=.230 45- .>9-7.

. /.957-?. 6. @7:;-:7. A B6:=0 0;-78:.>C .79D )EFC GHD

Page 55: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! !"#$%$&#% "#$%"&' ()* +*(,-&#"&' ./(,* 0 1-21-%& %(',%,/%3)*

+*(+4"4(,45

!"#$%&' #()#*' +%" , ,-."$#/, 0 &"1$&#(2#& "3*!%1#/'4"($" 51 #(1$#$%#67"1

#($"2&'($"1 ), 1#1$"4' 8#('(*"#&, ' *,49"$:(*#' 9'&' &"'!#;'& ,9"&'67"1 )"

*&0)#$,<= 9&,/>/"! '&2%4"($, %1'), 9'&' .%1$#8#*'& "11')"$"&4#('6?, )"/"

1"& , )" +%" ' 4"14' 8'*#!#$' , *,($&,!" )"11'1 ,9"&'67"1@ +%"& 9"!, A'(*,

B"($&'!@ *,4, C&2?, 8#1*'!#;'),& " ),$'), )' 8'*%!)')" )" #49,&D!E"1

&"1$&#67"1 ), !'), )' ,8"&$' )" &"*%&1,1@ +%"& 9"!, F#(#1$0&#, )' G';"()'@

' +%"4 ' HIG J'&$< KLM '$&#-%# *,49"$:(*#' 9'&' /"&#8#*'& , *%49&#4"($,

),1 !#4#$"1 " )'1 *,()#67"1 &"!'$#/,1 ' *')' ,9"&'6?, )" *&0)#$,<

)"4'#1@ '1 ,9"&'67"1 8#('(*"#&'1 9"&4#$#)'1 1?, -'1$'($" &"1$&#$'1 N (?,

8#('(*#'4@ )#&"$' ,% #()#&"$'4"($"@ )"19"1'1 *,&&"($"1 ("4 )O/#)'1 (?,

*,($&'O)'1 .%($, 5 9&C9&#' #(1$#$%#6?,<

P'! "($"()#4"($, 9"&4#$" +%" 1" 8'6' %4 *,(8&,($, "($&" "11' (,&4' )'

HIG " , '&$< QL )' B'&$' F'2('@ +%" '$&#-%# *,49"$:(*#' 9&#/'$#/' ',

R"('), G")"&'! 9'&'S

6 ! %'() #*% *14-&374' 48,4-(&' "4 (&,/-49& :%(&(+4%-&; "4 %(,4-4''4

"& <(%)*; "*' =',&"*'; "* >%',-%,* ?4"4-&@; "*' A/(%+#1%*'B

6 ! "#+% ; 1*- 1-*1*',& "* C-4'%"4(,4 "& D41EF@%+&; @%G%,4' H@*F&%'

1&-& * G*(,&(,4 "& "#$%"& +*('*@%"&"& "& <(%)*; "*' =',&"*'; "*

>%',-%,* ?4"4-&@; "*' A/(%+#1%*'B

6 ! ,#-.) '*F-4 @%G%,4' H@*F&%' 4 +*("%374' 1&-& &' *14-&374' "4

+-I"%,* 48,4-(* 4 %(,4-(* "& <(%)*; "*' =',&"*'; "* >%',-%,* ?4"4-&@

"*' A/(%+#1%*'; "4 '/&' &/,&-J/%&' 4 "4G&%' 4(,%"&"4' +*(,-*@&"&'

14@* C*"4- CEF@%+* ?4"4-&@B

6 ! ,#-.) '*F-4 @%G%,4' 4 +*("%374' 1&-& & +*(+4'')* "4 H&-&(,%&

"& <(%)* 4G *14-&374' "4 +-I"%,* 48,4-(* 4 %(,4-(* ! 4

K ! !-(%/!0!&! @%G%,4' H@*F&%' 4 +*("%374' 1&-& * G*(,&(,4 "& "#$%"&

G*F%@%L-%& "*' =',&"*'; "* >%',-%,* ?4"4-&@ 4 "*' A/(%+#1%*'B

= !"#$% &!$!'#(@ '$&'/01 )' I"1,!%6?, (º !" #$ %&'% '(! )*+, #$

%!'% '(!-" #./01/ /234$ 5.6.7$/ $ 829#.:;$/ #$ <=724.><:?2 0<4< </ 20$4<@

:;$/ #$ 84A#.72 $B7$492 $ .97$492 #2/ C/7<#2/" #2 *./74.72 D$#$4<5" #2/

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 56: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&#'( ) *) (!+( +!,+-.!#+( ) /!"*+01)(2 3)",-) +( 4)*+01)( 56

)(,+7)5)$#*+(8 "9' )(,6 ")":!;+ -)(,-#09' +'( $-)*'-)(8 #"$5!(#4) +'(

!"#$%&#'(8 $';' ' /)< ' +-,2 => *+ ?@A2

A#$+ )4#*)",) .!) '( *#(&'(#,#4'( $'"(,#,!$#'"+#( .!) ,-+,+;*' +((!",' B+-,(2

>C ) DE=F '7G),#4+; *#($#&5#"+- ' ;'",+",) ) +( $'"*#01)( *) )"*#4#*+H

;)",' *' (),'- &I75#$'8 "+ (!+ J5'7+5#*+*)8 *) /'-;+ .!) ' $K;&!,' *)

,'*'( '( /5!L'( *+( '7-#J+01)( *) ,'*'( '( )",)( B)(&)$#/#$+*'( "'( #"$#('(

M8 MNN8 MNNN ) NOF "9' )L$)*+ ';'",+",) *+ *%4#*+ $'"('5#*+*+ ,',+5 B)(,'.!)

&-)4#(,' "' #"$#(' MNF8 *+*+ (!+ -)5)4P"$#+ &+-+ +( &'5%,#$+( ;+$-')$'"K;#H

$+8 ;'"),6-#+ ) /#($+5 *' Q+%(2

R",-),+",'8 +",) + $';&),S"$#+ &-#4+,#4+ +,-#7!%*+ +' T)"+*' A)*)-+5 &+-+

*#(&'- ('7-) 5#;#,)( J5'7+#( ) $'"*#01)( &+-+ +( '&)-+01)( *) $-U*#,' )L,)-"'

) #",)-"'8 /#$+ + #;&-)((9' *) ,)- :+4#*' !;+ 5#;#,+09' #"*)4#*+ + !;+ *+(

;#((1)( )L$5!(#4+(*)((+V+(+?)J#(5+,#4+8 &'-.!)8 ())5+ )(,+7)5)$))(()( 5#;#,)(

) $'"*#01)( ) "9' /+< -)(,-#09' +'( $-)*'-)(8 + *)$#(9' "9' ,)-6 ")":!;+

()-4)",#+ &+-+ '( R(,+*'( ) '( !"#$%&#'( .!) 7!($+-);'!,-+( /'",)( *) '/)-,+

*) $-U*#,' *#(,#",+( *+( #"(,#,!#01)( 7+"$6-#+(8 + )L);&5' *'( /!"*'( )L#(,)",)(

); 46-#'( R(,+*'( *+ A)*)-+09'8 $!G+( +&5#$+01)( (9' 4'5,+*+( &+-+ /#"+"$#+-

+01)( ;!"#$#&+#( "+ 6-)+ *' *)()"4'54#;)",' !-7+"'8 *)",-) '!,-+(

!

2

2SHUDo}HV�GH�&UpGLWR�SRU�$QWHFLSDomR�GH�5HFHLWD2UoDPHQWiULD�²�$52��DUW�����

W !" *)(,#"+H() + +,)"*)- #"(!/#$#S"$#+ *) $+#L+ *!-+",) ' )L)-$%$#'

/#"+"$)#-' ) $!;&-#-6 +( "'-;+( &+-+ $'",-+,+09' *) '&)-+01)( *) $-U*#,'

B+-,2 =CF2 W5U; *#(('8 + ?@A (!7;),) + W@X Y( ()J!#",)( -)J-+(Z

#$%&'(%#)*$)+ (';)",) + &+-,#- *' ,-.'/0 ,'% *' #"%$#' *' )L)-$%$#'[

,$1$#+ ()- &+J+8 $'; G!-'( ) '!,-'( )"$+-J'( #"$#*)",)(8 +,U ' ,'% ,$(

,$ ,$($/2#0 *) $+*+ +"'[

!"#$%& '(

)( #*+,-./ 0,*, 123 0,*412*256.-/ . 7$8 4,99. :35039,9 ;;/ ;;; 2 ;< =, .-6> (?@ =. 8A =394,-

9,+-2B :3A =CD3=. 4E+130. 2F62-5. 2 3562-5./ 3501GC=. . =.9 .G6.-HG3.9/ IG5=.JK29 2 =2*.39

2563=.=29 0,56-,1.=.9 421, L,=2- LE+130,M :33A 0,50299N, =2 O.-.563.9 421.9 2563=.=29

4E+130.9M 2 333A 2*399N, 2 -29O.62 =2 6C6G1,9 =. =CD3=. 4E+130.>

Page 57: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$%& !"#$%& ' ( )* +#$*, -#.$ '#) #!"$#) */- $0#) 1!* /2# " 3

'* 4!$#) ' #5*$ 62#( #.$%0 "#$% ,*/"* 5$*+%3 ' ( #! %/'*3 ' 7 8 3

9:)%- ;%/ /-*%$ < 89;( #! 7 1!* =%*$ )!.)"%"!>?@ A

$#'(%& 5$#%.%' B

< $ )*( '" *3%)"%$ #5*$ 62# /"*$%#$ ' ,*), / "!$*& /2# %/"*0$ @?

,*/"* $*)0 " ' A

< " +,'-." ( " /$ .( /('" '# C$*)%'*/"*( D#=*$/ '#$ #! C$*+*%"#

E!/%-%5 @F

G* -#$'# -#, HI;( ) JIK)B

!" #$%!" -#,5!" ' ) 5 $ *+*%"# '# 1!* '%)5L* # %/-%)# MMM '# $"F NOP

' Q#/)"%"!%62# ' I*5R.@%- ( '*)'* 1!* @%1!%' ' ) /# 5$ &# '*+%/%'#

-%, A

#$%!" $* @%& ' ) ,*'% /"* .*$"!$ '* -$S'%"# 4!/"# 7 %/)"%"!%62# +%/ /?

-*%$ =*/-*'#$ ( *, 5$#-*))# -#,5*"%"%=# *@*"$T/%-#( 5$#,#=%'# 5*@#

9 /-# Q*/"$ @ '# 9$ )%@( # 1! @ , /"*$: )%)"*, '* -#,5 /U ,*/"# *

-#/"$#@* '# ) @'# '# -$S'%"# .*$"# *( /# - )# '* %/#.)*$=V/-% '#)

@%,%"*)( 5@%- $: ) ) /6L*) - .>=*%) 7 %/)"%"!%62# -$*'#$ F

Q#,# )* =*$%+%- ( #5*$ 62# '* -$S'%"# '*))* "%5#( *3*,5@# ' ) '*, %)(

*)": )!4*%" +#$"*) $*)"$%6L*)F J , %#$ '*@ ) S )! 5$#%.%62# " +,'-."

( " /$ .( /('" '# C$*+*%"#F W#) #!"$#) /#)( )#,*/"* 5#'*$: )*$ *+*"%?

= ' /# 5*$>#'# -#,5$**/'%'# */"$* NX '* 4 /*%$# * NX '* '*&*,.$#( *

5*/ ) !, '* - ' =*&F J))%,( */1! /"# /"*$%#$ /2#*)"%=*$ "#" @,*/"*

$*)0 " ' ( /2# S 5#))>=*@ $* @%& $ #!"$ F Y! -#/"$ " 62# /2# 5#'*$: )*$

/*0#-% ' */"$* # E!/%->5%# * %/)"%"!%62# +%/ /-*%$ ( 5#$1!* HI;

"$ /)+*$%! 5 $ # 9 /-# Q*/"$ @ '# 9$ )%@ %/-!,.Z/-% '* -#/'!&%$ #

5$#-*))# @%-%" "[$%# $*)5*-"%=#( $ "%+%- /'# 5$:"%- *)" .*@*-%' 5*@ ,*/?

-%#/ ' I*)#@!62# /º P\]^\( '# Y*/ '# ;*'*$ @F

2SHUDo}HV�FRP�R�%DQFR�&HQWUDO�GR�%UDVLO��DUW�����

W ) )! ) $*@ 6L*) -#, $ '$ ' ;*'*$ 62#( # 9 /-# Q*/"$ @ '# 9$ )%@ *)":

)!4*%"# #!"$ ) =*' 6L*)( @S, ' 1!*@ ) $*@ "%= ) 7 $* @%& 62# '* #5*$ 6L*)

'* -$S'%"# _ $"F `ab( */"$* ) 1! %) -#/)" , ) )*0!%/"*)B

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 58: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$% ! "#"$%& ' #() '* +' '"' ! ,$' -&%&-'./& +&0!1-' &* !2-!"&

"#"$%&, !0)") &, 3!%' 4+)/& 3'1' 1!5)+'+-)'1 ' #() ' 0&6)%)71)' 5! !1'%

8$! !,")(!1 (!+-!+ & !0 ,$' -'1"!)1'9

#&$"'(%* ')+ ' 8$! "!03&171)'* 3&1 )+"!10: )& ! )+,")"$)./& 5)+'+-!)1'

&$ +/&* ! "#"$%& ' #() ' ! &)(& ' ;! !1'./& 3&1 "#"$%& ' #() '

3<6%)-' 5! !1'%* 6!0 -&0& ' &3!1'./& ! -&031' ! (!+ '* ' "!10&*

'8$!%! "#"$%&* -$=& !5!)"& 5)+'% ,!=' ,!0!%>'+"! ? 3!10$"'9

!) &**+! ! @'1'+")'A

B (! './& ! 3!10$"' +/& ,! '3%)-' '& !,"&8$! ! C!"1', & D'+-& E!+"1'%

& D1',)%* F:1)! G,3!-)'%* !2),"!+"! +' -'1"!)1' ', )+,")"$).H!, 5)+'+-!)1',*

8$! 3& ! ,!1 1!5)+'+-)' & 0! )'+"! +&(', &3!1'.H!, ! (!+ ' ' "!10&A

I (! ' & '& J!,&$1& K'-)&+'% ' 8$)1)1 "#"$%&, ' #() ' 3<6%)-' 5! !1'%

!2),"!+"!, +' -'1"!)1' & D'+-& E!+"1'% & D1',)%* ')+ ' 8$! -&0 -%7$,$%'

! 1!(!1,/&* ,'%(& 3'1' 1! $L)1 ' #() ' 0&6)%)71)'A

J'), !"!10)+'.H!,* -&0& : 57-)% -&+,"'"'1* "M0 3&$-& &$ 8$',! +!+>$0'

'3%)-'6)%) ' ! 3'1' ' @1'+ ! 0')&1)' &, N$+)-#3)&, 61',)%!)1&,A K' 1!'%)O

' !* -&+,")"$!0 0'), $0 3',,& +& 31&-!,,& ! )+ !3!+ M+-)' & D'+-&

E!+"1'% & D1',)%A

*DUDQWLD�H�&RQWUDJDUDQWLD��DUW�����

P, &)(&* 3& !1/& -&+-! !1 @'1'+")' !0 &3!1'.H!, ! -1: )"& )+"!1+', &$

!2"!1+',* &6,!1(' &, & ),3&,"& +!,"! '1")@&* ', +&10', 3'1' -&+"1'"'./&

! &3!1'./& ! -1: )"& Q'1"A RST !* +& -',& ' 4+)/&* "'06:0 &, %)0)"!, !

', -&+ ).H!, !,"'6!%!-) &, 3!%& F!+' & ;! !1'%A

B @'1'+")' !,"'17 -&+ )-)&+' ' '& &5!1!-)0!+"& ! -&+"1'@'1'+")'

!

!0

('%&1 )@$'% &$ ,$3!1)&1 '& ' @'1'+")' ' ,!1 -&+-! ) ' 3!%& "&0' &1 ' BUPA

!"#$%& '(

!

)* !+,-./0 120313-14560 712/28619/0: 8;.; /0 +;8/+1</=/0 2; 6>3691;9: 6>1,6. ?69 / @21A;

8;.; =6B6=;9/: .60.; C-6 06 39/36 =6 ;D69/4A; =6 89E=13; =6 123696006 =6 ;-39; 6236

76=69/31B;F ;. 100;: / @21A; B12G/ 062=; ;H91,/=/ / ;7696869 ,/9/231/0 8;2=1<62360 8;.

; B/+;9 =600/0 ;D69/4560F ";9/B/236: / @21A; 0;.6236 D;=69I 96/+1</9 ;D69/4560 =/

60DE816: 06 ; H6267181I91; JK-218LD1;: #03/=; 638FM +G6 ;7696869 8;239/,/9/231/ 6.

.;23/236 2; .L21.; 1,-/+ /; =/ ;D69/4A; 6 06 6031B69 6. =1/ J/=1.D+6236M 8;. 0-/0

;H91,/4560: 2A; 0;.6236 N-23; / 6+/: @21A;: 8;.; 3/.HE. N-23; O0 6231=/=60 D;9 6+/

8;239;+/=/0 JP/28; =; P9/01+: #Q 638FM

Page 59: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"!#$!%&' ()*+,*' $) )$-*"./#0-) $) !#(-$)$! 12! ) ".!-(!)%' -3(4 ,' 04

02*"%-*!#(4 $! 32)3 4+%-5)67!3 04#(%)(2)-3 82#(4 )4 5)%)#(-$4% ! 93

!#(-$)$!3 "4% !3(! 04#(%4.)$)3: ;!%& )-#$) 4+3!%<)$4 4 3!52-#(!=

#>4 3!%& !?-5-$) 04#(%)5)%)#(-) $! @%5>43 ! !#(-$)$!3 $4 "%@"%-4 !#(!A

) 04#(%)5)%)#(-) !?-5-$) "!.) B#->4 ) C3()$4 42 D2#-0E"-4' 42 "!.43

C3()$43 )43 D2#-0E"-43' "4$!%& 04#3-3(-% #) <-#02.)6>4 $! %!0!-()3 (%-+2F

(&%-)3 $-%!()*!#(! )%%!0)$)$)3 ! "%4<!#-!#(!3 $! (%)#3G!%/#0-)3 04#3F

(-(20-4#)-3' 04* 42(4%5) $! "4$!%!3 )4 5)%)#(-$4% ")%) %!(/F.)3 ! !*"%!F

5)% 4 %!3"!0(-<4 <).4% #) .-12-$)6>4 $) $E<-$) <!#0-$):

H4 0)34 $! 4"!%)6>4 $! 0%,$-(4 !#(%! 2* 4%5)#-3*4 G-#)#0!-%4 -#(!%#)F

0-4#). I04*4 4 J)#04 K#(!%)*!%-0)#4 $! !3!#<4.<-*!#(4 L JK M' 42

2*) -#3(-(2-6>4 G!$!%). $! 0%,$-(4 ! G4*!#(4 ")%) 4 %!")33! $! %!02%343

!?(!%#43 I04*4 4 J)#04 H)0-4#). $! !3!#<4.<-*!#(4 C04#N*-04 ! ;40-).

L JH C;M ! 2* D2#-0E"-4 42 12).12!% 42(%4 !#(!' , 04*2* 12! 43

0%!$4%!3 !?-8)* 5)%)#(-) $) B#->4: C3() 3@ "%!3()%& !33) 5)%)#(-) ) !" 12!

)(!#$)' ).,* $4 4G!%!0-*!#(4 $! 04#(%)5)%)#(-)' !* <).4% -52). 42 32"!%-4%

)4 $) 5)%)#(-)' 93 !?-5/#0-)3 .!5)-3 ")%) 4 %!0!+-*!#(4 $! (%)#3G!%/#0-)3

<4.2#(&%-)3:

O !#$% ) 5)%)#(-) 04#0!$-$) )0-*) $43 .-*-(!3 G-?)$43 "!.4 ;!#)$4 P!$!%).:

O & '%'( 93 !#(-$)$!3 $) )$*-#-3(%)6>4 -#$-%!()' -#0.23-<! ) 32)3 !*"%!3)3

04#(%4.)$)3 ! 32+3-$-&%-)3' 04#0!$!% 5)%)#(-)' )-#$) 12! 04* %!02%343 $!

G2#$43: C?0!(2)F3! $!33) "%4-+-6>4 ) 04#0!33>4 $! 5)%)#(-) "4%=

)*+ ,% -(!"+($%'% ) 32+3-$-&%-) 42 04#(%4.)$) 32)' +!* 04*4 )

"%!3()6>4 $! 04#(%)5)%)#(-) #)3 *!3*)3 04#$-67!3A

.!,"."#./0( 1.!%!- .+% ) !*"%!3) #)0-4#).' #43 (!%*43 $) .!-:

23- "#%)4, $)3 %!5%)3 )0-*) )3 5)%)#(-)3 "%!3()$)3=

"4% -#3(-(2-67!3 G-#)#0!-%)3 !3()()-3' 12! 3! 32+*!(!%>4 93 #4%*)3 )".-0&F

<!-3 93 -#3(-(2-67!3 G-#)#0!-%)3 "%-<)$)3' $! )04%$4 04* ) .!5-3.)6>4

"!%(-#!#(!A

"!.) B#->4' #) G4%*) $! .!- G!$!%).' ) !*"%!3)3 $! #)(2%!Q) G-#)#0!-%)

"4% !.) 04#(%4.)$)3' $-%!() ! -#$-%!()*!#(!' 12)#(4 93 4"!%)67!3 $!

3!52%4 $! 0%,$-(4 9 !?"4%()6>4:

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 60: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$% &%#'"'()* +,-% .* /"0"'() " $12+$" $( %!-'% !" * () '"34% $(

0"'"#-+" /'(,-"$"* " 5#+4% ( %, 6,-"$%, /%$('4% #$!%&#&$!'( ", -'"#,7('8#9

:+", :%#,-+-!:+%#"+, "% '(,,"':+)(#-% $";!(<( /"0")(#-%= 6,," #%')"

$(:%''( $" 6)(#$" >%#,-+-!:+%#"< #º ?@AB@* ;!( $(-(')+#%! ,!" +#:<!,4%

#" >C :%)% /"'D0'"7% E#+:% $% ,(! "'-= FG?=

H !" $" C($('"I4%* :!J" $12+$" -+2(' ,+$% &%#'"$" /(<" 5#+4% %! /%'

6,-"$%* () $(:%''8#:+" $( 0"'"#-+" /'(,-"$" () %/('"I4% $( :'.$+-%* -('D

)*)+ !)$ % ":(,,% " #%2%, :'.$+-%, %! 7+#"#:+")(#-%, "-. " -%-"< <+;!+$"I4%

$" )(#:+%#"$" $12+$"=

5HVWRV�D�3DJDU��DUW�����

K , %'%$ "% -+-!<"' $( L%$(' %! M'04%* #%, -."&/$) %$&) 0*'%(&/ )"( )

$% ,(! )"#$"-% N)"+% " $(3()O'%P* #$!"('&( %O'+0"I4% $( $(,/(," ;!(Q

!1$ +$))' ,(' :!)/'+$" +#-(0'"<)(#-( $(#-'% $(<(R

" !2' +'(# .') " ,('() /"0", #% (S(':1:+% ,(0!+#-(* ,() ;!( &"J"

,!7+:+(#-( $+,/%#+O+<+$"$( $( :"+S" /"'" (,-( (7(+-%=

T" $(-(')+#"I4% $" %&)+$!&3&.&%'% % #'&4' ,('4% :%#,+$('"$%, %,

(#:"'0%, ( ", $(,/(,", :%)/'%)+,,"$", " /"0"' "-. % 7+#"< $% (S(':1:+%=

U%O'( (,,( -()"* % "'-= $( #º VF $% "#-(/'%J(-% W , "'%$ W (<(#:"2" 2D'+",

$(,/(,", ()/(#&"$", ;!( /%$('+") ,(' +#,:'+-", () X(,-%, " L"0"'= Y"<(

" /(#" -'"#,:'(2(' /"'-(, $", '"3Z(, $% 2(-%* $"$% ,(! :"'D-(' (<!:+$"-+2%Q

!"#$" %&$'%$() (# *"#$(# + ,+-+. /"0".%+1 2%3+. 4%1%$+/(# 5# /%#6

7(&%8%4%/+/"# /" 3+%9+ 3(1( 2(.1+ /" &:( $.+&#2".%. /"#7"#+ /" '1

"9".3;3%( 7+.+ ('$.( #"1 + 3(.."#7(&/"&$" 2(&$" /" /"#7"#+

< /%#7(#%$%0( =0"$+/() +3."#3"&$+1(#> 7".1%$") 7.%1"%.() %&#3."0". "1

*"#$(# + ,+-+. 0?.%+# /"#7"#+# 7+.+) +7"&+# /"7(%#) 3(&/%3%(&+. +

%&#3.%@:( /+# /"1+%# 5 "9%#$A&3%+ /" ."3'.#(# "1 3+%9+ B+4 7.?$%3+ 2"."

( 7.%&3;7%( /( "C'%4;8.%( 2%#3+4) 7(%# 2+D 3(1 C'" #"E+1 +##'1%/(#

3(17.(1%##(# #"1 + /%#7(&%8%4%/+/" 2%&+&3"%.+ &"3"##?.%+ 7+.+ #+4/?6

4(#) 3.%+ $.+&#$(.&(# 7+.+ + "9"3'@:( /( (.@+1"&$( ") 2%&+41"&$")

(3+#%(&+ ( 3."#3%1"&$( /" *"#$(# + ,+-+. C'" "CF%0+4") "1 $".1(#

2%&+&3"%.(#) + 3."#3%1"&$( /" /;0%/+ 7G84%3+

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 61: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$!%&'( )(*#$+*$" ,( -+!./!+0( 1*%)( ,( +!$2 34 ,+ 567 $"8 ( #+9:$+!

(;<"$%=( ," "=%$+! + )(*#$%$:%&'( ,+ ,>=%,+ -1;9%)+ 09:$:+*$"? + @:+9? )(8(

,"8(*#$!+ + -!.$%)+? #" $(!*+ +9$+8"*$" ,%#-"*,%(#+? ="A @:" (# "*)+!/(#

0%*+*)"%!(# #'( "8;:$%,(# *(# -!"&(# -!(-(#$(# -"9(# 0(!*")",(!"# -+!+

="*,+ ," -!(,:$(# (: 8"!)+,(!%+# (: -+!+ + -!"#$+&'( ," #"!=%&(#? ,"

+)(!,( )(8 +# "B-")$+$%=+# ," !")";%8"*$( ,(# )!C,%$(# )(!!"#-(*,"*$"#2

@:"#$'( #" $(!*+ 8+%# )(8-9"B+? -(!@:" + @:+*$%0%)+&'( ,"##"# "*)+!/(#

,%0%)%98"*$" -(," #"! +-:!+,+2

*(67®2�3$75,021,$/

'LVSRQLELOLGDGHV�GH�&DL[D��DUW�����

# !"#$%!&!'! ( )" ," )+%B+ ,(#D

*+%!,-#!$" #"!'( ,"-(#%$+,+# "8 %*#$%$:%&E"# 0%*+*)"%!+# (0%)%+%# FG Hº?

+!$2 IJ3 ,+ K7LM

.)/!0)" ) #.)1! 2%,!( "$,!('? /"!+9 " -!N-!%( ,(# #"!=%,(!"# -1;9%)(#?

+%*,+ @:" =%*):9+,+# + 0:*,(# "#-")>0%)(# + @:" #" !"0"!"8 (# +!$#2 43O

" 4PQ ,+ K7? 0%)+!'( ,"-(#%$+,+# "8 )(*$+ #"-+!+,+ ,+# ,"8+%# ,%#R

-(*%;%9%,+,"# ," )+,+ "*$" " +-9%)+,+# *+# )(*,%&E"# ," 8"!)+,(? )(8

(;#"!=S*)%+ ,(# 9%8%$"# " ,+# )(*,%&E"# ," -!($"&'( " -!:,T*)%+ 0%*+*R

)"%!+2 U =",+,+ #:+ +-9%)+&'( "8D

V 3-3+'$" ,+ ,>=%,+ -1;9%)+ "#$+,:+9 " 8:*%)%-+9? ;"8 )(8( "8 +&E"#

" (:$!(# -+-C%# !"9+$%=(# W# "8-!"#+# )(*$!(9+,+# -"9( !"#-")$%=( "*$"

,+ 7","!+&'(M

V )0#.4"3!0$"? ," @:+9@:"! *+$:!"A+? +(# #"/:!+,(# " +( X(,"! X1;9%R

)(? %*)9:#%=" + #:+# "8-!"#+# )(*$!(9+,+#2

Y+9=( + =",+&'( %8-(#$+ W# +-9%)+&E"# ,+# ,%#-(*%;%9%,+,"# ,(# 0:*,(#

-!"=%,"*)%.!%(#? @:" #(8"*$" )+:#+ %8-+)$( *(# Z:*%)>-%(# @:" )(*$+8

)(8 "##"# 0:*,(#? ( +!$%/( "8 +*.9%#" *'( #" !"="#$" ,"8+%(! %*$"!"##" -+!+

+ 8+%(!%+ ,+# 8:*%)%-+9%,+,"#2 [" @:+9@:"! 0(!8+? $"8 #%,( (;<"$( ,"

0(!$"# )!>$%)+# + -!(%;%&'( %8-(#$+ + $+%# 0:*,(# -+!+ )(*)","! "8-!C#$%8(#

+(# #":# #"/:!+,(#2

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 62: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

3UHVHUYDomR�GR�3DWULP{QLR�3~EOLFR��DUWV�����D����

!"#"# ! !"#$%!&'( )! *+%+$,! )+ %!"$,!# )+*$-!)! )! !#$+.!&'( )+ /+.0

+ )$*+$,(0 12+ $.,+3*!4 ( "!,*$45.$( "6/#$%( "!*! ( 7$.!.%$!4+.,( )+

)+0"+0! %(**+.,+8 0!#-( 0+ )+0,$.!)! "(* #+$ !(0 *+3$4+0 )+ "*+-$)9.%$!

0(%$!#8 3+*!# + "*:"*$( )(0 0+*-$)(*+0 "6/#$%(0;

< #+$ (*&!4+.,=*$! + !0 )+ %*>)$,(0 !)$%$(.!$0 0: $%&'($)*+ .(-(0 "*(?+,(0

!":0 !)+12!)!4+.,+ !,+.)$)(0 (0 ?= +4 !.)!4+.,( + %(.,+4"#!)!0 !0

)+0"+0!0 )+ %(.0+*-!&'( )( "!,*$45.$( "6/#$%(8 .(0 ,+*4(0 +4 12+

)$0"20+* ! #+$ )+ )$*+,*$@+0 (*&!4+.,=*$!0; A B()+* CD+%2,$-( )+ %!)! +.,+

+.%!4$.E!*= !( F+3$0#!,$-(8 #,- # "#,# )( +.-$( )( "*(?+,( )+ #+$ )+

)$*+,*$@+0 (*&!4+.,=*$!08 *+#!,:*$( %(4 !0 $.7(*4!&G+0 .+%+00=*$!0 !( %24H

"*$4+.,( )( )$0"(0,( .+0,+ !*,$3(8 !( 12!# 0+*= )!)! #./'# )$-2#3!&'(;

< "*+(%2"!&'( )! FIJ (/?+,$-! +.7!,$@!* ! -+)!&'( )! "*=,$%! )+ !,(0 12+

*+)2.)+4 .(0 %E!4!)(0 K+012+#+,(0 )+ (/*!0 $.!%!/!)!0L8 .!4+)$)! +4

12+ .(-(0 "*(?+,(0 0(4+.,+ )+-!4 0+* $.$%$!)(0 !":0 ! %(.%#20'( )!0 (/*!0

$.$%$!)!0 (28 0+ !$.)! +0,!0 +0,+?!4 +4 !.)!4+.,(8 (0 *+%2*0(0 "!*!

,+*4$.=H#!0 +0,+?!4 3!*!.,$)(0; I+#!,:*$(0 +0"+%M7$%(0 ! 0+*+4 +.%!4$H

.E!)(0 !( B()+* F+3$0#!,$-(8 %(.,+.)( $.7(*4!&G+0 0(/*+ ( !002.,(8 0+

$.0+*+4 .( %(.?2.,( )+ 4+)$)!0 +4 7!-(* )! ,*!.0"!*9.%$! )! 3+0,'(

"6/#$%!;

%('+ )+ "#+.( )$*+$,( ( !,( )+ )+0!"*("*$!&'( )+ $4:-+# 2*/!.(8

+D"+)$)( 0+4 ! "*>-$! + ?20,! $.)+.$@!&'( +4 )$.E+$*( NO Pº8 !*,; QRS )!

TJU8 (2 "*>-$( )+":0$,( ?2)$%$!# )( -!#(* )! $.)+.$@!&'(; C00! )+,+*4$.!&'(

"()+*= 0+* +.,+.)$)! )! 0+32$.,+ 7(*4!V 0+ (W2.$%M"$(8 (2 12!#12+* (2,*!

+07+*! 3(-+*.!4+.,!#8 .'( )$0"G+ )+ *+%2*0(0 "!*! !)12$*$* ( $4:-+#8

,!4/>4 +0,!*= $.%!"!%$,!)( 7$.!.%+$*!4+.,+ "!*! !)+12=H#( !( 20( "*+-$0H

,(8 !$.)! 4!$0 0+ E(2-+* .+%+00$)!)+ )+ +)$7$%!&'(;

(PSUHVDV�&RQWURODGDV�SHOR�6HWRU�3~EOLFR��DUW�����

< +4"*+0! %(.,*(#!)! 12+ 7$*4!* %(.,*!,( )+ 3+0,'( +4 12+ 0+ +0,!/+#+&!4

(/?+,$-(0 + 4+,!0 )+ )+0+4"+.E(8 .! 7(*4! )! #+$8 )$0"(*= )+ !2,(.(4$!

3+*+.%$!#8 (*&!4+.,=*$! + 7$.!.%+$*!8 0+4 "*+?2M@( )! $.0+*&'( )( 0+2

(*&!4+.,( )+ $.-+0,$4+.,( .! #+$ (*&!4+.,=*$! !.2!# N$.%$0( XX8 O Yº8 !*,;

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 63: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$ %&' ( #$ )*+,-./0 (1 .(-. 2$,$*30. 45)1(.45$). #( *04$ (67,)+$4)8$

(1 9-( )*:051$5;<

!"#$%&'$#(!#( 2(*. ( .(58)30. $0 +0*450,$#05= +01 5(.7(+4)80. 75(30.

( +0*#)3>(.= +017$5$*#0?0. +01 0. 75$4)+$#0. *0 1(5+$#0@

!) "$%*")!) 5(+(2)#0. #0 +0*450,$#05= $ 9-$,9-(5 4A4-,0= (.7(+):)+$*#0

8$,05= :0*4( ( #(.4)*$3/0@

+ ,$#-+ #( 2(*.= $ 75(.4$3/0 #( .(58)30. 0- $ +0*+(../0 #( (175B.4)10.

( :)*$*+)$1(*40. +01 75(30.= 4$6$.= 75$C0. 0- +0*#)3>(. #):(5(*4(. #0.

8)D(*4(. *0 1(5+$#0E

F G1(*#$ %0*.4)4-+)0*$, *º HIHJ $+5(.+(*40- $0 $54E KL #$ %& 0 M Jº (

.(-. )*+).0.= 0. 9-$). 7(51)4(1 $ $17,)$3/0 #$ $-40*01)$ D(5(*+)$,=

053$1(*4;5)$ ( :)*$*+()5$= 1(#)$*4( +0*45$40 9-( 4(*N$ 705 02O(40 $

:)6$3/0 #( 1(4$. #( #(.(17(*N0= $ .(5 :)51$#0 (*45( 0 70#(5 7P2,)+0 ( 0.

$#1)*).45$#05(. #( Q5D/0. ( (*4)#$#(. #$ $#1)*).45$3/0 #)5(4$ ( )*#)5(4$E

R-$*#0 $ +0*45$4$#$ :05 -1$ (175(.$ +0*450,$#$= $,B1 #$. 025)D$3>(.

(.7(+):)+$#$. *0 +0*45$40 #( D(.4/0= (,$ #(8( )*.(5)5 *04$ (67,)+$4)8$ (1

.(-. 2$,$*30. 45)1(.45$).= +0*4(*#0 $. )*:051$3>(. .-75$E

75$163$5È1&,$��&21752/(�(�),6&$/,=$d®2

7UDQVSDUrQFLD�GD�*HVWmR�)LVFDO��DUW�����H����

S/0 &#)("*'$#(!) -$ ("+#).+"/#%&+ -+ 0$)(1! &)%+2= $0. 9-$). .(5; #$#$

$17,$ #)8-,D$3/0= )*+,-.)8( $45$8B. #(1()0. (,(45T*)+0. #( $+(..0 7P2,)+0<

0. 7,$*0.= 0. 053$1(*40. ( $. ,(). #( #)5(45)C(. 053$1(*4;5)$.@

$. 75(.4$3>(. #( +0*4$. ( 0 5(.7(+4)80 7$5(+(5 75B8)0@

0 U(,$4Q5)0 U(.-1)#0 #$ G6(+-3/0 V53$1(*4;5)$@ (

0 U(,$4Q5)0 #( W(.4/0 &).+$,E

F ("+#).+"/#%&+ .(5; $..(D-5$#$= 4$12B1= 1(#)$*4( )*+(*4)80 X 7$54)+)7$?

3/0 707-,$5 ( X 5($,)C$3/0 #( $-#)Y*+)$. 7P2,)+$.= #-5$*4( 0. 750+(..0. #(

(,$205$3/0 ( #( #).+-../0 #0. 7,$*0.= #$ ,() #( #)5(45)C(. 053$1(*4;5)$. (

#0. 053$1(*40.E

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 64: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! !"#$% "#$%!%&'"("! #%)* +,%-% (* .*(%$ /0%12'34* -31"$5* (3!#*&64%3!7

(2$"&'% #!&!! '(') * +!,&* $%!#%1'34* .*(%$ 8%93!)"'34* %&* :$95* ';1&31*

$%!#*&!<4%) #%)" !2" %)"=*$">5*7 #"$" 1*&!2)'" % "#$%13">5* #%)*! 13("(5*!

%? 9%$") % #%)"! 3&!'3'23>@%! (" !*13%("(%A

#)$"%-$)." +$,1*&-*$?% !% (%#$%%&(%7 ;?23'*?"3! (* B2% 2? *=C%'34*

*2 2? #$3&16#3* (" 9%!'5* #D=)31"A E" $%")3("(%7 %)" (%1*$$% (% 2?"

!/)+0$12!7 3?#*!'" "*! 9%!'*$%! #D=)31*!7 &* !%&'3(* (% &5* !*?%&'%

12?#$3$ %-313%&'%?%&'% !2"! ?3!!@%!7 !%92&(* *! ?"&("?%&'*! 1*&!F

'3'213*&"3! % )%9"3!7 ?"! '"?=;? (% &'3!"%#)$) " '*(" " !*13%("(%7 B2% *

-3G%$"? 1*&-*$?% * %!'"=%)%13(* &*! *$>"?%&'*!7 &*! $%)"':$3*! 9%$%&13"3!

