0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

9

Transcript of 0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

Page 1: 0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

� ������������ ��������� �������������� �! �������"��#$��%& ��'���(�)�+*,�.-/ 0���� �� 12�2��$34�� ��$���

5/68796;:=<>5�?@:=<ACBED@FCFHGIFKJML�FON"P@QSRUT�V&ACB�WXT�Y@BZTL&[)V\Y@T�]HWXT_^�T�GXGXFHY/`4Y@WXaOT�VUb\WcRed

f WXRURUb\g@Q@V\]HDih fkj�l$mHnSl$oqproOsHtHn h)` A jdCWXN"WXY@]Cu4BZb$v B�NwQiv T�x@Q

yI?@:{z/|~}.�@�����H�Z�C:� T�V\WXRed�hO�eY@BHv�O�)�w� FHb\b4�.V$v

A�Q@Y@YCdCaH[)GXTHh@L j��)�CtH�O� hO` A j�EPkT�x@T�V\bUT$u.aHTZVUWXRed�v B�FON

���4�O�@�@�=�k�

� D@WXb&P�[KP�TZV&Wcb&[2B�FON"P�[KV�[)R\WXaHT&bUR\Q@x@d/F)JiJ;T$[)R\Q@VUTb\T�GXT�B�RUWXFOY�N"TZRUD@FCx@bWXY�b\R�[)R\WXbURUWXB$[KG�GXT$[KVUY@WXY@]�F)JR\T��CR_B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHYiv � D@T_J;F�BZQ@b_WXb_FHY9[)]O]HV\T�b pb\WcaOT�x@WXN/T�Y@bUWXFOY�[)GXWXRed�V\T�x@Q@B�R\WXFHYiv¡ �WXaHT�N/T�RUD pFCx@b�¢�T�VUT2T�aH[)GXQ�[KRUT�x�h@WXY@B�GXQ@x@WXY@]/RUT�V\N£bUT�GXT�BZRUWXFHYg�[KbUT�xwFOY�xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR¤J8VUT�¥CQ@TZY@B�d¦8�� =§�hKWcY�J8FHV\N>[ pR\WcFOY�]C[)WXY¨¦©�Uª_§�hMNwQ@RUQ�[KG�WXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHY�¦8^«�U§�h�[¬=­ p RUT�b\R>¦;L�®4�U§Zh�[)Y@x¯RUT�V\N0bUR\VUT�Y@]ORUD�¦ � AS§�v�°9TJ8FOQ@Y@x±�Uª²[KY@x�L�®4�.N"FObUR�TE³IT�B�RUWXaOT"WXY´FOQ@V_T�� pPkT�VUWXN/T�YCRUb$v2`.bUWXY@]�UªµRUD@V\T�bUDSFHGXx@WXY@]�¢&WXRUD9["¶ pY@T·[)VUTZbUR=Y@T�WX]HDCgkFHV�B�G¸[)bUb\Wº¹�T�V=FHY_R\D@T � T�Q@RUTZVUb�B�FOV pP@QSb$hCVUTZN"F)aH[)GSF)J»QSP>R\F �O�H¼ VUTZN"F)aH[)GSF)J»QSY@WX¥�QSTR\T�VUN/b�[KB�RUQ�[KGXGcd9dCWXT�GXx@T�x�[)Y¯WcN/P@VUF)aOT�x9B�G¸[)b\bUWº¹ pB$[KRUWXFHY[KB�B�Q@VE[)B�d�¦©N"T$[KbUQ@V\T�xgCd>[·aOT�V�[K]HT�P@V\T�B�W pb\WcFOY�§�v��� �RUDSVUT�b\D@FHGXx@WXY@]PkT�VrJ8FHV\N"T�x9b\WcN/WXG½[KVUGXdHv�eY@xST�T�x¢�T.J8FHQ@YSx"bUR\VUFOY@]wB�FHV\VUT�G¸[KRUWXFHY@b&gkT�Re¢�T�T�YR\D@T��� �hk�Uª�[)YSx¾L�®.�4aH[)GXQ@TZb4F)J&[wRUTZVUN´v � DSWcbb\Q@]H]OT�bUR\b�R\D�[)R��� �R\D@VUTZbUD@FOGcxSWcYS]�h=RUDSTwbUWXN"P@GXT�b\RN/T�RUD@FCxw¢&WXRUDwR\D@T�GXF)¢�T�b\R�B�FObUR&WXYwB�FHN/P@Q@RE[)RUWXFOYihB$[KY¨gkT±VUT�GXW¸[)g@GXd�Q@b\T�x¨WXY@b\RUT$[Kx¨FKJ��Uª¿FOV«L�®.�¢&D@TZY>R\D@T_B�FON"P@QSR�[)R\WXFHYwF)J=RUD@TZbUT_N/T$[)b\Q@VUT�b�[)V\TR\F�FÀT��CP�T�YSbUWXaHTHv � A±BZFHN"Pk[)VUTZb�JÁ[·aHFOV�[Kg@GXd>¢&WXR\DR\D@T�FHR\D@T�V�N"T�R\D@FCx@bI¢&WXRUD�Q@P�RUF mOtH¼ aHFCB$[)gSQ@G¸[)VUdV\T�x@Q@B�R\WXFHY2g@Q@R=WXbiY@FORiB�FON"PkT�RUWXRUWXaOT~[KRiD@WX]OD@T�V=aHF pB$[Kg@Q@G¸[)V\dÂVUTZx@Q@B�R\WcFOY¨GXT�aOT�GXb$vµ�eY¨B�FOYCRUV�[KbUR·h_^��D�[KxÂVUTZG½[KRUWXaHTZGcd�PkFCFHV"PkT�VrJ8FHV\N>[)YSB�T´xSQ@T´R\F�WXRUbg@W¸[Kb�RUF)¢&[)V\x@b�JÁ[·aHFOVUWXY@]�V�[KVUT&RUTZVUN"b·h�[KY@x2WcR\b�bUTZY pb\WcR\WXa�WXRedwR\FwP@VUFOg�[)g@WXGXWXRed�TZbURUWXN�[)RUWXFOYwT�VUV\FHVUb·v

à ÄHÅ ���SÆ&Ç4È4�k�@É\Æ Å

� T��CR�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[)R\WXFHYÂWXb�RUD@T±P@V\FHg@GXT�N¡FKJ�[)Q@R\FHN�[)RUWXB$[KGXGcd[)b\bUWX]HYSWcYS]²P@V\T�x@TE¹kY@T�x0B$[KRUT�]OFHV\WcTZb�RUFµJ8VUT�TµRUT��CR�x@FCB�Q pN"TZY�R\b$vÀ°ÂD@WXGXT�N/FHVUT"[KY@x9N"FOVUTwR\T��CRUQ�[KG�WXYCJ8FOVUN�[)RUWXFOYWXb[·aH[)WXG¸[)gSGcT�FOY@GXWcYSTHhkTE³ÊTZB�RUWXaHTwV\T�RUV\WXT�aH[)G�WXb�x@WºË"B�Q@GXR.¢&WcR\D@FHQSR]HFCFCx�WXY@xST��CWcYS]¾[KY@x�bUQ@N/N>[)V\WX�$[)R\WcFOY´FKJ x@FCB�QSN"T�YCR2B�FHY pRUTZY�R·v��.FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb±B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHYÌWXb´FOY@T�b\FHGXQ@R\WcFOY�R\FRUDSWcbwPSVUFHgSGcTZN´v j ]HV\F)¢&WXY@]YCQ@NwgkT�VwF)J�bUR�[KRUWXbUR\WXB$[)G.B�G¸[)b pbUWº¹�B·[)RUWXFOY�N"T�R\D@FCx@b[)Y@x�N�[)BED@WXY@TGXT$[KVUY@WXY@]ÂR\T�BED@Y@WX¥CQ@T�b