% &"! !2"! #$%!'">@%! (% 1*&'"!7 12C*! $%!2)'"(*! (%4%$5* !%$ !2=?%'3(*! H

"#$*4">5* (" !*13%("(%A

I$"'"F!% (% 2?" "!4$ -)5#+ $ "(?3&3!'$"'34" 3?#*!'" #%)" 8JK7 %&!%C"&(*

2? #$*1%!!* (% +"#')$12! #%$?"&%&'% %&'$% *! 9%!'*$%! % *! 13("(5*!A

.*$'"&'*7 " #)$"%-$)." +$ !% 3&313" 1*? 2?" $12! (* 9%!'*$7 "'$"4;! (" B2")

(%?*&!'$" % 1*?#$*4"7 #%$3*(31"?%&'% % 1*? * ?"3*$ (%'"),"?%&'*

#*!!64%)7 * B2% -*3 $%")3G"(* % B2"3! *! =%&%-613*! !*13"3! (%1*$$%&'%!A L

!*13%("(% M " B2%? ; (3$%13*&"(" " 1*?#$*4">5* (*! $%!2)'"(*! M 1"=%

"4")3"$ % "#$*4"$ *2 %0393$ &*4*! %!1)"$%13?%&'*! *2 "'; ?2("&>" (% $2?*!

&" 9%!'5*A

/!#%$"F!% B2%7 %? -2'2$* #$:03?*7 " !%(3?%&'">5* ("&*4" #$<'31" 1*&1*$$"

#"$" ?"3*$ %-313N&13"7 %-31<13" % %-%'343("(% (" 9%!'5* #D=)31"A O% #$*&'*7

1"=% "-3$?"$ B2% "! #%$!#%1'34"! !5* "&3?"(*$"!7 #*$B2%7 %&'$% *2'$"!

$"G@%!7 " *=$39"'*$3%("(% 3?#*!'" "*! 9%!'*$%! 1%$'"?%&'% *! 3&(2G3$< "

(%!#%&(%$ %!-*$>*! "(313*&"3! &" %!1*)," % &" 3?#)%?%&'">5* ("! ">@%!7

!*= #%&" (% '%$ !2" "'2">5* $%#$*4"(" #%)*! %)%3'*$%!A

'D�(VFULWXUDomR�H�&RQVROLGDomR�GDV�&RQWDV��DUWV�����H����

);? (% *=%(%1%$ H! (%?"3! &*$?"! (% 1*&'"=3)3("(% #D=)31"7 " %!1$3'2$"F

>5* ("! 1*&'"! #D=)31"! *=!%$4"$< "! !%923&'%!P

$ &+%-!"+/+6+&$&' (% 1"30" 1*&!'"$< (% $%93!'$* #$:#$3*7 (% ?*(* B2%

*! $%12$!*! 43&12)"(*! " :$95*7 -2&(* *2 (%!#%!" *=$39"':$3" -3B2%?

3(%&'3-31"(*! % %!1$3'2$"(*! (% -*$?" 3&(343(2")3G"("Q

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 65: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$"# ! !""#$%&' ( )'*+,'*-""' " ,&' , .-"/,!(!" " .#$(' '

, .-* ( )'*+ /0$)-!1 !+#,!$('2" 1 * )!,3/ , )'*+4 * $/!,1 '

, "#4/!(' ('" 54#6'" 5-$!$) -,'" + 4' , .-* ( )!-6!7

# !"%&'#() *+"# )'$/38 -" )'*+, $( ,&'1 -"'4!(! )'$9#$/!* $/ 1

!" /,!$"!%: " !" '+ ,!%: " ( )!(! ;,.&'1 5#$(' '# $/-(!( (!

!(*-$-"/,!%&' (-, /!1 !#/3,<#-)! 5#$(!)-'$!41 -$)4#"-= *+, "! "/!/!4

( + $( $/ 7

# )","-( # !" ( "+ "!" +, =-( $)-3,-!" " ,&' !+, " $/!(!" *( *'$"2

/,!/-='" 5-$!$) -,'" ',%!* $/3,-'" "+ )>5-)'"7

# &$") *+"# ( ),?(-/'1 !" -$"),-%: " * @ "/'" ! A!.!, !" ( *!-"

5',*!" ( 5-$!$)-!* $/' '# !""#$%&' ( )'*+,'*-""'" 9#$/' ! / ,) -,'"

( = ,&' " , "),-/#,!(!" ( *'(' ! =-( $)-!, ' *'$/!$/ ! =!,-!%&'

(! (>=-(! +B84-)! $' + ,>'('1 ( /!4C!$('1 + 4' * $'"1 ! $!/#, D! '

/-+' ( ), (',7

!"%&'#() *.&(!" =!,-!%: " +!/,-*'$-!-" (!,3 ( "/!<# E ',-. * !'

( "/-$' ('" , )#,"'" +,'= $- $/ " (! !4- $!%&' ( !/-='"F

G "!-*.& ( $',*!" . ,!-" +!,! )'$"'4-(!%&' (!" )'$/!" +B84-)!" )!8 ,3

!' /)0.& ,"'() 1 ( )'$/!8-4-(!( (! H$-&'1 $<#!$/' $&' "/-= , -*+4!$2

/!(' ' 2&'#"13& !" 4"#(.& 5-#, 11 ! " , )'$"/-/#>(' +', , +, " $/!$/ " (

/'('" '" A'( , " "5 ,!" ( I'= ,$'1 ('J-$-"/?,-' AB84-)' ( $/-(!( "

/?)$-)!" , +, " $/!/-=!" (! "')- (!( K!,/F LM (! N@OPF

G G(*-$-"/,!%&' AB84-)! *!$/ ,3 #-#("% !" ,6#(&#1 <# ( = ,3 + ,*-/-,

! !=!4-!%&' ' !)'*+!$C!* $/' (! . "/&' ',%!* $/3,-!1 5-$!$) -,!

+!/,-*'$-!4F Q' )!"' (!" ( *'$"/,!%: " )'$9#$/!"1 6)4#-,2" 2&' !" '+ ,!2

%: " -$/,!.'= ,$!* $/!-"F

R A'( , S6 )#/-=' (! H$-&' +,'*'= ,31 !/? ' (-! /,-$/! ( 9#$C'1 !

,&'#&1-! *.&1 $!)-'$!4 +', "5 ,! ( .'= ,$'1 (!" ,&'( # !&# "'("# (!

O ( ,!%&'1 , 4!/-=!" !' 6 ,)>)-' !$/ ,-',1 ! "#! (-=#4.!%&'1 -$)4#"-= +',

* -' 4 /,T$-)' ( !) ""' +B84-)'F R" S"/!('" '" J#$-)>+-'" $)!*-2

$C!,&' "#!" )'$/!" !' A'( , S6 )#/-=' (! H$-&' $'" " .#-$/ " +,!D'"1 )#9'

( ")#*+,-* $/' -*+ (-,3 ' , ) 8-* $/' ( /,!$"5 ,0$)-!" ='4#$/3,-!"

)'$/,!/!%&' ( '+ ,!%: " ( ),?(-/'U

76'-,8$-&#1 )'* );+-! +!,! ' A'( , S6 )#/-=' (' , "+ )/-=' S"/!('1 (9

()-'( !" :)-17

;#( !&#1 !/? ()-'( " 6% !" % -&F

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 66: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#"$%&'()*+ !" ,-" (. !"%+'.#$()/". 0+'#12"&. 0+%3$""'!"$*+4

&.+5(!( " 0+'6-'#(%"'#"4 (. #$('.()/". " (. +3"$()/". !" 0(!( 7$8*+4 9-'!+

+- "'#&!(!" !( (!%&'&.#$()*+ !&$"#(4 (-#1$,-&0( " 9-'!(0&+'(54 &'05-.&:"

"%3$".( ".#(#(5 !"3"'!"'#"4 0+%35"%"'#( ( $"8$( 0+'#&!( '+ 3($18$(9+

;'&0+ !+ ($#< ==> !( ?"& 'º !"#$%& ' ()* +,-./0 0 -*1*220 3+2 ,04056+2

302 *57.303*2 30 031.5.27-068+ .53.-*70' 5+2 9-0:+2 ;.<03+2 50 4*/.24068+'

0+2 -*29*=7.>+2 ?-/8+2 =*57-0.2 3* =+570,.4.303*' 90-0 ;.52 3* .5=+-9+-068+

3+2 -*2)4703+2! @+,-* *22* 3.29+2.7.>+' + A-+;! B*-043+' =+1*57+)

!

C

!" #$% &'()*('+,*- .,* (!/'$ )*((01!% $ !1'&!.2'$+,* $ 34! (! /!5!/!

* $/#6 78 &!(#$ %!' ! $ #/$.(5!/9.2'$ &$( '.5*/"$+:!( .$( &!"*.(#/$+:!(

2*.#;<!'( 5'2$/'$ )/!=4&'2$&$- <!" 2*"* $ )/>)/'$ ?&"'.'(#/$+,* 34!

&!(2*.@!2!/'$ * "*.#$.#! &*( /!24/(*( "*1'"!.#$&*( ! (! *( *<=!A

#'1*( 5*/$" /!$%"!.#! $%2$.+$&*(- $(('" 2*"* * )B<%'2* !C#!/.*- 34!

#$"<D" &!(2*.@!2!/'$ $ ('#4$+,* /!$% &$ !.#'&$&! E*1!/.$"!.#$%

2*"* 4" #*&*6

D57*2' 9+-E1' FG ()* 2*- 3*2*5>+4>.3+ )1 /-053* *2;+-6+ =+5H)57+ 30

I5.8+' 3+2 J2703+2 * 3+2 K)5.=L9.+2 90-0 3.22*1.50-' 50 D31.5.27-068+

AM,4.=0' 0 9-G7.=0 3* 09)-068+ 3* !"#$"% N+1+ E 20,.3+' 09*20- 3* 0 O*.

5º !"#$%& ' *1 2*) 0-7! P$&' 7*- *270,*4*=.3+ 5+-102 90-0 0>04.068+ 3+2

*4*1*57+2 907-.1+5.0.2' 28+ 9+)=+ =+5F*=.3+2 +2 -*2)4703+2 3* 2)0 094.=0Q

68+! D31.7*Q2* ()* 02 3.;.=)4303*2 90-0 ()* 704 094.=068+ 2* -*04.:* 28+ 3*

+-3*1 =)47)-04' 7E=5.=0 * 07E 1*21+ 9+4L7.=0! R 9-*=.2+' 9+-7057+' ()* *220

3*;.=.S5=.0 2*H0 2)9*-030' 90-0 + S<.7+ 3*220 3*7*-1.5068+ 30 OTU!

5HODWyULR�5HVXPLGR�GD�([HFXomR�2UoDPHQWiULD��DUWV�����H����

D7E #&'(#) *')" 09?2 + *5=*--01*57+ 3* )*) +',-"#&-' 2*-G 9),4.=03+' 2+,

9*50 3* .19*3.- + -*=*,.1*57+ 3* 7-052;*-S5=.02 >+4)57G-.02 * 0 =+57-070Q

68+ 3* +9*-06V*2 3* =-E3.7+' .-/)#0&'$ .-"!,'*$ *) 12- !34$ 5&3),-(6

#7&') WX "º' 0-7! P&Y 30 NUZ' 0,-05/*53+ 7+3+2 +2 A+3*-*2 * + K.5.27E-.+

AM,4.=+' * =+19+27+ 3*C

+)/)(3$ $&3),-(#7&'$' ()* *29*=.;.=0-G' 9+- =07*/+-.0 *=+5[1.=0' 02C

!"#$%& '(

!

)* $#+,- ./01234 31 4561- 7! .!"& 809 4:9 ;<69 :9 (=>9

Page 67: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"!#$%& '( )(*$!! "#$%&'(#)% (* &+(,"-()(* + ( &+(,"-(&! .+' /%'%

( 0&+1"*2% (34(,"-()(5

+!&'!&%& '( , -'( +! *%$- !.%! )"*/&"'"#(#)% ( )%3(62% 0(&( %

+7+&/8/"%! ( )+*0+*( ,"94")()( + % *(,)%5

+!/(*&$ %$#0(& )( +7+/462% )(*:

!"!#$%&! 0%& /(3+;%&"( +/%#<'"/( + $%#3+! +*0+/"$"/(#)%:

= ( 0&+1"*2% "#"/"(,5

= ( 0&+1"*2% (34(,"-()( 0(&( % +7+&/8/"%5

= ( &+/+"3( &+(,"-()( #% ."'+*3&+5

= ( &+(,"-()( #% +7+&/8/"%5 +

= ( 0&+1"*2% ( &+(,"-(&5

+!&'!&%&! 0%& /(3+;%&"( +/%#<'"/( + ;&40% )+ #(34&+-( )( )+*0+*(!

)"*/&"'"#(#)%:

= )%3(62% "#"/"(,5

= )%3(62% 0(&( % +7+&/8/"%5

= )+*0+*(* +'0+#>()( + ,"94")()(! #% ."'+*3&+ + #% +7+&/8/"%5

+!&'!&%&! 0%& $4#62% + *4.$4#62%?

@* 1(,%&+* &+$+&+#3+* (% !)#*%*"#%/!*$( +% +10#+% /(2#3#4 #%/%#*3(&2%

)+*3(/()('+#3+ #(* &+/+"3(* )+ %0+&(6A+* )+ /&B)"3% + #(* )+*0+*(* /%'

('%&3"-(62% )( )81")(?

5"(/'%*6% 7( % &+,(3C&"% &+*4'")% )+'%#*3&(3"1%* &+,(3"1%*:

D (04&(62% )( &+/+"3( /%&&+#3+ ,894")(! *4( +1%,462%! (**"' /%'% D

0&+1"*2% )+ *+4 )+*+'0+#>% (3B % $"#(, )% +7+&/8/"%5

D* &+/+"3(* + )+*0+*(* 0&+1")+#/"E&"(*5

(%* &+*4,3()%* #%'"#(, + 0&"'E&"%5

D* )+*0+*(* /%' F4&%*5

(%* &+*3%* ( 0(;(&! )+3(,>(#)%! 0%& G%)+& + C&;2%! %* 1(,%&+* "#*/&"3%*!

%* 0(;('+#3%* &+(,"-()%* + % '%#3(#3+ ( 0(;(&?

8 !3%$9 #( &+$+&+#3+ (% :3$#/( 2#/!&$ !)% +7+&/8/"% *+&E (/%'0(#>()%

3('.B' )+ )+'%#*3&(3"1%*:

)% (3+#)"'+#3% )% )"*0%*3% #% "#/"*% HHH )% (&3? IJK )( L%#*3"34"62%! 94+

)"*0A+ *%.&+ ( 1+)(62% )( &+(,"-(62% )+ %0+&(6A+* )+ /&B)"3% +'

'%#3(#3+ *40+&"%& (% )(* )+*0+*(* )+ /(0"3(,! *(,1% (* (43%&"-()(* +'

/&B)"3%* *40,+'+#3(&+* %4 +*0+/"("* /%' $"#(,")()+ 0&+/"*(! (0&%1()%*

0+,% G%)+& M+;"*,(3"1% 0%& '("%&"( (.*%,43(5

!"#$%& '(

Page 68: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$%&'()'" !*+!$,!," %" $'-,.'" ' #$'/, 012,! "%2,!34 -'$!3 ' #$5#$,%

%" "'$/, %$'" #673,2%"8

! /!$,!(9% #!*$,.%1,!34 '/, '12,!1 % ! !3,'1!(9% ' !*,/%" ' ! !#3,2!(9%

%" $'2+$"%" '3! '2%$$'1*'":

!"#$% ;%$ % 2!"%4 "'$9% !#$'"'1*! !" &+"*,;,2!*,/!"<

! 3,.,*!(9% ' '.#'1=%8

! ;$+"*$!(9% ' $'2',*!"4 '"#'2,;,2!1 % !" .' , !" ' 2%.7!*' > "%1'?

-!(9% ' > '/!"9% ;,"2!34 ! %*! !" ' ! ! %*!$4 ' !" !()'" ' ;,"2!3,@!(9% '

2%7$!1(!:

A. /,$*+ ' ' % $'3!*5$,% $'"+., % ' 'B'2+(9% %$(!.'1*C$,! ' "+!

#+73,2!(9% '"*!$'. '*'$.,1! %" 1% D Eº4 !$*: FGH ! IJ4 ' +.! ;%$.!

%+ ' %+*$!4 *% !" !" '";'$!" ' -%/'$1% 2+.#$,!. %+ '/'$,!. 2+.#$,$ !

%7$,-!*%$,' ! ': K 2%1*'6 % ' ! ;%$.!4 '"2%3=, %" ' *%$1! %" %7$,-!*5$,%"

#'3! LMJ4 ,$9% #! $%1,@!$ ' ;!2,3,*!$ !" *!$';!" ' !1C3,"' ' 2%1"%3, !(9% !"

2%1*!" #673,2!"4 !"",. 2%.% 2%12%$$'$9% #!$! % !#'$;',(%!.'1*% %

#$%2'""% ' *$!1"#!$012,!:

5HODWyULR�GH�*HVWmR�)LVFDO��DUWV�����H����

N*O &'(#&" $(") "*+) % ;,1!3 ' ,"$" -!"$'(./)&'/4 "'$C '.,*, % ' #+73,2!?

%4 2%. !.#3% !2'""% !% #673,2%4 ,123+",/' #%$ .',% '3'*$P1,2%4 '/0"&+'(%

$/ 1/)&2% 3(),"04 2%1*'1 % !" !"",1!*+$!" !" !+*%$, ! '" $'"#%1"C/'," #'3!

! .,1,"*$!(9% ;,1!12',$! ' #'3% ,%#&'%0/ (#&/'#% ' %<

I=';' % Q% '$ AB'2+*,/%8

Q$'", '1*' ' '.!," .'.7$%" ! R'"! S,$'*%$! %+ 5$-9% '2,"5$,%

'T+,/!3'1*'4 2%1;%$.' $'-,.'1*%" ,1*'$1%" %" 5$-9%" % Q% '$ L'-,"3!?

*,/%8

Q$'", '1*' ' U$,7+1!3 ' '.!,".'.7$%" 'I%1"'3=% 'N .,1,"*$!(9%

%+ 5$-9% '2,"5$,% 'T+,/!3'1*'4 2%1;%$.' $'-,.'1*%" ,1*'$1%" %" 5$-9%"

% Q% '$ V+ ,2,C$,%8

I=';' % R,1,"*O$,% Q673,2%4 ! W1,9% ' %" A"*! %":

X 23!$% T+' !" '*'$.,1!()'" '1/%3/'1 % !" !+*%$, ! '"4 $';'$, !" 1%" %,"

63*,.%" ,*'1" !2,.!4 19% "' !#3,2!. !%" R+1,2Y#,%":

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 69: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&!'( !"#$%&)

!'()%)#*+! *(+ (, #'+'%", -" ./" %!$%$ ",%$ 0123 -(, ,"4/'5%", +(56

%$5%",)

7 ,$-($-) %(%$# *(+ 8",,($#3 -',%'54/'5-( $ *(+ '5$%'9(, " 8"5,'(5',%$,:

7 ,.+*,)- *(5,(#'-$-$ " +(;'#'<!'$:

7 !" $--/! -" 4$!$5%'$,:

7 !($%)01$- ,$ %2,*#!3 '5*#/,'9" 8(! $5%"*'8$=>( -" !"*"'%$:

*",* )0/! -$, +"-'-$, *(!!"%'9$, $-(%$-$, (/ $ $-(%$!3 ," /#%!$8$,,$-(

./$#./"! -(, #'+'%",:

,$'!"-#%)#*+!-3 5( ?#%'+( ./$-!'+",%!")

7 ,! '!"#)"#$ -$, -',8(5';'#'-$-", -" *$'@$ "+ %!'5%$ " /+ -" -"A"+6

;!(:

7 ,) *"- %*0/! "+ 1",%(, $ B$4$!3 -$, -",8",$,)

6 #'./'-$-$,:

6 "+8"5C$-$, " 5>( #'./'-$-$,3 '5,*!'%$, $%D ( #'+'%" -( ,$#-( -$

-',8(5';'#'-$-" -" *$'@$:

6 5>( '5,*!'%$, 8(! E$#%$ -" -',8(5';'#'-$-" -" *$'@$ " */F(, "+8"5C(,

E(!$+ *$5*"#$-(,:

7 ,! 3'(%*'$"#! -" ./" $, (8"!$=G", -" H1 E(!$+ ./'%$-$, $%D (

-'$ IJ -" -"A"+;!( (/ 5>( !"$#'A$-$,3 ," ," ",%'9"! 5( ?#%'+( $5( -"

+$5-$%( -( B!"E"'%( K'5*',( LL " $#M5"$ -( '5*',( LN3 $!%O PQRO

S,," !"#$%&!'( -" 4",%>( E',*$# D +$', /+$ -$, *"!+)01$- -$ 012O H,

'5E(!+$=G", ./" -"9"+ '5%"4!<6#( ,>( +$', -" */5C( 4"!"5*'$# -( ./"

8!(8!'$+"5%" *(5%<;"',3 $,8"*%(, ,"+ -?9'-$ '+8(!%$5%", %$+;D+ 8$!$ (

$8"!E"'=($+"5%( -( 8!(*",,( -" %!$5,8$!T5*'$3 ( ./" D !"E(!=$-( 8"#$

(;!'4$%(!'"-$-" ./" '+8G" -" ( +",+( ,"! $,,'5$-( 8"#$, $/%(!'-$-",

!",8(5,<9"', 8"#$ $-+'5',%!$=>( E'5$5*"'!$3 8"#( !"#%!4$ *"#$%"! " 8"#(

UC"E" -( B(-"! S@"*/%'9( K5( *$,( -(, V/5'*M8'(,3 8"#(, !",8"*%'9(,

B!"E"'%(,RO

3UHVWDo}HV�GH�&RQWDV��DUWV�����D����

H 8!",%$=>( -" *(5%$, -(, UC"E", -( B(-"! S@"*/%'9( '5*#/'!<3 $#D+ -$,

,/$, 8!&8!'$,3 $, -(, B!",'-"5%", -(, &!4>(, -(, B(-"!", 0"4',#$%'9( "

W/-'*'<!'( " -( UC"E" -( V'5',%D!'( B?;#'*(O X"!>( (;F"%( -" )'(4)

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 70: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&'() !" #$"%&'( !" (" )!*'(" +%&,( (" !% '!-( (". $ $/0 $*)0(#1! !

$"$-2$*3! ( (##$)( (41! $- #$&(41!5

* +,-"!.(). $"'()(* ! (" 2#!/0 6*)0(" ( !'( (" *! 7-80'!5

9 ( /!.0&$!1&'() (" #$)$0'(": $

9 ! 0)23&4- * .)5-%&'():

*. &'6-. $ #$)%2$#(41! $ )#; 0'!" *(" 0*"'7*)0(" ( -0*0"'#('0/( $

+% 0)0(&:

*. -2&!. 2- ! &.. 2(#( 0*)#$-$*'! (" #$)$0'(" '#08%'<#0(" $ $

)!*'#08%04=$">

?" @#08%*(0" $ A!*'(" $-0'0#1! 2(#$)$# 2#;/0! )!*)&%"0/! "!8#$ (" )!*'("

*! 2#(B! $ "$""$*'( 0(" ! #$)$80-$*'!. "$ !%'#! *1! $"'0/$# $"'(8$&$)0 !

*(" )!*"'0'%04=$" $"'( %(0" C2(#( ! )("! !" D"'( !"E !% *(" &$0" !#,7*0)("

-%*0)02(0" C2(#( ! )("! !" F%*0)G20!"E> H%(* ! ! F%*0)G20! *1! I!#

)(20'(& !% '0/$# -$*!" $ JKK>KKK 3(80'(*'$". ! 2#(B! "$ $&$/(#< 2(#( LMK

0(". $ !" @#08%*(0" $ A!*'(" *1! $*'#(#1! $- #$)$""!. $*N%(*'! $O0"'0#$-

)!*'(" $ P! $# 2$* $*'$" $ 2(#$)$# 2#;/0!>

A!*/;- ()#$")$*'(# N%$ !" (#'"> QK ( QR ( AS (-2&0(#(-. "0,*0I0)('0/(T

-$*'$. ( 2(#'0)02(41! ! P! $# U$,0"&('0/! *( (41! $ I0")(&0B(41! )!*'<80&.

I0*(*)$0#( $ !#4(-$*'<#0( ! V$'!# PW8&0)!. ('#(/;" ! 0)54,)$- -74-,5).

$O$#)0 ! )!- ! (%OG&0! !" @#08%*(0" $ A!*'(". $ 2$&!.!.4-2& - 0)54,)$-

!54-,5) $ )( ( P! $#> @#('(T"$ $ )!* 0)0!*(-$*'! /0,$*'$ $" $ (

2#!-%&,(41! ( AS. (2&0)</$& 0* $2$* $*'$-$*'$ ( /0,6*)0( ( UXS>

? 2(#<,#(I! W*0)! ! (#'> QK ( AS. )!- #$ (41! ( ( 2$&( D-$* (

A!*"'0'%)0!*(& *º LY. $ KZ[K\[YM. $'$#-0*( N%$ 2#$"'(#< )!*'(" N%(&N%$#

2$""!( IG"0)( !% +%#G 0)(. 2W8&0)( !% 2#0/( (. N%$ %'0&0B$. (##$)( $. ,%(# $.

,$#$*)0$ !% ( -0*0"'#$ 0*3$0#!". 8$*" $ /(&!#$" 2W8&0)!" !% 2$&!" N%(0" (

]*01! #$"2!* (. !% N%$. $- *!-$ $"'(. (""%-( !8#0,(4=$" $ *('%#$B(

2$)%*0<#0(> ^ #$"2$0'!. ; 8("'(*'$ 0*)0"0/( ( &041! ! F$"'#$ _$&`5

!" #$ %"&'$ ( )(*+,-.( /" 0,1!" "+ /( %-''"( 2+- ( "3,&1( ( %,-'*(,

4")*('5 # ( ",&1-6 %738&4( /" 3-6 (/6&)&'*,(/" "+ /" /&)9-&," 1-,&/"

2+- (4(,,-*( %(,( " 1-'*", " /-:-, /- 4"6%,":(, '-+ .-8" - 3"6

-6%,-1";

^ 0(*'$. ! (#'> QZ $'$#-0*( N%$ !" P! $#$" U$,0"&('0/!. DO$)%'0/! $

a% 0)0<#0!2&54-,(). $ I!#-( 0*'$,#( (. .!.4-2& - 0)54,)$- !54-,5))!-

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 71: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"# $"% %& %&' &#()& *+()*, *-.&("/*,' 0*12)*/ ) $&3 $"% %& & / $" ) *,

)&,+$( %*,' 4+ #(* 5 &!"060" & 5 &!"0"7#0" ' ( #(* % 3&,(8* *)9 1&#(6)" '

!"# #0&") & 2 ()"1*#" $ #*, :)38*, & &#("% %&, % %1"#",() 98* !&%&) $'

0*1* % 2$"0 98* %& )&0+),*, 2;-$"0*, 2*) &#("% %&, %& %")&"(* 2)"/ %* &

2*" ) * !"#$!%& &'#&$"! &<&)0"%* 2&$ =,,&1-$>" ?&3",$ ("/ ' 0*1 *

+<@$"* %* A)"-+# $ %& B*#( , %* C,( %*D

E& 0*)%* 0*1* )(D FG % B*#,("(+"98* % H&2;-$"0 ' *, I*%&)&, C<&0+("/*

& ?&3",$ ("/* %&/&)8* 1 #(&)' %& !*)1 "#(&3) % ' * ,",(&1 %& !"#$!%&

("#&$"! %* J+#"0@2"*D C,,& ,",(&1 > !+#% 1&#( $ 2 ) * 7<"(* % ?HK'

2*" #%*' "#0$+,"/&' * ,",(&1 %& 0*#()*$& &<(&)#*D

=,,"1' 0 -& * )()#&*+ ,& !"#$!%& ("#&$"!%* J+#"0@2"* %&!"#")' () />,

%& "#,()+9L&, &,2&0@!"0 ,' *, 2)*0&%"1&#(*, ,&)&1 ,&3+"%*, 2*) (*% , ,

"#,("(+"9L&, 2;-$"0 , & 2)"/ % , 4+&' %& +1 !*)1 *+ %& *+() ' %&/&1

2)&,( ) 0*#( , %*, )&0+),*, 2;-$"0*, &#4+ %)6/&", #* )(D FM & ,&+ 2 )63) !*

;#"0* % BKD B*1* 2)&,( 98* %& 0*#( , 0*#,("(+" +1 % , ;$("1 , &( 2 ,

%* 2)*0&,,* &#/*$/&#%* %"#N&")*,' -&#, & / $*)&, 2;-$"0*,' , "#,()+9L&,

)&!&)"% , %&/&1' 2*) 1*("/*, %& 0*&)7#0" & %& ! 0"$"% %& %& &#4+ %) O

1&#(*' "#0$+") (*% , , &( 2 , #(&)"*)&,' %&,%& *)9 1&#( 98*' &,0)"(+) O

98* 0*#(6-"$' &$ -*) 98* & 2+-$"0 98* %*, H&$ (:)"*, %& C<&0+98* P)9 O

1&#(6)" & %& Q&,(8* K",0 $ & 2)&,&#( 98* % , 0*#( , *, :)38*, &,O

2&0"!"0 %*,D

I ) 4+& * )()#&*+ ,& !"#$!%& ("#&$"! 0+12) ,+ 1",,8*' %&/& (&)

"#,("(+0"*# $"R %* ,&+ :)38* 0&#() $ # &,()+(+) %1"#",() ("/ % I)&!&"(+)

J+#"0"2 $D P 2 2&$ -6,"0* %&,,& :)38* > #*)1 ("/*' 0**)%&# %*) & )("0+O

$ %*) %& 9L&,' "#(&3) %*) %& &,!*)9*, & 0&#() $"R %*) %& "#!*)1 9L&,D

S6 4+&1 %&!&#% 4+& &,,& :)38* 0&#() $' % % ,+ "12*)(T#0" ' .6

&<2$"0"( % #* )(D FU % ?&" #º GDVWMXYG' 12$" % 2&$ B )( J 3# %&

Z[\\' & , 0) 1&#( % # ?HK' %&/ ,&) $*0 $"R %* #* 2)"1&")* &,0 $8* %

=%1"#",() 98* J+#"0"2 $ ]2*) &<&12$*' ^&0)&( )" J+#"0"2 $ *+ :)38* %&

,,&,,*) 1&#(* ,+2&)"*) * I)&!&"(*_D

I )("0"2 )8* %* ,",(&1 *+()*, :)38*, ,&(*)" ", 0+. , ()"-+"9L&, "#!$+&#0"&1

, 0*#( , 2;-$"0 ,' 0*1* 0*#( -"$"% %&' 2&,,* $' 0*12) ,' ))&0 % 98*&(0D

P *-.&("/*' #&,(& 0 ,*' > ,+-*)%"# ) * ,",(&1 %& 0*#()*$& "#(&)#* (*% ,

, ("/"% %&, "12*)( #(&, 2 ) 1 #+(&#98* %* &4+"$@-)"* !"# #0&")* %*

J+#"0@2"*D

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 72: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$#!"#!%#&#!%# "# '() '(*+,"-!)./+ 0-#,1,2(-3)4 +' 5,6/+' '#%+,-)-'

-!%#6,)!%#' "+ '-'%#&) '# '(7#-%),/+4 !+ 2(# '# ,#8#,# )+' $,+3#"-&#!%+' "#

3+!%,+9# -!%#,!+4 : +,-#!%)./+ # : '($#,;-'/+ %<3!-3) "+ 5,6/+ 3#!%,)9=

)LVFDOL]DomR�GD�*HVWmR�)LVFDO��DUW�����

> !"#$ %#&'()*+',!4 "-,#%)&#!%# +( 3+& + )(?@9-+ "+' A,-*(!)-' "# B+!%)'4

# + ('(+#-* "# .!/+$!)# '/+#$/! "# 3)") C+"#, # "+ D-!-'%<,-+ CE*9-3+4

8-'3)9-F),/+ + 3(&$,-&#!%+ ")' !+,&)' ") GHI4 3+& J!8)'# !+ 2(# '#

,#8#,# )K

*+'/&'-#/+! ")' &#%)' #'%)*#9#3-")' !) 9#- "# "-,#%,-F#' +,.)&#!%1,-)'L

)'-'+#( # .!/"'01#( $),) ,#)9-F)./+ "# +$#,).M#' "# 3,<"-%+ # -!'3,-./+

#& H#'%+' ) C)6),L

-#"'"*( )"+%)")' $),) + ,#%+,!+ ") "#'$#') %+%)9 3+& $#''+)9 )+

,#'$#3%-;+ 9-&-%#L

2$!,'"3/.'*( %+&)")' $),) ,#3+!"(./+ "+' &+!%)!%#' ")' "@;-")'

3+!'+9-")") # &+*-9-1,-) )+' ,#'$#3%-;+' 9-&-%#'L

"#(+'/*04!"# ,#3(,'+' +*%-"+' 3+& ) )9-#!)./+ "# )%-;+'4 %#!"+ #& ;-'%)

)' ,#'%,-.M#' 3+!'%-%(3-+!)-' # )' "#'%) G#- B+&$9#&#!%),L

.5-2$'-#/+! "+ 9-&-%# "# 6)'%+' %+%)-' "+' 9#6-'9)%-;+' &(!-3-$)-'4

2()!"+ 0+(;#,=

>' 6$'75/*'( "# 8!/+*(4 ) 2(#& 3+&$#%# )-!") ;#,-8-3), +' 3193(9+' "+'

9-&-%#' ") "#'$#') %+%)9 3+& $#''+)9 "# 3)") C+"#, # 5,6/+4 )9#,%),/+ #''#'

C+"#,#' +( 5,6/+'4 2()!"+ 3+!'%)%),#&K

) 2!(('7')'"*"# "# +3+,,J!3-) ") $,+*)*-9-")"# "# ) ,#)9-F)./+ ")

,#3#-%) !/+ 3+&$+,%), + 3(&$,-&#!%+ ")' &#%)' "# ,#'(9%)"+ $,-&1,-+

+( !+&-!)9 #'%)*#9#3-")'L

2(# + -!/+*/+# ") "#'$#') %+%)9 3+& $#''+)9 (9%,)$)''+( NOP Q!+;#!%)

$+, 3#!%+R "+ 9-&-%#L

2(# +' -!/+*/+#( ")' "@;-")' 3+!'+9-")") # &+*-9-1,-)4 ")' +$#,).M#'

"# 3,<"-%+ # ") 3+!3#''/+ "# 6),)!%-) '# #!3+!%,)& )3-&) "# NOP

Q!+;#!%) $+, 3#!%+R "+' ,#'$#3%-;+' 9-&-%#'L

2(# +' &*(+!( 3+& -!)%-;+' # $#!'-+!-'%)' '# #!3+!%,)& )3-&) "+ 9-&-%#

"#8-!-"+ #& 9#-L

9*+!( 2(# 3+&$,+&#%)& +' 3('%+' +( +' ,#'(9%)"+' "+' $,+6,)&)' +(

-!"@3-+' "# -,,#6(9),-")"#' !) 6#'%/+ +,.)&#!%1,-)=

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 73: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$#%&'()*+#! ),'&) %#-.%*)& .! ,.&#($/%'.! )($#%'.%#!0 #1'"#(,')(".

) (#,#!!'")"# "# #!,.23) "# 4&) 4('")"# -4(,'.()2 5.2'$',)&#($# -.%$#0

'!$. 60 !'$4)") (. 5%'&#'%. #!,)27. ". 8.1#%(. 94(','5)20 ,.& . .:;#$'1.

"# <#%#(,')% . ! "#$% &# '()"*(+# !)"#*)(= >)!. ,.($%/%'.0 3)1#%/ "'-',42?

")"#! 5)%) ) )52',)*7. ")! (.%&)! #!$)$4@")! () ABC=

',6326,d¯(6�),1$,6�(�75$16,7Ð5,$6��$57�����

/LPLWHV�H�7tWXORV��DUWV�����H����

A#' #!$)"4)2 .4 &4(','5)2 ,(&#*- .!/%* +!$!"# !).#*!(*# ).! 5%#1'!$.! ()

ABC 5)%) )! "@1'")! ,.(!.2'")") # &.:'2'/%')0 5)%) .5#%)*+#! "# ,%6"'$. #

,.(,#!!7. "# <)%)($')!=

D! "0"1+( ") "@1'") 5E:2',)0 "#!"# F4# "#1'")&#($# # '*!"1*%&( #&

!'!$#&) ,#($%)2'G)". "# 2'F4'")*7. # ,4!$H"')0 5."#%7. !#% .-#%#,'".! #&

'%123( 5)%) <)%)($') "# #&5%6!$'&.!0 .4 #& .4$%)! $%)(!)*+#! 5%#1'!$)!

#& 2#'0 5#2. !#4 1)2.% #,.(I&',.0 ,.(-.%&# "#-'('". 5#2. 9'('!$6%'. ")

C)G#(")=

J)'! "#$#%&'()*+#! !7. &)'! #!,2)%#,#".%)! ". F4# '&5.!'$'1)!=

0XQLFtSLRV��DUWV�����D����

D!41)!'0,!( !H ,.($%':4'%7. 5)%) . '1 "#!( "# "#!5#!)! "# ,.&5#$K(,')

&# (1"*( #)"# ") C#"#%)*7.0 !# 3.41#%L

%1"(*!5%23( () 2#' "# "'%#$%'G#! .%*)&#($/%')! # () 2#' .%*)&#($/%')

)(4)2M

'()67)!(0 ),.%".0 );4!$# .4 ,.(<K(#%#0 ,.(-.%&# !4) 2#<'!2)*7.=

N!!) "#$#%&'()*7. 1)' 5#%&'$'% F4# !#;)& ,.%%'<'".! )2<4(! "#!1'.! #($%# )!

"'1#%!)! #!-#%)! "# 8.1#%(.0 #!5#,')2&#($# ) O('7. # . N!$)".0 "# 4& 2)".0

# . 94(',@5'.0 "# .4$%.= N&:.%) !#;) %#,.&#("/1#2 ) ,..5#%)*7. #($%#

#2#!0 #& :#(#-@,'. ". '($#%#!!# 5E:2',.0 (7. "#1#& !#% .,42$)".! .! ,4!$.!

#& <#%)2 !45.%$)".! 5#2.! 94(',@5'.!0 F4)(". -.%(#,#& ,.&:4!$@1#'! 5)%)

1')$4%)! 5.2',')'!0 ,#"#& "#5#("K(,')! 5)%) 4!. "# %#5)%$'*+#! #!$)"4)'! #

-#"#%)'! #$,= '(.1)".%) &#"'") 6 "# <%)("# 1)2.% 5)%) . ,.($%.2# # )

$%)(!5)%K(,') ") <#!$7. &4(','5)2=

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 74: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%!&' !'( )#*+",-+'( !"# $"$%&'()" +* ./+'/ ' !*+,-.+/' #*&

0'1*/'+/.2 "$/'3 $"34

0./+ +"!/ " !%#$3*#.+/" 5"2 &*#*/.2 5"2 6'2/"2 !"# $.22"'& . 5' 578*5'

!"+2"&*5'5' '" 9*+'& 5" (.1.(%/.:

&+0#$2!/ (.1.(%/!$1.*%.4

; <.&'/=3*" 5. >.2/)" ?*2!'&:

; "2 5.#"+2/3'/*8"2 3.&'/*8"2 '4

@ '$%3'()" 5' 3.!.*/' !"33.+/. &7,%*5'A 2%' .8"&%()"A '22*# !"#" '

$3.8*2)" 5. 2.% 5.2.#$.+0" '/B " 9*+'& 5" .C.3!7!*":

@ 3.!.*/'2 . 5.2$.2'2 $3.8*5.+!*D3*'2:

@ 3.2%&/'5"2 +"#*+'& . $3*#D3*":

@ 5.2$.2'2 !"# E%3"2:

@ 3.2/"2 ' $'6'3A 5./'&0'+5"A $"3 F"5.3 . =36)"A "2 8'&"3.2 *+2!3*/"2A

"2 $'6'#.+/"2 3.'&*G'5"2 . " #"+/'+/. ' $'6'3H

.$!3'/!/A ' $'3/*3 5" ,%*+/" .C.3!7!*" 2.6%*+/. IJKKLM '" 5' $%1&*!'()"

5.2/' N.* O"#$&.#.+/'3A "4

; P+.C" 5. F"&7/*!' ?*2!'& 5" $&'+" $&%3*'+%'& I!"# " 8./" '" '3/H QºA

.2/. P+.C" 5.*C"% 5. .C*2/*3A #'2 ' N<?A /'&8.G $"3 %#' 9'&0'A 9'G

#.+()" ' .&. +" *+!*2" RRR 5" '3/H SQM:

; P+.C" 5. T./'2 ?*2!'*2:

; P+.C" 5. <*2!"2 ?*2!'*2 5' &.* 5. 5*3./3*G.2 "3('#.+/D3*'2: .

; U.#"+2/3'/*8" 5' O"#$'/*1*&*5'5. 5' $3"63'#'()" 5"2 "3('#.+/"2

!"# "2 "1E./*8"2 . '2 #./'2 !"+2/'+/.2 5" P+.C" 5. T./'2 ?*2!'*2

I*+!*2" RA '3/H LºMH

P$.2'3 5. 0'8.3 !"+!.5*5" 9'!%&5'5.A $'3' "2 T%+*!7$*"2 !"# #.+"2 5.

!*+,-.+/' #*& 0'1*/'+/.2A $'3' .&'1"3'3 " P+.C" 5. T./'2 ?*2!'*2 2= .#

JKKLA ' N<? .C*6. ,%. /"5"2A *+5.$.+5.+/.#.+/. 5. 2.% $"3/. $"$%&'!*"@

+'&A '!"#$'+0.# ' .8"&%()" 5. 2.%2 3.2%&/'5"2 $3*#D3*" . +"#*+'& I'3/H

LQMH P22*#A #.2#" "2 T%+*!7$*"2 ,%. 9*G.3.# E%2 ' .22' 9'!%&5'5.A /.3)"

,%. .&'1"3'3 " 5.#"+2/3'/*8" !"33.2$"+5.+/. ' .22.2 3.2%&/'5"2A ED ' $'3/*3

5" $3=C*#" '+"H

P &+0#$2!45' 5"2 3.&'/=3*"2 . 5.#"+2/3'/*8"2 5.8.3D 2.3 3.'&*G'5' .# !%6

%/+*%! &+!( '$=2 " .+!.33'#.+/" 5" (.1.(%/.H V. %&/3'$'22'5"2 "2 &*#*/.2

3.&'/*8"2 W 5.2$.2' /"/'& !"# $.22"'& "% W 578*5' !"+2"&*5'5'A .+,%'+/"

$.35%3'3 .2/' 2*/%'()"A " )#*+",-+' 9*!'3D 2%E.*/" '"2 #.2#"2 $3'G"2 5.

8.3*9*!'()" . 5. 3./"3+" '" &*#*/.A 5.9*+*5"2 $'3' "2 5.#'*2 .+/.2H

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 75: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%!&'( )(* #+!,(* #!+! )%-.$/!&'( )( 01$!23+%( )1 41*2'( 5%*6!$ 1 )1

(.2+(* )1"(7*2+!2%-(*8 1" #+%769#%(8 7'( )1-1+: 2+!,1+ 717;." /!7;( #!+!

! )"%7%*2+!&'( )1**1* <.7%69#%(* 6(" !2= >?@??? ;!A%2!721*@

!"#$ #+1*2!+: %&&"&'(!)"% '*)!")% 1 )$$+,-%.#$ /"!%!),"-% !(*01!"2

)3+"$&#!+! !"()1+7%,!&'( )!* +1*#162%-!* !)"%7%*2+!&B1* 2+%A.2:+%!8 C%7!7D

61%+!8 #!2+%"(7%!$ 1 #+1-%)176%:+%!8 6(" -%*2!* !( 6."#+%"172( )!* 7(+"!*

)1*2! E1% F("#$1"172!+@

%&&"&'(!)"% '*)!")% 6(7*%*2%+: 7( 2+1%7!"172( 1 7( )1*17-($-%"172(

)1 +16.+*(* ;."!7(* 1 7! 2+!7*C1+G76%! )1 2167($(/%!8 A1" 6("( 7(

!#(%( H )%-.$/!&'( )(* %7*2+."172(* )1 2+!7*#!+G76%! )! /1*2'( C%*6!$ 1"

"1%( 1$12+I7%6( )1 !"#$( !61**( #JA$%6(@

)$$+,-%.#$ /"!%!),"-% 6("#+117)1+: ! )(!&'( )1 A17* 1 -!$(+1*8 (

C%7!76%!"172(8 #(+ %721+"=)%( )!* %7*2%2.%&B1* C%7!761%+!* C1)1+!%*8 1 (

+1#!**1 )1 +16.+*(* (+%.7)(* )1 (#1+!&B1* 1K21+7!*@

L.2+( +16(7;16%"172( %"#$96%2( )! !.*G76%! )( &"&',4% 5, )$!'-$6,

"!',-!$@ M!+! C%6!+ "!%* 6$!+(8 ! E05 )1-1+%! 21+ 6+%!)( "16!7%*"(* N.1

#(**%A%$%2!**1" ! %"#$!72!&'( )!N.1$1* !71K(* %"1)%!2!"1721 !#3* ! #+1*D

2!&'( )! !**%*2G76%! 2=67%6! 1 )! 6((#1+!&'( C%7!761%+! )1*6+%2!* !6%"!@

)DWRUHV�([WHUQRV��DUWV�����H����

O! (6(++G76%! )1 )%6%4"5%5, +786")%8 +16(7;16%)! #1$( F(7/+1**( O!D

6%(7!$8 7( 6!*( )! P7%'(8 (. #1$!* **1"A$=%!* E1/%*$!2%-!*

8 7! ;%#321*1

)(* Q*2!)(* 1 <.7%69#%(*8 17N.!72( #1+).+!+ ! *%2.!&'(R

&,-#$ &1&+,!&%& ! 6(72!/1" )(* #+!,(* 1 !* )%*#(*%&B1* 1*2!A1$16%)!*

7(* !+2*@ ST U1K61**(* )1 $%"%21* 6(" )1*#1*!* )1 #1**(!$V8 TW U1K61**(*

)1 $%"%21* 6(")1*#1*!* )! )9-%)!V 1 X? U1K61**(* )1 $%"%21* 6(")1*#1*!*

)1 #1**(!$ 7( !7( )1 WYYYVZ

&,-#$ 5"&+,!&%5$& ( !2%7/%"172( )(* +1*.$2!)(* C%*6!%* 1 ! $%"%2!&'( )1

1"#17;(8 #(+ %7*.C%6%G76%! )1 +161%2! #!+! 6."#+%+ !* "12!* 1*2!A1$1D

6%)!*8 #+1-%*2(* 7( !+2@ Yº@

!"#$%& '(

!

)) ! *+,--.* /0 1+020 /3 43230/*23- 5 ,678-9,:,;<=3>? * @83 6.* 0 ,+A3/3 /3 3:39802 *

23;*6B3;,+369* 3? +0,- /* @83 ,--*? 0A*,02 * C*/32 #D3;89,=* 60 ,+A>3+3690E.* /0-

0EF3- /3-9,60/0- 0 3>,+,602 *8 +,6*202 *- 3:3,9*- /0 ;0>0+,/0/3G

Page 76: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&'( ) *#'!)'+) %$#,% -) $%') *( ('+%*) *( *(.('% )/ *( '0+#)1

*($2(+%*) -% .)2,% *% 34 5!2(6#'+)' (, '(/' %2+'7 89: ( 89;<7

=' !2%>)' ('+%?("($#*)' -)' %2+'7 @91 98 ( ;A '(2B) */!"#$%*)'1 -) !"# $%

&%" '(%)*# &%!+ ?%#C) )/ -(D%+#6) *) E2)*/+) F-+(2-) G2/+) 5EFG< -%$#)&

-%"1 2(D#)-%" )/ ('+%*/%"1 !)2 !(20)*) #D/%" )/ '/!(2#)2 % H/%+2) +2#,('+2('7

I-+(-*(&'( !)2 ?%#C) $2('$#,(-+) % +%C% *( 6%2#%JB) 2(%" %$/,/"%*% *)

E2)*/+) F-+(2-) G2/+) #-.(2#)2 % 8K 5/, !)2 $(-+)<1 -) !(20)*) $)22('!)-&

*(-+( %)' H/%+2) L"+#,)' +2#,('+2('1 %!/2%*% !("% 4/-*%JB) F-'+#+/+) G2%&

'#"(#2) *( M()D2%.#% ( I'+%+0'+#$% )/ )/+2) N2DB) H/( 6#(2 % '/?'+#+/0&"%1

%*)+%*% % ,(',% ,(+)*)")D#% !%2% %!/2%JB) *)' EFG -%$#)-%"1 ('+%*/%" (

2(D#)-%"7 O('+% P#!N+('(1 $)-+#-/%2B) % '(2 %*)+%*%' %' ,(*#*%' !2(6#'+%'

-) %2+7 @@7

O% P#!N+('( *( '( 6(2#.#$%2(,,/*%-J%' *2Q'+#$%' -% $)-*/JB) *%' !)"0+#$%'

,)-(+Q2#% ( $%,?#%"1 2($)-P($#*%' !(") R(-%*) 4(*(2%"1 ) !2%>) 2(.(2#*)

-) !"#$ *) %2+7 98 !)*(2Q '(2 %,!"#%*) (, %+S ,-!*&# ,-!$&'(%"*&%"7

T%#' 2($),(-*%JU(' (6#*(-$#%, % !2()$/!%JB) $), % ."(C#?#"#>%JB) *%'

2('+2#JU(' (, '#+/%JU(' *('.%6)2Q6(#'7 RB) ?(,&6#-*%'1 !)2H/(1 *) $)-+2Q&

2#)1 !)*(2#%, (-'(V%2 #-+(2!2(+%JU(' 20D#*%'1 %"D/,%' %+S $)-+2Q2#%' %)

#-+(2(''( !L?"#$)7

&RQVHOKR�GH�*HVWmR�)LVFDO��DUW�����

= ! #(.!)/!(%)*# % ! !0!+'!12#1 *( .)2,% !(2,%-(-+(1 *% !)"0+#$% ( *%

)!(2%$#)-%"#*%*( *% D('+B) .#'$%" '(2B) 2(%"#>%*)' !)2 /, 3#)"%+/# $%

4%"*2# 5'" !+1 $)-'+#+/0*) !)2 2(!2('(-+%-+(' *( +)*)' )' E)*(2(' (%"6%&!"

$% 4#0%&)#1 *) W#-#'+S2#) EL?"#$) ( *( (-+#*%*(' +S$-#$%' 2(!2('(-+%+#6%'

*% ')$#(*%*(1 6#'%-*) XY

/!&(#)'7!12# ( X ##&$%)!12# (-+2( )' (-+(' *% 4(*(2%JB)Z

$'""%(')!12#*( !2Q+#$%' H/( 2('/"+(, (,,%#)2 (.#$#[-$#% -% %")$%JB)

( -% (C($/JB) *) D%'+) !L?"#$)1 -% %22($%*%JB) *( 2($(#+%'1 -) $)-+2)"(

*) (-*#6#*%,(-+) ( -% +2%-'!%2[-$#% *% D('+B) .#'$%"Z

!$#12# *( -)2,%' *( $)-')"#*%JB) *%' $)-+%' !L?"#$%'1 !%*2)-#>%JB)

*%' !2('+%JU(' *( $)-+%' ( *)' 2("%+N2#)' ( *(,)-'+2%+#6)' *( D('+B)

.#'$%"1 *( H/( +2%+% ('+% \(# 3),!"(,(-+%21 -)2,%' ( !%*2U(' ,%#'

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 77: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$% #&'& ( #%)*%+( ,*+!-.#!( / 0%" -("( (*1'( / +%-% 2'!( &(

-(+1'($% (-!&$3

!"#$%&'() 4% &+2$! % / % 1*4( % 4!&5+6 1!-( 7

8 -(+ %$9( !*+,!,#!-. :('"& 4%/-01!&'() 0 -02)*302!10*,) /45$!2)&(

1!1*$&'% 4% ;(4%' )*% &$-&+<&'%" '% *$1&4( "%'!16'!( %" *& #($.1!-&

4% 4% %+=($=!"%+1( (-!&$/ -(+>*5&4( -(" & #'21!-& 4% *"& 5% 1?( :! -&$

#&*1&4& #%$& +('"& 4& @AB7 @%! :%4%'&$ 4! #('2 (0'% & -("#( !<?( % &

:('"& 4% :*+-!(+&"%+1( 4( -(+ %$9(7

C %D%"#$( 4% -("%+12'!( &+1%'!('% / )*&+4( 4! -(''%"( (0'% & *+1(

>2 -(+1%"#$&4( #%$& @%! +º !"#$%& ' ()* +*,-.*/ *012,34 56- */ /-6/

34728*/ 999 3 99" :; 7437313. ,- +4*12,<(=23/ /-.-0>3(7-/! ?301-@' ,*43A

13(7-' 2.+60/2*(3,*/ +-0*/ =03.*4-/ ,3 +*+603B)*' +-03 CDE - +-03/

+-(302,3,-/ 3 56- -/734)* /6:-27*/' */ F8-(7-/ G*0H72=*/ 3742I63. 3 2.+*4A

7J(=23 ,-12,3 3*/ /2/7-.3/ ,- =*(74*0- 2(7-4(* - =*(=*443. +343 56- */

*I:-721*/ K2L3,*/ /-:3. 30=3(B3,*/!

)XQGR�GR�5HJLPH�*HUDO�GH�3UHYLGrQFLD�6RFLDO��DUWV�����H����

M3 K*4.3 ,* 347! #N$ ,3 O*(/72762B)*' P =423,* * E6(,* ,* D-82.- Q-430

,- G4-12,<(=23 R*=230' 12(=603,* 3* S2(2/7P42* ,3 G4-12,<(=23 - F//2/7<(=23

R*=230' =*.3 K2(302,3,- ,-+4*1-4 4-=64/*/ +343 * +383.-(7* ,*/ I-(-KH=2*/

,* 4-82.- 8-430 ,3 +4-12,<(=23 /*=230! T E6(,* /-4; 8-42,* +-0* U(/72767*

M3=2*(30 ,* R-864* R*=230' (3 K*4.3 ,3 0-2 - /-4; =*(/7276H,* ,-V

I-(/ .W1-2/ - 2.W1-2/' 130*4-/ - 4-(,3/ ,* U(/72767* M3=2*(30 ,* R-864*

R*=230 ()* 67202@3,*/ (3 *+-43=2*(302@3B)* ,-/7-X

I-(/ - ,24-27*/ 56-' 3 563056-4 7H760*' 0>- /-:3. 3,:6,2=3,*/ *6 56- 0>-

12-4-. 3 /-4 12(=603,*/ +*4 K*4B3 ,- 0-2X

4-=-273 ,3/ =*(742I62BY-/ /*=232/ +343 3 /-8642,3,- /*=230' +4-12/73/ (3

30H(-3 ,* 2(=2/* U - (* 2(=2/* UU ,* 347! 9ZN ,3 O*(/72762B)*X

+4*,67* ,3 02562,3B)* ,- I-(/ - 3721*/ ,- +-//*3 KH/2=3 *6 :64H,2=3 -.

,PI27* =*. 3 G4-12,<(=23 R*=230X

4-/6073,* ,3 3+02=3B)* K2(3(=-243 ,- /-6/ 3721*/X

4-=64/*/ +4*1-(2-(7-/ ,* *4B3.-(7* ,3 [(2)*!

T -(7- ,3 E-,-43B)*' 56- .3(721-4 *6 12-4 3 2(/727624 4-82.- +4W+42* ,-

+4-12,<(=23 /*=230 +343 /-6/ /-412,*4-/' =*(K-424; 3* .-/.* =34;7-4 =*(742A

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 78: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$% & % %'()*#+)', -%. )/& &. *%'.)/ 0& -%*") #1#0)0& & )"!,'#) 2!&

3'&/&'$&. /&! &2!#14 '#% 5#*)*-&#'% & )"!)'#)16

78% 3%0&'#) /&' %!"') ) 0&"&'.#*)98%: 3%' /&' 0) 1;(#-) #*/"#"!-#%*)1 &

%3&')-#%*)1 0& 2!)12!&' '&(#.& 0& 3'&$#0<*-#) 2!& /& 3'&%-!3& -%. %

5!"!'% 0& /&!/ 5#1#)0%/6 =& 2!)12!&' 5%'.): % 0&/-!.3'#.&*"% #.31#-) )

#.3!")98% 0)/ 3&*)1#0)0&/ -%''&/3%*0&*"&/: /&. -%*")' 2!& #'#) 0& &*-%*>

"'% ? @&# A&0&')1 *º B6CDC: 0& EC 0& *%$&. '% 0& DBBF: 2!& 0#/3G& /% '&

'&(')/ (&')#/ 3)') ) %'()*#+)98% & % 5!*-#%*).&*"% 0%/ '&(#.&/ 3';3'#%/

0& 3'&$#0<*-#) /%-#)1 0%/ /&'$#0%'&/ 3H 1#-%/ 0) I*#8%: 0%/ J/")0%/: 0%

=#/"'#"% A&0&')1 & 0%/ K!*#-43#%/: 0%/ .#1#")'&/ 0%/ J/")0%/ & 0% =#/"'#"%

A&0&')1 & 0, %!"')/ 3'%$#0<*-#)/6

'(63(6$�727$/�&20�3(662$/�12�(;(5&Ì&,2�'(�����

=& )-%'0% -%. % )'"6 CL: % M%0&' %! ;'(8% -!N) 0&/3&/) "%")1 -%. 3&//%)1

!1"')3)//)$): &. DBBB: %/ 1#.#"&/ &/") &1&-#0%/ *%/ )'"/6 DB & EL 0) @OA:

"&. 2!& /& &*2!)0')' ) &1&/ &. )"P 0%#/ &Q&'-4-#%/: &1#.#*)*0% % &Q-&//%:

(')0!)1.&*"&: ? ')+8% 0& 3&1% .&*%/ RLS )6)6 M)') #//% 3%0& '&-%''&' ?

)0%98%: &*"'& %!"')/: 0)/ .&0#0)/ 3'&$#/")/ *%/ )'"/6 EE & ET 0) @U *º

DLDVELLL6 I.) 1&#"!') .)#/ )3'&//)0) 3%0& 1&$)' ? #.3'&//8% 2!& ) @OA

&/") &1&-&! &Q#(<*-#) -%. &5&#"% '&"'%)"#$%6 W)1 *8% %-%''&! 3%'2!&: *)

0)") 0& /!) 3! 1#-)98% & &*"')0) &. $#(%': ) @&# U%.31&.&*")' *º BX: 0&

TDVLRVBB: .)#/ -%*Y&-#0) -%.% @&# O#") U).)"): N, 5#Q)$) 1#.#"&/ 0& ()/"%/

-%. 3&//%)1: 0#/3%*0%Z

!"# $º# %&!"'! (& )*"!&(& )+ ,'-.! ()/"& 0)' 1.+%2)+)*"&!3 ./ )*")/

)/"&"&'/ 456&/ ()/%)/&/ 4.+%)//.&2 )/"',)!)+&4'+& (./ 2'+'")/ 7'8&(./

*. &!"# 9º (),)!:. &(&%"&!;/) & )/")/ 2'+'")/3 < !&=:. ()3 *. +>*'+.3

(.'/ ")!?./ (. )84)//. *./ %!'+)'!./ (.=) +)/)/ ) . !)/"&*") *./ (.=)

+)/)/ /5@/)AB)*")/#

[1#,/: ) '&$%()98% 0) 1&# )-#.) -#")0) 5%# '&)1#+)0) *% )'"6 CR 0) @OA6 [

#*% /&'$\*-#) 0% 0#/3%/"% )-#.): *% 3')+% 5#Q)0%: /!N&#") % &*"& ?/ /)*9G&/

3'&$#/")/ *% ] Tº 0% )'"6 ET: %! /&N): &1& *8% 3%0&',Z

!"!#! "')*/5&'<*-#)/ $%1!*",'#)/^

$#%! ()')*"#): 0#'&") %! #*0#'&"): 0& %!"'% &*"&^

!"#$%& '(

Page 79: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%#%$ !"#$%&"' (" )#*(+, - #"''$./$($' $' ("',+0$($' $ #"1+0$0)+$2

3"0, ($ (4/+($ 3 5+.+6#+$ " $' 78" /+'"3 9 #"(8%: ($' ("'!"'$' ) 3

!"'' $.;

<"''$./$($ $ =+!>,"'" ( +0)+' ? ( $#,; @A ($ BC D#"/+': E"#$. $08$.-

'"3!#" 0$3"'3$ ($,$ " '"3(+',+0%: (" 40(+)"'F- $,* ,*#3+0 ( ,"#)"+#

"G"#)4)+ 1+0$0)"+# - '"E8+0," 9 "0,#$($ "3 /+E # ($ H<C DIJJ@F- $ ("'!"'$

, ,$. ) 3 !"'' $. ( ' K ("#"' " >#E: ' #"1"#+( ' 0 $#,; IJ 0: 8.,#$!$''$#6-

"3 !"#)"0,8$. ($ #")"+,$ ) ##"0," .478+($- $ ("'!"'$ /"#+1+)$($ 0 "G"#)4)+

+3"(+$,$3"0," $0,"#+ #- $)#"')+($ (" $,* LJM D("N ! # )"0, F- '" "',$ 1 #

+01"#+ # $ .+3+," ("1+0+( 0$ 1 #3$ ( $#,; IJ DOM " PQM- 0 )$' ( '

R80+)4!+ 'F;

S H<C- 0 78" #"'!"+,$ 9 ("'!"'$ ) 3 !"'' $.- ) 01 #3" "G! ', - $( , 8

( +' !# )"(+3"0, 'T 83- #$%"&'#($'!- /+'$0( ".+3+0$# ' "G)"'' ' $!8#$2

( ' 0 $0 (" LUUUV " 8,# - )*+'"'#',!- $ /+E #$# $ !$#,+# (" JPWJPWIJJJ-

78$. ("/" '"# 5X", (" !"#3$0"0," $) 3!$0=$3"0, ! # !$#," ( '

>#E: ' " ($' "0,+($("' '8X"+,$' $ '"8 #("0$3"0, ;

S ("'!"'$ ) 3 '"#/+% ' (" ,"#)"+# ' ( ' K ("#"' " ( ' >#E: '- #"1"#+( ' 0

$#,; IJ- 0: ! ("#6 "G)"("#- "3 !"#)"0,8$. ($ <BH- 9 ( "G"#)4)+ $0,"#+ #

9 "0,#$($ "3 /+E # ($ H<C- $,* ,*#3+0 ( ,"#)"+# "G"#)4)+ '"E8+0,";

Y''$ (","#3+0$%: - $ "G"3!. (" 8,#$' X6 ) 3"0,$($'- ,$35*3 ,"3 '+(

5X", (" )#4,+)$' (+/"#'$'; Z$ !#6,+)$- '" $!#"'"0,$ ) 3 83$ 0"E$%: ("

/6#+ ' ( ' '"8' (+'! '+,+/ '- 78" +3!&"3 #+E+("N " #"',#+%: 9 1+G$%: ( '

)#*(+, ' #%$3"0,6#+ ' "- !#+0)+!$.3"0,"- 9 #"$.+N$%: (" E$', ' ("'!# 2

/+( ' (" '8! #," 1+0$0)"+# ;

3HQDOLGDGHV��DUW�����

S' +01#$%&"' ( ' (+'! '+,+/ ' ("',$ H"+ B 3!."3"0,$# '"#: !80+($' '"E802

( [")#", 2H"+ 0º I;\Q\- (" A (" ("N"35# (" LUQJ DB>(+E K"0$.FV $

H"+ 0º L;JAU- (" LJ (" $5#+. (" LUPJV [")#", 2H"+ 0º IJL- (" IA ("

1"/"#"+# (" LUOAV $V " ("3$+' 0 #3$' ($ ."E+'.$%: !"#,+0"0,";

B 01 #3" X6 "G!.+)+,$( - ) 3 $ !# 38.E$%: ($ H"+ 0º LJ;JI\WIJJJ- $'

0 /$' !"0$.+($("' X6 "',: "3 /+E #- "- ) 0'"7]"0,"3"0,"- ,+!+1+)$( ' '

)#+3"' " $' #"'!"),+/$' !"0$'- )+#)80',^0)+$ ) 0'+("#$($ ! # 38+, ' ) 3

+0',#83"0, (" E#$0(" /$.+$ !$#$ $ !."0+,8(" " "1+)6)+$ ($ H<C;

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 80: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

&DOHQGiULR�GDV�3URYLGrQFLDV�3UHYLVWDVQD�/5)�SDUD�RV�0XQLFtSLRV

$QH[R��

!"#$%& '(

Page 81: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%& '(

Page 82: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$% &º% !"#$

'($)*+,+-./+0$1% 2+,1 314+# '5+-6$.71% )$8 ! "#$% )29( ) 26*,.-):;1

41 1#:)/+0$1% 4) 2#1<#)/):;1 =.0)0-+.#) + 41 -#101<#)/) 4+ +5+-6>

:;1 /+0(), 4+ 4+(+/*1,(1!

?! "#$! @º% !"#$ + A BºC

D+#.=.-):;1% )1 &#'$( ") *$"$ +#,)%-.)/ 01 %)2$/ '0 &#, "0% ,)%)% ")

&)3).)#.0/ $+.#(/ 21'40/ $50%-0/ 01-1+.0 ) ")6),+.0% (+ ) #+),.E):;1

4) #+-+.$)% 4) 4+(2+() + 41 +04.7.4)/+0$1 2F*,.-1 214+#G 16 0;1

-1/21#$)# 1 -6/2#./+0$1 4)(/+$)( 4+ #+(6,$)41 2#./G#.1 16 01/.0),

+($)*+,+-.4)( 01 "0+51 4)( H+$)( I.(-).(C

3#1/1:;1 01 =./ 41( ,)%)% ") ,$.70/ ,$#0/ 21(40/ %)-),+.0/

'03),+.0 "0 )8).*9*#0 ), *1.%0 ) 2$')#.0 "0 %)51#'-)% 2+,1( 314+#+(

J+<.(,)$.71 + '5+-6$.71% 16 (+K)% 01( ! "#$% %1+%):;)'-)% $0 &#'$( ")

*$"$ +#,)%-.)% )$#)78( 4+ )$1 2#92#.1% 41 )K6($+ 4) (.$6):;1% 01 -)(1

4+ ) 7+#.=.-):;1 )-./) /+0-.10)4) /1($#)# ) ./21((.*.,.4)4+ 4+

),-)0-+ 4+(()( /+$)(C

L+/10($#):;1 + )7),.):;1 )$8 1 =./ 41( /+(+( 4+,$#0/ %)-),+.0 "0

)8).*9*#0+/-6#(1 + &)3).)#.0 "0 %)51#'-)% 41 -6/2#./+0$1 4)(/+$)(

=.(-).( +/ -)4) M6)4#./+($#+% +/ $1"#<'*#$ =>+(#*$ 0) -1/.((;1 /.($)

2+#/)0+0$+ 41 314+# J+<.(,)$.71 N<+#),/+0$+ O1/.((;1 4+P#:)/+0$1

+ I.0)0:)( 16 +M6.7),+0$+Q!

R! "#$! ?% A Rº

O1,1-):;1% 2+,1 314+# '5+-6$.71% '0 ,9'#,0/ ! "#$% $'-)% "0 =.$60

&#'$( ") )'*$,#'4$,)'-0 ") %1$ =.0=0%-$ 0.7$,)'-?.#$% S 4.(>

21(.:;1 41 314+# J+<.(,)$.71% 41( +($641( + +($./)$.7)( 4)( #+-+.$)(2)#)

1 +5+#-T-.1 (+<6.0$+% .0-,6(.7+ 4) #+-+.$) -1##+0$+ ,TM6.4) + 4)( #+(>

2+-$.7)( /+/9#.)( 4+ -G,-6,1!

&DOHQGiULR�GDV�3URYLGrQFLDV�3UHYLVWDV�QD�/5)SDUD�RV�0XQLFtSLRV

!"#$% % &'( $% ()* +"', -( &-,'"$% %! *./"$% %! $%('#0%1 +%#*'$-,"2*- 3!- % 4,"5%

6-#+- #% $'" 78'9 '(-$'"8"(-#8- 4%*8-,'%,:

!"#$%&' ()

!

Page 83: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$! %&' !"#$

()*+,-#./)0$,' !" #$ %& ' ()' (*+,&- ./0 %0 01. 234!0' 1)2,

3,+)# 45)67$89,' +.* #)6)8$.* 1#)98*$.* )/ /)$.* -8/)*$#.8* +) .#:

#)6.+.;<,' 6,/ . )*1)68=86.;<, )/ *)1.#.+,' >7.0+, 6.-?9)2@ 5 +.*

/)+8+.* +) 6,/-.$) A )9.*<, ) A *,0)B.;<,C +5 +. >7.0$8+.+) )

9.2,#)* +) .;D)* .E78F.+.* 1.#. 6,-#.0;. +. +?98+. .$89.' ) -5 +.

)9,27;<, +, /,0$.0$) +,* 6#G+8$,* $#8-7$H#8,* 1.**?9)8* +) 6,-#.0;.

.+/808*$#.$89.!

I! "#$! JJ' !"#$

K)#8=86.;<,' ! "#$ %!& $'&'& %' +1&,6 70'!0 3 %3832+10' +,

67/1#8/)0$, +,* 28/8$)* +. +)*1)*. $,$.2 6,/ 1)**,.2' ,7 *)E.' ., 9&4 ,

%3 - % :* %1&23'!13' 1.#.' *) )56)+8+,* ,* LIM+, 28/8$)1#7+)068.2'

*) =.;. . 8/12)/)0$.;<, +.* 1#,98+N068.* )07/)#.+.* 0,* 8068*,* +,

1.#HB#.=, O086, +)*$) .#$8B,!

P! "#$! J&' !"#$ ) QQ &º ) º

428/80.;<,' 40' %0&' :* %1&23'!13' *)B780$)*' 0.* 1#,1,#;D)* +) %R&

0, 1#8/)8#, ) JR& 0, *)B70+,' ,7 *)E.' ;<# !" 9&2 %3 70'!0 3 =<# !"

9&2 %3 %3832+10' +, 1)#6)0$7.2 )56)+)0$) +, 28/8$) +. +)*1)*. $,$.2

6,/ 1)**,.2' 1#)98*$, 0, .#$!JSC

"1286.;<, &23%& ! +.* *)B780$)* #)*$#8;D)* 1#)98*$.* 0, Q &º +, .#$! J&'

+)*+) >7) 0<, .26.0;.+. . #)+7;<, 0, 1#.F, )*$.-)2)68+,! 40>7.0$,

1)#+7#.# , )56)**,' . )0$8+.+) 0<, 1,+)#H@ 5 #)6)-)# $#.0*=)#N068.*

9,270$H#8.*C +5 ,-$)# B.#.0$8.' +8#)$. ,7 80+8#)$.' +) ,7$#, )0$) 1.#.

,1)#.;D)* +) 6#G+8$,C ) -5 6,0$#.$.# ,1)#.;D)* +) 6#G+8$,' #)**.29.+.*

.* +)*$80.+.* ., #)=80.068./)0$, +. +?98+. /,-828H#8. ) .* >7) 98*)/

A #)+7;<, +.* +)*1)*.* 6,/ 1)**,.2!

"1286.;<, &23%& ! +.* #)*$#8;D)* 1#)98*$.* 0, Q &º *) . +)*1)*. $,$.2

6,/ 1)**,.2 )56)+)# , 28/8$) 0, 1#8/)8#, >7.+#8/)*$#) +, O2$8/, .0,

+, /.0+.$, +,* $8$72.#)* +) 3,+)# ,7 T#B<,!

U! "#$! &S' Q º

"17#.;<, +, /,0$.0$) +. +?98+. 6,0*,28+.+.' 0 9&4 , %3 - % :* >

%1&23'!13' ,7 *)E.' 40 9&2 %0' 23'3' %3 +1&,6 70'!0 3 %3832+10

1.#. =80* +) 9)#8=86.;<, +, .$)0+8/)0$, +, 28/8$) B2,-.2' 1#)98*$, 0.

=,#/. )*$.-)2)68+. 0, !"#$ +)*$) .#$8B, ) )/ *)7 8068*, V %& '()($* + &

,#* *-$. *-$!/*'* (0& 1! 2*-3 45677 0& 8*1!0& 9*0*:!';3

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 84: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$! %&' !"#$' (( &º' %º ) *º

+),-./012- /3 /456/3 ,-.7-86/3/3 3- 7)0 8696$)' 7) - 9)79- $65)# 76/-

08$#3:3773/- 3- ;6.38 /) 09 !"#$%&'()$'' /)5)./- 7)# 3 9)/6/3

69:8)9).$3/3 .-7 )$*( !"#$%&'()$'( 7)<06.$)7' )7$3=)8),6/3 3 #)/0>

12- 94.693 /) ?*@ .- :#69)6#-A

":86,312- !"# $%$/37 7)<06.$)7 #)7$#61B)7 :#)567$37 .- ( &º' ).C03.$-

:)#/0#3# - )D,)77-E "+ :#-6=612- /) #)386F3# -:)#312- /) ,#G/6$- 6.$)#.3

-0 )D$)#.3' 6.,80765) :-# 3.$),6:312- /3 #),)6$3' #)773853/- - #);6.3.>

,639).$- /- :#6.,6:38 3$0386F3/- /3 /456/3 9-=686H#63A ,+ -=$).12- /)

%&'#($!)*"%+,-%+*.),)77H#6- :3#3 3 #),-./012- /3 /456/3 3- 7)0 8696$)'

:#-9-5)./-' ).$#) -0$#37 9)/6/37' (+,+$!./* )& &,"&01*' .3 ;-#93

/- 3#$! IºA

":86,312-' 3:J7 - 5).,69).$- /- :#3F- :3#3 3 #),-./012- /3 /456/3

3- 7)0 8696$)' /- 69:)/69).$- /) #),)=)# $#3.7;)#K.,637 5-80.$H#637 /3

L.62- -0 /- M7$3/-' ).C03.$- :)#/0#3# - )D,)77-!

I! "#$! % ' 6.,67-7 N ) NN

+)386F312- /37 -:)#31B)7 /) ,#G/6$- :-# 3.$),6:312- /3 #),)6$3 O"+PQ

7-9).$) 3 :3#$6# /- -.º #%" #/ %012%/ /- )D)#,4,6- -0 #%" 3)%4 %&'#%"5

)"&'0)' ('6!%0)'A

R3<39).$-' ")7 / #%" -. 8#'9+ #' #'9'&,$/ #/ ':'$212%/ #' /$%6'&

#" ;<=' ,-9 S0#-7 ) -0$#-7 ).,3#<-7 6.,6/).$)7!

&T! "#$ U?' !"#$ ) :3#H<#3;- V.6,-

R#-6=612-' 3- $6$083# /) R-/)# -0 /) J#<2-' /) ,-.$#36# -=#6<312- /)

/)7:)73 .-7 #/%( 34)%&/( !"#$%&'()$'( #& '"( !$)#$%&' -0 7)S3'

/)7/) C03./- )773 -=#6<312- .2- :-773 7)# ,09:#6/3 6.$)<#389).$)

/).$#- /- :)#4-/- /)77) 93./3$-' -0 C03./- $).W3 :3#,)837 3 7)#)9

:3<37 .- )D)#,4,6- :-7$)#6-# 7)9 C0) W3S3 70;6,6).$) /67:-.6=686/3/) /)

,36D3' )*+ & #" !$ & #& ,-% !& $)& #" !$)#$%&!

N.,8072-' $%. & / )$- #& "0"1+*+ &2 .3 /)$)#96.312- /37 /67:-.6=686>

/3/)7 /) ,36D3' /-7 ).,3#<-7 ) /)7:)737 SH ,-9:#-96773/-7 3 :3<3#!

&&! "#$! U*' !"#$ ) :3#H<#3;- V.6,-

M.,396.W39).$-' ")7 #")" #' '0>%/ #/ ?$/@')/ #' A'% #' B%$')$%9'(

=$C"&'0)D$%"(' :)8- R-/)# MD),0$65- 3- R-/)# X)<6783$65-' /) #)83$J#6-

,-9 37 6.;-#931B)7 7-=#) -7 :#-S)$-7 )9 3./39).$- ) 7)0 3$).>

/69).$- 3/)C03/- ) 7-=#) 37 /)7:)737 /) ,-.7)#5312- ,-9 - :3$#6>

9Y.6- :V=86,-' ,-.;-#9) :#)567$- .- !"#$/)7$) 3#$6<-' :3#3 3 6.,8072-

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 85: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$#% &'#(!)#% "* +!, #'-*.!")/',* ! "*% '!0!'!")!% *#% 1'2 ,)#%

* ,1,#"*,%3

453 6')3 789 &*'/:'*0# ;",1#

<"1+=%># ! "#)* !?&+,1*),$*9 &!+* !.&'!%* 1#")'#+* * &!+# @=",1A&,#9

! " #" $%&%'()" !"#$% !&"%9 ,"1+=," # *% ,"0#'.*-B!% !+!"1* *% "#%

,"1,%#% <9 << ! <<< # &*'/:'*0# ;",1#3

4C3 6')3 7D9 !"#$

E#+#1*->#9 '(!&) $ *'* * $+$!,-,"*9 *% 1#")*% *&'!%!")* *% &!+#

F'!0!,)# @=",1,&*+9 G ,%&#%,-># #% 1, * >#% ! *% ,"%),)=,-B!% *

%#1,! * ! &*'* 1#"%=+)* ! *&'!1,*->#9 "# F# !' H!:,%+*),$# @=",1,&*+

! "# I':># )21",1# '!%&#"%/$!+ &#' %=* !+*J#'*->#3

473 6')3 K49 !"#$9 ,"1,%# < # L 4º ! L 5º

M"1*.,"N*.!")# &!+#@=",1A&,#9& . /0 '$ &1!"29 ! 1I&,* # J*+*"-#

# !?!'1A1,# *")!',#' *# F# !' M?!1=),$# # '!%&!1),$# M%)* # &*'* O=!

!%)! &#%%* &'#1! !' G 1#"%#+, *-># *% 1#")*% !. %=* !%0!'* !