D�[·aOT,gkT�T�Y£[)PSP@GXWcTZx�RUF�R\T��CR�B$[KRUT�]OFHV\Wc�·[)RUWXFOYÍWXYÌVUTZB�T�YCRdHT·[)VUb·hkWcYSB�GXQ@x@WXY@]wNwQ@GXRUWXaH[KVUWc[KRUT&V\T�]HV\T�bUb\WcFOY´N/FCx@T�GXb$Î � h nHsqÏ hY@T$[KVUT�b\RÂY@T�WX]OD�gkFHV¯B�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�B$[KRUWXFHYiÎ � h nHoZÏ h/ÐÑ[·dOT�b�P@VUFOg�[ pg@WXGXWXbURUWXB´[KP@P@V\F�[)BED@TZb$Î nHt h l·o·Ï h&x@TZB�WXbUWXFHY�R\VUT�T�b·Î l$o·Ï h.Y@T�Q@VE[)GY@T�Re¢�FHV\¶Cb$Î n@l'Ï h�bUdCNwgkFHGXWXB_VUQSGcT/GXT$[)V\Y@WXY@]�Î l h l·Ò h oqÏ [KY@x9WXY px@Q@BZRUWXaHT�GXT$[)V\Y@WXY@]"[)GX]OFHVUWXR\D@N"b·Î o h l$nZÏ vj N�[��EFOVwB�Dk[)V�[KB�RUTZVUWXbUR\WcBOh4FOV>xSWÓË"BZQ@GXRed�h�F)J_R\T��CR>B·[)RUTZ]HF pVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY�PSVUFHgSGcTZN"b�WXbRUD@T9DSWc]OD�x@WXN"T�YSbUWXFHY�[KGXWcRed¯F)JwRUD@TJ8T$[KRUQ@V\T´b\P�[)BZTHv � D@T´Yk[)RUWXaOTJ8T·[)RUQSVUT±bUP�[KB�T9B�FHYSbUWXbUR\bF)JRUDST�Q@Y@WX¥CQ@T9R\T�VUN/b�¦¸¢�FHV\x@bFHVÀP@D@V�[KbUT�bE§±RUD�[KRFCB�B�Q@V±WXYx@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb·h�¢&DSWcBED�B$[KY,gkTR\T�Y@b"FOVwDCQ@Y@x@V\T�x@b"FKJ R\D@FHQ pb�[KY@x@b_FKJÑR\T�VUN/b.J8FHV_TZaHT�Y�[/N"FCx@TZV�[)R\T p bUWX��T�x9R\T��CR_B�FHGXGXT�B pRUWXFOYiv � D@WXb�Wcb�P@V\FHD@WXg@WXR\WcaOT�GXd"D@WX]OD�J8FHV�N�[)YCd"GXT$[KVUY@WXY@]�[)G p]HFOVUWXRUDSN"b$v� @T�¢�Y@T�Q@VE[)GkY@T�Re¢�FHVU¶Cb·hOJ8FHV�TZ��[KN"P@GXTHhKB$[)Y/D�[)Y px@GXT2bUQ@BED9["G¸[KVU]HT�Y�QSNwg�T�V.F)J&WXY@P@[email protected]@FCx@T�b$v2Ð&[·dHT�b�gkT�GXWXTEJN"FCx@TZGcb·hi[)b_[KY@FHR\D@T�V_T��@[KN"P@GXTHhI¢&WXGXG=g�TwBZFHN"PSQ@R�[KRUWXFHY�[KGXGcdWXYCRUV�[KB�R�[Kg@GXT�Q@Y@GXT�bUb�[)Y�WXY@x@T�PkT�Y@xST�Y@B�T"[KbUbUQSN"P@R\WcFOY´¦©F)J8R\T�YY@FOR R\VUQ@T·§ [KN"FOY@]2J8T$[KRUQ@V\T�b�Wcb�WXN"PkFHb\T�xiv.�eR�Wcb.D@WX]HD@GXd�x@T pbUWXVE[)g@GXTwRUF�V\T�x@Q@B�T/RUD@T/Y�[)R\WXaHT2bUP�[KB�T"¢&WXRUDSFHQ@R�b�[KB�VUWº¹�BZWcYS]B$[KRUT�]OFHVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY�[)B�BZQ@V�[KB�d�vM�eR&WXbÑ[KGcb\F�xST�bUWXV�[Kg@GXT�RUF"[)BED@WXT�aOTbUQSB�D�[.]HF�[KG�[)QSRUFHN�[)R\WcB·[)GXGXd�hEWev THvXh)Y@F_N�[)YCQ�[KGHx@TE¹kY@WXRUWXFHYwFOVB�FOY@bUR\VUQ@B�R\WXFHYFKJiJ8T$[KRUQ@V\T�b4WXb&V\T�¥CQ@WXVUT�xivj QSRUFHN�[)R\WcB2J;T$[)R\Q@VUTb\T�GXT�B�R\WcFOYÂN"TZRUD@FCx@b2WXY@B�GXQ@x@T�RUDST>V\T pN"F)aH[KG�FKJ_Y@FHY p WXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXaHTwR\T�VUN/b>[KB�B�FHV\x@WXY@]9RUF¯B�FHV\P@Q@bbURE[)R\Wcb\RUWXB�b·hÊ[KY@xR\D@T_B�FOY@bUR\VUQ@B�R\WXFHY±F)J�Y@T�¢{J8T·[)RUQSVUT�b�¢&D@WXBEDB�FONwg@WXY@T_GXF)¢�TZV4GXT�aHTZG=J8T$[KRUQ@V\T�b"¦¸Wev THvXhIR\T�VUN/b�§.WXY�R\F"D@WX]OD@T�V pGXT�aHTZG�FOVURUDSFH]HFOY�[)G2x@WXN"TZY@bUWXFHYSb$v0ÔITZ¢&Wcb9Õ � WXY@]OQ@T�RUR\THÎ l$oZÏQ@b\T�x�[)Y9WXYCJ8FOVUN�[)RUWXFOY"]�[KWXY´N/T$[)b\Q@VUTwR\F«[K]H]OVUT�b\bUWXaHT�GXdV\T px@Q@BZT4RUDST&x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�RMaHFCB$[)gSQ@G¸[)VUd�WcYw[�Y�[KWXaHT�ÐÑ[·dOT�b�N"FCx@TZG[)YSx�[�x@T�B�WXb\WcFOY p RUVUTZT>[)PSP@VUFC[)BED9RUFgSWcYk[)VUd±B�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�B$[KRUWXFHY�v°ÂWXT�Y@TZV»TZR~[KGevcÎ nSl h l$�qÏ Q@bUT�xwNwQSRUQ�[KGHWXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHY4[KY@xw[ ¬»­bURE[)R\Wcb\RUWXB�RUF4b\T�GXT�B�R=J;T$[)R\Q@VUT�b~J8FHV�WcYSP@Q@R=RUF.Y@T�Q@VE[)G@Y@TZRe¢�FOVU¶Cb$vÖ [KY@]´Î n)�·Ï [KY@x¾A�B�DCQ@R\��TwT�R_[)GevwÎ l$� h nSl h l$�ZÏ QSbUT�x±P@VUWXY@BZW pP�[KGIB�FHN/P�FOY@T�YCR�[)Yk[)GXdCbUWXb�R\F_¹kY@x�FHVUR\D@FH]OFHY�[KG�xSWcN/T�Y@b\WcFOY@bWXYÂRUDST9aHT�B�R\FHV�bUPk[)B�T9FKJ�x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb$v Ö [)Y@]�Õ¿°ÂWXGXg@Q@VÎ nH�ZÏ QSbUT�x9x@FCB�QSN"T�YCR�B�GXQ@bUR\T�VUWXY@]ÀRUT�BED@Y@WX¥CQ@T�b�RUFT�b\RUWXN>[KRUTP@V\FHg�[Kg@WXGcWXb\RUWXB�×\RUT�V\NØb\RUVUTZY@]HR\D@Ù�h&[)YSx,QSbUT�x�WXRwRUF±VUT�xSQ@B�TRUDST aH[KVUW¸[)gSGcTZb�WXY"GXWXY@T$[)VMVUT�]OVUT�b\bUWXFHY´[KY@x"YST$[)V\T�bUR&Y@TZWc]ODCg�FOVB�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�B$[KRUWXFHY�v�^�FHQ@GXWXY@WXT�V/T�R[)Gev²Î l·ÒZÏ QSbUT�x�[KYÂWXY@x@Q@B pRUWXaOT�GXT$[KVUY@WXY@]´[KGX]HFHV\WXRUD@N£R\F>FOg@R�[KWXYJ8T·[)RUQSVUT�b2WXY´x@WXbX�EQ@Y@B p