:#$!'"#9 ! 0#'.* * $,*J,+,P*' * &#%)!',#' 1#"%#+, *-># *% 1#")*%

&;J+,1*% ! Q.J,)# "*1,#"*+3 R !%1=.&',.!")# # &'*P#9 *)2 O=! *

%,)=*-># %!(* '!:=+*',P* *9 ,.&+,1*'/ &'#,J,-># *#@=",1A&,# ! '!1!J!'

)'*"%0!'S"1,*% $#+=")/',*% ! '!*+,P*' #&!'*-B!% ! 1'2 ,)#9 !?1!)# *%

!%),"* *% *# '!0,"*"1,*.!")# # &',"1,&*+ *)=*+,P* # * A$, * .#J,T

+,/',*3

4K3 6')3 K59 !"#$9 %!=% ,"1,%#% ! *+A"!*%

F=J+,1*-># # '!+*)I',# '!%=., # * !?!1=-># #'-*.!")/',* & . /0

'"&% &34% * $),$!!&#$) * '$ ,&'& 1"#$% !$9 #= %!(*9 & . * 5"# '*%

#$%$% '$ #&!6*7 #&"*7 &8*% *7 )*9$#1!* '* $+$!,-,"* $# ,(!%* $

:&)$"!* '* 3*% $!"*!9 1#. * 1#.&#%,-># &'!$,%)* "#% ,"1,%#% !%)!

*'),:#3 6"!?*-># *# '!+*)I',# '!%=., # * !?!1=-># #'-*.!")/',* *%

!.#"%)'*-B!% !"=.!'* *% "#% ,"1,%#% # *')3 KC ! # %!= L 4º3 !9

O=*" # 0#' # 1*%#9 * *&'!%!")*-># *% (=%),0,1*),$*% &'!$,%)*% "# L 5º3

!%)! *'),:#3

4U3 6')3 KC

61#.&*"N*.!")# # '!+*)I',# '!%=., # * !?!1=-># #'-*.!")/',*9

& . /0 '"&% &34% * $),$!!&#$) * '$ ,&'& 1"#$% !$9 #= %!(*9 *)2 #

5")&2 '*% #$%$% '$ #&!6*7 #&"*7 &8*% *7 )*9$#1!* '* $+$!,-,"* $#

,(!%* $ :&)$"!* '* %$8(") $9 &#' !.#"%)'*),$#% '!+*),$#% *V

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 86: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$!%&' (! $)*)+,! *'$$)-,) ./0#+(! -! 1'$2! ()1+-+(! -' +-*+3' 45

(' !$,6 7º !"# $%&'"()& #!!*+ ,&+& # -.$%*!)& /$ !$" /$!$+-$01&

!" # $%& ' (# )*)+,-,%#2

3 .$,$*4#! $ /$!-$!#! -.$%*/$0,*5.*#! # 6"$ !$ .$7$.$ & *0,*!& 89 /& #.4:

;<2

3 .$!"'4#/&! 0&+*0#' $ -.*+5.*&2

3 /$!-$!#! ,&+ =".&! 0# 7&.+# /& *0,*!& 88 /& #.4: >º2

3 ?$!4&! # @#A#. /$4#'1#0/& -&. @&/$. $ B.A)& .$7$.*/& 0& #.4: C<

&! %#'&.$! *0!,.*4&! &! -#A#+$04&! .$#'*D#/&! $ & +&04#04$ # -#A#.:

E,&+-#01#+$04& /& .$'#4B.*& .$!"+*/& /# $F$,"()& &.(#+$045.*#

!" ./ (% 0 120 # )&,)++ 3)&!# (# 4'!%3# 5%3)0!+) (# )*)+,-,%#

4#+GH+ -&. /$+&0!4.#4*%&!I

3 /& #4$0/*+$04& /& /*!-&!4& 0& *0,*!& 888 /& #.4: JKL /# M&0!4*4"*()&

/# .$-NG'*,# ,&07&.+$ & O Pº /& #.4: PC /# Q?R2

3 /#! -.&=$(S$! #4"#.*#*! /&! .$A*+$! /$ -.$%*/T0,*# !&,*#' A$.#' $

-.B-.*# /&! !$.%*/&.$! -NG'*,&!2

3 /# %#.*#()& -#4.*+&0*#' $%*/$0,*#0/& # #'*$0#()& /$ #4*%&! $ #

#-'*,#()& /&! .$,".!&! /$'# /$,&..$04$!:

E,&+-#01#+$04& /& .$'#4B.*& .$!"+*/& /# $F$,"()& &.(#+$045.*#

!" ./ (% 0 120 # )&,)++ 3)&!# () , ( 5%3)0!+)6 78 &(# $#+ #

, 0# -&. ="!4*7*,#4*%#!I

3 /# '*+*4#()& /& $+-$01&2

3 /# 7."!4.#()& /$ .$,$*4#! $!-$,*7*,#0/& #! +$/*/#! /$ ,&+G#4$ U

!&0$A#()& $ U $%#!)& 7*!,#' #/&4#/#! $ # #/&4#. $ #! #(S$! /$

7*!,#'*D#()& $ ,&G.#0(#:

JL: E.4: ;>

V0,#+*01#+$04& #& $%& ' () , ( 78 (+%3)0!+) &" !$=# &# $%3 (#0

3)0)0 () 5+%'6 9#0!# ) ():)35+# #& @.$7$*4& W"0*,*-#' -$'&!

4*4"'#.$! /# MX+#.# W"0*,*-#' $ /& Y.*G"0#' &" M&0!$'1& /$ M&04#! /&

W"0*,Z-*& &0/$ 1&"%$. /& ?$'#4B.*& /# [$!4)& R*!,#' -#.# 7*0! /$

*04$A.#()& /#! ,&04#! +"0*,*-#*!:

J\: E.4:;; OO Cº $ Pº

@"G'*,#()& !" ./ (% 0 120 # )&,)++ 3)&!# (# 1)+-#(# 78)

,#++)01#&()+ &" !$=# #4H & 7*+ /&! +$!$! /$ 3 %#6 0)!)35+# (#

)*)+,-,%# )3,8+0# ) ; &)%+#/& !$A"*04$: /& ?$'#4B.*& /$ [$!4)& R*!,#'

,&+ #+-'& #,$!!& #& -NG'*,& *0,'"!*%$ -&. +$*& $'$4.]0*,&! ^ W"0*_

,Z-*& 6"$ /$!,"+-.*. & -.#D& -.$%*!4& $!45 -.&*G*/& /$ .$,$G$. 4.#0!_

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 87: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&'( )*+,$-."&'( ! /! %*$-"'-'" *0!"'12!( /! %"3/&-*4 !5%!-* '(

/!(-&$'/'( '* "! &$'$%&'6!$-* /* 0"&$%&0'+ '-,'+&7'/* /' /8)&/' 6*9&:

+&."&';

<=; >"-; ?@4 A Bº

C"* !"&6!$-* !" #$ %& ' %( )*+*,&-*.!( %*'! '4 0!+' D*6&((E* /!

F"1'6!$-* ! G&$'$1'( /' DH6'"' I,$&%&0'+ /! 0'"!%!" (*9"! '( %*$-'(

/*( -"&9,$'&( *, %*$(!+J*( /! %*$-'( /* I,$&%80&*4 *$/! J*,)!";

BK; >"-; ?L4 !"#$ ! A <º

M6&((E* /! 0'"!%!" 0"3)&* %*$%+,(&)* (*9"! '( %*$-'( 6,$&%&0'&( 0!+*(

-"&9,$'&( /! %*$-'( /* M(-'/* *, /* 0"N0"&* I,$&%80&*4 *$/! J*,)!"4

.( /) 0( %* #$ %& '4 (! *,-"* $E* -&)!" (&/* /!-!"6&$'/* 0!+' +!&

*"OH$&%' 6,$&%&0'+ *, 0!+' D*$(-&-,&1E* M(-'/,'+; F 0'"!%!" 0"3)&*

(!". 0"* !"&/* $* 0"'7* /! <PK /&'( 0'"' *( I,$&%80&*( Q,! $E* (!R'6

%'0&-'+ ! Q,! -!$J'6 6!$*( /! /,7!$-*( 6&+ J'9&-'$-!(;

B<; >"-; @S4 (!,( &$%&(*(4 '+8$!'( ! AA

>,-*"&7'1E* 0'"' Q,! *( I,$&%80&*( %*6 0*0,+'1E* &$ !"&*" ' ?K 6&+

J'9&-'$-!( *0-!6 0*"T

U "!'+&7'" '* 1&. 2 %* + % '*-*'!)*4 *, (!R'4 .( 1&- %(' -*'*' %*

34.5( * %* %*0*-,)(4 ' )!"& &%'1E* /* %,60"&6!$-* V0"!)&(-' $*

'"-;BBW /*( +&6&-!( /' /!(0!(' -*-'+ %*6 0!((*'+ V)&/! '"-; <=W ! /'

"!0'"-&1E* /!((!( +&6&-!( O+*9'&( V/&(0*(-* $* '"-; BKWX

U "!'+&7'" '* 1&. 2 %* + % '*-*'!)*4 *, (!R'4 .( 1&- %(' -*'*' %*

34.5( * %* %*0*-,)(4 ' )!"& &%'1E* /* %,60"&6!$-* /* +&6&-! /'

/8)&/' %*$(*+&/'/'X

U /&),+O'" !" 6$ %& ' %( *.+*)) -*.!( %( '*-*'!)*4 *, (!R'4 !" (

1&- %(' -*'*' %* 3425( %( *7*)+8+&( *- +4)'( * %* 3 .*&)( %(

'*94&.!* * Y!+'-N"&* /' Z!(-E* G&(%'+X

U /&),+O'"4 !" 6$ %& ' %( *.+*)) -*.!( %( '*-*'!)*4 *, (!R'4 !" (

1&-%('-*'*' %* 3425(%( *7*)+8+&( *-+4)'( * 3 .*&)(%( '*94&.!*

'( /!6*$(-"'12!( Q,! '%*60'$J'6 * Y!+'-N"&* Y!(,6&/* /' M5!:

%,1E* F"1'6!$-."&' V)&/! '"-; ?SWX

U !+'9*"'" ' 0'"-&" /* :4&.!( *7*)+8+&( '*94&.!* ( % /4,2&+ ;<( %

=>?4 *, (!R'4 / )!&) %( .(@A$$B*( >$!5*( U I!-'( G&(%'&( ! Y&(%*(

G&(%'&( U /' [!& /! \&"!-"&7!( F"1'6!$-."&'( ! * >$!5* /' [!&

F"1'6!$-."&' >$,'+ %*$-!$/* ' /!6*$(-"'1E* /' %*60'-&9&+&/'/!

/' 0"*O"'6'1E* /* *"1'6!$-* %*6 *( *9R!-&)*( /* >$!5* /'( I!-'(

G&(%'&( V)&/! &$%&(* ] /* '"-; ?º ! A <º /* '"-; ^ºWX

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 88: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%%&' (' )!*$+,-$'. +'# -'-!/01&' $*234$'4 0 56 #$/ 70"$80*83%. %3

!/840-0%%04 '% /$#$83% 43/08$9'% : (3%-3%0 8'80/ +'# -3%%'0/ '! : (,9$(0

+'*%'/$(0(0. !"#$!%& ' ()#($( *%$ *+%#$,-&. $&* / */&* '($0&* )

1 (+2+3$,-& ) ( %&(!& $&* 4+/+% * ) 2+!+)&* '$($ &* ) /$+* !% *;

<<; =48; >5. $*+$%'% ? 3 ?? 3 -04@A402' B*$+'

!%-3*%&' -040 ' )!*$+,-$'. *'% +0%'% (3 +0/0#$(0(3 -B"/$+0 43+'C

*73+$(0 -3/0% =%%3#"/D$0% E3A$%/08$90%. "3# +'#' *'% (3 3%80(' (3

(323%0 '! (3 %,8$'. (3+4380(' *0 2'4#0 -439$%80 *0 F'*%8$8!$1&' G3(340/.

!"#$!%& $ *+%#$,-& ' ()#($(. (0 +'*80A3# ('% -40H'% 3 (0% ($%C

-'%$1I3% 3%80"3/3+$(0% *'% 048%; <J K84080 (0 43+'*(!1&' 0'% /$#$83% (0

(3%-3%0 8'80/ (3 -3%%'0/L. JM K($%-I3 %'"43 0 43+'*(!1&' 0'% /$#$83% (0

(,9$(0 +'*%'/$(0(0L 3 N6 K($%-I3 %'"43 ' 3*O!0(40#3*8' 0' /$#$83 *'%

+0%'% 3# O!3 0 (3%-3%0 8'80/ (3 -3%%'0/ -439$%80 P@ 8$934 %$(' !/840-0%C

%0(0 *' 3Q34+,+$' 0*834$'4 0' (3 -!"/$+01&' (0 ERGLS

T$%-3*%0 -040 '% )!*$+,-$'%. *'% +0%'% (3 +0/0#$(0(3 -B"/$+0 43+'C

*73+$(0 -3/0% =%%3#"/D$0% E3A$%/08$90%. "3# +'#' *'% (3 3%80(' (3

(323%0 '! (3 %,8$'. (3+4380(' *0 2'4#0 -439$%80 *0 F'*%8$8!$1&' G3(340/.

!"#$!%& ' ()#($( $ *+%#$,-&. (' 08$*A$#3*8' ('% 43%!/80('% 2$%+0$% 3

(0 /$#$801&' (3 3#-3*7' K-439$%80 *' 048; UºCL;

<J; =48; >>. !"#$ 3 V V Jº 3 Wº

T!-/$+01&' ('% -40H'% 3%80"3/3+$('% *'% 048%; <J. JM 3 N6. *' +0%' (3

+43%+$#3*8' 430/ "0$Q' '! *3A08$9' (' X4'(!8' ?*834*' Y4!8' KX?YL

*0+$'*0/. 43A$'*0/ '! 3%80(!0/.'&( ' (5&)& +6#$4 &# *#' (+&( $ "#$%(&

%(+/ *%( *. 0%%$# 3*83*($(0Z $7 K048; <JL ' 3Q+3(3*83 (0 (3%-3%0 (3

-3%%'0/ 834@ (3 %34 3/$#$*0(' !&* "#$%(& "#$)(+/ *%( * * 6#+!% *.

* !)& 89: !&* )&+* '(+/ +(&* &* ( *%$!% * ;9: !&* * 6#+!% *< =7

K048;JML ( 3&!)#,-&$%> & %>(/+!&)&* * +* "#$)(+/ *%( * *#=* "? !@

% *. 3&/ ( )#,-& ) ;AB !&* )&+* '(+/ +(&* &* ( *%$!% * CAB !&*

"#$)(+/ *%( * * 6#+!% *< 3 37 K048;N6L !"#$)($/ !%& $%> "#$%(&

D (353+&*. 3&/ 4+/+!$,-& )&* D3 **&* ) AEB ) )&+* / )&+*

$!&*S

=#-/$01&'. / $%> "#$%(& "#$)(+/ *%( *. (' -40H' -439$%8' *' 048;JM.

*0 7$-[83%3 (3 %3 934$2$+043# #!(0*10% (4@%8$+0% *0 +'*(!1&' (0%

-'/,8$+0% #'*38@4$0 3 +0#"$0/. 43+'*73+$(0% -3/' 3*0(' G3(340/;

<W; =48; >N. !"#$ 3 V <º

F% !,-& '$($ 1 !%#$+* '($0&* O!3 93*70# 0 %34 +4$0('% 3# 2!*1&'

(0% !"!#$% 0-4'901&' 3 3*840(0 3# 9$A'4 (0 /3$ &'&#$(. -439$%80 *' V

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 89: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

º !" #$%& '() *+, !-./"$0 ."1$, # 2"3/".-45" , # 6"$3# !, 6+72-"7#8

3,7%" !" 9"7.,:;" !, <,.%5" =-.2#:) *+, ., ,72#$$,>#$0 !" #2"3/#8

7;#3,7%" , !# #?#:-#45" !"#$%!%&!'!# /":@%-2# , "/,$#2-"7#:-!#!,

!# >,.%5" 6-.2#:) "1A,%-?#7!"B ! ;#$3"7-C#$ , 2""$!,7#$ ". ,7%,. !#

=,!,$#45"D "! !-..,3-7#$ /$0%-2#. *+, $,.+:%,3 ,33#-"$ ,6-2-E72-# 7#

#:"2#45" , ,F,2+45" !" >#.%" /G1:-2") 7# #$$,2#!#45" !, $,2,-%#.) 7"

2"7%$":, !" ,7!-?-!#3,7%" , 7# %$#7./#$E72-# !# >,.%5" 6-.2#:D#! #!"%#$

7"$3#. !, 2"7.":-!#45" !#. 2"7%#. /G1:-2#.) /#!$"7-C#$ #. /$,.%#4H,.

!, 2"7%#. , $,:#%I$-". , !,3"7.%$#%-?". !, >,.%5" 6-.2#:) !, #2"$!" 2"3

" /$,?-.%" 7" #$%->" #*+- 2"3,7%#!"D , $! !-?+:>#$ #70:-.,.) ,.%+!". ,

!-#>7I.%-2".& %&& '() *+$(,-. )/#'0&)1(. 2)3 , *, 4+& * , #+/&5

6)60)78+ ( )/9#)+ $ & 6)1)$ $(& $(&&( :+/&(';+. )/#'0&)1( #,) /$+

#+<*,+<)&&+&. #+< ,(' 78+ + <(&<+. * , +& =0/)#9*)+&&

J& K$%& (L) !"#$

M7*+#!$#3,7%") !# $&( )*+' !,!"-.-+*' !" N"!,$ "+ I$>5" $,6,$-!"

7" #$%& L) 2+A# !,./,.# %"%#: 2"3 /,.."#: 7" ,F,$2@2-" !, /000 ,.%#?#

#2-3# !". :-3-%,. ,.%#1,:,2-!". 7" #$%& OP Q/,$2,7%+#: !# !,./,.# %"%#:

/$,?-.%# /#$# 2#!# ,7%, !# =,!,$#45") .,7!" /#$# " R+7-2@/-" !, 'LS

!# T,2,-%# 9"$$,7%, U@*+-!#V , 7" #$%& L Q$,/#$%-45" !,.., /,$2,7%+#:

,7%$, U,>-.:#%-?"R+7-2-/#:) -72:+-7!" W$-1+7#: !, 2"7%#. !"R+7-2@/-")

"7!, ;"+?,$ X 'S X , MF,2+%-?" R+7-2-/#: X JYSV 7" $,./,2%-?" :-3-%,)

,:-3-7#7!" " ,F2,!,7%,) >$#!+#:3,7%,) Z $#C5" !,) /,:" 3,7".) JL S

#&#&) "+ .,A#) (')<)/ 78+ $(. /+ <9/)<+. <(6 $(. (< >??@ ( +

,(&6 /6( (< >??>&

'& K$%& (O) !"#$

N$"-1-45" #%[ " %[$3-7" !" 6(,#(),+ (3(,#9#)+ 2)/ /#(),+ &(A0)/6( B

(/6, $ (< 1)A+, $ CDE) "+ .,A#) 6F $(4(<",+ $( >??G) !, # !,./,.#

%"%#: 2"3 /,.."#: !". N"!,$,. , I$>5". 3,72-"7#!". 7" #$%& L !# UT=

+:%$#/#..#$) ,3 /,$2,7%+#: !# %& &'$! ()**&+$& ,-.#'/!) # !,./,.#

?,$-6-2#!# 7" ,F,$2@2-" -3,!-#%#3,7%, #7%,$-"$) #2$,.2-!# !, OLS) .,

,.%# 6"$ -76,$-"$ #" :-3-%, !,6-7-!" 7" #$%& L) $,..#:?#!# # ;-/I%,., !"

-72-." \ !" #$%& ]( !# 9"7.%-%+-45" =,!,$#:&

(& K$%& ( ) !"#$

N$"-1-45") 6F + 6F,<)/+ $+ 6(,#(),+ (3(,#9#)+ &(A0)/6() -.%" [) >H??G)

!# !,./,.# 2"3 .,?-4". !, %,$2,-$". !". N"!,$,. , I$>5" $,6,$-!". 7"

#$%& L ,F2,!#) ,3 /,$2,7%+#: !# %& &'$! ()**&+$& ,-.#'/!) # !" ,F,$2@8

2-" #7%,$-"$ Z ,7%$#!# ,3 ?->"$ !# UT=&

!"#$%& '(

Page 90: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

/HL�&RPSOHPHQWDU�Qº�����GH���GH�PDLR�GH�����

/HL�Qº��������GH����GH�RXWXEUR�GH�����

$QH[R��

!"#$%& '(

Page 91: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%& '(

Page 92: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&%'% ()*+#! ,% -.(#(/#! 01$&.'#! 2)&"#,#! 0#*# # *%!0)(!#$.3

&.,#,% (# 4%!"5) -.!'#& % ,6 )7"*#! 0*)2.,8('.#!9

!"#$%&#'(# &) "#!*+,%-)

!"# $!%&' ()& # *#+,'&$$# -!./#+!0 1&.'&2! & &) $!+./#+# ! $&,)/+2& 3&/

*#450&4&+2!'6

-./01234 %

&%$! $%56#$ !"#,%7%')"#$

7'28 9:8 ;$2! 3&/ *#450&4&+2!' &$2!%&0&.& +#'4!$ 1& </+!+"!$ 5=%0/.!$

>#02!1!$ 5!'! ! '&$5#+$!%/0/1!1& +! ,&$2?# </$.!0@ .#4 !45!'# +# *!5A2)0#

BB 1# CA2)0# DB 1! *#+$2/2)/"?#8

E 9º 7 '&$5#+$!%/0/1!1& +! ,&$2?# </$.!0 5'&$$)5F& ! !"?# 50!+&G!1! &

2'!+$5!'&+2&@ &4 ()& $& 5'&>/+&4 '/$.#$ & #'/,&41&$>/#$ .!5!H&$ 1& !<&2!'

# &()/0A%'/# 1!$ .#+2!$ 5=%0/.!$@ 4&1/!+2& # .)45'/4&+2# 1& 4&2!$ 1&

'&$)02!1#$ &+2'& '&.&/2!$ & 1&$5&$!$ & ! #%&1/I+./! ! 0/4/2&$ & .#+1/"F&$ +#

()& 2!+,& ! '&+=+./! 1& '&.&/2!@ ,&'!"?# 1& 1&$5&$!$ .#4 5&$$#!0@ 1!

$&,)'/1!1& $#./!0 & #)2'!$@ 1A>/1!$ .#+$#0/1!1! & 4#%/0/J'/!@ #5&'!"F&$ 1&

.'K1/2#@ /+.0)$/>& 5#' !+2&./5!"?# 1& '&.&/2!@ .#+.&$$?# 1& ,!'!+2/! &

/+$.'/"?# &4 L&$2#$ ! M!,!'8

E Nº 7$ 1/$5#$/"F&$ 1&$2! 3&/ *#450&4&+2!' #%'/,!4 ! O+/?#@ #$ ;$2!1#$@

# P/$2'/2# &1&'!0 & #$ Q)+/.A5/#$8

E Rº -!$ '&<&'I+./!$6

B S T O+/?#@ !#$ ;$2!1#$@ !# P/$2'/2# &1&'!0 & !#$ Q)+/.A5/#$@ &$2?#

.#45'&&+1/1#$6

!U # M#1&' ;V&.)2/>#@ # M#1&' 3&,/$0!2/>#@ +&$2& !%'!+,/1#$ #$ C'/%)+!/$ 1&

*#+2!$@ # M#1&' W)1/./J'/# & # Q/+/$2K'/# M=%0/.#X

/HL�&RPSOHPHQWDU�1º������GH���GH�0DLR�GH�����

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 93: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "# $%#&%'()*"# "+,)-)#($"./%# +)$%("#0 12-+3#0 "2("$42)"#0 12-+"./%# %

%,&$%#"# %#("(")# +%&%-+%-(%#5

66 7 " 8#("+3# %-(%-+%9#% '3-#)+%$"+3 3 :)#($)(3 ;%+%$"<5

666 7 " =$) 2-")# +% >3-("# %#(?3 )-'<2@+3#A =$) 2-"< +% >3-("# +" B-)?30

=$) 2-"< +% >3-("# +3 8#("+3 %0 42"-+3 C32*%$0 =$) 2-"< +% >3-("# +3#

D2-)'@&)3# % =$) 2-"< +% >3-("# +3 D2-)'@&)3E

F$(E GHE I"$" 3# %1%)(3# +%#(" J%) >3,&<%,%-("$0 %-(%-+%9#% '3,3A

6 7 %-(% +" ;%+%$".?3A " B-)?30 '"+" 8#("+30 3 :)#($)(3 ;%+%$"< % '"+"

D2-)'@&)35

66 7 %,&$%#" '3-($3<"+"A #3')%+"+% '2K" ,")3$)" +3 '"&)("< #3')"< '3,

+)$%)(3 " *3(3 &%$(%-."0 +)$%(" 32 )-+)$%(",%-(%0 " %-(% +" ;%+%$".?35

666 7 %,&$%#" %#("("< +%&%-+%-(%A %,&$%#" '3-($3<"+" 42% $%'% " +3 %-(%

'3-($3<"+3$ $%'2$#3# 1)-"-'%)$3# &"$" &"L",%-(3 +% +%#&%#"# '3, &%##3"<

32 +% '2#(%)3 %, L%$"< 32 +% '"&)("<0 %M'<2@+3#0 -3 N<(),3 '"#30 "42%<%#

&$3*%-)%-(%# +% "2,%-(3 +% &"$()')&".?3 "')3-O$)"5

6P 7 $%'%)(" '3$$%-(% <@42)+"A #3,"(Q$)3 +"# $%'%)("# ($) 2(O$)"#0 +% '3-($)9

2)./%#0 &"($),3-)")#0 )-+2#($)")#0 "L$3&%'2O$)"#0 +% #%$*).3#0 ($"-#1%$R-')"#

'3$$%-(%# % 32($"# $%'%)("# (", S, '3$$%-(%#0 +%+2T)+3#A

"! -" B-)?30 3# *"<3$%# ($"-#1%$)+3# "3# 8#("+3# % D2-)'@&)3# &3$ +%(%$,)9

-".?3 '3-#()(2')3-"< 32 <%L"<0 % "# '3-($) 2)./%# ,%-')3-"+"# -" "<@-%" "

+3 )-')#3 6 % -3 )-')#3 66 +3 "$(E UVW0 % -3 "$(E GXV +" >3-#()(2).?35

! -3# 8#("+3#0 "# &"$'%<"# %-($%L2%# "3# D2-)'@&)3# &3$ +%(%$,)-".?3

'3-#()(2')3-"<5

'! -" B-)?30 -3# 8#("+3# % -3# D2-)'@&)3#0 " '3-($) 2).?3 +3# #%$*)+3$%#

&"$" 3 '2#(%)3 +3 #%2 #)#(%," +% &$%*)+R-')" % "##)#(R-')" #3')"< % "# $%'%)("#

&$3*%-)%-(%# +" '3,&%-#".?3 1)-"-'%)$" ')("+" -3 Y Vº +3 "$(E GZU +"

>3-#()(2).?3E

Y Uº [%$?3 '3,&2("+3# -3 'O<'2<3 +" $%'%)(" '3$$%-(% <@42)+" 3# *"<3$%#

&"L3# % $%'% )+3# %, +%'3$$R-')" +" J%) >3,&<%,%-("$ -3 \]0 +% UX +%

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 94: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"!#$%& '! ())*+ ! '& ,-.'& /%!01 "& /!2& 3%"4 *5 '& 6"& '3 71 /& 189!

:&. "1"-;1&.31 <%3. 1"=%13 4

> ?º !" #$%!" &"'#()$%*)"# '* %$&$(+* &"%%$'+$ ,-./()* )" 0(#+%(+" 1$)$%*,

$ )"# 2#+*)"# )" 34*56 $ )$ 7"%*(4* "# %$&/%#"# %$&$8()"# )* 9'(!" 5*%*

*+$')(4$'+" )*# )$#5$#*# )$ ./$ +%*+* " ('&(#" : )" ; <º )" *%+= <>=

; ?º 3 %$&$(+* &"%%$'+$ ,-./()* #$%6 *5/%*)* #"4*')"@#$ *# %$&$(+*# *%%$@

&*)*)*# '" 4A# $4 %$B$%A'&(* $ '"# "'C$ *'+$%("%$#D $E&,/-)*# *# )/5,(&(@

)*)$#=

!"#$%&' ((

)* +,-./0-1/.2*

!"#$ %

)' +&!3' +&%45!3%!&

3%+= ?F= G:2H30IJ

!"#$ %%

)! ,65 76 )546$45869 *4:!;63$<45!9

3%+= KF= 3 ,$( )$ )(%$+%(C$# "%L*4$'+6%(*# *+$')$%6 " )(#5"#+" '" ; Mº )" *%+=

<NO )* P"'#+(+/(L!" $Q

R S )(#5"%6 +*48T4 #"8%$Q

*J $./(,-8%(" $'+%$ %$&$(+*# $ )$#5$#*#U

8J &%(+T%("# $ B"%4* )$ ,(4(+*L!" )$ $45$'V"D * #$% $B$+(W*)* '*# V(5X+$#$#

5%$W(#+*# '* *,-'$* )" ('&(#" RR )$#+$ *%+(Y"D '" *%+= >º $ '" ('&(#" RR )" ;

<º )" *%+= ?<U

&J G:2H30IJ

)J G:2H30IJ

$J '"%4*# %$,*+(W*# *" &"'+%",$ )$ &/#+"# $ Z *W*,(*L!" )"# %$#/,+*)"# )"#

5%"Y%*4*# B('*'&(*)"# &"4 %$&/%#"# )"# "%L*4$'+"#U

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 95: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$%&' ()*"&+,#' # #-&./*(&%' 0%1% 21%*' #1/*(&%' "# 1#(31')' % #*2&"%"#'

0456&(%' # 01&7%"%'8

99 : ;<=>?@A!

999 : ;<=>?@A!

B Cº 9*2#.1%1D ) 01)E#2) "# 6#& "# "&1#21&F#' )1+%$#*2D1&%' ?*#-) "# G#2%'

H&'(%&'I #$ J3# '#1K) #'2%5#6#(&"%' $#2%' %*3%&'I #$ 7%6)1#' ()11#*2#' #

()*'2%*2#'I 1#6%2&7%' % 1#(#&2%'I "#'0#'%'I 1#'362%")' *)$&*%6 # 01&$D1&) #

$)*2%*2# "% "L7&"% 0456&(%I 0%1% ) #-#1(L(&) % J3# '# 1# #1&1#$ # 0%1% )'

")&' '#.3&*2#'M

B Nº A ?*#-) ()*2#1DI %&*"%O

9 : %7%6&%+K) ") (3$01&$#*2) "%' $#2%' 1#6%2&7%' %) %*) %*2#1&)18

99 : "#$)*'21%2&7) "%' $#2%' %*3%&'I &*'213L") ()$ $#$P1&% # $#2)")6).&%

"# (D6(36) J3# E3'2& &J3#$ )' 1#'362%")' 01#2#*"&")'I ()$0%1%*")Q%' ()$

%' &-%"%' *)' 21/' #-#1(L(&)' %*2#1&)1#'I # #7&"#*(&%*") % ()*'&'2/*(&% "#6%'

()$ %' 01#$&''%' # )' )5E#2&7)' "% 0)6L2&(% #()*R$&(% *%(&)*%68

999 : #7)63+K) ") 0%21&$R*&) 6LJ3&")I 2%$5S$ *)' 462&$)' 21/' #-#1(L(&)'I

"#'2%(%*") % )1&.#$ # % %06&(%+K) ")' 1#(31')' )52&")' ()$ % %6&#*%+K)

"# %2&7)'8

9< : %7%6&%+K) "% '&23%+K) &*%*(#&1% # %23%1&%6O

%! ")' 1#.&$#' .#1%6 "# 01#7&"/*(&% ')(&%6 # 01P01&) ")' '#17&")1#' 0456&()'

# ") H3*") "# ?$0%1) %) >1%5%6T%")18

5! ")' "#$%&' 3*")' 0456&()' # 01).1%$%' #'2%2%&' "# *%231#F% %23%1&%68

< : "#$)*'21%2&7) "% #'2&$%2&7% # ()$0#*'%+K) "% 1#*4*(&% "# 1#(#&2% #

"% $%1.#$ "# #-0%*'K) "%' "#'0#'%' )51&.%2P1&%' "# (%1D2#1 ()*2&*3%")M

B Uº ? 6#& "# "&1#21&F#' )1+%$#*2D1&%' ()*2#1D ?*#-) "# V&'()' H&'(%&'I )*"#

'#1K) %7%6&%")' )' 0%''&7)' ()*2&*.#*2#' # )321)' 1&'()' (%0%F#' "# % #2%1 %'

()*2%' 0456&(%'I &* )1$%*") %' 01)7&"/*(&%' % '#1#$ 2)$%"%'I (%') '#

()*(1#2&F#$M

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 96: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º " #$%&'($# )*$ $%+'#,%-'. / 0./1$2/ 3' 4%,5/ '0.$&$%2'.67 $#

'%$8/ $&0$+9:,+/7 /& /;1$2,</& 3'& 0/=92,+'& #/%$26.,'7 +.$3,29+,' $ +'#;,'=7

;$# +/#/ /& 0'.>#$2./& $ '& 0./1$?@$& 0'.' &$*& 0.,%+,0',& '(.$('3/& $

<'.,6<$,&7 $ ',%3' '& #$2'& 3$ ,%:='?5/7 0'.' / $8$.+9+,/ &*;&$)A$%2$B

!"#$ %%%

! "#$ %&'!(#)*+&$! ,)-!.

".2B CDBE 0./1$2/ 3$ =$, /.?'#$%26.,' '%*'=7 $=';/.'3/ 3$ :/.#' +/#0'29<$=

+/# / 0='%/ 0=*.,'%*'=7 +/# ' =$, 3$ 3,.$2.,F$& /.?'#$%26.,'& $ +/# '&

%/.#'& 3$&2' G$, H/#0=$#$%2'.I

J K +/%2$.67 $# '%$8/7 3$#/%&2.'2,</ 3' +/#0'2,;,=,3'3$ 3' 0./(.'#'?5/

3/& /.?'#$%2/& +/# /& /;1$2,</& $ #$2'& +/%&2'%2$& 3/ 3/+*#$%2/ 3$ )*$

2.'2' / Lº 3/ '.2B !ºM

JJ K &$.6 '+/#0'%-'3/ 3/ 3/+*#$%2/ ' )*$ &$ .$:$.$ / Nº 3/ '.2B LNC 3'

H/%&2,2*,?5/7 ;$# +/#/ 3'& #$3,3'& 3$ +/#0$%&'?5/ ' .$%O%+,'& 3$

.$+$,2' $ '/ '*#$%2/ 3$ 3$&0$&'& /;.,('2P.,'& 3$ +'.62$. +/%2,%*'3/M

JJJ K +/%2$.6 .$&$.<' 3$ +/%2,%(Q%+,'7 +*1' :/.#' 3$ *2,=,F'?5/ $ #/%2'%2$7

3$:,%,3/ +/# ;'&$ %' .$+$,2' +/..$%2$ =9)*,3'7 &$.5/ $&2';$=$+,3/& %' =$, 3$

3,.$2.,F$& /.?'#$%26.,'&7 3$&2,%'3' '/I

'R STUV"WER

;R '2$%3,#$%2/ 3$ 0'&&,</& +/%2,%($%2$& $ /*2./& .,&+/& $ $<$%2/& :,&+',&

,#0.$<,&2/&B

Lº V/3'& '& 3$&0$&'& .$='2,<'& X 39<,3' 0O;=,+'7 #/;,=,6.,' /* +/%2.'2*'=7

$ '& .$+$,2'& )*$ '& '2$%3$.5/7 +/%&2'.5/ 3' =$, /.?'#$%26.,' '%*'=B

Yº E .$:,%'%+,'#$%2/ 3' 39<,3' 0O;=,+' +/%&2'.6 &$0'.'3'#$%2$ %' =$,

/.?'#$%26.,' $ %'& 3$ +.Z3,2/ '3,+,/%'=B

[º " '2*'=,F'?5/ #/%$26.,' 3/ 0.,%+,0'= 3' 39<,3' #/;,=,6.,' .$:,%'%+,'3'

%5/ 0/3$.6 &*0$.'. ' <'.,'?5/ 3/ 9%3,+$ 3$ 0.$?/& 0.$<,&2/ %' =$, 3$

3,.$2.,F$& /.?'#$%26.,'&7 /* $# =$(,&='?5/ $&0$+9:,+'B

!º \ <$3'3/ +/%&,(%'. %' =$, /.?'#$%26.,' +.Z3,2/ +/# :,%'=,3'3$ ,#0.$]

+,&' /* +/# 3/2'?5/ ,=,#,2'3'B

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 97: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º " #$% &'()*$+,-'%) +.& /&+0%1+)'- 2&,)(.& 3)') %+4$0,%*$+,& /&*

25')(.& 053$'%&' ) 5* $6$'/7/%& 8%+)+/$%'& 95$ +.& $0,$:) 3'$4%0,& +&3#)+&

3#5'%)+5)# &5 $* #$% 95$ )5,&'%;$ ) 05) %+/#50.&< /&+8&'*$ 2%03&0,& +&

=º 2& )',> =?@ 2) A&+0,%,5%(.&>

?º B+,$1')'.& )0 2$03$0)0 2) C+%.&< $ 0$'.& %+/#572)0 +) #$% &'()*$+,-'%)<

)0 2& D)+/& A$+,')# 2& D')0%# '$#),%4)0 ) 3$00&)# $ $+/)'1&0 0&/%)%0< /50,$%&

)2*%+%0,'),%4&< %+/#50%4$ &0 2$0,%+)2&0 ) E$+$87/%&0 $ )00%0,F+/%) )&0 0$'4%G

2&'$0< $ ) %+4$0,%*$+,&0>

@º HIJK"LMN

"',> ?O> HIJK"LMN

"',> @O> M '$05#,)2& 2& D)+/& A$+,')# 2& D')0%#< )35')2& )3P0 ) /&+0,%,5%(.&

&5 '$4$'0.& 2$ '$0$'4)0< /&+0,%,5% '$/$%,) 2& K$0&5'& Q)/%&+)#< $ 0$'-

,')+08$'%2& ),R & 2R/%*& 2%) S,%# 05E0$9T$+,$ U )3'&4)(.& 2&0 E)#)+(&0

0$*$0,')%0>

=º M '$05#,)2& +$1),%4& /&+0,%,5%'- &E'%1)(.& 2& K$0&5'& 3)') /&* &

D)+/& A$+,')# 2& D')0%# $ 0$'- /&+0%1+)2& $* 2&,)(.& $03$/78%/) +&

&'()*$+,&>

Vº M %*3)/,& $ & /50,& 8%0/)# 2)0 &3$')(W$0 '$)#%;)2)0 3$#& D)+/& A$+,')#

2& D')0%# 0$'.& 2$*&+0,')2&0 ,'%*$0,')#*$+,$< +&0 ,$'*&0 $* 95$ 2%0350$'

) #$% 2$ 2%'$,'%;$0 &'()*$+,-'%)0 2) C+%.&>

Xº M0 E)#)+(&0 ,'%*$0,')%0 2& D)+/& A$+,')# 2& D')0%# /&+,$'.& +&,)0

$63#%/),%4)0 0&E'$ &0 /50,&0 2) '$*5+$')(.& 2)0 2%03&+%E%#%2)2$0 2& K$0&5G

'& Q)/%&+)# $ 2) *)+5,$+(.& 2)0 '$0$'4)0 /)*E%)%0 $ ) '$+,)E%#%2)2$ 2$

05) /)',$%') 2$ ,7,5#&0< 2$0,)/)+2& &0 2$ $*%00.& 2) C+%.&>

!"#$ %&

! "#$%&'() *+'!,$-./+0! $ 1) 2&,3+0,$-.) 1!4 5$.!4

"',> YO> ",R ,'%+,) 2%)0 )3P0 ) 35E#%/)(.& 2&0 &'()*$+,&0< +&0 ,$'*&0 $*

95$ 2%0350$' ) #$% 2$ 2%'$,'%;$0 &'()*$+,-'%)0 $ &E0$'4)2& & 2%03&0,& +)

)#7+$) 2& %+/%0& B 2& )',> Z&< & [&2$' J6$/5,%4& $0,)E$#$/$'- )3'&1')*)(.&

8%+)+/$%') $ & /'&+&1')*) 2$ $6$/5(.& *$+0)# 2$ 2$0$*E&#0&>

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 98: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$"!%& '()*&+ ,- ".*/"-&- 0.$!01.(2. 3)(*/0!4&- ! %)(!0)4!4. .-5.*6%)*!