Page 2: 0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

RUWXaOT_Y@FHV\N>[KGkJ8FHV\N�J8FOV4Y@TZ¢&b b\RUFOVUd�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHYiv.Ôi[)YS]Î lHl\Ï Q@b\T�x¨[±N/WcYSWcN2Q@N£x@TZbUB�V\WcPSRUWXFHYÂGXT�YS]HRUD¯P@VUWXY@BZWcPSGcT�R\FbUTZGcTZB�R4R\T�VUN/b�J8FHV � T�R\Y@T�¢&b�B$[KRUT�]OFHVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY�v°ÂD@WXGXT±N>[)YCd�J;T$[)R\Q@VUT¯bUT�GXT�B�R\WXFHY�RUTZB�DSY@WX¥�QST�b9D�[·aHT9gkT�T�YRUV\WXT�xih�RUD@FOVUFHQS]HD9T�aH[KGcQk[)RUWXFOY@b [KVUT"VE[)V\T�GXdB$[)V\VUWXT�x¯[email protected]¸[)V\]HT&RUTZ��RMB$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[)R\WXFHYwP@V\FHg@GXT�N/b$v � D@WXb�WXb�xSQ@T&WXYwP�[)V\RRUF�RUD@T JÁ[)B�RMRUD�[KR�N�[)YCd�GcT·[)VUYSWcYS]�[)GX]HFOVUWXRUDSN"bixSF_Y@FHRMbUB$[KGcTRUFw[�D@WX]OD p xSWcN/T�Y@b\WcFOY�[)GOJ8T·[)RUQSVUT�bUP�[KB�THv � D�[KR�WXb·hHWºJ~[!B�G¸[)b pbUWº¹�TZV�B$[)Y2FHYSGcd�g�T&R\T�bUR\T�x"FOY�[.bUN�[)GXGHb\Q@g@b\T�R�FKJ�RUDST&Y�[)R\WcaOTbUPk[)B�THh�FHYSTwB$[)Y@YSFHR�Q@bUTwWXR�RUF�T�aH[KGXQ�[)R\T�R\D@T_J;Q@GXG»VE[)Y@]OTwF)JPkFHRUTZY�R\W¸[)GIF)J=J8T·[)RUQSVUT�bUT�GXT�BZRUWXFHYN/T�RUDSF�xSb$v j VUT�B�TZY�R�R\D@T�F pVUTZRUWXB$[)GkB�FON"P�[KVUWXbUFOYihZJ8FHV=T��@[)N/P@GXTHh·¢Ñ[Kb�g�[KbUT�xwFOY�R\D@T&P�TZV pJ8FOVUN>[KY@B�T_FKJÑxST�B�WXbUWXFHY9R\VUT�T�[)GX]HFOVUWXRUDSN"b&WXY´b\FHGXaCWXY@]"P@V\FHg pGXT�N"b2¢&WXRUD Ò R\F l$�Ot J8T$[)R\Q@VUTZb"WXYÂRUDSTY�[)R\WXaHT�bUP�[KB�THÎ l$tqÏ vj Y9[)Yk[)GXdCbUWXb�FHY±RUD@WXb�bUB$[KGXTwWcb�x@WXb\R�[)YCR.J8V\FHN£RUDSTwVUT$[KGcWXR\WcTZbF)J=RUT��CR.B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[)R\WXFHYiv� [email protected]�Q@b&WXY/RUD@WXb�P�[)PkT�V4WXb�RUD@T�T�aH[KGXQ�[)R\WcFOY"[)Y@x/B�FHN/P�[)V pWXbUFOY"F)JIJ;T$[)R\Q@VUT�bUTZGcTZB�RUWXFHY�N/T�RUD@FCx@b�WXY"R\D@T�VUT�x@QSB�RUWXFHY�FKJ»[D@WX]HD±x@WXN"TZY@bUWXFHYk[)GIJ;T$[)R\Q@VUTwb\P�[)B�TwWXY±RUT��CR_B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOYP@V\FHg@GXT�N/b$v/°9TwQ@bUTwRe¢�FB�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V\b�¢&DSWcBED9D�[·aOT"[)GXVUT·[)x@dbUB·[)GXT�x_R\F [&RE[)V\]HT�R�bUP�[KB�T�¢&WXR\D_RUD@FOQ@b�[KY@x@b�FHViR\T�Y@b=F)J@R\D@FHQ pb�[KY@[email protected])J�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b·v4°9T�bUTZT�¶´[)YSbU¢�T�VUb�RUFwR\D@T�J8FHGXGXF)¢&WXY@]¥CQ@T�b\RUWXFHY@b&¢&WXR\D>TZN"P@WXVUWXB$[KG�TZa�WXx@TZY@B�T��

� °ÂDk[)R»[KVUT�R\D@T�bURUV\T�Y@]ORUD@b�[KY@x_¢�T$[)¶CY@TZbUbUTZb�F)J@T��CWXbUR\WcYS]J8T·[)RUQSVUT_b\T�GXT�B�RUWXFOY´N/T�RUD@FCx@b4[KP@P@GXWXT�x�RUF/RUT��CR4B·[)RUTZ]HF pV\Wc�·[)RUWXFOY��

� � F_¢&D�[KR�TZ��R\T�Y@x/B$[)Y�J8T$[)R\Q@VUT�b\T�GXT�B�RUWXFOY"WXN"P@V\F)aHT�RUD@T[KB�B�Q@VE[)B�d�F)J [±BZG½[KbUb\WÓ¹kT�V�� ®4F)¢µNwQ@BED�F)J�RUD@T�x@FCB pQ@N/T�YCR&aHFCB$[Kg@Q@G¸[)V\d"B$[KYg�T2VUTZx@Q@B�T�x±¢&WXRUD@FOQ@R4GXFObUWXY@]Q@b\TEJ8Q@G�WXYCJ8FHV\N>[KRUWXFHY2WXY"B$[KRUT�]OFHVUd�P@V\T�x@WXB�R\WcFOY��

ACT�BZRUWXFHY n x@T�b\B�VUWXgkT�b2RUD@TwR\T�VUN¿bUTZGcTZB�RUWXFHY9N/T�RUDSF�xSb$vw�.Q@TRUF/bUP�[KB�T2GcWXN/WcRE[)R\WcF)YSb$hO¢�T2¢&WXGcGIYSFHR4WXY@BZGcQSx@T_P@D@VE[)b\T�b\T�GXT�B pRUWXFOY�¦¸THv ]kvcÎ o'Ï §4[)YSx´[)P@PSVUF�[KBED@T�b�g�[)b\T�x±FHYP@V\WXY@B�WXP�[)G�B�FHN pPkFHY@T�YCR�[)Y�[KGcdCb\Wcb·Î m h n)� h n@l h l$�·Ï v�ACT�B�R\WcFOY o x@T�b\B�VUWXgkT�b�RUD@TB�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V\b4[)Y@xwR\D@T4xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR�BZFHVUPSQ@b&BED@FHb\T�YwJ8FOV�TZN"P@WXVUW pB$[KG�aH[KGcWXx�[KRUWXFHY�vÊA�T�B�RUWXFOY � P@V\T�bUTZY�R\b4R\D@T4T��CPkT�VUWXN/T�YCRUb�[KY@xRUDST´V\T�bUQ@GXR\b$v�ACT�BZRUWXFHY m x@WXbUB�QSbUbUTZbRUD@T±N>[Z�EFHV2¹�YSx@WXY@]Hb·vACT�BZRUWXFHY Ò bUQSN"N>[KVUWX��T�bMRUD@T_BZFHY@B�GXQ@b\WXFHY@b·v

� � ���@È4� �� ��� �k�@É\Æ Å��� ���.Æ&Ç4�

 �WXaHT&N"TZRUD@FCx@b�[)V\T4WXY@B�GXQ@xST�xwWXY�R\D@WXb�bUR\Q@x@dChHT$[KBED"F)JI¢&D@WXBEDQ@b\T�b_[wRUTZVUN p ]HFCFCx@Y@TZbUb4BZVUWXRUT�V\WXFHYR\D@VUT�b\D@FHGXx@TZx´R\F>[)BED@WXT�aOT[wxST�bUWXVUTZx´x@TZ]HVUTZT�FKJ~R\T�VUN T�GXWXN"WXY�[)R\WXF)Y2J8VUFON²R\D@T_J;Q@GXGiaHF pB$[Kg@Q@G¸[)V\d,FKJ�[±x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R/B�FHV\P@Q@b·v � D@TZbUT±B�VUWXRUTZVUW¸[�[KVUT��x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR=J8V\T�¥CQ@T�Y@B�d¦;�� »§Zh)WXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHY�]C[)WXY>¦©�Uª_§�hONwQ pRUQk[)GiWXYCJ;FHVUN�[)R\WcFOY>¦;^��U§�hk[ ¬»­ b\R�[KRUWXbUR\WcB/¦8L�®4�U§Zh�[KY@xRUTZVUNbUR\VUT�YS]HRUD¯¦ � A@§Zv

� |�� �������=79��:� "!U�)�$#%�=��:&��'( *)=�)���+),��-e��6¸:=<(./�1032�.FCB�Q@N"TZY�R�J8V\T�¥CQ@T�Y@B�d�WXb2RUD@T�YCQ@NwgkT�V�FKJ x@FCB�QSN"T�YCRUb2WXY¢&D@WXBED [¯R\T�VUN�FCB�B�Q@V\b$v£°9T±B�FON"P@Q@R\T�x{RUD@T±x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR

J8V\T�¥CQ@T�Y@B�d J8FHV/T$[)BED{Q@Y@WX¥CQ@TRUTZVUN¡WXYÂRUDST´R\V�[)WXY@WXY@]9BZFHV pP@Q@b2[)Y@x9V\T�N"F)aOT�x�J8V\FHN R\D@TwJ;T$[)R\Q@VUTwb\P�[)B�T/RUD@FObUTwR\T�VUN/b¢&D@FObUT_x@FCB�QSN"T�YCR�J8V\T�¥CQ@T�Y@B�d�¢&[)b&GXT�b\b4RUDk[)Y�bUFON"T�P@VUTZx@T pRUTZVUN"WXY@TZxwRUD@V\T�bUD@FOGXxiv � D@T&g�[KbUWXB4[)b\bUQ@N/P@RUWXFHY2WXb�RUDk[)R�VE[)VUTRUTZVUN"b_[KVUTwT�WXRUDST�V�YSFHY p WXYCJ8FHV\N>[KRUWXa)T.J8FHV�B$[KRUT�]OFHVUd±P@V\T�x@WXB pRUWXFOYih·FHV=Y@FHR=WXY54�QST�YCRUW¸[)GCWXY_]HGXFOg�[)GOP�T�VrJ8FHV\N>[KY@B�THv��eY�TZWcR\D@T�VB$[KbUT_V\T�N"F)aH[KG�FKJ»V�[KVUT_R\T�VUN/b&VUT�xSQ@B�T�b�RUDST_x@WXN"T�YSbUWXFHY�[KGXWcRedF)J�RUD@T�J8T$[KRUQ@V\T>b\P�[)BZTHv��eN/P@VUF)aOT�N"TZY�R�WXY�B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOY[)BZB�Q@V�[KB�d�WXb�[KGcb\F´PkFHb\bUWXg@GXT�WºJ V�[KVUT�RUTZVUN"bwDk[)P@PkT�Y�RUF±g�TY@FOWcb\T�RUT�V\N"b$v�� ±RUD@V\T�bUDSFHGXx@WXY@]wWXb�R\D@T�bUWXN"PSGcTZbUR�RUT�BED@Y@WX¥[email protected]�aOF�B·[)g@Q pG¸[)V\dVUT�xSQ@B�RUWXFOYiv2�eR T·[)bUWXGXdb\B$[)GXT�b_R\F�aHT�V\dG¸[)VU]OT�BZFHVUPkFHVE[@h¢&WXRUDÂ[±B�FON"P@Q@RE[)R\WcFOY�[)G�B�FON"P@GXT��CWXRed¾[KP@P@V\F)��WXN�[)RUTZGcd±GXWXY pT$[KV&WcY�R\D@T�Y�QSNwg�T�V�F)J�R\V�[)WXY@WXY@]2x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb·vi®.F)¢�T�aOT�V$hSWXRWXb�Q@bUQ�[KGXGcdÀB�FHY@b\WXx@T�VUTZx,[)Y�[Kx´DSF�B"[KP@P@V\F�[)BED±RUFWXN/P@VUF)aOTTEË"B�WXT�YSB�d�h�Y@FOR![�P@VUWXY@BZWcPSGcTZx´B�V\WXRUT�V\WcFOY±J8FHV�b\T�GXT�B�RUWXY@]�P@V\T px@WXB�R\WcaOT�J8T$[KRUQ@V\T�b$v j GXb\F�h4�� �WXb/Red�PSWcB·[)GXGXd�Y@FORwQ@bUT�x�J8FOV[)]O]HV\T�bUb\WcaOTwRUT�V\N V\T�N"F)aH[KGigkT�B$[)QSbUT"FKJÑ[/¢&WXx@T�GXdVUTZB�T�WXaHT�x[)b\bUQ@N/P@RUWXFOY>WXYWXYCJ;FHVUN�[)R\WcFOYwVUT�R\VUWXT�aH[KGÁv � Dk[)R4WXb·h�GXF)¢ p �� RUTZVUN"b[KVUT9[)bUb\Q@N"TZxÂRUF�gkT´V\T�G¸[)RUWXaOT�GXd,WXYCJ;FHVUN�[)R\WcaOT>[KY@xRUDST�VUTEJ;FHVUT�bUD@FOQ@GXx"Y@FOR�gkT_VUTZN"F)aHTZx"[)]H]OVUT�b\bUWXaHTZGcdCv�°9T4¢&WXGXGVUT p T��@[KN"WXY@T4R\D@WXb [KbUbUQSN"P@R\WcFOYw¢&WXRUD�VUT�b\P�TZB�R_RUFwR\T��CR&B$[)R\T p]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY/R�[)b\¶Cb$v

� | � 6 :�!����)79?$ ·67��:9<k?@6;:8. 6*9 2�eYCJ8FOVUN�[)RUWXFOY,]C[)WXYÂWXb/J8VUTZ¥�QST�YCRUGXdÂT�N/P@GXF)dHT�x¨[Kb[�R\T�VUN p]HFCFCx@Y@TZbUb4BZVUWXRUT�V\WXFHYWXY�RUD@T!¹�T�GXx�F)J�N>[KB�DSWcYST4GXT$[)V\Y@WXY@]�Î l·s hl��KÏ v¨�eR/N"T$[KbUQ@V\T�b"R\D@TYCQ@NwgkT�V"FKJ_g@WXRUb"FKJ_WcY�J8FHV\N>[)R\WXFHYFHgSR�[)WXY@TZxwJ8FOV�B$[KRUT�]OFHV\d"P@V\T�x@WXB�RUWXFOY>gCdw¶CY@F)¢&WXY@]_R\D@T�P@VUTZb pT�Y@BZT�FOV4[)g@b\T�Y@B�T2F)J�[2RUT�V\N£WcY[2x@FCB�QSN"T�YCR$v�Ô¤T�R;:=</>@?*A>CB�Dx@T�YSFHRUTwR\D@TwbUTZR_F)J�B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WXT�b_WXY´R\D@TwR�[KVU]OT�R_bUPk[)B�THv � D@TWXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHY2]�[KWXY"F)J=RUT�V\N�E&WXb&x@TE¹�YST�xRUFwgkT��

F�¦GE�§,H IKJ A>�B�D�L�M ¦N< > §CGXFH] L�M ¦7< > §O L M ¦CE�§ J A>�B�D L M ¦N</>QP E�§CGXFH] L M ¦N</>QP E�§O L�M ¦SRE�§$J A>�B�D L�M ¦N< > PTRE�§CGXFH] L�M ¦N< > PTRE�§

� D@WXb�x@TE¹�Y@WXR\WcFOY"WXb�N/FHVUT&]OT�Y@T�VE[)G�RUD�[KY"RUDST4FHYST4T�N/P@GXF)dHT�xWXY¨gSWcYk[)VUd�B�G¸[KbUbUWº¹�B·[)RUWXFOY¨N/F�xST�GXb$Î l$o h l$ÒZÏ v °9TQ@b\T9RUD@TN"FOVUTw]OT�Y@T�VE[)G�J8FOVUN0gkT�B$[KQ@bUTR\T��CR�B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOY�P@V\FHg pGXT�N"b�Q@bUQ�[KGXGcd±D�[·aOT>[VU p [)VUd9B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\d�b\P�[)B�T9¦©¢&D@T�VUTVUN>[·d�gkT4Q@PwR\F_RUTZY@b�FKJiRUD@FOQ@b�[KY@x@bE§�h@[)YSxw¢�T&Y@TZT�x"R\F_N"T$[ pbUQSVUT"R\D@T"]OFCF�xSY@T�bUb2F)J [/R\T�VUN0]OGXFHg�[KGcGXd�¢&WXRUD9V\T�bUPkT�B�RwR\F[)GXGIB$[KRUT�]OFHV\WcTZb&FHY[·aHT�VE[)]OTHvª�WXaHTZY�[.RUVE[)WXY@WXY@]�B�FOVUP@Q@b·h)J;FHV�T$[KBEDwQ@Y@WX¥CQ@T&RUT�V\NÌ¢�T�B�FHN pP@Q@R\T�xwRUDST&WcY�J8FHV\N>[)R\WXFHY4]C[)WXYih)[)YSx�V\T�N"F)aOT�x�J8V\FHN�R\D@TMJ8T$[ pRUQSVUT�bUP�[KB�T&RUD@FObUT�RUT�V\N"b�¢&D@FHb\T�WXYCJ8FOVUN�[)RUWXFOY&]�[)WXY_¢&[)b�GXT�bUbRUDk[)Y2bUFHN/T�P@V\T�x@T�R\T�VUN/WcYST�xwRUD@V\T�bUDSFHGXxiv � D@T&B�FHN/P@Q@RE[)RUWXFOYWXY@B�GXQ@x@TZb�RUD@T�T�b\RUWXN>[KRUWXFHY_FKJ�RUDST&B�FHY@xSWcR\WXFHY�[KG�PSVUFHgk[)g@WXGXWXRUWXT�bF)J�[_B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\d"]OWcaOT�Y[_R\T�VUN±h@[)Y@x/RUD@T�T�YCR\VUFHPCd/B�FHN/P@Q@R�[ pRUWXFOY@b�WXY"R\D@T4x@T'¹�Y@WXRUWXFHY�v � [email protected]@VUFOg�[)gSWcGXWXRed_T�b\RUWXN>[KRUWXFHY2D�[Kb[2RUWXN/T&B�FHN/P@GXT��CWcRed2F)J&Ww¦NXÀ§&[)Y@x[2bUPk[)B�T_BZFHN"PSGcTZ��WXRed2F)JWw¦ZY[X§=¢&D@TZVUT\XµWcb=R\D@T&YCQ@Nwg�TZV»FKJ�RUVE[)WXY@WXY@]�x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb·h[)YSx]YÌWXb R\D@T2aHFCB$[)gSQ@G¸[)VUd�b\Wc�ZTHv � D@T�TZY�R\VUFOP�dÀB�FHN/P@Q@R�[ pRUWXFOY@b&D�[)b4[�RUWXN/T4B�FON"P@GXT��CWXRed�FKJ^Ww¦ZY_U/§�v