-."7& /2)0)8!4&- .9*0/-)3!1.(2. 5!"! !2.(4." !& &:;.2& 4. -/! 3)(*/0!<7&=

!)(4! >/. .1 .9."*6*)& 4)3."-& 4!>/.0. .1 >/. &*&""." & )($".--&+

?"2+ @A+ B. 3.")%)*!4&= !& %)(!0 4. /1 :)1.-2".= >/. ! ".!0)8!<7& 4! ".*.)2!

5&4."# (7& *&15&"2!" & */15")1.(2& 4!- 1.2!- 4. ".-/02!4& 5")1#")& &/

(&1)(!0 .-2!:.0.*)4!- (& ?(.9& 4.C.2!- D)-*!)-= &- &4.".- . &C)()-2E")&

':0)*& 5"&1&3."7&= 5&" !2& 5"F5")& . (&-1&(2!(2.- (.*.--#")&-= (&- 2")(2!

4)!- -/:-.>G.(2.-= 0)1)2!<7& 4. .15.(H& . 1&3)1.(2!<7& %)(!(*.)"!=

-.$/(4& &- *")2E")&- %)9!4&- 5.0! 0.) 4. 4)".2")8.- &"<!1.(2#")!-+

I Jº K& *!-& 4. ".-2!:.0.*)1.(2& 4! ".*.)2! 5".3)-2!= !)(4! >/. 5!"*)!0= !

".*&15&-)<7& 4!- 4&2!<L.- */;&- .15.(H&- %&"!1 0)1)2!4&- 4!"M-.M# 4.

%&"1! 5"&5&"*)&(!0 N- ".4/<L.- .%.2)3!4!-+

I Oº K7& -."7& &:;.2& 4. 0)1)2!<7& !- 4.-5.-!- >/. *&(-2)2/!1 &:")$!<L.-

*&(-2)2/*)&(!)- . 0.$!)- 4& .(2.= )(*0/-)3. !>/.0!- 4.-2)(!4!- !& 5!$!1.(2&

4& -."3)<& 4! 463)4!= . !- ".--!03!4!- 5.0! 0.) 4. 4)".2")8.- &"<!1.(2#")!-+

I Pº K& *!-& 4. &- &4.".- Q.$)-0!2)3& . R/4)*)#")& . & C)()-2E")& ':0)*&

(7& 5"&1&3.".1 ! 0)1)2!<7& (& 5"!8& .-2!:.0.*)4& (& !"#$= E & &4."

S9.*/2)3& !/2&")8!4& ! 0)1)2!" &- 3!0&".- %)(!(*.)"&- -.$/(4& &- *")2E")&-

%)9!4&- 5.0! 0.) 4. 4)".2")8.- &"<!1.(2#")!-+

I Tº ?2E & %)(!0 4&- 1.-.- 4.1!)&= -.2.1:"& . %.3.".)"&= & &4." S9.*/2)3&

4.1&(-2"!"# . !3!0)!"# & */15")1.(2& 4!-1.2!- %)-*!)- 4. *!4! >/!4")1.-M

2".= .1 !/4)U(*)! 5':0)*! (! *&1)--7& ".%.")4! (& I Jº 4& !"2+ JVV 4!

W&(-2)2/)<7& &/ .>/)3!0.(2. (!- W!-!- Q.$)-0!2)3!- .-2!4/!)- . 1/()*)5!)-+

I Xº K& 5"!8& 4. (&3.(2! 4)!- !5F- & .(*.""!1.(2& 4. *!4! -.1.-2".= &

Y!(*& W.(2"!0 4& Y"!-)0 !5".-.(2!"#= .1 "./()7& *&(;/(2! 4!- *&1)--L.-

2.1#2)*!- 5."2)(.(2.- 4& W&($".--& K!*)&(!0= !3!0)!<7& 4& */15")1.(2&

4&- &:;.2)3&- . 1.2!- 4!- 5&062)*!- 1&(.2#")!= *".4)26*)! . *!1:)!0= .3)4.(M

*)!(4& & )15!*2& . & */-2& %)-*!0 4. -/!- &5."!<L.- . &- ".-/02!4&-

4.1&(-2"!4&- (&- :!0!(<&-+

?"2+ JZ+ ? .9.*/<7& &"<!1.(2#")! . %)(!(*.)"! )4.(2)%)*!"# &- :.(.%)*)#")&-

4. 5!$!1.(2& 4. -.(2.(<!- ;/4)*)!)-= 5&" 1.)& 4. -)-2.1! 4. *&(2!:)0)4!4.

. !41)()-2"!<7& %)(!(*.)"!= 5!"! %)(- 4. &:-."3[(*)! 4! &"4.1 *"&(&0F$)*!

4.2."1)(!4! (& !"2+ JZZ 4! W&(-2)2/)<7&+

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 99: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&' (((

)* +, ,(-* ./01( *

!"#$ %)! .234567' 3 8! *2239!8!:7'

!"# $$# %&'(")"*+, !+-*)()"&( +((+'.)/)( 0/ !+(1&'(/2)3)0/0+'/ 4+("5& 6)(./3

/ )'(")"*)75&8 1!+9)(5& + +6+")9/ /!!+./0/75& 0+ "&0&( &( "!)2*"&( 0/ .&,1+:

";'.)/ .&'(")"*.)&'/3 0& +'"+ 0/ <+0+!/75&#

=/!>4!/6& ?').&# @ 9+0/0/ / !+/3)A/75& 0+ "!/'(6+!;'.)/( 9&3*'">!)/( 1/!/ &

+'"+ -*+ '5& &2(+!9+ & 0)(1&("& '& !"#$8 '& -*+ (+ !+6+!+ /&( ),1&("&(#

!"# $B# ( 1!+9)(C+( 0+ !+.+)"/ &2(+!9/!5& /( '&!,/( "D.')./( + 3+4/)(8

.&'()0+!/!5& &( +6+)"&( 0/( /3"+!/7C+( '/ 3+4)(3/75&8 0/ 9/!)/75& 0& E'0).+

0+ 1!+7&(8 0& .!+(.),+'"& +.&'F,).& &* 0+ -*/3-*+! &*"!& 6/"&! !+3+9/'"+

+ (+!5& /.&,1/'G/0/( 0+ 0+,&'("!/")9& 0+ (*/ +9&3*75& '&( ?3"),&( "!;(

/'&(8 0/ 1!&H+75& 1/!/ &( 0&)( (+4*)'"+( I-*+3+ / -*+ (+ !+6+!)!+, + 0/

,+"&0&3&4)/ 0+ .>3.*3& + 1!+,)((/( *")3)A/0/(#

J $º K++("),/")9/ 0+ !+.+)"/ 1&! 1/!"+ 0& =&0+! L+4)(3/")9& (M (+!> /0,)")0/

(+ .&,1!&9/0& +!!& &* &,)((5& 0+ &!0+, "D.')./ &* 3+4/3#

J Bº N ,&'"/'"+ 1!+9)("& 1/!/ /( !+.+)"/( 0+ &1+!/7C+( 0+ .!D0)"& '5&

1&0+!> (+! (*1+!)&! /& 0/( 0+(1+(/( 0+ ./1)"/3 .&'("/'"+( 0& 1!&H+"& 0+ 3+)

&!7/,+'">!)/#

J Oº N =&0+! PQ+.*")9& 0+ ./0/ +'"+ .&3&./!> I 0)(1&()75& 0&( 0+,/)(

=&0+!+( + 0& R)')("D!)& =?23).&8 '& ,E'),& "!)'"/ 0)/( /'"+( 0& 1!/A& 6)'/3

1/!/ +'./,)'G/,+'"& 0+ (*/( 1!&1&("/( &!7/,+'">!)/(8 &( +("*0&( + /(

+("),/")9/( 0/( !+.+)"/( 1/!/ & +Q+!.E.)& (*2(+-S+'"+8 )'.3*()9+ 0/ .&!!+'"+

3E-*)0/8 + /( !+(1+.")9/( ,+,M!)/( 0+ .>3.*3&#

!"# $O# T& 1!/A& 1!+9)("& '& /!"# Uº8 /( !+.+)"/( 1!+9)("/( (+!5& 0+(0&2!/0/(8

1+3& =&0+! PQ+.*")9&8 +, ,+"/( 2),+("!/)( 0+ /!!+./0/75&8 .&, / +(:

1+.)6)./75&8 +, (+1/!/0&8 -*/'0& ./2E9+38 0/( ,+0)0/( 0+ .&,2/"+ I

+9/(5& + I (&'+4/75&8 0/ -*/'")0/0+ + 9/3&!+( 0+ /7C+( /H*)A/0/( 1/!/

.&2!/'7/ 0/ 0E9)0/ /")9/8 2+, .&,& 0/ +9&3*75& 0& ,&'"/'"+ 0&( .!D0)"&(

"!)2*">!)&( 1/((E9+)( 0+ .&2!/'7/ /0,)')("!/")9/#

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 100: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$ %%

! "#$%$&'! (# "#&#')!

!"# $%# &'(&)**+' ', -./01-2+' 3) 1(&)("14' ', 5)()67&1' 3) (-",!)8-

"!15,"9!1- 3- :,-0 3)&'!!- !)(;(&1- 3) !)&)1"- 3)4)!9 )*"-! -&'./-(<-3-

3) )*"1.-"14- 3' 1./-&"' '!2-.)("9!1'=61(-(&)1!' (' )>)!&7&1' ). :,)

3)4- 1(1&1-! *,- 41?@(&1- ) ('* 3'1* *)?,1(")*A -")(3)! -' 31*/'*"' (- 0)1 3)

31!)"!18)* '!2-.)("9!1-* ) - /)0' .)('* ,.- 3-* *)?,1(")* &'(312B)*C

D E 3).'(*"!-2+' /)0' /!'/'()(") 3) :,) - !)(;(&1- 6'1 &'(*13)!-3- (-

)*"1.-"14- 3) !)&)1"- 3- 0)1 '!2-.)("9!1-A (- 6'!.- 3' -!"# $FA ) 3) :,) (+'

-6)"-!9 -* .)"-* 3) !)*,0"-3'* 61*&-1* /!)41*"-* (' -()>' /!G/!1' 3- 0)1 3)

31!)"!18)* '!2-.)("9!1-*H

DD E )*"-! -&'./-(<-3- 3) .)313-* 3) &'./)(*-2+'A (' /)!7'3' .)(&1'=

(-3' (' !"#$A /'! .)1' 3' -,.)("' 3) !)&)1"-A /!'4)(1)(") 3- )0)4-2+'

3) -07:,'"-*A -./01-2+' 3- 5-*) 3) &90&,0'A .-I'!-2+' ', &!1-2+' 3) "!15,"'

', &'("!15,12+'#

J $º !)(;(&1- &'./!))(3) -(1*"1-A !).1**+'A *,5*731'A &!K31"' /!)*,.13'A

&'(&)**+' 3) 1*)(2+' ). &-!9")! (+' ?)!-0A -0")!-2+' 3) -07:,'"- ',

.'3161&-2+' 3) 5-*) 3) &90&,0' :,) 1./01:,) !)3,2+' 31*&!1.1(-3- 3)

"!15,"'* ', &'("!15,12B)*A ) ',"!'* 5)()67&1'* :,) &'!!)*/'(3-. - "!-"-=

.)("' 316)!)(&1-3'#

J Fº L) ' -"' 3) &'(&)**+' ', -./01-2+' 3' 1(&)("14' ', 5)()67&1' 3) :,)

"!-"- ' !"#$ 3)*") -!"1?' 3)&'!!)! 3- &'(312+' &'("13- (' 1(&1*' DDA '

5)()67&1' *G )("!-!9 ). 41?'! :,-(3' 1./0).)("-3-* -* .)313-* !)6)!13-*

(' .)(&1'(-3' 1(&1*'#

J Mº N 31*/'*"' ()*") -!"1?' (+' *) -/01&-C

D E O* -0")!-2B)* 3-* -07:,'"-* 3'* 1./'*"'* /!)41*"'* ('* 1(&1*'* DA DDA DP ) P

3' -!"# $QM 3- R'(*"1",12+'A (- 6'!.- 3' *), J $ºH

DD E -' &-(&)0-.)("' 3) 3K51"' &,I' .'("-(") *)I- 1(6)!1'! -' 3'* !)*=

/)&"14'* &,*"'* 3) &'5!-(2-#

!"#$%& '(

Page 101: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&' ()

*+ *,-.,-+ ./01( +

!"#$ %

*! 234!56' 7! *38"38!

!"# $%# &'!() *)+,-.'!/./, +() /0")!-1/./,2 -!!'304/!', ' 4',-5/, /) 6/"!-7

89+-) 6:;4-*) / 3'!/<() .' .',6',/ )0 /,,0+<() .' );!-3/<() =0' +()

/"'+./8 ) .-,6),") +), /!",# $> ' $?#

!"# $># *!-/<()2 '@6/+,() )0 /6'!A'-<)/8'+") .' /<() 3)5'!+/8'+"/4

=0' /*/!!'"' /08'+") ./ .',6',/ ,'!B /*)86/+C/.) .'D

E F ',"-8/"-5/ .) -86/*") )!</8'+"B!-)7A-+/+*'-!) +) '@'!*G*-) '8=0'.'5/

'+"!/! '8 5-3)! ' +), .)-, ,0;,'=H'+"',I

EE F .'*4/!/<() .) )!.'+/.)! ./ .',6',/ .' =0' ) /08'+") "'8 /.'=0/<()

)!</8'+"B!-/ ' A-+/+*'-!/ *)8 / 4'- )!</8'+"B!-/ /+0/4 ' *)86/"-;-4-./.'

*)8 ) 64/+) 640!-/+0/4 ' *)8 / 4'- .' .-!'"!-1', )!</8'+"B!-/,#

J $º K/!/ ), A-+, .',"/ L'- M)864'8'+"/!2 *)+,-.'!/7,'D

E F /.'=0/./ *)8 / 4'- )!</8'+"B!-/ /+0/42 / .',6',/ );N'") .' .)"/<()

',6'*GA-*/ ' ,0A-*-'+"'2 )0 =0' ',"'N/ /;!/+3-./ 6)! *!O.-") 3'+O!-*)2 .'

A)!8/ =0' ,)8/./, ")./, /, .',6',/, ./ 8',8/ ',6O*-'2 !'/4-1/./, ' /

!'/4-1/!2 6!'5-,"/, +) 6!)3!/8/ .' "!/;/4C)2 +() ,'N/8 04"!/6/,,/.), ),

4-8-"', ',"/;'4'*-.), 6/!/ ) '@'!*G*-)I

EE F *)86/"G5'4 *)8 ) 64/+) 640!-/+0/4 ' / 4'- .' .-!'"!-1', )!</8'+"B!-/,2

/ .',6',/ =0' ,' *)+A)!8' *)8 /, .-!'"!-1',2 );N'"-5),2 6!-)!-./.', '8'"/,

6!'5-,"), +',,', -+,"!08'+"), ' +() -+A!-+N/ =0/4=0'! .' ,0/, .-,6),-<P',#

J Qº ',"-8/"-5/ .' =0' "!/"/ ) -+*-,) E .) !"#$ ,'!B /*)86/+C/./ ./,

6!'8-,,/, ' 8'").)4)3-/ .' *B4*04) 0"-4-1/./,#

J Rº S',,/45/7,' .) .-,6),") +',"' /!"-3) / .',6',/ *)+,-.'!/./ -!!'4'5/+"'2

+), "'!8), '8 =0' .-,60,'! / 4'- .' .-!'"!-1', )!</8'+"B!-/,#

J Tº , +)!8/, .) !"#$ *)+,"-"0'8 *)+.-<() 6!O5-/ 6/!/D

!"#$%& '(

!!

Page 102: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$"%&' " ()*)+,-.' /" 0"12)-'03 4'1%"*)#"%+' /" 5"%0 '6 "7"*6-.' /"

'51,08

! /"0,$1'$1),-.' /" )#92")0 615,%'0 , :6" 0" 1"4"1" ' ; <º /' ,1+= >?@

/, A'%0+)+6)-.'=

!"#$%&' (

! "#$"#! %&'()!*+'(! ," -!'.*"' -/0*(01!,/

B1+= >C= A'%0)/"1,D0" '51)E,+91), /" *,1F+"1 *'%+)%6,/' , /"0$"0, *'11"%+"

/"1)2,/, /" (")3 #"/)/, $1'2)091), '6 ,+' ,/#)%)0+1,+)2' %'1#,+)2' :6"

4)7"# $,1, ' "%+" , '51)E,-.' ("E,( /" 06, "7"*6-.' $'1 6# $"1G'/'

06$"1)'1 , /')0 "7"1*G*)'0=

; >º H0 ,+'0 :6" *1),1"# '6 ,6#"%+,1"# /"0$"0, /" :6" +1,+, ' !"#$

!"!#$% &!# '(&)#*+ %& ,%- . !&)'-.)'". /#!"'&). (% '(,'&% 0 % .#)1 23 !

!-%(&)#.# . %#'4!- %& #!,*#&%& /.#. &!* ,*&)!'%1

5 6º 7.#. !8!')% % .)!( '-!()% % 5 2º9 % .)% &!#: .,%-/.(;. % !

,%-/#%".<$% ! =*! . !&/!&. ,#'. . %* .*-!(). . ($% .8!).#: .& -!).&

! #!&*>). %& 8'&,.'& /#!"'&).& (% .(!?% #!8!#' % (% 5 2º % .#)1 @º9 !"!( %

&!*& !8!')%& 8'(.(,!'#%&9 (%& /!#+% %& &!4*'()!&9 &!# ,%-/!(&. %& /!>%

.*-!()% /!#-.(!()! ! #!,!'). %* /!>. #! *<$% /!#-.(!()! ! !&/!&.1

5 Aº 7.#. !8!')% % 5 6º9 ,%(&' !#.B&! .*-!()% /!#-.(!()! ! #!,!'). %

/#%"!('!()! . !>!".<$% ! .>+=*%).&9 .-/>'.<$% . C.&! ! ,:>,*>%9

-.D%#.<$% %* ,#'.<$% ! )#'C*)% %* ,%()#'C*'<$%1

5 @ºE ,%-/#%".<$% #!8!#' . (% 5 6º9 ./#!&!(). . /!>% /#%/%(!()!9 ,%()!#:

.& /#!-'&&.& ! -!)% %>%4'. ! ,:>,*>% *)'>'F. .&9 &!- /#!D*+F% % !?.-!

! ,%-/.)'C'>' . ! . !&/!&. ,%- .& !-.'& (%#-.& % />.(% />*#'.(*.>

! . >!' ! '#!)#'F!& %#<.-!():#'.&1

5 Gº E !&/!&. ! =*! )#.). !&)! .#)'4% ($% &!#: !?!,*). . .()!& . '-/>!B

-!().<$% .& -! ' .& #!8!#' .& (% 5 6º9 .& =*.'& '()!4#.#$% % '(&)#*-!()%

=*! . ,#'.# %* .*-!().#1

5 3º H '&/%&)% (% 5 2º ($% &! ./>',. I& !&/!&.& !&)'(. .& .% &!#"'<% .

+"' . (!- .% #!.D*&).-!()% ! #!-*(!#.<$% ! /!&&%.> ! =*! )#.). %

'(,'&% J % .#)1 AK . L%(&)')*'<$%1

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 103: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º "#$%&'()*+%( *,-($.# '( '(%/(%* * /)#))#0*12# '*3,(4* 5)&*'* /#)

/)*6# '(.()-&$*'#7

!"#$ %%

!" #"$#"!" %&' (#""&!)

&'(!"#$ %

#*+,+-.#" # /+'+0#"

8).7 9:7 ;*)* #% (<(&.#% '(%.* =(& "#-/4(-($.*)> ($.($'(+%( 5#-# '(%/(%*

.#.*4 5#- /(%%#*4? # %#-*.@)&# '#% 0*%.#% '# ($.( '* A('()*12# 5#- #%

*.&B#%> #% &$*.&B#% ( #% /($%&#$&%.*%> )(4*.&B#% * -*$'*.#% (4(.&B#%> 5*)0#%>

<,$1C(% #, (-/)(0#%> 5&B&%> -&4&.*)(% ( '( -(-D)#% '( ;#'()> 5#- 3,*&%+

3,() (%/E5&(% )(-,$()*.@)&*%> .*&% 5#-# B($5&-($.#% ( B*$.*0($%> <&F*% (

B*)&GB(&%> %,D%H'&#%> /)#B($.#% '* */#%($.*'#)&*> )(<#)-*% ( /($%C(%> &$54,+

%&B( *'&5&#$*&%> 0)*.&<&5*1C(%> I#)*% (F.)*% ( B*$.*0($% /(%%#*&% '( 3,*43,()

$*.,)(6*> D(- 5#-# ($5*)0#% %#5&*&% ( 5#$.)&D,&1C(% )(5#4I&'*% /(4# ($.(

J% ($.&'*'(% '( /)(B&'K$5&*7

9º L% B*4#)(% '#% 5#$.)*.#% '( .()5(&)&6*12# '( -2#+'(+#D)* 3,( %(

)(<()(- J %,D%.&.,&12# '( %()B&'#)(% ( (-/)(0*'#% /MD4&5#% %()2# 5#$.*D&+

4&6*'#% 5#-# NL,.)*% O(%/(%*% '( ;(%%#*4P7

Qº 8 '(%/(%* .#.*4 5#- /(%%#*4 %()G */,)*'* %#-*$'#+%( * )(*4&6*'* $#

-K% (- )(<()K$5&* 5#- *% '#% #$6( &-('&*.*-($.( *$.()&#)(%> *'#.*$'#+%(

# )(0&-( '( 5#-/(.K$5&*7

8).7 9R7 ;*)* #% <&$% '# '&%/#%.# $# !"#$ '# *).7 9SR '* "#$%.&.,&12#> *

'(%/(%* .#.*4 5#- /(%%#*4> (- 5*'* /()H#'# '( */,)*12# ( (- 5*'* ($.(

'* A('()*12#> $2# /#'()G (F5('() #% /()5($.,*&% '* )(5(&.* 5#))($.(

4H3,&'*> * %(0,&) '&%5)&-&$*'#%?

T U V$&2#? WXY Z5&$3[($.* /#) 5($.#\]

TT U ^%.*'#%? SXY Z%(%%($.* /#) 5($.#\]

TTT U _,$&5H/&#%? SXY Z%(%%($.* /#) 5($.#\7

9º `* B()&<&5*12# '# *.($'&-($.# '#% 4&-&.(% '(<&$&'#% $(%.( *).&0#> $2#

%()2# 5#-/,.*'*% *% '(%/(%*%?

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 104: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "# $%"#%$&'()* +*, "#-$..)* "# .#,/$"*,#. *0 #-+,#1'"*.2

! ,#3'4$/'. ' $%5#%4$/*. 6 "#-$..)* /*30%47,$'2

! "#,$/'"'. "' '+3$5'()* "* "$.+*.4* %* $%5$.* "* 8 9º "* ',4: ;< "'

=*%.4$40$()*2

> ! "#5*,,#%4#. "# "#5$.)* ?0"$5$'3 # "' 5*-+#4@%5$' "# +#,A*"* '%4#,$*,

'* "' '+0,'()* ' B0# .# ,#C#,# * 8 Dº "* ',4: EF2

> ! 5*- +#..*'3G "* H$.4,$4* I#"#,'3 # "*. J.4'"*. "* K-'+7 # L*,'$-'G

50.4#'"'. 5*- ,#50,.*. 4,'%.C#,$"*. +#3' M%$)* %' C*,-' "*. $%5$.*. N #

N > "* ',4: DE "' =*%.4$40$()* # "* ',4: OE "' J-#%"' =*%.4$405$*%'3 %º

EP2

> ! 5*- $%'4$/*.G '$%"' B0# +*, $%4#,-Q"$* "# C0%"* #.+#5AC$5*G 50.4#'"'.

+*, ,#50,.*. +,*/#%$#%4#.R

'S "' ',,#5'"'()* "# 5*%4,$T0$(U#. "*. .#10,'"*.2

TS "' 5*-+#%.'()* C$%'%5#$,' "# B0# 4,'4' * 8 Pº "* ',4: DVE "' =*%.W

4$40$()*2

5S "'. "#-'$. ,#5#$4'. "$,#4'-#%4# ',,#5'"'"'. +*, C0%"* /$%503'"* ' 4'3

C$%'3$"'"#G $%530.$/# * +,*"04* "' '3$#%'()* "# T#%.G "$,#$4*. # '4$/*.G T#-

5*-* .#0 .0+#,7/$4 C$%'%5#$,*:

8 Dº XT.#,/'"* * "$.+*.4* %* $%5$.* > "* 8 EºG '. "#.+#.'. 5*- +#..*'3

"#5*,,#%4#. "# .#%4#%('. ?0"$5$'$. .#,)* $%530A"'. %* 3$-$4# "* ,#.+#54$/*

Y*"#, *0 Z,1)* ,#C#,$"* %* ',4: DV:

K,4: DV: K ,#+',4$()* "*. 3$-$4#. 13*T'$. "* ',4: EP %)* +*"#,7 #[5#"#, *.

.#10$%4#. +#,5#%40'$.R

! %' #.C#,' C#"#,'3R

'S DG;\ ]"*$. $%4#$,*. # 5$%5* "Q5$-*. +*, 5#%4*S +',' * ^#1$.3'4$/*G $%530A"*

* _,$T0%'3 "# =*%4'. "' M%$)*2

TS 9\ ].#$. +*, 5#%4*S +',' * `0"$5$7,$*2

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 105: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$%& '()*+,-.* /-.,/+01 , -02, 34 /501 60+ ,-.0! 6*+* 0 78, )./20$

3,1.* *-3091, :& '.+;1 60+ ,-.0! 6*+* *1 3,16,1*1 056,110*<3, 0++,-.,1

30 (), 3/16=,5 01 /- /101 >??? , >?@ 30 *+.A BC 3* D0-1./.)/EF0 , 0 *+.A :C

3* 75,-3* D0-1./.) /0-*< -º C%$ +,6*+./301 3, G0+5* 6+060+ /0-*< H543/*

3*1 3,16,1*1 +,<*./2*1 * *3* )5 3,1.,1 3/1601/./201$ ,5 6,+ ,-.)*< 3*

+, ,/.* 0++,-., <I()/3*$ 2,+/G/ *3*1 -01 .+;1 ,8,+ I /01 G/-*- ,/+01 /5,3/*9

.*5,-., *-.,+/0+,1 *0 3* 6)J</ *EF0 3,1.* K,/ D056<,5,-.*+L

3! #$M& '1,/1 34 /501 60+ ,-.0! 6*+* 0 N/-/1.4+/0 OPJ</ 0 3* Q-/F0L

?? R -* ,1G,+* ,1.*3)*<S

*! :& '.+;1 60+ ,-.0! 6*+* 0 K,T/1<*./20$ /- <)I30 0 U+/J)-*< 3, D0-.*1 30

71.*30L

J! M& '1,/1 60+ ,-.0! 6*+* 0 V)3/ /W+/0L

! "%& '()*+,-.* , -02, 60+ ,-.0! 6*+* 0 78, )./20L

3! B& '30/1 60+ ,-.0! 6*+* 0 N/-/1.4+/0 OPJ</ 0 301 71.*301L

??? R -* ,1G,+* 5)-/ /6*<S

*! M& '1,/1 60+ ,-.0! 6*+* 0 K,T/1<*./20$ /- <)I30 0 U+/J)-*< 3, D0-.*1 30

N)-/ I6/0$ ()*-30 X0)2,+L

J! Y"& ' /-(Z,-.* , ()*.+0 60+ ,-.0! 6*+* 0 78, )./20A

[ Cº \01 O03,+,1 K,T/1<*./20 , V)3/ /W+/0 3, *3* ,1G,+*$ 01 </5/.,1 1,+F0

+,6*+./301 ,-.+, 1,)1 ]+TF01 3, G0+5* 6+060+ /0-*< H 543/* 3*1 3,16,1*1

05 6,110*<$ ,5 6,+ ,-.)*< 3* +, ,/.* 0++,-., <I()/3*$ 2,+/G/ *3*1 -01 .+;1

,8,+ I /01 G/-*- ,/+01 /5,3/*.*5,-., *-.,+/0+,1 *0 3* 6)J</ *EF0 3,1.* K,/

D056<,5,-.*+A

[ Bº O*+* ,G,/.0 3,1., *+./T0 ,-.,-3,91, 050 ]+TF0S

? R 0 N/-/1.4+/0 OPJ</ 0L

?? R -0 O03,+ K,T/1<*./20S

*! ^,3,+*<$ *1 +,16, ./2*1 D*1*1 , 0 U+/J)-*< 3, D0-.*1 3* Q-/F0L

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 106: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$%&'%() % *##+, (-.% /+0.#(%$.1% + 2# 34. '5%.# &+ 625$%#7

8! &29.#$4.$2 :+&+4%() % 6;,%4% /+0.#(%$.1% +2 34. '5%( &+625$%# &29.#$4.$2

:+&+4%(7

&!<'5.8.=%() % 6;,%4% &+>+4+%&24+# + 2 34. '5%( &+625$%# &2<'5.8?=.2)

@'%5&2 A2'1+47

BBB C 52 D2&+4 E'&.8.F4.2G

%! :+&+4%() 2# $4. '5%.# 4+H+4.&2# 52 %4$I JK &% 625#$.$'.LM27

! "#$%&'%() 2 34. '5%( &+ E'#$.L% + 2'$42#) @'%5&2 A2'1+4I

N Oº P# (.,.$+# =%4% %# &+#=+#%# 82, =+##2%( &2 D2&+4 E'&.8.F4.2) % 8%402

&% Q5.M2 =24 H24L% &2 .58.#2 RBBB &2 %4$I KS &% 625#$.$'.LM2) #+4M2 +#T

$% +(+8.&2# ,+&.%5$+ %=(.8%LM2 &% 4+04% &2 N SºI

N Uº V2# "#$%&2# +, @'+ A2'1+4 34. '5%( &+ 625$%# &2# <'5.8?=.2#) 2#

=+48+5$'%.# &+H.5.&2# 5%# %(?5+%# + ! &2 .58.#2 BB &2 ! "#$ #+4M2) 4+#T

=+8$.1%,+5$+) %84+#8.&2# + 4+&'W.&2# +, X)UY Z@'%$42 &-8.,2# =24 8+5$2!I

N [º D%4% 2# H.5# =4+1.#$2# 52 %4$I S\] &% 625#$.$'.LM2) % +5$4+0% &2# 4+8'4#2#

H.5%58+.42# 8244+#=25&+5$+# ^ &+#=+#% $2$%( 82, =+##2%( =24 D2&+4 + _40M2

#+4F % 4+#'($%5$+ &% %=(.8%LM2 &2# =+48+5$'%.# &+H.5.&2# 5+#$+ %4$.02) 2'

%@'+(+# H.`%&2# 5% (+. &+ &.4+$4.W+# 24L%,+5$F4.%#I

N \º Z>"3*9P!

!"#$%&' ((

! "!#$%!&' () '*+'*) ,!$)& -!. /'**!)&

*4$I KSI a 5'(2 &+ =(+52 &.4+.$2 2 %$2 @'+ =4212@'+ %',+5$2 &% &+#=+#%

82, =+##2%( + 5M2 %$+5&%G

B C %# +`.0b58.%# &2# %4$#I S\ + Sc &+#$% /+. 62,=(+,+5$%4) + 2 &.#=2#$2 52

.58.#2 RBBB &2 %4$I Oc + 52 N Sº &2 %4$I S\J &% 625#$.$'.LM27

BB C 2 (.,.$+ (+0%( &+ 82,=42,+$.,+5$2 %=(.8%&2 ^# &+#=+#%# 82, =+##2%(

.5%$.12I

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 107: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$"!%& '()*&+ ,!-./- / (01& 23 413(& 2)"3)5& & !5& 23 603 "370153

!0-3(5& 2! 237437! *&- 4377&!1 38432)2& (&7 *3(5& 3 &)53(5! 2)!7

!(53")&"37 !& %)(!1 2& -!(2!5& 2& 5)501!" 2& "3743*5)9& &23" &0 :"$;&

"3%3")2& (& !"5+ <=+

>"5+ <<+ > 93")%)*!?;& 2& *0-4")-3(5& 2&7 1)-)537 375!.313*)2&7 (&7 !"57+

@A 3 <= 73"# "3!1)B!2! !& %)(!1 23 *!2! 60!2")-375"3+

!"#$"!%& '()*&+ C3 ! 237437! 5&5!1 *&- 4377&!1 38*323" ! ADE F(&93(5! 3

*)(*& 4&" *3(5&G 2& 1)-)53H 7;& 932!2&7 !& &23" &0 :"$;& "3%3")2& (& !"5+

<= 603 I&093" )(*&"")2& (& 38*377&J

K L *&(*377;& 23 9!(5!$3-H !0-3(5&H "3!M0753 &0 !2360!?;& 23 "3-0(3N

"!?;& ! 60!1603" 5O501&H 7!19& &7 23")9!2&7 23 73(53(?! M02)*)!1 &0 23

2353"-)(!?;& 13$!1 &0 *&(5"!50!1H "377!19!2! ! "39)7;& 4"39)75! (& )(*)7& P

2& !"5+ QR 2! S&(75)50)?;&T

KK L *")!?;& 23 *!"$&H 3-4"3$& &0 %0(?;&T

KKK L !153"!?;& 23 375"050"! 23 *!""3)"! 603 )-41)603 !0-3(5& 23 237437!T

KU L 4"&9)-3(5& 23 *!"$& 4'.1)*&H !2-)77;& &0 *&(5"!5!?;& 23 4377&!1 !

60!1603" 5O501&H "377!19!2! ! "34&7)?;& 23*&""3(53 23 !4&73(5!2&")! &0

%!13*)-3(5& 23 73"9)2&"37 2!7 #"3!7 23 320*!?;&H 7!'23 3 73$0"!(?!T

U L *&(5"!5!?;& 23 I&"! 385"!H 7!19& (& *!7& 2& 2)74&75& (& )(*)7& KK 2& V

Wº 2& !"5+ DR 2! S&(75)50)?;& 3 !7 7)50!?X37 4"39)75!7 (! 13) 23 2)"35")B37

&"?!-3(5#")!7+

>"5+ <Q+ C3 ! 237437! 5&5!1 *&- 4377&!1H 2& &23" &0 :"$;& "3%3")2& (& !"5+

<=H 015"!4!77!" &7 1)-)537 23%)()2&7 (& -37-& !"5)$&H 73- 4"3M0OB& 2!7

-32)2!7 4"39)75!7 (& !"5+ <<H & 43"*3(50!1 38*323(53 53"# 23 73" 31)-)(!2&

(&7 2&)7 60!2")-375"37 73$0)(537H 73(2& 431& -3(&7 0- 53"?& (& 4")-3)"&H

!2&5!(2&N73H 3(5"3 &05"!7H !7 4"&9)2Y(*)!7 4"39)75!7 (&7 VV Qº 3 Zº 2& !"5+

@WA 2! S&(75)50)?;&+

V @º [& *!7& 2& )(*)7& K 2& V Qº 2& !"5+ @WA 2! S&(75)50)?;&H & &.M35)9&

4&23"# 73" !1*!(?!2& 5!(5& 431! 385)(?;& 23 *!"$&7 3 %0(?X37 60!(5& 431!

"320?;& 2&7 9!1&"37 ! 3137 !5").0O2&7+

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 108: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º " #$%&'($)$ $ *+)&,-. (+/0.*1*2$ )$ 3.*4$)$ )+ (*$5$'6. %./ $)+7&$8

,-. ).9 :+4%2/+4(.9 ; 4.:$ %$*<$ 6.*1*2$=

>º ?-. $'%$4,$)$ $ *+)&,-. 4. 0*$@. +9($5+'+%2).A + +47&$4(. 0+*)&*$*

. +B%+99.A . +4(+ 4-. 0.)+*1C

D E *+%+5+* (*$49#+*F4%2$9 :.'&4(1*2$9G

DD E .5(+* <$*$4(2$A )2*+($ .& 24)2*+($A )+ .&(*. +4(+G

DDD E %.4(*$($* .0+*$,H+9 )+ %*I)2(.A *+99$':$)$9 $9 )+9(24$)$9 $. *+#24$48

%2$/+4(. )$ )J:2)$ /.52'21*2$ + $9 7&+ :29+/ ; *+)&,-. )$9 )+90+9$9 %./

0+99.$'=

Kº L9 *+9(*2,H+9 ). >º $0'2%$/89+ 2/+)2$($/+4(+ 9+ $ )+90+9$ (.($' %./

0+99.$' +B%+)+* . '2/2(+ 4. 0*2/+2*. 7&$)*2/+9(*+ ). M'(2/. $4. ).

/$4)$(. ).9 (2(&'$*+9 )+ N.)+* .& O*<-. *+#+*2).9 4. $*(= !P=

!"#$ %%%

!" #"$#"!" %&' ! (#)*+,-!-# (&%,!.

L*(= !K= ?+46&/ 5+4+#J%2. .& 9+*:2,. *+'$(2:. ; 9+<&*2)$)+ 9.%2$' 0.)+*1

9+* %*2$).A /$3.*$). .& +9(+4)2). 9+/ $ 24)2%$,-. )$ #.4(+ )+ %&9(+2. (.($'A

4.9 (+*/.9 ). Qº ). $*(= RSQ )$ T.49(2(&2,-.A $(+4)2)$9 $24)$ $9

+B2<F4%2$9 ). $*(= RU=

Rº " )290+49$)$ )$ %./0+49$,-. *+#+*2)$ 4. $*(= RU . $&/+4(. )+)+90+9$

)+%.**+4(+ )+C

D E %.4%+99-. )+ 5+4+#J%2. $ 7&+/ 9$(29#$,$ $9 %.4)2,H+9 )+ 6$52'2($,-.