Page 3: 0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

� | � � � *�=?$-�6;:�!����)79?$ ·67��: . � 6 2^�Q@R\Q�[)G&WXYCJ;FHVUN�[)R\WcFOY´WXbw[BZVUWXRUT�V\WXFHY�B�FHN/N"FOY@GXd>QSbUT�x�WXYbURE[)R\Wcb\RUWXB$[KG�G¸[KY@]HQ�[K]HT=N"FCx@TZGcGXWXY@]�F)J@¢�FHVUx2[)bUb\FCB�W¸[)RUWXFOY@b»[KY@xVUTZG½[KRUT�xw[)PSP@GXWcB·[)RUWXFOY@b�Î s h n h n@l'Ï vI�;J�FHYST�B�FOY@bUWXx@TZVUb�R\D@T&Re¢�F p¢&[·d´B�FOYCRUWXY@]HTZY@B�d9R�[Kg@GXTwF)J [�R\T�VUN E�[)Y@x�[ÀB$[KRUT�]OFHVUd]<Kh¢&D@T�V\T��{Wcb�RUDST YCQ@NwgkT�V�F)J=RUWXN"T�b^E [KY@x < B�F p FCB�B�Q@V·h�� WXbRUDST�YCQ@NwgkT�VIF)J@R\WcN/T=RUD@T EiFCB�B�Q@V\b»¢&WXR\D@FHQ@R,<)h���WXbiYCQ@NwgkT�VF)JIRUWXN/T�b&<�F�BZB�Q@VUb&¢&WXR\D@FHQ@R�E$hC[)Y@x�X WXb�R\D@T&RUFOR�[KG�YCQ@NwgkT�VF)J4xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR\b$h=RUDST�Y�R\D@T"NwQ@R\Q�[)GMWcY�J8FHV\N>[)R\WXFHYB�V\WXRUT�V\WcFOYgkT�Re¢�TZT�Y1E4[)Y@x <.WXb�x@T'¹�Y@T�xR\Fwg�T

� ¦GE/<�§&H�GXFH] L�M ¦GE��1<�§L M ¦GE�§� L M ¦N<�§

[)YSx>WXb�T�bUR\WXN>[)R\T�x�Q@bUWXY@]

� ¦GE/<�§���GXFH] �� X¦�� O �_§� 9¦�� O ��§

� ¦CE�<Z§2D�[)b"[±Y�[KRUQ@VE[)G.aH[)GXQ@T"FKJ_��T�VUF¯WºJ\E"[)Y@x <�[)V\TWXY px@T�PkT�Y@xST�YCR$v � F�N"T$[KbUQ@V\T´R\D@T9]HFCFCx@Y@TZbUbFKJ�[¯RUT�V\N WXY[±]HGXFOg�[)GMJ8T$[KRUQ@V\T>b\T�GXT�B�R\WcFOYih&¢�T�B�FHNwg@WXY@TwR\D@TB$[KRUT�]OFHV\d pbUPkT�B�Wº¹�B�bUB�FOVUT�b�F)J�[2RUT�V\N²WXYCRUF2Re¢�F"[)GXRUT�V\Y�[)R\T�¢Ñ[·dCb �

������� ¦GE�§&H A�>�B�D

L M ¦7</>Á§ � ¦CE�</>e§

� A ��� ¦CE�§&H AN>[)�>�B�D : � ¦CE�< > §/?� D@T&^��IB�FON"P@Q@RE[)R\WcFOY�D�[)b�[&R\WXN"T=B�FHN/P@GXT��CWXRed4F)J�Ww¦ZY_U/§�hbUWXN/WcG¸[KV»R\FwRUD@T��Uª�B�FON"P@Q@RE[)R\WcFOYivj ¢�T$[K¶�YST�bUb/F)J_NwQ@RUQk[)G�WcY�J8FHV\N>[)R\WXFHY9WXbwRUD�[KR"R\D@TbUBZFHVUTWXb&bUR\VUFHYS]HGXd"WXY54�QST�Y@B�T�x±gCd"R\D@T_N>[KVU]OWcYk[)G@P@V\FHg�[Kg@WXGXWcR\WXT�b&F)JRUTZVUN"b·h@[)b&B$[KY�g�T_b\T�T�YWXY/RUD@WXb&T�¥CQ@WXaH[)GXT�YCRMJ8FHV\N(�

� ¦GE/<�§,H�GcFO] L M ¦GE P <�§�I±GXFH] L M ¦CE�§�� SFHV�R\T�VUN/b�¢&WXRUD [)Y¡TZ¥�Qk[)G{B�FHY@xSWcR\WXFHY�[KGÂP@VUFOg�[)gSWcGXWXRedL�M ¦GE P <�§ZhCV�[KVUT_R\T�VUN/b&¢&WcGXGID�[·aOT_[2D@WX]HD@T�V&b\B�FHV\T_RUDk[)Y�B�FHN pN"FOYwRUT�V\N"b·v � D@T�b\B�FHV\T�b$hkRUDST�VUTEJ;FHVUTOh�[)V\T�Y@FHR�B�FHN/P�[)VE[)g@GXT[)BZVUFHb\b4R\T�VUN/b�FKJ~¢&WXx@TZGcdwxSWÓ³IT�V\WcYS]2J8VUT�¥CQ@TZY@B�dCv

� |�� ¬»­ �Q ·?$ ·6Á�+ $6@� .� �! 6 2� D@T ¬=­ b\R�[)R\WXbURUWXB&N/T$[)b\Q@VUT�b=R\D@T&G¸[)BE¶_F)JkWcYSx@T�PkT�Y@x@T�YSB�T4gkT pRe¢�T�T�Y E�[)Y@x�<&[KY@xwB$[KYwg�T&B�FON"P�[KVUT�x2RUF�RUD@T ¬»­ x@WXbUR\VUWXg@Q pRUWXFOYw¢&WcR\D"FOY@T4x@TZ]HVUTZT FKJIJ8VUTZT�x@FHNµRUF&�EQ@x@]OT4T��CRUV\T�N"TZY@T�bUb·v`4b\WXY@]"R\D@TwRe¢�F p ¢&[·d"BZFHYCRUWXY@]OT�Y@B�dRE[)g@GXT_FKJÑ[/RUT�V\N E [KY@x[wB·[)RUTZ]HFHV\d <)hk¢&D@T�VUT"�ÌWXb&RUD@T2YCQ@Nwg�TZV4F)J�R\WcN/T�b E [)YSx(<B�F p FCB�B�QSV$h#� Wcb�R\D@T�YCQ@NwgkT�V.F)J&RUWXN"T�RUDST E FCB�B�Q@V\b_¢&WXRUD pFHQSR\<)h$��WXb&RUDST YCQ@NwgkT�V�F)J=RUWXN"T�b<.FCB�B�Q@V\b4¢&WXRUD@FOQ@R E$h$%WXb4R\D@TwYCQ@Nwg�TZV&F)J�R\WcN/T�b4YST�WXRUD@T�V;<�Y@FHV E FCB�B�QSVUb$h=[)YSx(XWXb4R\D@TwRUFOR�[)G�YCQ@Nwg�TZV4F)J�x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R\b$hIR\D@T2RUT�V\N p ]HFCFCx@Y@T�b\bN"T·[)bUQSVUT�WXb&x@TE¹�Y@TZxRUF2g�T �

¬ ­ ¦GE/<�§,H X& ¾¦��'% I(���_§ ­¦�� O �_§� ´¦)� O %w§� 9¦�� O �_§* ±¦+� O %w§ �

� D@T ¬=­ bURE[)R\Wcb\RUWXB�D�[Kbi[&Y�[KRUQ@VE[)GOaH[)GXQ@T=F)JC��T�VUF�WºJ�E»[KY@x;<�[)V\TWXY@x@T�PkT�Y@xST�YCR$vw°9T2B�FHN/P@Q@R\T�xJ;FHV4T·[)BED9B$[)R\T�]HFOVUd±RUD@T ¬»­bURE[)R\Wcb\RUWXB�g�T�Re¢�T�T�YwT·[)BED_Q@Y@WX¥CQ@T�RUT�V\N�WXY�[ RUV�[KWXY@WXY@]&B�FHV\P@Q@b[)YSx�RUDk[)R2B$[)R\T�]HFOVUdCh�[)Y@x¯RUD@T�Y¯B�FHNwgSWcYST�x9RUD@T�B$[KRUT�]OFHV\d pbUPkT�B�Wº¹�B�bUB�FOVUT�b�F)J=T$[)BEDR\T�VUN WXYCRUF2Re¢�F2bUB�FOVUT�b*�

¬ ­����� ¦CE�§&HA�>�B�D

L M ¦7</>e§ ¬ ­ ¦GE/</>Á§

¬ ­A ��� ¦CE�§&H AN�[)�>�B�D : ¬ ­ ¦GE/< > §/?� D@T_BZFHN"PSQ@R�[KRUWXFHY/F)JÑL�®.�&bUB�FOVUT�b�D�[Kb [w¥CQ�[Kx@V�[KRUWXB�B�FHN pP@GXT��CWXRed�hObUWXN/WcG¸[KV�RUFw^��&[)Y@x��Uªwvj N�[��EFOV�x@Wº³IT�VUTZY@B�T2g�T�Re¢�T�T�Y9L�®4�4[KY@x^��&WXb&RUD�[KR ¬=­ WXb[�Y@FOVUN�[)GXWX��T�x±aH[)GXQ@THh�[KY@x9D@T�Y@BZT ¬=­ aH[KGcQST�b�[KVUT/B�FHN/P�[ pV�[Kg@GXT[)B�V\FHbUb/RUT�V\N"b�J8FHV2RUD@TÀb�[)N/T�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUdCv®4F)¢�T�aOT�V$hRUDSWcb.Y@FHV\N>[KGcWX�$[KRUWXFHYwgSVUT$[K¶�b.x@F)¢&Y�¦©B$[)YYSFwGcFOY@]HTZV4gkT�[)B pB�Q@VE[)R\T�GXd�B�FON"P�[KVUT�x2RUF�R\D@T ¬»­ x@WXb\RUVUWXg@QSRUWXFHY�§�WºJÊ[KY�d�B�T�GXG@WXYRUDST�B�FOYCRUWXY@]HTZY@B�d2R�[)gSGcTMWcb=GXWX]HDCRUGXd.P�FOP@Q@G¸[)R\T�xih)¢&D@WXBED2Wcb�RUD@TB$[KbUT2J8FOV4GXF)¢{J8VUTZ¥�QST�Y@B�d±RUT�V\N"b·v_®4TZY@B�THh=R\D@T ¬=­ bURE[)RUWXb\RUWXBWXb�¶CY@F)¢&YwYSFHR�RUF2g�T.VUT�GXW¸[)g@GXT�J8FOV�GXF)¢ p J8VUTZ¥�QST�Y@B�dwR\T�VUN/b$Î ÒZÏ v

� |-, .��C�)7 �+ $�)�C:=<� *)8.�."/,2� T�VUNÌb\RUVUTZY@]HR\D>WXb�FOVUWX]HWXY�[KGXGcd�P@V\FHPkFHb\T�x>[KY@xwT�aH[)GXQ�[KRUT�xwgCd°ÂWXGXg@Q@V_[)YSx�ACWXVUFHR\¶CWcY�Î nHnZÏ J;FHV_aOF�B·[)g@Q@G¸[KVUdV\T�x@Q@B�R\WXFHY9WXYRUTZ��R�VUT�R\VUWXT�aH[)Gehi[KY@x±G½[KRUT�V_[KP@P@GXWXT�x´gCd Ö [)Y@]�[)Y@x±°ÂWXGXg@Q@VRUF2RUTZ��R�B$[KRUT�]OFHVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY±Î n)� h nH�ZÏ v � D@WXb�N/T�RUDSF�xwTZbURUWXN�[)RUTZbRUTZVUN WcN/P�FOVURE[)Y@B�T/g�[)b\T�x�FHY¯D@F)¢�B�FON"N"FOY@GXd[R\T�VUN WXbGXWX¶HT�GXd&RUF�[)P@PkT$[KViWXY�×UB�GXFHb\T�GXd p V\T�G¸[)RUTZx@Ù4x@FCB�QSN"T�YCRUb·vI�eRiQSbUT�b[wR\V�[KWcYSWcYS]wbUT�R_FKJ�x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R\b4R\F"x@T�V\WXaHT2x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R.P�[)WXV\b¢&D@FObUT"b\WXN"WXG¸[)VUWXRed±¦¸N"T·[)bUQSVUT�x9Q@b\WXY@]RUDST"B�FObUWXY@T"aH[KGXQ@TwF)JRUDST�Re¢�F&xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCRIaOT�B�RUFOVUbE§iWXbi[Kg�F)aOT~[�R\D@VUTZbUD@FOGcx�v4× � TZVUNACR\VUT�Y@]ORUD@Ù¯RUD@TZY,WXbwB�FON"P@QSRUT�x�g�[KbUT�x�FHY�R\D@TT�b\RUWXN>[KRUT�xB�FOY@x@WXRUWXFHYk[)GiPSVUFHgk[)g@WXGXWXRedwRUD�[KR [wR\T�VUN£FCB�BZQ@VUb_WXY�RUDST�b\T�B pFHYSx´D�[KGºJÑFKJ [/P�[KWcV�FKJÑV\T�G¸[)RUTZx9x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R\b�]HWXaHT�Y±RUDk[)R�WXRFCB�B�Q@V\b�WXY9R\D@T2¹�VUb\R�Dk[)GºJ�vwÔIT�R"0�[)YSx21�g�T�[)Y9[)V\g@WXRUV�[KVUdP�[KWcVIFKJ�x@WXbUR\WXY@B�RigSQ@RiV\T�G¸[)RUTZx_x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb$h)[KY@x"EigkT�[&R\T�VUN±hRUDST�YRUDST b\RUV\T�Y@]HR\DF)J=RUD@T�RUT�V\N²WXb&x@TE¹kY@T�xR\Fwg�T��

3 ¦GE�§&H L M ¦GE*451�P E*460k§��� D@T�RUTZVUN£bUR\VUT�YS]HRUDÀB�VUWXRUTZVUWXFHY�WXb&V�[Kx@WXB$[)GXGXdwx@Wº³ÊTZVUT�YCR&J;VUFHNRUDSTÂFHY@TZb�N"TZY�R\WXFHY@T�xÌT$[KVUGXWXT�V$v �eR�WXb9g�[KbUT�x�FOY�x@FCB�Q pN"TZY�RMB�GXQ@bUR\T�VUWXY@]kh�[)b\bUQ@N/WXY@]_RUDk[)R�x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R\b&¢&WXRUD"N�[)YCdbUDk[)VUTZx¢�FOVUx@b4[KVUT_V\T�G¸[)R\T�xih�[KY@x�RUD�[KR&RUT�V\N"b&WXY"R\D@T_D@T·[·a pWXGXd4F)aHTZVUG¸[)P@PSWcYS]4[)VUT·[&F)JkVUT�G¸[)R\T�x_x@FCB�QSN"T�YCRUb=[)V\T�V\T�G¸[)RUWXaOT�GXdWXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXaHTOv � D@WXb�N"T�R\D@FCx´WXb_YSFHR�R�[KbU¶ p b\P�TZB�Wº¹�BHh=Wev THvXhIWXRx@FCT�b�Y@FOR4Q@b\T_WXYCJ8FHV\N>[KRUWXFHY"[Kg�FOQ@R4R\T�VUN p B$[KRUT�]OFHV\d«[KbUb\F�BZW p[)R\WXFHY@b·v��eYR\D@WXb&bUT�Y@b\THhIWXR&WXb&bUWXN"WXG¸[)VMRUF"R\D@T��� 9BZVUWXRUT�V\WXFHYihg@Q@R&xSWÓ³IT�V\T�YCR&J8V\FHN�R\D@T_�Uªwh@^���[)Y@x�RUDST ¬»­ bURE[)R\Wcb\RUWXBHvj P�[)VE[)N"TZRUT�V�WXY"RUDST � A/B$[KGXB�Q@G¸[)R\WcFOYwWXb�R\D@T�RUD@V\T�bUD@FOGXx>FOYx@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRwbUWXN"WXG¸[)V\WXRedaH[)GXQ@T�b·v � D�[)RwWXb$h�D@F)¢ B�GXFHb\TRe¢�Fx@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUbwNwQ@b\R�gkTR\F´gkTB�FOY@bUWXx@T�V\T�x�[V\T�G¸[)RUTZxÂP�[)WXV·v°9T"QSbUT j��87 ÔMh=RUD@T�[·aHT�VE[)]OT"YCQ@NwgkT�V�FKJ4VUT�G¸[KRUT�x�x@FCB�Q pN"TZY�R\b&P�TZV4x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR&WXY>R\D@VUTZbUD@FOGcx±RUQSY@WXY@]�v � D�[)R.Wcb·h@¢�T