0*+:29($ 4$ '+<29'$,-. 0+*(24+4(+G

DD E +B0$49-. 7&$4(2($(2:$ ). $(+4)2/+4(. + ).9 9+*:2,.9 0*+9($).9G

DDD E *+$3&9($/+4(. )+ :$'.* ). 5+4+#J%2. .& 9+*:2,.A $ #2/ )+ 0*+9+*:$* .

9+& :$'.* *+$'=

!º V )290.9(. 4+9(+ $*(2<. $0'2%$89+ $ 5+4+#J%2. .& 9+*:2,. )+ 9$M)+A

0*+:2)F4%2$ + $9929(F4%2$ 9.%2$'A 24%'&92:+ .9 )+9(24$).9 $.9 9+*:2).*+9

0M5'2%.9 + /2'2($*+9A $(2:.9 + 24$(2:.9A + $.9 0+492.429($9=

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 109: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&' (

)*+ ,-*.+/0-1. 2*+ (345.,6-2*+

!"# $%# &'!' ()(*"+ ,(-"' .(* /+012(0(3"'!4 (3"(3,(5-( 1+! "!'3-)(!637*'

8+293":!*' ' (3"!(;' ,( !(79!-+- 7+!!(3"(- +9 ,( 7'1*"'2 ' +9"!+ (3"( ,'

<(,(!'=>+4 ' "?"92+ ,( 7++1(!'=>+4 '9@?2*+ +9 '--*-"637*' )*3'37(*!'4 A9(

3>+ ,(7+!!' ,( ,("(!0*3'=>+ 7+3-"*"97*+3'24 2(;'2 +9 +- ,(-"*3',+- '+

B*-"(0' C3*7+ ,( B'D,(#

E Fº B>+ (@*;637*'- 1'!' ' !('2*G'=>+ ,( "!'3-)(!637*' 8+293":!*'4 '2H0 ,'-

(-"'I(2(7*,'- 3' 2(* ,( ,*!("!*G(- +!='0(3":!*'-J

K L (@*-"637*' ,( ,+"'=>+ (-1(7?)*7'M

KK L NOPQ RST

KKK L +I-(!8U37*' ,+ ,*-1+-"+ 3+ *37*-+ V ,+ '!"# FWX ,' /+3-"*"9*=>+M

KO L 7+01!+8'=>+4 1+! 1'!"( ,+ I(3()*7*:!*+4 ,(J

'T A9( -( '7Y' (0 ,*' A9'3"+ '+ 1';'0(3"+ ,( "!*I9"+-4 (01!H-"*0+- (

)*3'37*'0(3"+- ,(8*,+- '+ (3"( "!'3-)(!*,+!4 I(0 7+0+ A9'3"+ Z 1!(-"'=>+

,( 7+3"'- ,( !(79!-+- '3"(!*+!0(3"( ,(2( !(7(I*,+-M

IT 7901!*0(3"+ ,+- 2*0*"(- 7+3-"*"97*+3'*- !(2'"*8+- Z (,97'=>+ ( Z -'D,(M

7T +I-(!8U37*' ,+- 2*0*"(- ,'- ,?8*,'- 7+3-+2*,',' ( 0+I*2*:!*'4 ,( +1(!'5

=[(- ,( 7!H,*"+4 *3729-*8( 1+! '3"(7*1'=>+ ,( !(7(*"'4 ,( *3-7!*=>+ (0\(-"+-

' &';'! ( ,( ,(-1(-' "+"'2 7+0 1(--+'2M

,T 1!(8*->+ +!='0(3":!*' ,( 7+3"!'1'!"*,'#

E $º ] 8(,',' ' 9"*2*G'=>+ ,( !(79!-+- "!'3-)(!*,+- (0 )*3'2*,',( ,*8(!-' ,'

1'7"9','#

E ^º &'!' )*3- ,' '12*7'=>+ ,'- -'3=[(- ,( -9-1(3->+ ,( "!'3-)(!637*'-

8+293":!*'- 7+3-"'3"(- ,(-"' .(* /+012(0(3"'!4 (@7("9'05-( 'A9(2'- !(2'5

"*8'- ' '=[(- ,( (,97'=>+4 -'D,( ( '--*-"637*' -+7*'2#

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 110: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&' ()

*+ *,-.)/+012 *, 3, 43-2- 5678) 2- 5+3+ 2 -,.23

53)(+*2

!"# $%# &'(")*+,-. &' !'/0!(.( 1+!+2 &)!'"+ .0 )*&)!'"+3'*"'2 /.4!)!

*'/'(()&+&'( &' 1'((.+( 56()/+( .0 &75)/)"( &' 1'((.+( 80!6&)/+( &'9'!: ('!

+0".!);+&+ 1.! <') '(1'/65)/+2 +"'*&'! =( /.*&),>'( '("+4'<'/)&+( *+ <') &'

&)!'"!);'( .!,+3'*":!)+( ' '("+! 1!'9)("+ *. .!,+3'*". .0 '3 ('0( /!7&)".(

+&)/).*+)(#

? @ºA&)(1.(". *. !"#$ +1<)/+B(' + ".&+ + +&3)*)("!+,-. )*&)!'"+2 )*/<0()9'

50*&+,>'( 1C4<)/+( ' '31!'(+( '("+"+)(2 'D/'". *. 'D'!/6/). &' (0+( +"!)40)B

,>'( 1!'/610+(2 +( )*(")"0),>'( 5)*+*/')!+( ' . E+*/. F'*"!+< &. E!+()<#

? $º F.31!''*&'B(' )*/<06&+ + /.*/'((-. &' '31!7(")3.(2 5)*+*/)+3'*".(

' !'5)*+*/)+3'*".(2 )*/<0()9' +( !'(1'/")9+( 1!.!!.G+,>'( ' + /.31.(),-.

&' &69)&+(2 + /.*/'((-. &' (049'*,>'( ' + 1+!")/)1+,-. '3 /.*(")"0),-. .0

+03'*". &' /+1)"+<#

!"# $H# I+ /.*/'((-. &' /!7&)". 1.! '*"' &+ J'&'!+,-. + 1'((.+ 56()/+2 .0

80!6&)/+ K0' *-. '("'8+ (.4 ('0 /.*"!.<' &)!'". .0 )*&)!'".2 .( '*/+!G.(

5)*+*/')!.(2 /.3)((>'( ' &'(1'(+( /.*GL*'!'( *-. ('!-. )*5'!).!'( +.(

&'5)*)&.( '3 <') .0 +. /0(". &' /+1"+,-.#

M+!:G!+5. C*)/.# N'1'*&'3 &' +0".!);+,-. '3 <') '(1'/65)/+ +( 1!.!B

!.G+,>'( ' /.31.(),>'( &' &69)&+( &'/.!!'*"'( &' .1'!+,>'( &' /!7&)".2

4'3 /.3. + /.*/'((-. &' '31!7(")3.( .0 5)*+*/)+3'*".( '3 &'(+/.!&.

/.3 . !"#$2 ('*&. . (04(6&). /.!!'(1.*&'*"' /.*()G*+&. *+ <') .!,+3'*B

":!)+#

!"# $O# P+<9. 3'&)+*"' <') '(1'/65)/+2 *-. 1.&'!-. ('! 0")<);+&.( !'/0!(.(

1C4<)/.(2 )*/<0()9' &' .1'!+,>'( &' /!7&)".2 1+!+ (./.!!'! )*(")"0),>'( &.

P)("'3+ J)*+*/')!. I+/).*+<2 +)*&+ K0' 3'&)+*"' + /.*/'((-. &' '31!7(B

")3.( &' !'/01'!+,-. .0 5)*+*/)+3'*".( 1+!+ 30&+*,+ &' /.*"!.<' +/).B

*:!).#

? @º 1!'9'*,-. &' )*(.<9L*/)+ ' .0"!.( !)(/.( 5)/+!: + /+!G. &' 50*&.(2 '

.0"!.( 3'/+*)(3.(2 /.*(")"06&.( 1'<+( )*(")"0),>'( &. P)("'3+ J)*+*/')!.

I+/).*+<2 *+ 5.!3+ &+ <')#

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 111: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º !"#$%#&% '% !"#$ '(% $)%*+, % -.'/% 0,'&).1 !% -).#"1 !, /%'/,!,)

2# "'#&"&3"45,# 6"'.'/,").# %$,).45,# !, ),!,#/%'&% , !, ,7$)8#&"7%# !,

$).9% "'6,)"%) . &),9,'&%# , #,##,'&. !".#:

!"#$%&' ())

*+ *,()*+ - *. -/*)()*+0-/1.

!"#$ %

*234546728 9:84;!8

;)&: <=: >.). %# ,6,"&%# !,#&. ?," 0%7$1,7,'&.)@ #(% .!%&.!.# .# #,A3"'&,#

!,6"'"45,#B

C D !*E"!. $F+1"/. /%'#%1"!.!. %3 63'!.!.B 7%'&.'&, &%&.1@ .$3).!% #,7

!3$1"/"!.!,@ !.# %+)"A.45,# 6"'.'/,").# !% ,'&, !. G,!,).4(%@ .##37"!.#

,7 E")&3!, !, 1,"#@ /%'&).&%#@ /%'EH'"%# %3 &).&.!%# , !. ),.1"9.4(% !,

%$,).45,# !, /)8!"&%@ $.). .7%)&"9.4(% ,7 $).9% #3$,)"%) . !%9, 7,#,#I

CC D !*E"!. $F+1"/. 7%+"1"J)".B !*E"!. $F+1"/. ),$),#,'&.!. $%) &*&31%#

,7"&"!%# $,1. K'"(%@ "'/13#"E, %# !% -.'/% 0,'&).1 !% -).#"1@ L#&.!%# ,

M3'"/*$"%#I

CCC D %$,).4(% !, /)8!"&%B /%7$)%7"##% 6"'.'/,")% .##37"!% ,7 ).9(% !,

7F&3%@ .+,)&3). !, /)8!"&%@ ,7"##(% , ./,"&, !, &*&31%@ .N3"#"4(% 6"'.'/".!.

!, +,'#@ ),/,+"7,'&% .'&,/"$.!% !,E.1%),# $)%E,'",'&,# !. E,'!. . &,)7%

!, +,'# , #,)E"4%#@ .)),'!.7,'&% 7,)/.'&"1 , %3&).# %$,).45,# .##,7,O

1P.!.#@ "'/13#"E, /%7 % 3#% !, !,)"E.&"E%# 6"'.'/,")%#I

CQ D /%'/,##(% !, A.).'&".B /%7$)%7"##% !, .!"7$1H'/". !, %+)"A.4(%

6"'.'/,"). %3 /%'&).&3.1 .##37"!. $%) ,'&, !. G,!,).4(% %3 ,'&"!.!, . ,1,

E"'/31.!.I

Q D ),6"'.'/".7,'&% !. !*E"!. 7%+"1"J)".B ,7"##(% !, &*&31%# $.). $.A.7,'O

&% !% $)"'/"$.1 ./),#/"!% !. .&3.1"9.4(% 7%',&J)".:

R Sº LN3"$.).O#, . %$,).4(% !, /)8!"&% . .##3'4(%@ % ),/%'P,/"7,'&% %3

. /%'6"##(% !, !*E"!.# $,1% ,'&, !. G,!,).4(%@ #,7 $),T3*9% !% /37$)"O

7,'&% !.# ,U"AH'/".# !%# .)&#: SV , SW:

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 112: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º "#$% &'()*+,- '- ,+.&,- /01)&(- (2'32)&,-,- ,- 4'&52 - $#)-6&.- 7

#8&3352 ,# 6+6*)23 ,# $#3/2'3-1&)&,-,# ,2 9-'(2 :#'6$-) ,2 9$-3&);

<º =-81>8 &'6#?$-8 - ,+.&,- /01)&(- (2'32)&,-,- -3 2/#$-@A#3 ,# ($>,&62

,# /$-B2 &'C#$&2$ - ,2B#8#3#3 (*D-3 $#(#&6-3 6#'E-8 (2'36-,2 ,2 2$@-8#'F

62;

Gº H $#C&'-'(&-8#'62 ,2 /$&'(&/-) ,- ,+.&,- 821&)&%$&- '52 #I(#,#$%J -2

6>$8&'2 ,# (-,- #I#$(+(&2 C&'-'(#&$2J 2 82'6-'6# ,2 C&'-) ,2 #I#$(+(&2

-'6#$&2$J 328-,2 -2 ,-3 2/#$-@A#3 ,# ($>,&62 -*62$&B-,-3 '2 2$@-8#'62

/-$- #36# #C#&62 # #C#6&.-8#'6# $#-)&B-,-3J -($#3(&,2 ,# -6*-)&B-@52 82'#F

6%$&-;

!"#$ %%

!" #$%$&'" () *+$() ,-./$0) ' ()" 12'3)45'" (' 637($&!

K$6; <L; M2 /$-B2 ,# '2.#'6- ,&-3 -/N3 - /*1)&(-@52,#36- O#& :28/)#8#'F

6-$J 2 P$#3&,#'6# ,- Q#/01)&(- 3*18#6#$% -2R

S T "#'-,2 U#,#$-)R /$2/236- ,# )&8&6#3 ?)21-&3 /-$- 2 82'6-'6# ,- ,+.&,-

(2'32)&,-,- ,- 4'&52J V36-,23 # W*'&(+/&23J (*8/$&',2 2 X*# #36-1#)#(#

2 &'(&32 YS ,2 -$6; Z! ,- :2'36&6*&@52J 1#8 (282 ,# )&8&6#3 # (2',&@A#3

$#)-6&.23 -23 &'(&323 YSSJ YSSS # S[ ,2 8#382 -$6&?2\

SS T :2'?$#332 M-(&2'-)R /$2D#62 ,# )#& X*# #36-1#)#@- )&8&6#3 /-$- 2

82'6-'6# ,- ,+.&,- 821&)&%$&- C#,#$-) - X*# 3# $#C#$# 2 &'(&32 [SY ,2 -$6;

G] ,- :2'36&6*&@52J -(28/-'E-,2 ,- ,#82'36$-@52 ,# 3*- -,#X*-@52 -23

)&8&6#3 C&I-,23 /-$- - ,+.&,- (2'32)&,-,- ,- 4'&52J -6#',&,2 2 ,&3/2362 '2

&'(&32 S ,2 ^º ,#36# -$6&?2;

^º K3 /$2/236-3 $#C#$&,-3 '23 &'(&323 S # SS ,2 !"#$ # 3*-3 -)6#$-@A#3

(2'6#$52R

S T ,#82'36$-@52 ,# X*# 23 )&8&6#3 # (2',&@A#3 ?*-$,-8 (2#$_'(&- (28 -3

'2$8-3 #36-1#)#(&,-3 '#36- O#&

:28/)#8#'6-$ # (28 23 21D#6&.23 ,- /2)+6&(- C&3(-)\

SS T #36&8-6&.-3 ,2 &8/-(62 ,- -/)&(-@52 ,23 )&8&6#3 - (-,- *8- ,-3 6$_3

#3C#$-3 ,# ?2.#$'2\

!"#$%& '(

Page 113: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$%&' (& &)&*+,#- ."/./'012/ (& -030+&' (04&"&*50#(/' ./" &'4&"# (&

6/)&"*/7

8 ! 3&+/(/-/60# (& #.,"#12/ (/' "&',-+#(/' ."039"0/ & */30*#-:

; <º =' ."/./'+#' 3&*50/*#(#' */' 0*50'/' & (/ !"#$ +#3>?3 ./(&"2/

'&" #."&'&*+#(#' &3 +&"3/' (& (@)0(# -@A,0(#B &)0(&*50#*(/ # 4/"3# & #

3&+/(/-/60# (& ',# #.,"#12/:

; Cº D' -030+&' (& A,& +"#+#3 /' 0*50'/' & (/ !"#$ '&"2/ 40E#(/' &3

.&"5&*+,#- (# "&5&0+# 5/""&*+& -@A,0(# .#"# 5#(# &'4&"# (& 6/)&"*/ &

#.-05#(/' 06,#-3&*+& # +/(/' /' &*+&' (# F&(&"#12/ A,& # 0*+&6"&3B

5/*'+0+,0*(/B .#"# 5#(# ,3 (&-&'B -030+&' 39E03/':

; Gº H#"# 40*' (& )&"0405#12/ (/ #+&*(03&*+/ (/ -030+&B # #.,"#12/ (/

3/*+#*+& (# (@)0(# 5/*'/-0(#(# '&"9 &4&+,#(# #/ 40*#- (& 5#(# A,#("03&'I

+"&:

; Jº K/ ."#$/ ."&)0'+/ */ #"+: JºB / H"&'0(&*+& (# L&.M>-05# &*)0#"9 #/

N&*#(/ F&(&"#- /, #/ O/*6"&''/ K#50/*#-B 5/*4/"3& / 5#'/B ."/./'+# (&

3#*,+&*12/ /, #-+&"#12/ (/' -030+&' & 5/*(01%&' ."&)0'+/' */' 0*50'/' &

(/ !"#$:

; Pº N&3."& A,& #-+&"#(/' /' 4,*(#3&*+/' (#' ."/./'+#' (& A,& +"#+# &'+&

#"+06/B &3 "#$2/ (& 0*'+#>0-0(#(& &5/*Q305# /, #-+&"#1%&' *#' ./-@+05#'

3/*&+9"0# /, 5#3>0#-B / H"&'0(&*+& (# L&.M>-05# ./(&"9 &*5#30*R#" #/

N&*#(/ F&(&"#- /, #/ O/*6"&''/ K#50/*#- '/-050+#12/ (& "&)0'2/ (/' -030+&':

; Sº D' ."&5#+T"0/' U,(050#0' *2/ .#6/' (,"#*+& # &E&5,12/ (/ /"1#3&*+/

&3 A,& R/,)&"&3 '0(/ 0*5-,@(/' 0*+&6"#3 # (@)0(# 5/*'/-0(#(#B .#"# 40*'

(& #.-05#12/ (/' -030+&':

!"#$ %%%

! "#$%&'()*% '! +,-'! !%. /-0-1#.

="+: CV: N& # (@)0(# 5/*'/-0(#(# (& ,3 &*+& (# F&(&"#12/ ,-+"#.#''#" /

"&'.&5+0)/ -030+& #/ 40*#- (& ,3 A,#("03&'+"&B (&)&"9 '&" # &-& "&5/*(,$0(#

#+? / +?"30*/ (/' +"W' ',>'&AX&*+&'B "&(,$0*(/ / &E5&(&*+& &3 .&-/ 3&*/'

<JY Z)0*+& & 50*5/ ./" 5&*+/[ */ ."03&0"/:

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 114: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º "#$%&#'( )*+,%+&+ ( *-.*//(0 ( *#'* $%* #*1* 2(%3*+ 4#.(++4,(5

6 7 */'&+8 )+(494,( ,* +*&14:&+ ()*+&;<( ,* .+=,4'( 4#'*+#& (% *-'*+#&0

4#.1%/43* )(+ &#'*.4)&;<( ,* +*.*4'&0 +*//&13&,( ( +*>4#&#.4&?*#'( ,(

)+4#.4)&1 &'%&14:&,( ,& ,@34,& ?(94148+4&A

66 7 (9'*+8 +*/%1'&,( )+4?8+4( #*.*//8+4( B +*.(#,%;<( ,& ,@34,& &( 14?4'*0

)+(?(3*#,(0 *#'+* (%'+&/ ?*,4,&/0 14?4'&;<( ,* *?)*#2(0 #& >(+?& ,(

&+'C DºC

Eº F*#.4,( ( )+&:( )&+& +*'(+#( ,& ,@34,& &( 14?4'*0 * *#$%&#'( )*+,%+&+

( *-.*//(0 ( *#'* >4.&+8 '&?9=? 4?)*,4,( ,* +*.*9*+ '+&#/>*+G#.4&/

3(1%#'8+4&/ ,& H#4<( (% ,( "/'&,(C

IºJ/ +*/'+4;K*/ ,( !º &)14.&?L/* 4?*,4&'&?*#'* /* (?(#'&#'* ,& ,@34,&

*-.*,*+ ( 14?4'* #( )+4?*4+( $%&,+4?*/'+* ,( M1'4?( &#( ,( ?&#,&'( ,(

N2*>* ,( O(,*+ "-*.%'43(C

Pº Q R4#4/'=+4( ,& S&:*#,& ,43%1T&+80 ?*#/&1?*#'*0 & +*1&;<( ,(/ *#'*/

$%* '*#2&? %1'+&)&//&,( (/ 14?4'*/ ,&/ ,@34,&/ .(#/(14,&,& * ?(94148+4&C

Uº J/ #(+?&/ ,*/'* &+'4T( /*+<( (9/*+3&,&/ #(/ .&/(/ ,* ,*/.%?)+4?*#'(

,(/ 14?4'*/ ,& ,@34,& ?(94148+4& * ,&/ ()*+&;K*/ ,* .+=,4'( 4#'*+#&/ *

*-'*+#&/C

!"#$ %&

!" #$%&!'(%" )% *&+),-.

'()!"#$ %

! *./-&!-!'0.

J+'C IEC Q R4#4/'=+4( ,& S&:*#,& 3*+4>4.&+8 ( .%?)+4?*#'( ,(/ 14?4'*/ *

.(#,4;K*/ +*1&'43(/ B +*&14:&;<( ,* ()*+&;K*/ ,* .+=,4'( ,* .&,& *#'* ,&

S*,*+&;<(0 4#.1%/43* ,&/ *?)+*/&/ )(+ *1*/ .(#'+(1&,&/0 ,4+*'& (% 4#L

,4+*'&?*#'*C

!ºQ*#'* 4#'*+*//&,( >(+?&14:&+8 /*% )1*4'( >%#,&?*#'&#,(L( *?)&+*.*+

,* /*%/ V+T<(/ '=.#4.(/ * W%+@,4.(/0 ,*?(#/'+&#,( & +*1&;<( .%/'(L9*#*>@L

.4(0 ( 4#'*+*//* *.(#X?4.( * /(.4&1 ,& ()*+&;<( * ( &'*#,4?*#'( ,&/

/*T%4#'*/ .(#,4;K*/5

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 115: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$%&'()$* +" ,-./$* " "#,-"%%* *0&1-$2*341 ,*-* * )1(&-*&*3415 (1 &"#&1

+* 6"$ 1-3*7"(&8-$*5 "7 )-.+$&1% *+$)$1(*$% 10 6"$ "%,")9:$)*;

! $()60%41 (1 1-3*7"(&1 10 "7 )-.+$&1% *+$)$1(*$% +1% -")0-%1% ,-1/"<

($"(&"% +* 1,"-*3415 "#)"&1 (1 )*%1 +" 1,"-*3="% ,1- *(&")$,*341 +"

-")"$&*;

! 1>%"-/?()$* +1% 6$7$&"% " )1(+$3="% :$#*+1% ,"61 @"(*+1 A"+"-*6;

B ! *0&1-$2*341 "%,")9:$)* +1 @"(*+1 A"+"-*65 C0*(+1 %" &-*&*- +" 1,"-*341

+" )-.+$&1 "#&"-(1;

B ! *&"(+$7"(&1 +1 +$%,1%&1 (1 $()$%1 +1 *-&D EFG +* H1(%&$&0$341;

B ! 1>%"-/?()$* +*% +"7*$% -"%&-$3="% "%&*>"6")$+*% ("%&* I"$ H17,6"7"(<

&*-D

J Kº L% 1,"-*3="% -"6*&$/*% M +9/$+* 71>$6$8-$* :"+"-*6 *0&1-$2*+*%5 (1 &"#&1

+* 6"$ 1-3*7"(&8-$* 10 +" )-.+$&1% *+$)$1(*$%5 %"-41 1>N"&1 +" ,-1)"%%1

%$7,6$:$)*+1 C0" *&"(+* M% %0*% "%,")$:$)$+*+"%D

J Oº P*-* :$(% +1 +$%,1%&1 (1 $()$%1 B +1 J Eº5 )1(%$+"-*-<%"<85 "7 )*+*

"#"-)9)$1 :$(*()"$-15 1 &1&*6 +1% -")0-%1% +" 1,"-*3="% +" )-.+$&1 ("6"

$(Q-"%%*+1% " 1 +*% +"%,"%*% +" )*,$&*6 "#")0&*+*%5 1>%"-/*+1 1 %"Q0$(&"R

! (41 %"-41 )17,0&*+*% (*% +"%,"%*% +" )*,$&*6 *% -"*6$2*+*% %1> * :1-7*

+" "7,-.%&$71 10 :$(*()$*7"(&1 * )1(&-$>0$(&"5 )17 1 $(&0$&1 +" ,-171/"-

$()"(&$/1 :$%)*65 &"(+1 ,1- >*%" &-$>0&1 +" )17,"&'()$* +1 "(&" +* A"+"-*<

3415 %" -"%06&*- * +$7$(0$3415 +$-"&* 10 $(+$-"&*5 +1 S(0% +"%&";

! %" 1 "7,-.%&$71 10 :$(*()$*7"(&1 * C0" %" -":"-" 1 $()$%1 :1-

)1()"+$+1 ,1- $(%&$&0$341 :$(*()"$-* )1(&-16*+* ,"61 "(&" +* A"+"-*3415 1

/*61- +* 1,"-*341 %"-8 +"+02$+1 +*% +"%,"%*% +" )*,$&*6;

! TBUVLWXY

J Zº @"7 ,-"N0921 +*% *&-$>0$3="% ,-[,-$*% +1 @"(*+1 A"+"-*6 " +1 \*()1

H"(&-*6 +1 \-*%$65 1 ]$($%&.-$1 +* A*2"(+* ":"&0*-8 1 -"Q$%&-1 "6"&-S($)1

)"(&-*6$2*+1 " *&0*6$2*+1 +*% +9/$+*% ,^>6$)*% $(&"-(* " "#&"-(*5 Q*-*(&$+1

1 *)"%%1 ,^>6$)1 M% $(:1-7*3="%5 C0" $()60$-41R

! "()*-Q1% " )1(+$3="% +" )1(&-*&*341;

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 116: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$%&" #'(#$)*#%&" + $),)'+" -+$#').&" /" %0.)%#" 1&2"&$)%#%# + ,&3)$)4-)#5

&6+-#78+" %+ 1-9%)'& + 1&21+"":& %+ ;#-#2')#"<

= >º ?" 1&2'-#'&" %+ &6+-#7:& %+ 1-9%)'& +@'+-2& 2:& 1&2'+-:& 1$4("($#

A(+ ),6&-'+ 2# 1&,6+2"#7:& #('&,4')1# %+ %93)'&" + 1-9%)'&"<

B-'< CC< B )2"')'()7:& D)2#21+)-# A(+ 1&2'-#'#- &6+-#7:& %+ 1-9%)'& 1&, +2'+

%# E+%+-#7:&5 +@1+'& A(#2%& -+$#').# / %0.)%# ,&3)$)4-)# &( / +@'+-2#5

%+.+-4 +@);)- 1&,6-&.#7:& %+ A(+ # &6+-#7:& #'+2%+ /" 1&2%)78+" + $),)'+"

+"'#3+$+1)%&"<

= Fº B &6+-#7:& -+#$)*#%# 1&, )2D-#7:& %& %)"6&"'& 2+"'# G+) H&,6$+,+2'#-

"+-4 1&2")%+-#%# 2($#5 6-&1+%+2%&I"+ #& "+( 1#21+$#,+2'&5 ,+%)#2'+ #

%+.&$(7:& %& 6-)21)6#$5 .+%#%&" & 6#;#,+2'& %+ J(-&" + %+,#)" +21#-;&"

D)2#21+)-&"<

= Kº L+ # %+.&$(7:& 2:& D&- +D+'(#%# 2& +@+-101)& %+ )2;-+""& %&" -+1(-"&"5

"+-4 1&2");2#%# -+"+-.# +"6+10D)1# 2# $+) &-7#,+2'4-)# 6#-# & +@+-101)&

"+;()2'+<

= Cº M2A(#2'& 2:& +D+'(#%& & 1#21+$#,+2'&5 # #,&-')*#7:&5 &( 1&2"')'(0%#

# -+"+-.#5 #6$)1#,I"+ #" "#278+" 6-+.)"'#" 2&" )21)"&" %& = Cº %& #-'< KC<

= Nº O#,39, "+ 1&2"')'()-4 -+"+-.#5 2& ,&2'#2'+ +A().#$+2'+ #& +@1+""&5

"+ 2:& #'+2%)%& & %)"6&"'& 2& )21)"& %& #-'< FPQ %# H&2"')'()7:&5

1&2")%+-#%#" #" %)"6&")78+" %& = Cº %& #-'< CK<

!"#$%&' ((

!" #$%!&'$"

B-'< CN< ? R#21& H+2'-#$ %& R-#")$ 2:& +,)')-4 '0'($&" %# %0.)%# 6S3$)1# #

6#-')- %+ %&)" #2&" #6T" # 6(3$)1#7:& %+"'# G+) H&,6$+,+2'#-<

B-'< C>< U .+%#%# # -+#$)*#7:& %+ &6+-#7:& %+ 1-9%)'& +2'-+ (, +2'+ %#

E+%+-#7:&5 %)-+'#,+2'+ &( 6&- )2'+-,9%)& %+ D(2%&5 #('#-A()#5 D(2%#7:&

&( +,6-+"# +"'#'#$ %+6+2%+2'+5 + &('-&5 )21$(").+ "(#" +2')%#%+" %#

#%,)2)"'-#7:& )2%)-+'#5 #)2%# A(+ "&3 # D&-,# %+ 2&.#7:&5 -+D)2#21)#,+2'&

&( 6&"'+-;#7:& %+ %0.)%# 1&2'-#0%# #2'+-)&-,+2'+<

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 117: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º "#$%&'()*+% ,( -%,(./0 ( 1'% +% 2%3%2% 0 !"#$ (+ 04%2(.5%+ %6&2%

76+&7&'7./0 376(6$%72( %+&(&(8 % 0'&20 %6&% ,( 9%,%2(./0: 76$8'+7-% +'(+

%6&7,(,%+ ,( (,)767+&2(./0 76,72%&(: 1'% 6/0 +% ,%+&76%) (;

< = 376(6$7(2: ,72%&( 0' 76,72%&()%6&%: ,%+4%+(+ $022%6&%+>

<< = 2%376(6$7(2 ,?-7,(+ 6/0 $06&2(?,(+ @'6&0 A 42B427( 76+&7&'7./0 $06$%,%6*

&%C

Dº E ,7+40+&0 60 !"#$ 6/0 7)4%,% "+&(,0+ % F'67$?470+ ,% $0)42(2

&?&'80+ ,( ,?-7,( ,( G67/0 $0)0 (487$(./0 ,% +'(+ ,7+4067H787,(,%+C

I2&C JKC L 4207H7,( ( 04%2(./0 ,% $2M,7&0 %6&2% ')( 76+&7&'7./0 376(6$%72(

%+&(&(8 % 0 %6&% ,( 9%,%2(./0 1'% ( $06&208%: 6( 1'(87,(,% ,% H%6%37$7N270

,0 %)42M+&7)0C

O(2NP2(30 Q67$0C E ,7+40+&0 60 !"#$ 6/0 420?H% 76+&7&'7./0 376(6$%72(

$06&208(,( ,% (,1'7272: 60 )%2$(,0: &?&'80+ ,( ,?-7,( 4QH87$( 4(2( (&%6,%2

76-%+&7)%6&0 ,% +%'+ $87%6&%+: 0' &?&'80+ ,( ,?-7,( ,% %)7++/0 ,( G67/0 4(2(

(487$(./0 ,% 2%$'2+0+ 42B4270+C

I2&C JRC "1'74(2()*+% ( 04%2(.5%+ ,% $2M,7&0 % %+&/0 -%,(,0+;

< = $(4&(./0 ,% 2%$'2+0+ ( &?&'80 ,% (6&%$74(./0 ,% 2%$%7&( ,% &27H'&0 0'

$06&27H'7./0 $'@0 3(&0 P%2(,02 (76,( 6/0 &%6S( 0$0227,0: +%) 42%@'?T0 ,0

,7+40+&0 60 Rº ,0 (2&C !UV ,( W06+&7&'7./0>

<< = 2%$%H7)%6&0 (6&%$74(,0 ,%-(802%+ ,% %)42%+( %) 1'% 0 O0,%2 OQH87$0

,%&%6S(: ,72%&( 0' 76,72%&()%6&%: ( )(7027( ,0 $(47&(8 +0$7(8 $0) ,72%7&0 (

-0&0: +(8-0 8'$20+ % ,7-7,%6,0+: 6( 302)( ,( 8%P7+8(./0>

<<< = (++'6./0 ,72%&( ,% $0)420)7++0: $0637++/0 ,% ,?-7,( 0' 04%2(./0

(++%)%8S(,(: $0) 3026%$%,02 ,% H%6+: )%2$(,027(+ 0' +%2-7.0+: )%,7(6&%

%)7++/0: ($%7&% 0' (-(8 ,% &?&'80 ,% $2M,7&0: 6/0 +% (487$(6,0 %+&( -%,(./0

( %)42%+(+ %+&(&(7+ ,%4%6,%6&%+>

<X = (++'6./0 ,% 0H27P(./0: +%) ('&027T(./0 02.()%6&N27(: $0) 3026%$%*

,02%+ 4(2( 4(P()%6&0 ( 40+&%27027 ,% H%6+ % +%2-7.0+C

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 118: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&' (((

!" #$%&!'(%" )% *&+),-. $.& /0-%1,$!'2. )% 3%1%,-! #&'!4%0-5&,!

!"# $%# &'(!)*+& ,( -!.,/"& '&! )0"(-/')*+& ,( !(-(/") ,(1"/0)21( )

)"(0,(! /0134/-/50-/) ,( -)/6) ,3!)0"( & (6(!-7-/& 4/0)0-(/!& ( -38'!/!9 )1

(6/:50-/)1 8(0-/&0),)1 0& )!"# $; ( 8)/1 )1 1(:3/0"(1<

= > !()?/@)!21(29 1&8(0"( ) ')!"/! ,& ,.-/8& ,/) ,& /07-/& ,& (6(!-7-/&A

== > ,(B(!9 1(! ?/C3/,),)D -&8 E3!&1 ( &3"!&1 (0-)!:&1 /0-/,(0"(1D )". & ,/)

,(@ ,( ,(@(8F!& ,( -),) )0&A

=== > 0+& 1(!9 )3"&!/@),) 1( 4&!(8 -&F!),&1 &3"!&1 (0-)!:&1 C3( 0+& ) ")6)

,( E3!&1 ,) &'(!)*+&D &F!/:)"&!/)8(0"( '!(4/6),) &3 /0,(6),) G ")6) F91/-)

4/0)0-(/!)D &3 G C3( B/(! ) (1") 13F1"/"3/!A

=H > (1")!9 '!&/F/,)<

)I (0C3)0"& (6/1"/! &'(!)*+& )0"(!/&! ,)8(18) 0)"3!(@) 0+& /0"(:!)?8(0"(

!(1:)"),)A

FI 0& J?"/8& )0& ,( 8)0,)"& ,& K!(1/,(0"(D L&B(!0),&! &3 K!(4(/"&

M30/-/')?#

N Oº 1 &'(!)*P(1 ,( C3( "!)") (1"( )!"/:& 0+& 1(!+& -&8'3"),)1')!) (4(/"&

,& C3( ,/1'P( & /0-/1& === ,& )!"# OQR ,) S&01"/"3/*+&D ,(1,( C3( ?/C3/,),)1

0& '!)@& ,(4/0/,& 0& /0-/1& == ,& !"#$#

N ;º 1 &'(!)*P(1 ,( -!.,/"& '&! )0"(-/')*+& ,( !(-(/") !()?/@),)1 '&!

T1"),&1 &3 M30/-7'/&1 1(!+& (4("3),)1 8(,/)0"( )F(!"3!) ,( -!.,/"& E30"&

G /01"/"3/*+& 4/0)0-(/!) B(0-(,&!) (8 '!&-(11& -&8'("/"/B& (?("!U0/-&

'!&8&B/,& '(?& V)0-& S(0"!)? ,& V!)1/?#

N $º W V)0-& S(0"!)? ,& V!)1/? 8)0"(!9 1/1"(8) ,( )-&8')0X)8(0"& (

-&0"!&?( ,& 1)?,& ,& -!.,/"& )F(!"& (D 0& -)1& ,( /0&F1(!BY0-/) ,&1 ?/8/"(1D

)'?/-)!9 )1 1)0*P(1 -)F7B(/1 G /01"/"3/*+& -!(,&!)#

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 119: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&' ()

!" #$%&!'(%" )*+ * ,!-)* .%-/&!0 1* ,&!"20

!"# $%# &'( ()'( !*+',-*( ./0 *1"* 2' 3*2*!',4/5 / 6'1./ 7*1"!'+ 2/ 6!'(8+

*("9 ():*8"/ ;( <*2',-*( ./1("'1"*( 2/ '!"# $= * 0'8( ;( (*>)81"*(?

@ A ./0B!' 2* "C")+/ 2' 2C<82'5 1' 2'"' 2* ()' ./+/.',4/ 1/ 0*!.'2/5

!*(('+<'2/ / 28(B/("/ 1/ D Eº 2*("* '!"8>/F

@@ A B*!0)"'5 '812' G)* "*0B/!9!8'5 B/! 81"*!0H28/ 2* 81("8")8,4/ I81'1.*8!'

/) 14/5 2* "C")+/ 2' 2C<82' 2* *1"* 2' 3*2*!',4/ B/! "C")+/ 2' 2C<82' BJK+8.'

I*2*!'+5 K*0 ./0/ ' /B*!',4/ 2* ./0B!' * <*12'5 ' "*!0/5 2'G)*+* "C")+/5

.):/ *I*8"/ I81'+ (*:' (*0*+L'1"* ; B*!0)"'F

@@@ A ./1.*((4/ 2* >'!'1"8'#

D Mº N 28(B/("/ 1/ 81.8(/ @@5 81 I81*5 14/ (* 'B+8.' '/ *("/G)* 2* O*"!'( 2/

6'1./ 7*1"!'+ 2/ 6!'(8+5 PH!8* Q(B*.8'+5 *R8("*1"* 1' .'!"*8!' 2'( 81("8")8,-*(

I81'1.*8!'(5 G)* B/2* (*! !*I81'1.8'2/0*28'1"* 1/<'( /B*!',-*( 2* <*12'

' "*!0/#

D Eº N 6'1./ 7*1"!'+ 2/ 6!'(8+ (S B/2*!9 ./0B!'! 28!*"'0*1"* "C")+/(

*08"82/( B*+' T184/ B'!' !*I81'1.8'! ' 2C<82' 0/K8+89!8' I*2*!'+ G)* *("8<*!

<*1.*12/ 1' ()' .'!"*8!'#

D $º /B*!',4/ 0*1.8/1'2' 1/ D Eº 2*<*!9 (*! !*'+8U'2' ; "'R' 0H28' *

./128,-*( '+.'1,'2'( 1/ 28'5 *0 +*8+4/ BJK+8./#

D Vº W <*2'2/ '/ X*(/)!/ &'.8/1'+ '2G)8!8! "C")+/( 2' 2C<82' BJK+8.' I*2*!'+

*R8("*1"*( 1' .'!"*8!' 2/ 6'1./ 7*1"!'+ 2/ 6!'(8+5 '812' G)* ./0 .+9)()+'

2* !*<*!(4/5 ('+</ B'!' !*2)U8! ' 2C<82' 0/K8+89!8'#

$%&' )

! 3!&!-/2! % 1! .*-/&!4!&!-/2!

!"# VY# N( *1"*( B/2*!4/ ./1.*2*! >'!'1"8' *0 /B*!',-*( 2* .!H28"/

81"*!1'( /) *R"*!1'(5 /K(*!<'2/( / 28(B/("/ 1*("* '!"8>/5 '( 1/!0'( 2/ '!"#

$E *5 1/ .'(/ 2' T184/5 "'0KH0 /( +808"*( * '( ./128,-*( *("'K*+*.82/(

B*+/ P*1'2/ 3*2*!'+#

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 120: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º " #$%$&'($ )*'$%+ ,-&.(,(-&$.$ $- -/)%),(0)&'- .) ,-&'%$#$%$&'($1 )0

2$3-% (#4$3 -4 *45)%(-% $- .$ #$%$&'($ $ *)% ,-&,).(.$1 ) 6 $.(0537&,($ .$

)&'(.$.) 84) $ 53)(')$% %)3$'(2$0)&') $ *4$* -9%(#$:;)* <4&'- $- #$%$&'(.-%

) 6* )&'(.$.)* 5-% )*') ,-&'%-3$.$*1 -9*)%2$.- - *)#4(&')=

> ? &@- *)%+ )A(#(.$ ,-&'%$#$%$&'($ .) B%#@-* ) )&'(.$.)* .- 5%B5%(- )&')C

>> ? $ ,-&'%$#$%$&'($ )A(#(.$ 5)3$ D&(@- $ E*'$.- -4 F4&(,G5(-1 -4 5)3-*

E*'$.-* $-* F4&(,G5(-*1 5-.)%+ ,-&*(*'(% &$ 2(&,43$:@- .) %),)('$* '%(94'+H

%($* .(%)'$0)&') $%%),$.$.$* ) 5%-2)&()&')* .) '%$&*/)%7&,($* ,-&*'('4H

,(-&$(*1 ,-0 -4'-%#$ .) 5-.)%)* $- #$%$&'(.-% 5$%$ %)'7H3$* ) )05%)#$% -

%)*5),'(2- 2$3-% &$ 3(84(.$:@- .$ .G2(.$ 2)&,(.$I

Jº K- ,$*- .) -5)%$:@- .) ,%L.('- <4&'- $ -%#$&(*0- /(&$&,)(%- (&')%&$H

,(-&$31 -4 $ (&*'('4(:@- /).)%$3 .) ,%L.('- ) /-0)&'- 5$%$ - %)5$**) .)

%),4%*-* )A')%&-*1 $ D&(@- *B 5%)*'$%+ #$%$&'($ $ )&') 84) $')&.$1 $3L0 .-

.(*5-*'- &- !º1 $* )A(#7&,($* 3)#$(* 5$%$ - %),)9(0)&'- .) '%$&*/)%7&,($*

2-34&'+%($*I

Mº NOEP"QRS

Tº NOEP"QRS

Uº V &43$ $ #$%$&'($ ,-&,).(.$ $,(0$ .-* 3(0(')* /(A$.-* 5)3- W)&$.-

X).)%$3I

Yº V 2).$.- 6* )&'(.$.)* .$ $.0(&(*'%$:@- (&.(%)'$1 (&,34*(2) *4$*

)05%)*$* ,-&'%-3$.$* ) *49*(.(+%($*1 ,-&,).)% #$%$&'($1 $(&.$ 84) ,-0

%),4%*-* .) /4&.-*I

Zº R .(*5-*'- &- Yº &@- *) $53(,$ 6 ,-&,)**@- .) #$%$&'($ 5-%=

> ? )05%)*$ ,-&'%-3$.$ $ *49*(.(+%($ -4 ,-&'%-3$.$ *4$1 &)0 6 5%)*'$:@- .)

,-&'%$#$%$&'($ &$* 0)*0$* ,-&.(:;)*C

>> ? (&*'('4(:@- /(&$&,)(%$ $ )05%)*$ &$,(-&$31 &-* ')%0-* .$ 3)(I

[º EA,)'4$H*) .- .(*5-*'- &)*') $%'(#- $ #$%$&'($ 5%)*'$.$=

> ? 5-% (&*'('4(:;)* /(&$&,)(%$* )*'$'$(*1 84) *) *490)')%@- 6* &-%0$*

$53(,+2)(* 6* (&*'('4(:;)* /(&$&,)(%$* 5%(2$.$*1 .) $,-%.- ,-0 $ 3)#(*3$:@-

5)%'(&)&')C

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 121: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$% &'()*+ '% ,*-.% /# $#( ,#/#-%$+ % #."-#0%0 /# '%12-#3% ,('%'4#(-%

"*- #$% 4*'1-*$%/%0+ /(-#1% # ('/(-#1%.#'1#+ 52%'1* 60 *"#-%78#0 /# 0#92-*

/# 4-:/(1* 6 #;"*-1%7)*<

= >º ?2%'/* @*'-%-#. /AB(/% /# *21-* #'1#+ #. -%3)* /# 9%-%'1(% "-#01%/%+

% &'()* # *0 C01%/*0 "*/#-)* 4*'/(4(*'%- %0 1-%'0,#-D'4(%0 4*'01(124(*'%(0

%* -#00%-4(.#'1* /%52#$# "%9%.#'1*<

= EF< G #'1# /% H#/#-%7)* 42I% /AB(/% 1(B#- 0(/* @*'-%/% "#$% &'()* *2

"*- C01%/*+ #. /#4*--D'4(% /# 9%-%'1(% "-#01%/% #. *"#-%7)* /# 4-:/(1*+

1#-J 020"#'0* * %4#00* % '*B*0 4-:/(1*0 *2 ,('%'4(%.#'1*0 %1: % 1*1%$

$(52(/%7)* /% .#'4(*'%/% /AB(/%<

!"#$ %&

!" #$"%!" & '&(&)

K-1< LE< MNCOKPGQ

K-1< LR< S B#/%/* %* 1(12$%- /# T*/#- *2 U-9)* -#,#-(/* '* %-1< RF+ '*0 V$1(.*0

/*(0 52%/-(.#01-#0 /* 0#2 .%'/%1*+ 4*'1-%(- *W-(9%7)* /# /#0"#0% 52# ')*

"*00% 0#- 42."-(/% ('1#9-%$.#'1# /#'1-* /#$#+ *2 52# 1#'@% "%-4#$%0 %

0#-#. "%9%0 '* #;#-4A4(* 0#92('1# 0#. 52# @%I% 02,(4(#'1# /(0"*'(W($(/%/#

/# 4%(;% "%-% #01# #,#(1*<

T%-J9-%,* V'(4*< X% /#1#-.('%7)* /% /(0"*'(W($(/%/# /# 4%(;% 0#-)* 4*'Y

0(/#-%/*0 *0 #'4%-9*0 # /#0"#0%0 4*."-*.(00%/%0 % "%9%- %1: * ,('%$ /*

#;#-4A4(*<

*&+,%-.! /000

1 234567 '15#087901:

!"#$ &

&" ;"+!<;=;.;>&>$" >$ *&;?&

K-1< LZ< K0 /(0"*'(W($(/%/#0 /# 4%(;% /*0 #'1#0 /% H#/#-%7)* 0#-)* /#"*0(Y

1%/%0 4*',*-.# #01%W#$#4# * = Zº /* %-1< E[L /% \*'01(12(7)*<

= Eº K0 /(0"*'(W($(/%/#0 /# 4%(;% /*0 -#9(.#0 /# "-#B(/D'4(% 0*4(%$+ 9#-%$ #

"-U"-(* /*0 0#-B(/*-#0 "VW$(4*0+ %('/% 52# B('42$%/%0 % ,2'/*0 #0"#4A,(4*0

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 122: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"# $# %#&#%#' ($ %)$* +,- # +./ 0 1(2$)3)"345(6 &37 %5( 0#8($3) 0 $ #'

7(2) $#8 % 0 0 $ 0#' 3$ 03$8(2393:30 0#$ 0# 7 0 #2)# # 8:37 0 $ 2 $

7(2034;#$ 0# '#%7 0(6 7(' (9$#%<=273 0($ :3'3)#$ # 7(2034;#$ 0# 8%()#>

45( # 8%"0?273 &32 27#3% *

@ +º A <#0 0 8:37 45( 0 $ 03$8(2393:30 0#$ 0# !"# )% ) ( @ Bº #'C

D E )F)":($ 0 0F<30 8G9:37 #$) 0" : # '"23738 :6 9#' 7('( #' 4;#$ #

(")%($ 8 8H3$ %#: )3<($ I$ #'8%#$ $ 7(2)%(: 0 $ 8#:( %#$8#7)3<( #2)# 0

J#0#% 45(K

DD E #'8%H$)3'($6 0# !" :!"#% 2 )"%#L 6 ($ $#M"% 0($ # ( N(0#% NG9:37(6

327:"$3<# $" $ #'8%#$ $ 7(2)%(: 0 $*

!"#$ %%

! "#$%$#&!'() *) "!+#,-./,) "012,3)

O%)* ,,* A <#0 0 8:37 45( 0 %#7#3) 0# 7 83) : 0#%3< 0 0 :3#2 45(

0# 9#2$ # 03%#3)($ !"# 32)#M% ' ( 8 )%3'P23( 8G9:37( 8 % ( &32 273 '#2)(

0# 0#$8#$ 7(%%#2)#6 $ :<( $# 0#$)32 0 8(% :#3 ($ %#M3'#$ 0# 8%#<30?273

$(73 :6 M#% : # 8%Q8%3( 0($ $#%<30(%#$ 8G9:37($*

O%)* ,.* R9$#%< 0( ( 03$8($)( 2( @ .º 0( %)* .º6 :#3 (%4 '#2)S%3 # $ 0#

7%H03)($ 0373(2 3$ $Q 327:"3%5( 2(<($ 8%(T#)($ 8Q$ 0#!" 0 '#2)# )#2>

030($ ($ #' 20 '#2)( # 7(2)#'8: 0 $ $ 0#$8#$ $ 0# 7(2$#%< 45( 0(

8 )%3'P23( 8G9:37(6 2($ )#%'($ #' !"# 03$8"$#% :#3 0# 03%#)%3L#$ (%4 >

'#2)S%3 $*

N %SM% &( G237(* R N(0#% UV#7")3<( 0# 7 0 #2)# #27 '32W %S ( X#M3$: >

)3<(6 )H 0 ) 0( #2<3( 0( 8%(T#)( 0# :#3 0# 03%#)%3L#$ (%4 '#2)S%3 $6

%#: )Q%3( 7(' $ 32&(%' 4;#$ 2#7#$$S%3 $ ( 7"'8%3'#2)( 0( 03$8($)( 2#$)#

%)3M(6 ( !" : $#%S 0 0 '8: 03<":M 45(*

O%)* ,Y* A 2":( 0# 8:#2( 03%#3)( )( 0# 0#$ 8%(8%3 45( 0# 3'Q<#: "%9 2(

#V8#030( $#' ( )#203'#2)( 0( 03$8($)( 2( @ Zº 0( %)* B[+ 0 1(2$>

)3)"345(6 (" 8%H<3( 0#8Q$3)( T"0373 : 0( < :(% 0 320#23L 45(*

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 123: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$ %%%

!" #$%&'"!" ()*+&),!-!" %',) .'+)& /01,23)

!"# $%# &'(!&)* +,-"!,.*/* 01& 23!'*! +,-"!*", /& 4&)"5, &' 01& )&

&)"*6&.&7*' ,68&"39,) & '&"*) /& /&)&'(&-:,; -* 2,!'* /* .&3; /3)(,!< /&

*1",-,'3* 4&!&-+3*.; ,!7*'&-"<!3* & 23-*-+&3!*; )&' (!&81=>, /, /3)(,)",

-, 3-+3), ?? /, @ Aº /, *!"# BCA /* D,-)"3"1375,#

E*!<4!*2, F-3+,# &'(!&)* +,-"!,.*/* 3-+.13!< &' )&1) 6*.*-7,) "!3'&)"!*3)

-,"* &G(.3+*"39* &' 01& 3-2,!'*!<H

? I 2,!-&+3'&-", /& 6&-) & )&!937,) *, +,-"!,.*/,!; +,' !&)(&+"39,) (!&7,)

& +,-/37J&); +,'(*!*-/,K,) +,' ,) (!*"3+*/,) -, '&!+*/,L

?? I !&+1!),) !&+&63/,) /, +,-"!,.*/,!; * 01*.01&! "="1.,; &)(&+323+*-/,

9*.,!; 2,-"& & /&)"3-*75,L

??? I 9&-/* /& 6&-); (!&)"*75, /& )&!937,) ,1 +,-+&))5, /& &'(!M)"3',) &

23-*-+3*'&-",) +,' (!&7,); "*G*); (!*>,) ,1 +,-/37J&) /32&!&-"&) /,)

934&-"&) -, '&!+*/,#

(!%4+5,) 67

8 9:8;./8:<;(68= (>;9:>?# # @6.(8?6A8BC>

!"#$ %

! 9&!*"%!&D*32! -! E'"+F) @2"3!,

!"# $N# O5, 3-)"!1'&-",) /& "!*-)(*!P-+3* /* 4&)"5, 23)+*.; *,) 01*3) )&!<

/*/* *'(.* /391.4*75,; 3-+.1)39& &' '&3,) &.&"!Q-3+,) /& *+&)), (F6.3+,H

,) (.*-,); ,!7*'&-",) & .&3) /& /3!&"!3>&) ,!7*'&-"<!3*)L *) (!&)"*7J&) /&

+,-"*) & , !&)(&+"39, (*!&+&! (!M93,L , R&.*"S!3, R&)1'3/, /* TG&+175,

U!7*'&-"<!3* & , R&.*"S!3, /& V&)"5, W3)+*.L & *) 9&!)J&) )3'(.323+*/*)

/&))&) /,+1'&-",)#

E*!<4!*2, F-3+,# "!*-)(*!P-+3* )&!< *))&41!*/* "*'6M''&/3*-"& 3-+&-K

"39, X (*!"3+3(*75, (,(1.*! & !&*.3>*75, /& *1/3P-+3*) (F6.3+*); /1!*-"& ,)

(!,+&)),) /& &.*6,!*75, & /& /3)+1))5, /,) (.*-,); .&3 /& /3!&"!3>&) ,!7*K

'&-"<!3*) & ,!7*'&-",)#

!"#$%& '(

!!

Page 124: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"# $%# & '()"*& *+!,&,)"*-*& +,.( /0,1, -( 2(-,! 34,'5"67( 16'*!8(

-6&+()97,6&: -5!*)", "(-( ( ,4,!'9'6(: )( !,&+,'"67( 2(-,! ;,<6&.*"67( , )(

=!<8( ">')6'( !,&+()&?7,. +,.* &5* ,.*@(!*A8(: +*!* '()&5."* , *+!,'6*A8(

+,.(& '6-*-8(& , 6)&"6"56AB,& -* &('6,-*-,#

2*!?<!*1( C)6'(# +!,&"*A8( -, '()"*& -* D)68( '()",!? -,E()&"!*"67(&

-( F,&(5!(G*'6()*. , -*& *<H)'6*& 16)*)',6!*& (16'6*6& -, 1(E,)"(: 6)'.59-(

( I*)'( G*'6()*. -, J,&,)7(.76E,)"( 3'()KE6'( , L('6*.: ,&+,'616'*)-(

(& ,E+!>&"6E(& , 16)*)'6*E,)"(& '()',-6-(& '(E !,'5!&(& (!65)-(& -(&

(!A*E,)"(& 16&'*. , -* &,<5!6-*-, &('6*. ,: )( '*&( -*& *<H)'6*& 16)*)',6!*&:

*7*.6*A8( '6!'5)&"*)'6*-* -( 6E+*'"( 16&'*. -, &5*& *"676-*-,& )( ,4,!'9'6(#

!"#$ %%

! "#$%&'(%!)*+ , -+.#+/&0!)*+ 0!# -+.'!#

!"# MN# .>E -, (@,-,',! O& -,E*6& )(!E*& -, '()"*@6.6-*-, [email protected]'*: *

,&'!6"5!*A8( -*& '()"*& [email protected]'*& (@&,!7*!? *& &,<56)",&P

Q R * -6&+()[email protected]*-, -, '*64* '()&"*!? -, !,<6&"!( +!=+!6(: -, E(-( S5, (&

!,'5!&(& 76)'5.*-(& * =!<8(: 15)-( (5 -,&+,&* (@!6<*"=!6* 16S5,E 6-,)"616T

'*-(& , ,&'!6"5!*-(& -, 1(!E* 6)-676-5*.6U*-*V

QQ R * -,&+,&* , * *&&5)A8( -, '(E+!(E6&&( &,!8( !,<6&"!*-*& &,<5)-( (

!,<6E, -, '(E+,"H)'6*: *+5!*)-(T&,: ,E '*!?",! '(E+.,E,)"*!: ( !,&5.T

"*-( -(& 1.54(& 16)*)',6!(& +,.( !,<6E, -, '*64*V

QQQ R *& -,E()&"!*AB,& '()"?@,6& '(E+!,,)-,!8(: 6&(.*-* , '()W5)"*E,)",:

*& "!*)&*AB,& , (+,!*AB,& -, '*-* =!<8(: 15)-( (5 ,)"6-*-, -* *-E6)6&T

"!*A8( -6!,"*: *5"?!S56'* , 15)-*'6()*.: 6)'.5&67, ,E+!,&* ,&"*"*. -,+,)T

-,)",V

QX R *& !,',6"*& , -,&+,&*& +!,76-,)'6?!6*& &,!8( *+!,&,)"*-*& ,E -,E()&T

"!*"67(& 16)*)',6!(& , (!A*E,)"?!6(& ,&+,'916'(&V

X R *& (+,!*AB,& -, '!>-6"(: *& 6)&'!6AB,& ,E Y,&"(& * 2*<*! , *& -,E*6&

1(!E*& -, 16)*)'6*E,)"( (5 *&&5)A8( -, '(E+!(E6&&(& W5)"( * ",!',6!(&:

-,7,!8( &,! ,&'!6"5!*-*& -, E(-( * ,76-,)'6*! ( E()"*)", , * 7*!6*A8( -*

-976-* [email protected]'* )( +,!9(-(: -,"*.0*)-(: +,.( E,)(&: * )*"5!,U* , ( "6+( -,

'!,-(!V

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 125: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! " # $%&'()*+#,-' $#) .#+/#,0%) 1#*+/&'(/#/) $#+2 $%)*#34% 5 '+/6%& %

#' $%)*/(' $') +%74+)') 1+'.%(/%(*%) $# #8/%(#,-' $% #*/.')9

: ;º <' 7#)' $#) $%&'()*+#,0%) 7'(=4(*#)> %?784/+@)%@-' #) '1%+#,0%)

/(*+#6'.%+(#&%(*#/)9

: AºB%$/,-' $% ('+&#) 6%+#/) 1#+# 7'()'8/$#,-' $#) 7'(*#) 1CD8/7#) 7#D%+2

#' E+6-' 7%(*+#8 $% 7'(*#D/8/$#$% $# F(/-'> %(34#(*' (-' /&18#(*#$' '

7'()%8G' $% 34% *+#*# ' #+*9 HI9

: Jº B B$&/(/)*+#,-' KCD8/7# &#(*%+2 )/)*%&# $% 74)*') 34% 1%+&/*# #

#.#8/#,-' % ' #7'&1#(G#&%(*' $# 6%)*-' '+,#&%(*2+/#> L/(#(7%/+# %

1#*+/&'(/#89

B+*9 M;9 N K'$%+ O?%74*/.' $# F(/-' 1+'&'.%+2> #*P ' $/# *+/(*# $% =4(G'>

# 7'()'8/$#,-'> (#7/'(#8 % 1'+ %)L%+# $% 6'.%+('> $#) 7'(*#) $') %(*%) $#

Q%$%+#,-' +%8#*/.#) #' %?%+7R7/' #(*%+/'+> % # )4# $/.486#,-'> /(784)/.% 1'+

&%/' %8%*+S(/7' $% #7%))' 1CD8/7'9

: ;º N) O)*#$') % ') T4(/7R1/') %(7#&/(G#+-' )4#) 7'(*#) #' K'$%+

O?%74*/.' $# F(/-' (') )%64/(*%) 1+#U')V

! " T4(/7R1/')> 7'& 7E1/# 1#+# ' K'$%+ O?%74*/.' $' +%)1%7*/.' O)*#$'> #*P

*+/(*# $% #D+/8W

!! " O)*#$')> #*P *+/(*# % 4& $% &#/'9

: AºN $%)74&1+/&%(*' $') 1+#U') 1+%./)*') (%)*% #+*/6' /&1%$/+2> #*P 34%

# )/*4#,-' )%=# +%648#+/U#$#> 34% ' %(*% $# Q%$%+#,-' +%7%D# *+#()L%+X(7/#)

.'84(*2+/#) % 7'(*+#*% '1%+#,0%) $% 7+P$/*'> %?7%*' #) $%)*/(#$#) #' +%L/@

(#(7/#&%(*' $' 1+/(7/1#8 #*4#8/U#$' $# $R./$# &'D/8/2+/#9

!"#$ %%%

! "#$%&'()! "#*+,)-! -% ./#0+12! 3(1%,#4&5()%

B+*9 MA9 N +%8#*E+/' # 34% )% +%L%+% ' : Jº $' #+*9 ;HM $# Y'()*/*4/,-'

#D+#(6%+2 *'$') ') K'$%+%) % ' T/(/)*P+/' KCD8/7'> )%+2 14D8/7#$' #*P *+/(*#

$/#) #1E) ' %(7%++#&%(*' $% 7#$# D/&%)*+% % 7'&1')*' $%V

! " D#8#(,' '+,#&%(*2+/'> 34% %)1%7/L/7#+2> 1'+ 7#*%6'+/# %7'(S&/7#> #)V

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 126: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$#%& ' ()" *)+&#, %+*)"- +.) ' "# /%0 . ' # "# /%0 ", 1#- $)-)

("#2%'3) &4 /%0 . 5

1! .#'(#' ' ()" 6"4() .# + &4"#0 , .%'$"%-%+ +.) .)& 73) ( " )

#8#"$9$%), .#'(#' /%:4%. . # ) ' /.)5

;; < .#-)+'&" &%2)' . #8#$473) . '=

! "#$#%& ', ()" $ &#6)"% #$)+>-%$ # *)+&#, #'(#$%*%$ +.) ("#2%'3)

%+%$% /, ("#2%'3) &4 /%0 . ( " ) #8#"$9$%), "#$#%& "# /%0 . +)

1%-#'&"#, "# /%0 . +) #8#"$9$%) # ("#2%'3) "# /%0 "5

1! .#'(#' ', ()" $ &#6)"% #$)+>-%$ # 6"4() .# + &4"#0 . .#'(#' ,

.%'$"%-%+ +.) .)& 73) %+%$% /, .)& 73) ( " ) #8#"$9$%), .#'(#' ' #-(#?

+@ . # /%:4%. . , +) 1%-#'&"# # +) #8#"$9$%)5

$! .#'(#' ', ()" *4+73) # '41*4+73)A

B CºD' 2 /)"#' "#*#"#+&#' ) "#*%+ +$% -#+&) . .92%. -)1%/%E"% $)+'& "3)

.#'& $ . -#+&# + ' "#$#%& ' .# )(#" 7F#' .# $"G.%&) # + ' .#'(#' ' $)-

-)"&%0 73) . .92%. A

B Hº D .#'$4-("%-#+&) .) (" 0) ("#2%'&) +#'&# "&%6) '4I#%& ) #+&# J'

' +7F#' ("#2%'& ' +) B Hº .) "&A KCA

L"&A KMA L$)-( +@ "3) ) N#/ &O"%) N#'4-%.) .#-)+'&" &%2)' "#/ &%2)' =

; < (4" 73) . "#$#%& $)""#+&# /9:4%. , + *)"- .#*%+%. +) %+$%') ;P .)

"&A Hº, '4 #2)/473), ''%- $)-) ("#2%'3) .# '#4 .#'#-(#+@) &G ) *%+ /

.) #8#"$9$%)5

;; < "#$#%& ' # .#'(#' ' ("#2%.#+$%E"% ' :4# '# "#*#"# ) %+$%') ;P .) "&A

KQ5

;;; < "#'4/& .)' +)-%+ / # ("%-E"%)5

;P < .#'(#' ' $)- I4")', + *)"- .) %+$%') ;; .) "&A Rº5

P < N#'&)' S 6 ", .#& /@ +.), ()" S).#" # O"63) "#*#"%.) +) "&A HQ, )'

2 /)"#' %+'$"%&)', )' ( 6 -#+&)' "# /%0 .)' # ) -)+& +&# ( 6 "A

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 127: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º " #$%&'(#)* #$+$#$,'$ &* -%').* /).$0'#$ 1* $2$#343)* 0$#5 &3*.6&7

,8&1* '&./9. 1$ 1$.*,0'#&'):*0;

< = 1* &'$,1).$,'* 1* 1)06*0'* ,* ),3)0* <<< 1* &#'> !?@ 1& A*,0')'B)CD*E

3*,+*#.$ * Fº 1* &#'> FGH

<< = 1&0 6#*I$CJ$0 &'B&#)&)0 1*0 #$K).$0 1$ 6#$:)1L,3)& 0*3)&%E K$#&% $ 6#(6#)*

1*0 0$#:)1*#$0 6-/%)3*0H

<<< = 1& :&#)&CD* 6&'#).*,)&%E $:)1$,3)&,1* & &%)$,&CD* 1$ &'):*0 $ &

&6%)3&CD* 1*0 #$3B#0*0 1$%& 1$3*##$,'$0>

Gº MB&,1* +*# * 3&0*E 0$#D* &6#$0$,'&1&0 IB0')+)3&'):&0;

< = 1& %).)'&CD* 1$ $.6$,8*H

<< = 1& +#B0'#&CD* 1$ #$3$)'&0E $06$3)+)3&,1* &0 .$1)1&0 1$ 3*./&'$ N

0*,$K&CD* $ N $:&0D* +)03&%E &1*'&1&0 $ & &1*'&#E $ &0 &CJ$0 1$ +)03&%)O&CD*

$ 3*/#&,C&>

!"#$ %&

! "#$%&'()! *# +#,&-! .),/%$

P#'> QR> P* +),&% 1$ 3&1& SB&1#).$0'#$ 0$#5 $.)')1* 6$%*0 ')'B%&#$0 1*0

T*1$#$0 $ (#KD*0 #$+$#)1*0 ,* &#'> GU V$%&'(#)* 1$ W$0'D* X)03&%E &00),&1*

6$%*;

< = A8$+$ 1* T*1$# Y2$3B'):*H

<< = T#$0)1$,'$ $ 1$.&)0 .$./#*0 1& Z$0& [)#$'*#& *B (#KD* 1$3)0(#)*

$SB):&%$,'$E 3*,+*#.$ #$K).$,'*0 ),'$#,*0 1*0 (#KD*0 1* T*1$# \$K)0%&'):*H

<<< = T#$0)1$,'$ 1$ ]#)/B,&% $ 1$.&)0 .$./#*0 1$ A*,0$%8* 1$ P1.),)07

'#&CD* *B (#KD* 1$3)0(#)* $SB):&%$,'$E 3*,+*#.$ #$K).$,'*0 ),'$#,*0 1*0

(#KD*0 1* T*1$# ^B1)3)5#)*H

<_ = A8$+$ 1* Z),)0'9#)* T-/%)3*E 1& `,)D* $ 1*0 Y0'&1*0>

T&#5K#&+* -,)3*> " #$%&'(#)* '&./9. 0$#5 &00),&1* 6$%&0 &B'*#)1&1$0

#$06*,05:$)0 6$%& &1.),)0'#&CD* +),&,3$)#& $ 6$%* 3*,'#*%$ ),'$#,*E /$.

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 128: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"! #!$ !%&$'( )*+,-,)'( #!$ '&! #$.#$,! )* ')' /!)*$ !% .$01! $*+*$,)!

-! '$&2 342

5$&2 662 7 $*8'&.$,! !-&*$9:

; < !"#'$'&,=! !" !( 8,",&*( )* >%* &$'&' *(&' ?*, @!"#8*"*-&'$A )!(

(*0%,-&*( "!-&'-&*(:

'B )*(#*(' &!&'8 !" #*((!'8A ),(&,-0%,-)! ' !" ,-'&,=!( * #*-(,!-,(&'(C

DB )E=,)'( !-(!8,)')' * "!D,8,9$,'C

B !- *((1! )* 0'$'-&,'(C

)B !#*$'FG*( )* $H),&!A ,- 8%(,=* #!$ '-&* ,#'F1! )* $* *,&'C

*B )*(#*('( )* >%* &$'&' ! ,- ,(! ;; )! '$&2 IºC

;; < ,-), 'F1! )'( "*),)'( !$$*&,='( ')!&')'( !% ' ')!&'$A (* %8&$'#'((')!

>%'8>%*$ )!( 8,",&*(C

;;; < )*"!-(&$'&,=!(A -! J8&,"! >%')$,"*(&$*:

'B )! "!-&'-&* )'( ),(#!-,D,8,)')*( )* ',K' *" &$,-&' * %" )* )*L*"D$!C

DB )' ,-( $,F1! *" M*(&!( ' /'0'$A )'( )*(#*('(:

NB 8,>%,)')'(C

3B *"#*-O')'( * -1! 8,>%,)')'(A ,-( $,&'( #!$ '&*-)*$*" ' %"' )'(

!-),FG*( )! ,- ,(! ;; )! '$&2 INC

PB *"#*-O')'( * -1! 8,>%,)')'(A ,-( $,&'( '&H ! 8,",&* )! ('8)! )' ),(Q

#!-,D,8,)')* )* ',K'C

IB -1! ,-( $,&'( #!$ +'8&' )* ),(#!-,D,8,)')* )* ',K' * %R!( *"#*-O!(

+!$'" '- *8')!(C

B )! %"#$,"*-&! )! ),(#!(&! -! ,- ,(! ;; * -' '8E-*' )! ,- ,(! ;S )!

'$&2 PT2

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 129: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º " #$%&'(#)* +*, ')'-%&#$, +*, (#./*, 0$12)*1&+*, 1*, )12),*, 334 333 $ 35

+* &#'6 78 2*1'$#9 &:$1&, &, )1;*#0&<=$, #$%&')>&, ? &%@1$& & +* )12),* 34 $

*, +*2-0$1'*, #$;$#)+*, 1*, )12),*, 33 $ 3336

Aº " #$%&'(#)* ,$#9 :-B%)2&+* &'C '#)1'& +)&, &:(, * $12$##&0$1'* +*

:$#@*+* & D-$ 2*##$,:*1+$#4 2*0 &0:%* &2$,,* &* :EB%)2*4 )12%-,)>$ :*#

0$)* $%$'#F1)2*6

Gº " +$,2-0:#)0$1'* +* :#&H* & D-$ ,$ #$;$#$ * Aº ,-I$)'& * $1'$ ?

,&1</* :#$>),'& 1* A* +* &#'6 7!6

8º ", #$%&'(#)*, #$;$#)+*, 1*, &#',6 7A $ 78 +$>$#/* ,$# $%&B*#&+*, +$

;*#0& :&+#*1)H&+&4 ,$.-1+* 0*+$%*, D-$ :*+$#/* ,$# &'-&%)H&+*, :$%*

2*1,$%J* +$ D-$ '#&'& * &#'6 KL6

!"#$ %

!" #$%"&!'(%" )% *+,&!"

M#'6 7K6 M, 2*1'&, :#$,'&+&, :$%*, NJ$;$, +* O*+$# PQ$2-')>* )12%-)#/*4 &%C0

+&, ,-&, :#(:#)&,4 &, +*, O#$,)+$1'$, +*, (#./*, +*, O*+$#$, R$.),%&')>* $

S-+)2)9#)* $ +* NJ$;$ +* T)1),'C#)* OEB%)2*4 #$;$#)+*, 1* &#'6 AU4 &, D-&),

#$2$B$#/* :&#$2$# :#C>)*4 ,$:&#&+&0$1'$4 +* #$,:$2')>* V#)B-1&% +$ N*1'&,6

!º M, 2*1'&, +* O*+$# S-+)2)9#)* ,$#/* &:#$,$1'&+&, 1* W0B)'*X

3 Y +&Z1)/*4 :$%*, O#$,)+$1'$, +* [-:#$0* V#)B-1&% \$+$#&% $ +*, V#)B-1&),

[-:$#)*#$,4 2*1,*%)+&1+* &, +*, #$,:$2')>*, '#)B-1&),]

33 Y +*, P,'&+*,4 :$%*, O#$,)+$1'$, +*, V#)B-1&), +$ S-,')<&4 2*1,*%)+&1+* &,

+*, +$0&), '#)B-1&),6

Aº " :&#$2$# ,*B#$ &, 2*1'&, +*, V#)B-1&), +$ N*1'&, ,$#9 :#*;$#)+* 1*

:#&H* :#$>),'* 1* &#'6 7L :$%& 2*0),,/* 0),'& :$#0&1$1'$ #$;$#)+& 1* !*

+* &#'6 !KK +& N*1,')'-)</* *- $D-)>&%$1'$ +&, N&,&, R$.),%&')>&, $,'&+-&),

$ 0-1)2):&),6

Gº [$#9 +&+& &0:%& +)>-%.&</* +*, #$,-%'&+*, +& &:#$2)&</* +&, 2*1'&,4

I-%.&+&, *- '*0&+&,6

M#'6 7L6 ", V#)B-1&), +$ N*1'&, $0)')#/* :&#$2$# :#C>)* 2*12%-,)>* ,*B#$

&, 2*1'&, 1* :#&H* +$ ,$,,$1'& +)&, +* #$2$B)0$1'*4 ,$ *-'#* 1/* $,')>$#

$,'&B$%$2)+* 1&, 2*1,')'-)<=$, $,'&+-&), *- 1&, %$), *#.W1)2&, 0-1)2):&),6

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 130: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!º ! "#$! %& '()*"+,*!$ -(& ).! $&/#0 "#,*1#*$ & -(& 1&)2#0 0&)!$

%& %(3&)1!$ 0*4 2#5*1#)1&$ ! ,6#3! $&67 %& "&)1! & !*1&)1# %*#$8

9 :º ;$ <6*5()#*$ %& =!)1#$ ).! &)16#6.! &0 6&"&$$! &)-(#)1! &>*$1*6&0

"!)1#$ %& ?!%&6@ !( A6B.! 6&C&6*%! )! #618 :D@ ,&)%&)1&$ %& ,#6&"&6 ,6EF*!8

G618 HI8 G ,6&$1#J.! %& "!)1#$ &F*%&)"*#67 ! %&$&0,&)2! %# #66&"#%#J.!

&0 6&4#J.! K ,6&F*$.!@ %&$1#"#)%! #$ ,6!F*%L)"*#$ #%!1#%#$ )! M05*1! %#

C*$"#4*3#J.! %#$ 6&"&*1#$ & "!05#1& K $!)&B#J.!@ #$ #JN&$ %& 6&"(,&6#J.!

%& "6E%*1!$ )#$ *)$1M)"*#$ #%0*)*$16#1*F# & /(%*"*#4@ 5&0 "!0! #$ %&0#*$

0&%*%#$ ,#6# *)"6&0&)1! %#$ 6&"&*1#$ 16*5(176*#$ & %& "!)16*5(*JN&$8

!"#$ %&

! "#$%!&#'!()* +! ,-$.)* "#$%!&

G618 HO8 ; ?!%&6 P&B*$4#1*F!@ %*6&1#0&)1& !( "!0 ! #(>+4*! %!$ <6*5()#*$

%& =!)1#$@ & ! $*$1&0# %& "!)16!4& *)1&6)! %& "#%# ?!%&6 & %! '*)*$1E6*!

?Q54*"!@ C*$"#4*3#6.! ! "(0,6*0&)1! %#$ )!60#$ %&$1# P&* =!0,4&0&)1#6@

"!0 L)C#$& )! -(& $& 6&C&6& #R

S T #1*)B*0&)1! %#$ 0&1#$ &$1#5&4&"*%#$ )# 4&* %& %*6&16*3&$ !6J#0&)176*#$U

SS T 4*0*1&$ & "!)%*JN&$ ,#6# 6&#4*3#J.! %& !,&6#JN&$ %& "6E%*1! & *)$"6*J.!

&0 V&$1!$ # ?#B#6U

SSS T 0&%*%#$ #%!1#%#$ ,#6# ! 6&1!6)! %# %&$,&$# 1!1#4 "!0 ,&$$!#4 #!

6&$,&"1*F! 4*0*1&@ )!$ 1&60!$ %!$ #61$8 :: & :WU

SX T ,6!F*%L)"*#$ 1!0#%#$@ "!)C!60&!%*$,!$1! )! #618 WY@ ,#6# 6&"!)%(J.!