Page 4: 0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

B�FON"P@Q@R\T�R\D@T&bUWXN/WcG¸[KVUWXRed&bUB�FOVUT�b�F)JI[)GXGCRUD@T&x@FCB�QSN"T�YCRUb=WXYw[RUVE[)WXY@WXY@]wb\T�R$h�RUV\d>xSWÓ³IT�V\T�YCR_RUD@V\T�bUDSFHGXx@b�FHYR\D@T2bUWXN"WXG¸[)V\WcRedaH[)GXQ@TZb�FKJix@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R�P�[KWcV\b$h@[KY@x"R\D@T�Y"BED@FCFObUT�RUD@T�R\D@VUT�b\D pFHGXx/¢&D@WXB�D�V\T�bUQ@GXR\b4WXY[2VUT$[KbUFHYk[)g@GXT�aH[)GXQ@T�F)J j � 7 Ô�v � D@TaH[)GXQ@T�FKJ j � 7 Ô±WXb4BED@FObUT�YTZ��PkT�V\WcN/T�YCR�[KGcGXdCh�[KB�B�FOVUx@WXY@]wR\FD@F)¢9¢�T�GXGCWcR=FOP@RUWXN"WX��TZx R\D@T�P�T�VrJ8FHV\N>[KY@B�T�WcY�RUD@T�R�[KbU¶Iv j B pB�FOVUx@WXY@]�RUF�P@V\T�aCWXFHQ@b_TZaH[)GXQ�[)R\[email protected])J&VUT�R\VUWXT�aH[)G�[)Y@x±B$[)R\T p]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHYwFOYwbUT�aOT�V�[KGix@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR�B�FOGcGXT�BZRUWXFHY@b·Î nHn h nH�ZÏ hORUD@Tj � 7 Ô±aH[)GXQ@TZb4gkT�Re¢�TZT�Y l$t R\F nOt d�WXT�GXx�b�[KRUWXbeJe[)B�R\FHVUd/P�TZV pJ8FOVUN>[KY@B�THv � DST_B�FHN/P@Q@RE[)RUWXFOY"F)J � A/WXb&¥CQ�[)x@VE[)R\WcB�WXY�RUD@TYCQ@NwgkT�V�FKJ»R\V�[)WXY@WXY@]2x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb·v

� �(� �=�C���� �@�9� Š����i�@�

� |�� [-;?��·��6������H�� F´[)b\bUT�b\b"R\D@T"TE³IT�B�R\WXaHT�Y@TZbUb�F)J&J8T·[)RUQSVUT"b\T�GXT�B�R\WcFOY�N"T�R\D pFCx@b{¢�T Q@bUT�x Re¢�Fµx@Wº³ÊT�V\T�YCR U p [)V\d²B�G¸[KbUbUWº¹�TZVUb$h�[� pY@T$[KVUT�b\R p Y@T�WX]HDCgkFHV�B�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�Vw¦©¶ �3� §ZÎ nOo·Ï [)Y@x´[�VUT�]OVUT�b\bUWXFHYN"TZRUD@FCx"Yk[)N"TZxwRUD@T�Ô¤WXY@T$[)V&ÔIT·[)bUR4A�¥�Qk[)VUTZb  �WXR�N�[)P@P@WXY@]¦8Ô�ÔiA@ =§ZÎ nOsZÏ v � D@T4WXY@P@QSR�R\F�gkFHR\D"bUdCb\RUT�N/b�WXb&[�x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR¢&D@WXBED_WXbIVUT�PSVUT�b\T�YCRUT�x�[)b»[�b\P�[)V\bUT�aHT�BZRUFHV=FKJ�¢�FHV\x�¢�T�WX]OD�R\b$h[)[email protected]@R\P@Q@R�FKJiRUD@T�b\T4b\d�b\RUT�N/b�WXb�[�VE[)Y@¶OT�x"GXWXbUR=F)JiB·[)R pT�]OFHVUWXT�b&¢&WXR\D«[2BZFHYC¹�xST�Y@B�T_b\B�FHV\T�J8FOV&T$[)BED�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUdCvL&[)R\T�]HFOVUd9VE[)Y@¶CWXY@]±WcY9¶ �3� Wcb2g�[KbUT�x¯FHY�R\D@T�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b[)b\bUWX]HYST�x�R\F�RUD@T�_YST$[)V\T�bUR�RUVE[)WXY@WXY@]4xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR\biRUF�R\D@T&WXY pP@Q@R·v � DST�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b=F)J@R\D@T�bUT�Y@T�WX]OD�gkFHV\b»[KVUT�¢�T�WX]HDCRUTZx_Q@b pWXY@]_R\D@T4b\WcN/WXG½[KVUWXRed4FKJiT$[)BED/Y@T�WX]HDCgkFHV�R\F�R\D@T4WXY@P@QSR$hO¢&D@T�VUTRUDSTwbUWXN"WXG¸[)V\WcRed/WXb_N"T$[KbUQ@V\T�x±g�d±RUDSTwB�FHb\WcYSTwg�T�Re¢�T�T�Y¯RUD@TRe¢�F xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR=aHTZB�RUFOVUb$v=�;JIFHYST&B$[)R\T�]HFOVUd_gkT�GXFHY@]Ob�RUF�NwQ@G pRUWXP@GXT2Y@T�WX]HDCgkFHV\b$hIR\D@T�Y9RUDST�b\Q@N FKJÑR\D@T�b\WXN"WXG¸[)VUWXRedwb\B�FHV\T�bF)J=RUD@TZbUT_Y@TZWc]ODCg�FOVUb&WXb�R\D@T_R\D@T�¢�T�WX]OD�R�F)J=RUD@T�B$[KRUT�]OFHV\d"WXYRUDST_FHQ@R\P@Q@R·vÑL&[KRUT�]OFHV\d>VE[)Y@¶CWXY@]wWXY�RUD@T2ÔiÔiAS 9N"TZRUD@FCx�WXbg�[KbUT�x�FHY�[V\T�]HV\T�bUb\WXFHYÂN/F�xST�G�QSbUWXY@]±¢�FOVUx@bwWXY,[Àx@FCB�Q pN"TZY�R&R\F"P@V\T�x@WXB�R�¢�T�WX]HDCRUb�F)J�B$[KRUT�]OFHV\WcTZb$v � D@T2VUT�]OVUT�b\bUWXFHYB�FCTEË"B�WXT�YCR\b�[)V\Twx@T�RUTZVUN"WXY@TZx´gCdb\FHGXaCWcYS]>[/GXT$[)b\R_bU¥CQ�[KVUT�b¹�R=F)JkRUD@T&N�[)P@P@WXY@]MJ8V\FHN�R\V�[KWcYSWcYS]&x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R\b=RUF�RUVE[)WXY@WXY@]B$[KRUT�]OFHVUWXT�b·vACT�aOT�V�[KGiP@V\FHPkT�VUR\WXT�b4FKJ»¶ �\� [KY@xÔiÔiAS 9N>[K¶HT&R\D@T�N bUQ@WXR p[)gSGcT.J8FOV�FOQ@V&T��CPkT�VUWXN"TZY�R\b ��%2 Ð�FHRUD¯bUdCbUR\T�N"bw[)V\T�RUFHP p PkT�VeJ;FHVUN/WXY@]�hIb\R�[KRUT p F)J p RUDST p [KVURB�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V\b$v �eY²[ VUT�BZT�YCRÂT�aH[)GXQ�[KRUWXFHYÌFKJ«BZG½[KbUb\WÓ¹kB$[)R\WcFOYN"TZRUD@FCx@b·Î nOÒZÏ FHYR\D@T � T�QSRUT�V\b YST�¢&bU¢&WXVUT�B�FHGXGXT�B�R\WcFOY9¦¸Y@T��CRbUTZB�RUWXFHYk§�h2RUD@T¯g@VUT·[)¶ p TZaHT�Y P�FOWcYCRaH[KGXQ@T�b¢�T�VUT �HmO¼ J8FOVgkFHRUDµ¶ �3� [)Y@x ÔiÔiAS �h�FHQ@R\P�TZVeJ8FOVUN"WXY@]�[)GXGwR\D@TÂFHR\D@T�VbUdCb\RUT�N/b"T�aH[KGcQk[)RUTZx¨FOYÂRUD@TÀb�[)N/TB�FOGcGXT�BZRUWXFHYih WcYSB�GXQ@x@WXY@]bUdCNwgkFHGXWXB_VUQSGcT2GXT$[)V\Y@WXY@]�gCd � � f�f�7�� ¦ �OtH¼ §ZÎ oZÏ hiA�° j f�pl ¦ sO�H¼ §�Î l\Ï [KY@x9L�® j � j � 7 ¦ sH�O¼ §�Î l$ÒZÏ hi[/x@TZB�WXbUWXFHY9[)P pP@V\F�[)BED Q@bUWXY@]¨L � v m ¦ sH�O¼ §�Î l$m'Ï h_WXY@x@Q@BZRUWXaHT9GXT$[KVUY@WXY@]ÂgCdACGXT�T�PSWcYS] 7 ��PkT�V\RUb�¦ sHÒO¼ §�Î oZÏ hi[)YSx¾[/RedCP@WXB$[)GMWcY�J8FHV\N>[)R\WXFHYVUTZRUVUWXT�aH[KG4[)P@PSVUF�[KBED�Y�[KN"T�x � F�BZB�DSWcF¯¦ sHmO¼ §�Î oZÏ v��4Y�[)Y pFHR\D@T�V±aH[)V\W½[KRUWXFHY�F)J"RUDST � TZQ@RUT�V\b´BZFHGXGXT�B�RUWXFOY�¢&D@T�VUT¯RUD@TRUVE[)WXY@WXY@].bUT�R&[)Y@x2RUDST&RUT�b\R�bUT�R&[)V\T�Pk[)VUR\WXRUWXFHY@TZx�x@Wº³IT�VUTZY�R\GXd�h¶ �\� D�[)b&[�g@VUT$[K¶ p T�aOT�Y�P�FOWXY�R�F)J �OnH¼ ¢&D@WXBED"WXb�RUD@T�b�[KN"T[)b�R\D@TwVUT�b\Q@GXR_F)J�Y@T�Q@VE[)G�Y@T�Re¢�FHVU¶Cb·Î nSl\Ï hi[)Y@x9ÔiÔ�A@ �D�[Kb_[