%!$ 0!)1#)1&$ %#$ %+F*%#$ "!)$!4*%#%# & 0!5*4*76*# #!$ 6&$,&"1*F!$ 4*0*1&$U

X T %&$1*)#J.! %& 6&"(6$!$ !51*%!$ "!0 # #4*&)#J.! %& #1*F!$@ 1&)%! &0

F*$1# #$ 6&$16*JN&$ "!)$1*1("*!)#*$ & #$ %&$1# P&* =!0,4&0&)1#6U

XS T "(0,6*0&)1! %! 4*0*1& %& B#$1!$ 1!1#*$ %!$ 4&B*$4#1*F!$ 0()*"*,#*$@

-(#)%! 2!(F&68

9 Yº;$ <6*5()#*$ %& =!)1#$ #4&61#6.! !$ ?!%&6&$ !( A6B.!$ 6&C&6*%!$ )! #618

:D -(#)%! "!)$1#1#6&0R

S T # ,!$$*5*4*%#%& %& !"!66L)"*# %#$ $*1(#JN&$ ,6&F*$1#$ )! *)"*$! SS %! #618

Zº & )! #618 OºU

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 131: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$ % &%'()'($ *) *$+,$+) (%()- .%& ,$++%)- #-(/),)++%# 012 3'%4$'()

,%/ .$'(%5 *% -6&6($7

! "#$ %+ &%'()'($+ *)+ *846*)+ .%'+%-6*)*) $ &%96-6:/6); *)+ %,$/)<=$+

*$ ./>*6(% $ *) .%'.$++?% *$ @)/)'(6) +$ $'.%'(/)& ).6&) *$ 012 3'%4$'()

,%/ .$'(%5 *%+ /$+,$.(64%+ -6&6($+7

A ! "#$ %+ @)+(%+ .%& 6')(64%+ $ ,$'+6%'6+()+ +$ $'.%'(/)& ).6&) *% -6&6($

*$B6'6*% $& -$67

A ! B)(%+ "#$ .%&,/%&$()& %+ .#+(%+ %# %+ /$+#-()*%+ *%+ ,/%@/)&)+ %#

6'*8.6%+ *$ 6//$@#-)/6*)*$+ ') @$+(?% %/<)&$'(:/6)C

D Eº F%&,$($ )6'*) )%+ G/69#')6+ *$ F%'()+ 4$/6B6.)/ %+ .:-.#-%+ *%+ -6&6($+

*) *$+,$+) (%()- .%& ,$++%)- *$ .)*) H%*$/ $ I/@?% /$B$/6*% '% )/(C E1C

D Jº K G/69#')- *$ F%'()+ *) L'6?% ).%&,)'M)/: % .#&,/6&$'(% *%

*6+,%+(% '%+ DD Eº; Jº $ Nº *% )/(C J0C

!"#$%&' (

)*+,-+*./0+ 1*23*+ 0 4532+*465*3+

O/(C P1C Q$6 $+()*#)- %# &#'6.6,)- ,%*$/: B6R)/ -6&6($+ 6'B$/6%/$+ S"#$-$+

,/$46+(%+ '$+() Q$6 F%&,-$&$'()/ ,)/) )+ *846*)+ .%'+%-6*)*) $ &%96-6:/6);

%,$/)<=$+ *$ ./>*6(% $ .%'.$++?% *$ @)/)'(6)+C

O/(C PTC K+ (8(#-%+ *) *846*) ,U9-6.); *$+*$ "#$ *$46*)&$'($ $+./6(#/)*%+

$& +6+($&) .$'(/)-6V)*% *$ -6"#6*)<?% $ .#+(I*6); ,%*$/?% +$/ %B$/$.6*%+

$& .)#<?% ,)/) @)/)'(6) *$ $&,/>+(6&%+; %# $& %#(/)+ (/)'+)<=$+ ,/$46+()+

$& -$6; ,$-% +$# 4)-%/ $.%'W&6.%; .%'B%/&$ *$B6'6*% ,$-% X6'6+(>/6% *)

Y)V$'*)C

O/(C PEC K+ X#'6.8,6%+ +I .%'(/69#6/?% ,)/) % .#+($6% *$ *$+,$+)+ *$

.%&,$(Z'.6) *$ %#(/%+ $'($+ *) Y$*$/)<?% +$ M%#4$/[

! )#(%/6V)<?% ') -$6 *$ *6/$(/6V$+ %/<)&$'(:/6)+ $ ') -$6 %/<)&$'(:/6) )'#)-7

! .%'4Z'6%; ).%/*%; )\#+($ %# .%'@Z'$/$; .%'B%/&$ +#) -$@6+-)<?%C

O/(C PJC ] B).#-()*% )%+ X#'6.8,6%+ .%& ,%,#-)<?% 6'B$/6%/ ) .6'"^$'() &6-

M)96()'($+ %,()/ ,%/[

! ),-6.)/ % *6+,%+(% '% )/(C EE $ '% D Nº *% )/(C J1 )% B6')- *% +$&$+(/$7

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 132: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! "#$%&'() *+,+*-)(&,+.-+/

(0 12345670

80 9 :+&(-;)#9 "+ <+*-=9 >#*?(&@

?0 9* "+,9.*-)(-#$9* "+ A%+ -)(-( 9 ()-B CD@

! +&(89)() 9 5.+E9 "+ F9&G-#?( >#*?(& "9 H&(.9 H&%)#(.%(&I 9 5.+E9 "+

J+-(* >#*?(#* + 9 5.+E9 "+ :#*?9* >#*?(#* "( &+# "+ "#)+-)#K+* 9)L(,+.-M)#(*

+ 9 (.+E9 "+ A%+ -)(-( 9 #.?#*9 "9 ()-B Cº ( H()-#) "9 A%#.-9 +E+)?G?#9

*+'%#.-+ (9 "( H%8&#?(L=9 "+*-( N+# O9,H&+,+.-()B

P Qº 5 "#$%&'(L=9 "9* )+&(-;)#9* + "+,9.*-)(-#$9* "+$+)M *+) )+(&#K("( +,

(-R -)#.-( "#(* (H;* 9 +.?+))(,+.-9 "9 *+,+*-)+B

P Sº T+ %&-)(H(**("9* 9* &#,#-+* )+&(-#$9* U "+*H+*( -9-(& ?9, H+**9(& 9% U

"G$#"( ?9.*9&#"("(I +.A%(.-9 H+)"%)() +*-( *#-%(L=9I 9 J%.#?GH#9 V#?()M

*%W+#-9 (9* ,+*,9* H)(K9* "+ $+)#V#?(L=9 + "+ )+-9).9 (9 &#,#-+ "+V#.#"9*

H()( 9* "+,(#* +.-+*B

5)-B XYB 5 Z.#=9 H)+*-()M (**#*-[.?#( -R?.#?( + ?99H+)(L=9 V#.(.?+#)( (9*

J%.#?GH#9* H()( ( ,9"+).#K(L=9 "(* )+*H+?-#$(* (",#.#*-)(L\+* -)#8%-M)#(I

V#.(.?+#)(I H(-)#,9.#(& + H)+$#"+.?#M)#(I ?9, $#*-(* (9 ?%,H)#,+.-9 "(*

.9),(* "+*-( N+# O9,H&+,+.-()B

P Qº 5 (**#*-[.?#( -R?.#?( ?9.*#*-#)M .9 -)+#.(,+.-9 + "+*+.$9&$#,+.-9 "+

)+?%)*9* ]%,(.9* + .( -)(.*V+)[.?#( "+ -+?.9&9'#(I 8+, ?9,9 .9 (H9#9 U

"#$%&'(L=9 "9* #.*-)%,+.-9* "+ A%+ -)(-( 9 ()-B Y^ +, ,+#9 +&+-)_.#?9 "+

(,H&9 (?+**9 H`8&#?9B

P Sº 5 ?99H+)(L=9 V#.(.?+#)( ?9,H)++."+)M ( "9(L=9 "+ 8+.* + $(&9)+*I 9

V#.(.?#(,+.-9 H9) #.-+),R"#9 "(* #.*-#-%#L\+* V#.(.?+#)(* V+"+)(#* + 9

)+H(**+ "+ )+?%)*9* 9)#%."9* "+ 9H+)(L\+* +E-+).(*B

5)-B XCB a( 9?9))[.?#( "+ ?(&(,#"("+ H`8&#?( )+?9.]+?#"( H+&9 O9.')+**9

a(?#9.(&I .9 ?(*9 "( Z.#=9I 9% H+&(* 5**+,8&R#(* N+'#*&(-#$(*I .( ]#H;-+*+

"9* 3*-("9* + J%.#?GH#9*I +.A%(.-9 H+)"%)() ( *#-%(L=9/

! *+)=9 *%*H+.*(* ( ?9.-('+, "9* H)(K9* + (* "#*H9*#L\+* +*-(8+&+?#"(*

.9* ()-*B SDI DQ + bc@

! *+)=9 "#*H+.*("9* 9 (-#.'#,+.-9 "9* )+*%&-("9* V#*?(#* + ( &#,#-(L=9 "+

+,H+.]9 H)+$#*-( .9 ()-B dºB

!"#$%& '(

!

Page 133: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$"!%& '()*&+ ,-.)*!/01 & 2)0-&03& (& !"#$ (& *!0& 21 103!2& 21 21%10!

&4 21 053)&6 21*"13!2& (! %&"7! 2! 8&(03)34)9:&+

,"3+ ;;+ <0 -"!=&0 103!>1.1*)2&0 (&0 !"30+ ?@6 @A 1 BC 01":& 24-.)*!2&0 (&

*!0& 21 *"10*)71(3& "1!. >!)D& &4 (1$!3)E& 2& "&243& F(31"(& G"43& H FGI

(!*)&(!.6 "1$)&(!. &4 103!24!. -&" -1"5&2& )$4!. &4 04-1")&" ! J4!3"&

3")7103"10+

K Aº L(31(21/01 -&" >!)D& *"10*)71(3& ! 3!D! 21 E!")!9:& "1!. !*474.!2!

2& "&243& F(31"(& G"43& )(%1")&" ! AM H47 -&" *1(3&I6 (& -1"5&2&

*&""10-&(21(31 !&0 J4!3"& '.3)7&0 3")7103"10+

K ?º , 3!D! 21 E!")!9:& 01"# !J41.! !-4"!2! -1.! N4(2!9:& F(03)343&

G"!0).1)"& 21 O1&$"!%)! 1 L03!3503)*! &4 &43"& P"$:& J41 E)1" ! 04>03)345/.!6

!2&3!2! ! 7107! 713&2&.&$)! -!"! !-4"!9:& 2&0 FG (!*)&(!.6 103!24!. 1

"1$)&(!.+

K @º Q! R)-P3101 2& !"#$6 *&(3)(4!":& ! 01" !2&3!2!0 !0 712)2!0 -"1E)03!0

(& !"3+ ??+

K Sº Q! R)-P3101 21 01 E1")%)*!"17 742!(9!0 2"#03)*!0 (! *&(249:& 2!0

-&.53)*!0 7&(13#")! 1 *!7>)!.6 "1*&(R1*)2!0 -1.& T1(!2& N121"!.6 & -"!=&

"1%1")2& (& !"#$ 2& !"3+ @A -&21"# 01" !7-.)!2& 17 !3U J4!3"& J4!2")710/

3"10+

,"3+ ;B+ < !*&7-!(R!71(3& 1 ! !E!.)!9:&6 21 %&"7! -1"7!(1(316 2!

-&.53)*! 1 2! &-1"!*)&(!.)2!21 2! $103:& %)0*!. 01":& "1!.)=!2&0 -&" *&(01.R&

21 $103:& %)0*!.6 *&(03)3452& -&" "1-"101(3!(310 21 3&2&0 &0 &21"10 1 10%1"!0

21 O&E1"(&6 2& V)()03U")& '>.)*& 1 21 1(3)2!210 3U*()*!0 "1-"101(3!3)E!0

2! 0&*)12!216 E)0!(2& !W

F X R!"7&()=!9:& 1 *&&"21(!9:& 1(3"1 &0 1(310 2! N121"!9:&Y

FF X 2)0017)(!9:& 21 -"#3)*!0 J41 "104.317 177!)&" 1%)*)Z(*)! (! !.&*!9:&

1 1D1*49:& 2& $!03& -'>.)*&6 (! !""1*!2!9:& 21 "1*1)3!06 (& *&(3"&.1 2&

1(2)E)2!71(3& 1 (! 3"!(0-!"Z(*)! 2! $103:& %)0*!.Y

FFF X !2&9:& 21 (&"7!0 21 *&(0&.)2!9:& 2!0 *&(3!0 -'>.)*!06 -!2"&()=!9:&

2!0 -"103!9[10 21 *&(3!0 1 2&0 "1.!3P")&0 1 217&(03"!3)E&0 21 $103:& %)0*!.

21 J41 3"!3! 103! \1) 8&7-.171(3!"6 (&"7!0 1 -!2"[10 7!)0 0)7-.10 -!"!

&0 -1J41(&0 V4()*5-)&06 >17 *&7& &43"&06 (1*100#")&0 !& *&(3"&.1 0&*)!.Y

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 134: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! " #$%&'()*+, #- )./'$0-01 -02&#,0 - #$)(.302$4,05

6 7º 8 4,.0-'9, ) :&- 0- ;-<-;- , !"#$ $.02$2&$;/ <,;=)0 #- >;-=$)*+, -

;-4,.9-4$=-.2, >?@'$4, ),0 2$2&');-0 #- A,#-; :&- )'4).*);-= ;-0&'2)#,0

=-;$23;$,0 -= 0&)0 >,'B2$4)0 #- #-0-.%,'%$=-.2, 0,4$)'1 4,.C&()#,0 4,= )

>;/2$4) #- &=) (-02+, <$04)' >)&2)#) >-')0 .,;=)0 #-02) D-$ E,=>'-=-.2);5

6 Fº D-$ #$0>,;/ 0,@;- ) 4,=>,0$*+, - ) <,;=) #- <&.4$,.)=-.2, #,

4,.0-'9,5

G;25 HI5 J) <,;=) #, );25 FKL #) E,.02$2&$*+,1 M 4;$)#, , N&.#, #, O-($=-

P-;)' #- A;-%$#Q.4$) R,4$)'1 %$.4&')#, ), S$.$02M;$, #) A;-%$#Q.4$) -

G00$02Q.4$) R,4$)'1 4,= ) <$.)'$#)#- #- >;,%-; ;-4&;0,0 >);) , >)()=-.2,

#,0 @-.-<B4$,0 #, ;-($=- (-;)' #) >;-%$#Q.4$) 0,4$)'5

6 7º 8 N&.#, 0-;/ 4,.02$2&B#, #-T

" @-.0 =3%-$0 - $=3%-$01 %)',;-0 - ;-.#)0 #, .02$2&2, J)4$,.)' #, R-(&;,

R,4$)' .+, &2$'$U)#,0 .) ,>-;)4$,.)'$U)*+, #-02-V

" @-.0 - #$;-$2,0 :&-1 ) :&)':&-; 2B2&',1 '9- 0-C)= )#C&#$4)#,0 ,& :&- '9-

%$-;-= ) 0-; %$.4&')#,0 >,; <,;*) #- '-$V

" ;-4-$2) #)0 4,.2;$@&$*W-0 0,4$)$0 >);) ) 0-(&;$#)#- 0,4$)'1 >;-%$02)0 .)

)'B.-) ) #, $.4$0, - ., $.4$0, #, );25 7XK #) E,.02$2&$*+,V

! " >;,#&2, #) '$:&$#)*+, #- @-.0 - )2$%,0 #- >-00,) <B0$4) ,& C&;B#$4) -=

#M@$2, 4,= ) A;-%$#Q.4$) R,4$)'V

! " ;-0&'2)#, #) )>'$4)*+, <$.).4-$;) #- 0-&0 )2$%,0V

! " ;-4&;0,0 >;,%-.$-.2-0 #, ,;*)=-.2, #) Y.$+,5

6 Fº 8 N&.#, 0-;/ (-;$#, >-', .02$2&2, J)4$,.)' #, R-(&;, R,4$)'1 .) <,;=)

#) '-$5

G;25 HX5 8 -.2- #) N-#-;)*+, :&- =).2$%-; ,& %$-; ) $.02$2&$; ;-($=- >;3>;$,

#- >;-%$#Q.4$) 0,4$)' >);) 0-&0 0-;%$#,;-0 4,.<-;$;Z'9-Z/ 4);/2-; 4,.2;$@&2$%,

- , ,;().$U);/ 4,= @)0- -= .,;=)0 #- 4,.2)@$'$#)#- - )2&/;$) :&-

>;-0-;%-= 0-& -:&$'B@;$, <$.).4-$;, - )2&);$)'5

!"#$%& '(

!!

Page 135: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"# $%# & '()*! (+ ,!-.( !*/*!0)( 1( 2!"# 3% 4+52 )*67*62 "("28 4(9 7*66(28

1( *:*!4;40( 21"*!0(! 2( )2 7+<8042=.( )*6"2 >*0 ?(978*9*1"2! *6"0@*!

24092 )(6 8090"*6 *6"2<*8*40)(6 1(6 2!"6# AB * 3% )*@*!C *1D+2)!2!E6* 1(

!*67*4"0@( 8090"* *9 2"F )(06 *:*!4;40(6G *8090121)( ( *:4*66(G -!2)+289*1E

"*G H !2I.( )*G 7*8(9*1(6G J%K2#2# L401DM*1"2 7(! 4*1"( 2( 21(NG9*)021"*

2 2)(=.(G *1"!* (+"!26G )26 9*)0)26 7!*@06"26 1(6 2!"6# 33 * 3O#

'2!C-!2/( P104(# 01(<6*!@Q1402 )( )067(6"( 1( !"#$G 1( 7!2I( /0:2)(G

6+5*0"2 ( *1"* H6 621=R*6 7!*@06"26 1( S Oº )( 2!"# 3O#

!"# $A# T*6628@2)2 2 U07,"*6* )( 01406( V )( 2!"# O$ )2 ?(16"0"+0=.(G 2"F (

"F!901( )( "*!4*0!( *:*!4;40( /01214*0!( 6*-+01"* H *1"!2)2 *9 @0-(! )*6"2

>*0 ?(978*9*1"2!G 2 )*67*62 "("28 4(9 7*66(28 )(6 '()*!*6 * ,!-.(6

!*/*!0)(6 1( 2!"# 3% 1.( +8"!272662!CG *9 7*!4*1"+28 )2 !*4*0"2 4(!!*1"*

8;D+0)2G 2 )*67*62 @*!0/042)2 1( *:*!4;40( 09*)02"29*1"* 21"*!0(!G 24!*640)2

)* 2"F A%K L)*I 7(! 4*1"(NG 6* *6"2 /(! 01/*!0(! 2( 8090"* )*/010)( 12 /(!92

)( 2!"# 3%#

!"# $3# )*67*62 4(9 6*!@0=(6 )* "*!4*0!(6 )(6 '()*!*6 * ,!-.(6 !*/*!0)(6

1( 2!"# 3% 1.( 7()*!C *:4*)*!G *9 7*!4*1"+28 )2 !*4*0"2 4(!!*1"* 8;D+0)2G

2 )( *:*!4;40( 21"*!0(! H *1"!2)2 *9 @0-(! )*6"2 >*0 ?(978*9*1"2!G 2"F (

"F!901( )( "*!4*0!( *:*!4;40( 6*-+01"*#

!"# $O# 6 01/!2=R*6 )(6 )067(60"0@(6 )*6"2 >*0 ?(978*9*1"2! 6*!.( 7+10)26

6*-+1)( ( W*4!*"(E>*0 1º 3#XYXG )* $ )* )*I*9<!( )* ABY% L?,)0-(

'*128NZ 2 >*0 1º A#%$BG )* A% )* 2<!08 )* ABJ%Z ( W*4!*"(E>*0 1º 3%AG )*

3$ )* /*@*!*0!( )* AB[$Z 2 >*0 1º X#Y3BG )* 3 )* 5+1U( )* ABB3Z * )*9206

1(!926 )2 8*-0682=.( 7*!"01*1"*#

!"# $Y# \6"2 >*0 ?(978*9*1"2! *1"!2 *9 @0-(! 12 )2"2 )2 6+2 7+<8042=.(#

!"# $J# T*@(-2E6* 2 >*0 ?(978*9*1"2! 1( B[G )* OA )* 920( )* ABBB#

]!26;802G Y )* 920( )* 3%%%Z A$Bº )2 ^1)*7*1)_1402 * AA3º )2 T*7P<8042#

!"#$#%& '!#"()*! +$"%&,&

%&'() *!+!,

*!($#- .!/!(&-

L'+<8042)2 1( W#&# )* J#J#3%%%N

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 136: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$% & '#($#"&)*#+ ,º -./0/1 2# 3 2# 2#4#56$& 2# 7809 : ;<2+=&

>#,%!1 % *#+ ,º 7.9381 2# 79 2# %6$+! 2# 78?91 # & '#($#"&)*#+ ,º -971

2# -3 2# @#A#$#+$& 2# 78B3.

!"#$%&#'(# &) "#!*+,%-)

!"# $!%&' ()& # *#+,'&$$# -!./#+!0 1&.'&2! & &) $!+./#+# ! $&,)/+2& 3&/4

5'26 786 9 !'26 ::; 1# <&.'&2#=3&/ +º >6?@?A 1& B 1& 1&C&D%'# 1& 7;@EA

F!$$! ! G/,#'!' .#D ! $&,)/+2& '&1!"H#4

I5'26 ::;6 <!' .!)$! J /+$2!)'!"H# 1& /+G&$2/,!"H# F#0/./!0A 1&

F'#.&$$# K)1/./!0A /+$2!)'!"H# 1& /+G&$2/,!"H# !1D/+/$2'!2/G!A /+()L=

'/2# ./G/0 #) !"H# 1& /DF'#%/1!1& !1D/+/$2'!2/G! .#+2'! !0,)LDA

/DF)2!+1#=0M& .'/D& 1& ()& # $!%& /+#.&+2&4N O-PQ

IR&+!6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666

NS 7º666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666T

IS >º666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666N

5'26 >86 9 UV2)0# WX 1# <&.'&2#=3&/ +º >6?@?A 1& 7;@EA F!$$! ! G/,#'!'

!.'&$./1# 1# $&,)/+2& .!FV2)0# & !'2/,#$4

.-/012345 %6

& $ -"%7#$ - '(") )$ 8%')'9)$ !*+,%-)$:;

I*#+2'!2!"H# 1& #F&'!"H# 1& .'L1/2#N

I5'26 :Y;=56 9'1&+!'A !)2#'/C!' #) '&!0/C!' #F&'!"H# 1& .'L1/2#A

/+2&'+# #) &Z2&'+#A $&D F'LG/! !)2#'/C!"H# 0&,/$0!2/G!4N

IR&+! [ '&.0)$H#A 1& 7 O)DQ ! > O1#/$Q !+#$6N

IR!'\,'!]# ^+/.#6 X+./1& +! D&$D! F&+! ()&D #'1&+!A !)2#'/C! #)

'&!0/C! #F&'!"H# 1& .'L1/2#A /+2&'+# #) &Z2&'+#4N

/HL�1º���������GH����GH�2XWXEUR�GH�����

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 137: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

! " #$% &'$()*+,-'#&. /* 0&%&1*2 #$'/&34$ $5%$'1.'1* *)1.(*0*#&/$

*% 0*& $5 *% +*)$0534$ /$ 6*'./$ 7*/*+.089

!! " :5.'/$ $ %$'1.'1* /. /;,&/. #$')$0&/./. 501+.<.)). $ 0&%&1*

%=>&%$ .51$+&?./$ <$+ 0*&@9

!')#+&34$ /* /*)<*).) '4$ *%<*'A./.) *% +*)1$) . <.B.+9

C+1@ DEFGH@ I+/*'.+ $5 .51$+&?.+ . &')#+&34$ *% +*)1$) . <.B.+2 /*

/*)<*). :5* '4$ 1*'A. )&/$ <+*,&.%*'1* *%<*'A./. $5 :5* *>#*/.

0&%&1* *)1.(*0*#&/$ *% 0*&J9

K*'. " /*1*'34$2 /* L M)*&)N %*)*) . O M/$&)N .'$)@9

C))5'34$ /*$(+&B.34$ '$ P01&%$ .'$/$%.'/.1$$5 0*B&)0.15+.9

C+1@ DEFGQ@ I+/*'.+ $5 .51$+&?.+ . .))5'34$ /* $(+&B.34$2 '$) /$&)

P01&%$) :5./+&%*)1+*) /$ P01&%$ .'$ /$ %.'/.1$ $5 0*B&)0.15+.2 #5R.

/*)<*). '4$ <$)). )*+ <.B. '$ %*)%$ *>*+#;#&$ S&'.'#*&+$ $52 #.)$

+*)1* <.+#*0. . )*+ <.B. '$ *>*+#;#&$ )*B5&'1*2 :5* '4$ 1*'A.

#$'1+.<.+1&/. )5S&#&*'1* /* /&)<$'&(&0&/./* /* #.&>.J9

K*'. " +*#05)4$2 /* T M5%N . U M:5.1+$N .'$)@9

I+/*'.34$ /* /*)<*). '4$ .51$+&?./.9

C+1@ DEFGV@ I+/*'.+ /*)<*). '4$ .51$+&?./. <$+ 0*&J9

K*'. " +*#05)4$2 /* T M5%N . U M:5.1+$N .'$)@9

K+*)1.34$ /* B.+.'1&. B+.#&$).9

C+1@ DEFGW@ K+*)1.+ B.+.'1&. *% $<*+.34$ /* #+X/&1$ )*% :5* 1*'A.

)&/$ #$')1&15;/. #$'1+.B.+.'1&. *% ,.0$+ &B5.0 $5 )5<*+&$+ .$ ,.0$+ /.

B.+.'1&. <+*)1./.2 '. S$+%. /. 0*&J9

K*'. " /*1*'34$2 /* D M1+Y)N %*)*) . T M5%N .'$@9

Z4$ #.'#*0.%*'1$ /* +*)1$) . <.B.+9

C+1@ DEFG7@ V*&>.+ /* $+/*'.+2 /* .51$+&?.+ $5 /* <+$%$,*+ $

#.'#*0.%*'1$ /$ %$'1.'1* /* +*)1$) . <.B.+ &')#+&1$ *% ,.0$+

)5<*+&$+ .$ <*+%&1&/$ *% 0*&J9

K*'. " /*1*'34$2 /* L M)*&)N %*)*) . O M/$&)N .'$)@9

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 138: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$%&' ($ ($)*$)+ &'&+, -'# *$))'+, %' .,&/#' +%' (' #+%(+&'

'" ,$0/),+&"1+2

!1&3 45678391($%+1: +"&'1/;+1 '" $<$-"&+1 +&' ="$ +-+11$&$ +"#$%7

&' ($ ($)*$)+ &'&+, -'# *$))'+,: %') -$%&' $ '/&$%&+ (/+) +%&$1/'1$)

+' >/%+, (' #+%(+&' '" (+ ,$0/),+&"1+?2

@$%+ A 1$-,")B': ($ C D"#E + F D="+&1'E +%')32

9>$1&+ *.G,/-+ '" -','-+HB' ($ &I&",') %' #$1-+('2

!1&3 4567J3 91($%+1: +"&'1/;+1 '" *1'#'K$1 + '>$1&+ *.G,/-+ '" +

-','-+HB' %' #$1-+(' >/%+%-$/1' ($ &I&",') (+ (IK/(+ *.G,/-+ )$#

="$ &$%L+# )/(' -1/+(') *'1 ,$/ '" )$# ="$ $)&$M+# 1$0/)&1+(') $#

)/)&$#+ -$%&1+,/;+(' ($ ,/="/(+HB' $ ($ -")&N(/+?2

@$%+ A 1$-,")B': ($ C D"#E + F D="+&1'E +%')32

!1&3 4O3 ! P$/ %º C3QR6: ($ CQ ($ +G1/, ($ C65Q: *+))+ + K/0'1+1 -'# +)

)$0"/%&$) +,&$1+HS$)?

!1&3 CQ33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333

3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333332

5E ($/<+1 ($ '1($%+1 + 1$("HB' (' #'%&+%&$ (+ (IK/(+ -'%)',/(+(+:

%') *1+;') $)&+G$,$-/(') $# ,$/: ="+%(' ' #'%&+%&$ ",&1+*+))+1 '

K+,'1 1$)",&+%&$ (+ +*,/-+HB' (' ,/#/&$ #T</#' >/<+(' *$,' U$%+('

V$($1+,W2

XE '1($%+1 '" +"&'1/;+1 + +G$1&"1+ ($ -1Y(/&' $# ($)+-'1(' -'# ')

,/#/&$) $)&+G$,$-/(') *$,' U$%+(' V$($1+,: )$# >"%(+#$%&' %+ ,$/

'1H+#$%&T1/+ '" %+ ($ -1Y(/&' +(/-/'%+, '" -'# /%'G)$1KZ%-/+ ($

*1$)-1/HB' ,$0+,W2

RE ($/<+1 ($ *1'#'K$1 '" ($ '1($%+1 %+ >'1#+ (+ ,$/: ' -+%-$,+7

#$%&': + +#'1&/;+HB' '" + -'%)&/&"/HB' ($ 1$)$1K+ *+1+ +%",+1 ')

$>$/&') ($ '*$1+HB' ($ -1Y(/&' 1$+,/;+(+ -'# /%'G)$1KZ%-/+ ($ ,/#/&$:

-'%(/HB' '" #'%&+%&$ $)&+G$,$-/(' $# ,$/W2

[E ($/<+1 ($ *1'#'K$1 '" ($ '1($%+1 + ,/="/(+HB' /%&$01+, ($

'*$1+HB' ($ -1Y(/&' *'1 +%&$-/*+HB' ($ 1$-$/&+ '1H+#$%&T1/+: /%-,"7

)/K$ ') 1$)*$-&/K') M"1') $ ($#+/) $%-+10'): +&Y ' $%-$11+#$%&' ('

$<$1-I-/' >/%+%-$/1'W2

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 139: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!" #$%&'($ #) ()*#$+,($- &. %&/(0#$%# 0#. ( 1&+- ( $&(1+,(23# %&

#4&$(23# %& 0$5%+*# 0#. 6)(16)&$ ). %#/ %&.(+/ &'*&/ %( 7&%&$(8

23#- +'01)/+9& /)(/ &'*+%(%&/ %( (%.+'+/*$(23# +'%+$&*(- (+'%( 6)& '(

:#$.( %& '#9(23#- $&:+'('0+(.&'*# #) 4#/*&$;(23# %& %<9+%( 0#'8

*$(<%( ('*&$+#$.&'*&=>

?@" 0(4*($ $&0)$/#/ ( *<*)1# %& ('*&0+4(23# %& $&0&+*( %& *$+A)*# #)

0#'*$+A)+23# 0)B# :(*# ;&$(%#$ (+'%( '3# *&'C( #0#$$+%#=>

??" #$%&'($#)()*#$+,($(%&/*+'(23#%&$&0)$/#/4$#9&'+&'*&/%(&.+//3#

%& *<*)1#/ 4($( :+'(1+%(%& %+9&$/( %( 4$&9+/*( '( 1&+ 6)& ( ()*#$+,#)=>

?D" $&(1+,($ #) $&0&A&$ *$('/:&$E'0+( 9#1)'*F$+( &. %&/(0#$%# 0#.

1+.+*& #) 0#'%+23# &/*(A&1&0+%( &. 1&+G>

H$*G I!8HG J#'/*+*)&.- *(.A5.- 0$+.&/ %& $&/4#'/(A+1+%(%& %#

K$&/+%&'*& %# L)4$&.# M$+A)'(1 7&%&$(1 #) %& /&) /)A/*+*)*# 6)('%#

'# &N&$0<0+# %( K$&/+%E'0+(- (/ 0#'%)*(/ 4$&9+/*(/ '# ($*G ?@ %&/*(

O&+- 6)('%# 4#$ &1&/ #$%&'(%(/ #) 4$(*+0(%(/G>

K($F;$(:# P'+0#G Q %+/4#/*# '&/*& ($*+;# (41+0(8/& (#/ K$&/+%&'*&/-

& $&/4&0*+9#/ /)A/*+*)*#/ 6)('%# '# &N&$0<0+# %( K$&/+%E'0+(- %#/

M$+A)'(+/ L)4&$+#$&/- %#/ M$+A)'(+/ %& J#'*(/- %#/ M$+A)'(+/ R&;+#8

'(+/ 7&%&$(+/- %# M$(A(1C# & S1&+*#$(+/- %#/ M$+A)'(+/ %& T)/*+2( & %&

H12(%( %#/ S/*(%#/ & %# U+/*$+*# 7&%&$(1- & (#/ T)<,&/ U+$&*#$&/ %&

7#$# #) :)'23# &6)+9(1&'*& '# 4$+.&+$# ;$() %& B)$+/%+23#G>

H$*G V@8HG J#'/*+*)&.- *(.A5.- 0$+.&/ %& $&/4#'/(A+1+%(%& %# K$#8

0)$(%#$8W&$(1 %( R&4PA1+0(- #) %& /&) /)A/*+*)*# 6)('%# '# &N&$0<0+#

%( 0C&:+( %# X+'+/*5$+# KPA1+0# %( Y'+3#- (/ 0#'%)*(/ 4$&9+/*(/ '# ($*G

?@ %&/*( O&+- 6)('%# 4#$ &1&/ #$%&'(%(/ #) 4$(*+0(%(/G>

K($F;$(:# P'+0#G Q %+/4#/*# '&/*& ($*+;# (41+0(8/&Z>

[ \ (# H%9#;(%#8W&$(1 %( Y'+3#=>

[[ \ (#/ K$#0)$(%#$&/8W&$(+/ %# M$(A(1C#- S1&+*#$(1 & X+1+*($- (#/

K$#0)$(%#$&/8W&$(+/ %& T)/*+2( %#/ S/*(%#/ & %# U+/*$+*# 7&%&$(1- (#/

K$#0)$(%#$&/8W&$(+/ %#/ S/*(%#/ & %# U+/*$+*# 7&%&$(1- & (#/ .&.8

A$#/ %# X+'+/*5$+# KPA1+0# %( Y'+3# & %#/ S/*(%#/- %( H%9#0(0+(8

W&$(1 %( Y'+3#- %(/ K$#0)$(%#$+(/ %#/ S/*(%#/ & %# U+/*$+*# 7&%&$(1-

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 140: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!"#$% #% &'&()*)+% $& ,!#-.% $& )/&,+" $"0 !#+$"$&0 (&1+%#"+0 %!

2%)"+0 $"0 (&03&)4+5"0 +#04+4!+-6&078

9:(47 ;<=:7 >&03&+4"$" " 3(&((%1"4+5" $& ,%(% !& "00+04& ?0 "!4%(+$"=

$&0 " !& 0& (&,&(&@ % 3"(A1(",% B#+)% $% "(47 CD=: & % +#)+0% EE $%

3"(A1(",% B#+)% $% "(47 ;F=:G "0 "-6&0 3&#"+0 )%#4(" &2"0 "H!+I"$"0

3&2" 3(A4+)" $%0 )(+@&0 $& (&03%#0"J+2+$"$& 3(&5+04%0 #% "(47 <F $&04"

K&+ 0&(.% 3(%)&00"$"0 & H!21"$"0 $& ")%($% )%@ % (+4% +#04+4!*$% 3&2"

K&+ #% L7FCLG $& ML $& @"+% $& <DDFG 3&(@+4+$%G " 4%$% )+$"$.%G %

%,&(&)+@&#4% $" $&#B#)+"78

:(47 ;N7 O "(47 <º ! "#$%#&!'(#) *º +,-. # +/ # 0#1#%#)%! # -23/. 45665

5 1)7!%5% $!8 5 6#79)*&# %# 5:;!<

=>%&? -º????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????@

=ABC D #)E5% #!% #*5% 5 %# 9:;! !8!*&5*&# 5 F1) 5 $!*6!G) 5 5.

*!6 4%5H!6 #6&5I#G#$) !6 #8 G#). J95* ! !8!*&5*&# 9G&%545665% ! 15G!%

%#69G&5*&# 5 54G)$5:;! ! G)8)&#8KE)8! 0)E5 ! 4#G! L#*5 ! M# #%5GN@

=ABCC D !% #*5% !9 59&!%)H5% 5 5I#%&9%5 # $%O )&! #8 #65$!% ! $!8

!6 G)8)&#6 #6&5I#G#$) !6 4#G! L#*5 ! M# #%5G. 6#8 09* 58#*&! *5 G#)

!%:58#*&K%)5 !9 *5 # $%O )&! 5 )$)!*5G !9 $!8 )*!I6#%1P*$)5 #

4%#6$%):;! G#75GN@

=ABCCC D #)E5% # 4%!8!1#% !9 # !% #*5%. *5 0!%85 5 G#). !

$5*$#G58#*&!. 5 58!%&)H5:;! !9 5 $!*6&)&9):;! # %#6#%15 45%5

5*9G5% !6 #0#)&!6 # !4#%5:;! # $%O )&! %#5G)H5 5 $!8 )*!I6#%1P*$)5

# G)8)&#. $!* ):;! !9 8!*&5*&# #6&5I#G#$) ! #8 G#)N@

=ACA D #)E5% # 4%!8!1#% !9 # !% #*5% 5 G)J9) 5:;! )*&#7%5G #

!4#%5:;! # $%O )&! 4!% 5*&#$)45:;! # %#$#)&5 !%:58#*&K%)5. )*$G9'

6)1# !6 %#64#$&)1!6 Q9%!6 # #85)6 #*$5%7!6. 5&O ! #*$#%%58#*&! !

#E#%$F$)! 0)*5*$#)%!N@

=AA D !% #*5% !9 59&!%)H5%. #8 #65$!% ! $!8 5 G#). 5 %#5G)H5:;! #

!4#%5:;! # $%O )&! $!8 J95GJ9#% 98 !6 #85)6 #*&#6 5 M# #%5'

:;!. )*$G96)1# 6956 #*&) 5 #6 5 5 8)*)6&%5:;! )* )%#&5. 5)* 5 J9# *5

0!%85 # *!15:;!. %#0)*5*$)58#*&! !9 4!6&#%75:;! # F1) 5 $!*'

&%5F 5 5*&#%)!%8#*&#N@

!"#$%& '(

!"

Page 141: ComentÆrios à lei de responsabilidade fiscal...()* ') +),-./,!0*1*'!') 2*,3!1 4()* 5.6-1)6)/#!" / º 7879 ') &$:$;888< -")=> ?@)A ! "#$%& '()*+,(- ,**$*+.#/$, +0/#$/, ) /&&')(,1%&

!!" # $%&'%( ()$*(+,+ % '-'*., /) %0')$1&%23, /) ()$)1'% /) '(14*',

,* $,0'(14*123, $*5, 6%', 7)(%/,( %10/% 03, ')08% ,$,((1/,9:

!!"" # ,(/)0%( ,* %*',(1;%( % /)+'10%23, /) ()$*(+,+ &(,<)01)0')+

/% )=1++3, /) '-'*.,+ &%(% 610%.1/%/) /1<)(+% /% &()<1+'% 0% .)1 >*) %

%*',(1;,*9:

!!""" # ()%.1;%( ,* ()$)4)( '(%0+6)(?0$1% <,.*0'@(1% )= /)+%$,(/,

$,= .1=1') ,* $,0/123, )+'%4).)$1/% )= .)1A:

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA:

B('A CDA E,0+'1'*1 106(%23, %/=101+'(%'1<% $,0'(% %+ .)1+ /) 610%02%+ &F4.1$%+G

" # /)1H%( /) /1<*.7%( ,* /) )0<1%( %, I,/)( J)71+.%'1<, ) %, K(14*0%. /)E,0'%+

, ().%'L(1, /) 7)+'3, 61+$%.M 0,+ &(%;,+ ) $,0/12N)+ )+'%4).)$1/,+ )= .)19

"" # &(,&,( .)1 /) /1()'(1;)+ ,(2%=)0'@(1%+ %0*%. >*) 03, $,0')08% %+=)'%+

61+$%1+ 0% 6,(=% /% .)19

""" # /)1H%( /) )H&)/1( %', /)')(=10%0/, .1=1'%23, /) )=&)08, ) =,<1O

=)0'%23, 610%0$)1(%M 0,+ $%+,+ ) $,0/12N)+ )+'%4).)$1/,+ )= .)19

"P # /)1H%( /) ,(/)0%( ,* /) &(,=,<)(M 0% 6,(=% ) 0,+ &(%;,+ /% .)1M %

)H)$*23, /) =)/1/% &%(% % ()/*23, /, =,0'%0') /% /)+&)+% ','%. $,=

&)++,%. >*) 8,*<)( )H$)/1/, % ()&%('123, &,( I,/)( /, .1=1') =@H1=,A

Q Rº B 106(%23, &()<1+'% 0)+') %('17, S &*01/% $,= =*.'% /) '(10'% &,( $)0',

/,+ <)0$1=)0',+ %0*%1+ /, %7)0') >*) .8) /)( $%*+%M +)0/, , &%7%=)0',

/% =*.'% /) +*% ()+&,0+%41.1/%/) &)++,%.A

Q Tº B 106(%23, % >*) +) ()6)() )+') %('17, +)(@ &(,$)++%/% ) 5*.7%/% &).,

K(14*0%. /) E,0'%+ % >*) $,=&)'1( % 61+$%.1;%23, $,0'@41.M 610%0$)1(% )

,(2%=)0'@(1% /% &)++,% 5*(-/1$% /) /1()1', &F4.1$, )0<,.<1/%A

B('A UDA V+'% J)1 )0'(% )= <17,( 0% /%'% /) +*% &*4.1$%23,A

W(%+-.1%M RX /) ,*'*4(, /) TYYY9 RZXD /% "0/)&)0/?0$1% ) RRTD /% [)&F4.1$%A

!"#$#%& '!#"()*! +$"%&,&

!"# $%&'!%(

!"#$%& '(

!"