g@V\T$[)¶ p T�aHT�YÀP�FOWcYCR�F)J �@l$¼ v� 2 Ð�FHRUD/bUdCbUR\T�N"b�bUB·[)GXT4R\F�G¸[)V\]HT&B�G¸[KbUbUWº¹�B·[)RUWXFOYwP@VUFOg@GXT�N"b·vÐ�d�×UG¸[KVU]HTZÙ�¢�T�N"T$[KY"RUDk[)R�g�FORUD�RUD@T�WcYSP@Q@R&[)Y@x�RUDST FOQ@R pP@Q@RwFKJ [BZG½[KbUb\WÓ¹kT�V"B$[KY�D�[·aOT"R\D@FHQ@bE[)Y@xSbwF)J xSWcN/T�Y@b\WcFOY@bFHV&DSWc]OD@T�V·Î nOm h nK�·Ï v=°9T�¢&[)YCR&RUFwTZ��[KN"WXY@T�[)GXG�R\D@T_x@TZ]HVUTZT�bF)J�J8T$[KRUQ@V\T b\T�GXT�B�R\WcFOYihCJ;VUFHNÌY@F2VUTZx@Q@B�R\WcFOY9¦¸T��CB�T�PSR4VUTZN"F)a pWXY@]�bURE[)Y@x�[KVUx¯bURUFOP9¢�FOVUx@bE§�RUFÀT��CRUVUTZN"T�GXd9[)]H]OVUT�b\bUWXaHTwV\T px@Q@BZRUWXFHYih�[)Y@x±FHg@b\T�VUaOTwRUD@T2TE³IT�B�R\b�FOY´R\D@T�[KB�B�Q@VE[)B�d±F)J&[B�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V.F)aHT�V.RUD@T�T�YCRUWXVUT_RE[)V\]HT�R.bUP�[KB�THv& @FOV&[email protected]��@[)N"W pY�[KRUWXFHYihC¢�T�Y@T�T�x±[_b\B$[)G¸[)gSGcT�b\d�b\RUT�N±v� 2 Ð�FHR\D�¶ �3� [)Y@x�ÔiÔ�A@ �[KVUT_[ U p [KVUd/B�G¸[)bUb\Wº¹�T�V4PSVUF)aCWXx pWXY@]´[/]HGXFOg�[)G�VE[)Y@¶CWXY@]FKJÑB·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WXT�b�]OWXaHT�Y�[�xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR·v� D@WXb�[KGcGXF)¢&b�[�b\RUV�[KWX]HDCR p J8FHV\¢Ñ[KVUx2]HGXFHgk[)G@T�aH[KGXQ�[)R\WcFOY�FKJÊPkT�Vx@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR&B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHYPkT�VrJ8FHV\N>[)YSB�THh@Wev THvXhCN"T·[)bUQSVUWXY@]RUDST>]OFCF�xSY@T�bUbwFKJ4B$[)R\T�]HFOVUd¯V�[)YS¶�WXY@]À]HWXaHT�Y�[xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR·hV�[KRUD@TZV�R\D�[)Y9PkT�V2B$[)R\T�]HFOVUd9PkT�VeJ8FOVUN�[)Y@B�T"[Kb_WXb�b\R�[KY@x�[)V\x¢&D@T�Y[KP@P@GXdCWcYS]�g@WXY�[KVUdwB�G¸[KbUbUWº¹�TZVUb4R\FwRUD@T�P@VUFOg@GXT�N´v��2 Ð�FHR\DÂB�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V\b>[KVUT� ���������������������� ��� !��wWXY,R\D@T�bUT�YSbUTRUDk[)RwY@F9WXY@x@TZP�T�YSx@T�Y@B�T±WXb"[)b\bUQ@N/T�x�gkT�Re¢�T�T�Y{T�WXRUD@T�V/WXY pP@Q@R&aH[KVUW¸[)gSGcTZb ¦©RUT�V\N"b�§MFHV&FOQ@RUPSQ@R�aH[KVUW¸[)gSGcTZb ¦©B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b�§ZvÔiÔ�A@ �hZJ8FHV�T��@[)N"PSGcTOh�FHPSRUWXN"WX��T�b�RUD@T�N>[KP@P@WXY@]MJ8VUFON�[&x@FCB pQ@N/T�YCR R\F�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b$h�[KY@x±D@T�Y@B�T/x@FCT�b2Y@FHR�RUV\T$[)R2¢�FHVUxSbbUTZP�[)VE[)RUTZGcdCv�ACWXN"WXG¸[)VUGXdChI¶ �\� RUV\T$[)R\b>[Àx@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R"[Kb�[KYbUWXY@]OGXT4PkFHWXYCR&WcY�[2aHT�BZRUFHV&b\P�[)BZTHv � D@T�B�FHYCRUTZ��R&b\T�Y@b\WcR\WXa�WXRedWXb4WXY±x@WXbURUWXY@BZRUWXFHYR\F" ����#�$������%'&�()���.N"TZRUD@[email protected]�[)b\T�x´FOY´TZ� pP@GXWXB�WXR�WcYSx@T�PkT�Y@x@T�YSB�T[)bUb\Q@N"PSRUWXFHY@b�b\Q@BED,[)b�Y�[)WXaHT2Ð&[·dHT�bB�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V\b$Î l$oqÏ [KY@x9bUFON"TwFORUD@T�V�VUT�]OVUT�b\bUWXFHY�N"TZRUD@FCx@b·Î �ZÏ §Zvj B�FOYCRUT��CR p bUTZY@bUWXRUWXaOT>BZG½[KbUb\WÓ¹kT�V�N�[)¶OT�b�g�T�R\RUT�VwQSbUT�F)J&RUD@TWXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHY�P@V\F)aCWcxST�x�gCdÀJ8T$[)R\Q@VUTZb�R\D�[)Y�[�B�FHYCR\T��CR p J8VUT�TB�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�VMx@F�h)R\DCQ@b�T�Y�[Kg@GXWXY@] [.gkT�RUR\T�V�FOg@bUTZVUaH[)R\WXFHY2FHY�J8T$[ pRUQSVUT_b\T�GXT�B�RUWXFOYiv, 2i� D@T�Re¢�F4B�G¸[KbUbUWº¹�TZVUbixSWÓ³IT�V=bURE[)R\Wcb\RUWXB$[KGcGXdCvIÔiÔiAS "WXbIg�[KbUT�xFHY2[&GXWXY@T$[)VIPk[)V�[KN"T�R\VUWXB�N/F�xST�G+*�¶ �\� Wcb=[&Y@FOY p P�[)VE[)N"TZRUVUWXB[)YSxY@FHY p GXWXY@T$[KV&B�G¸[)bUb\Wº¹�T�V$h¤RUD�[KR N�[)¶OT�b�J8T�¢�[KbUbUQSN"P@R\WcFOY@b[)gkFHQSR4RUDST�WXY@P@QSR4x�[KR�[@v.®4TZY@B�Tw[wT�aH[KGcQk[)RUWXFOY>QSbUWXY@]"gkFHR\DB�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V\b=bUD@FOQ@GXx_VUT�xSQ@B�T&RUDST�PkFHb\[email protected])J@B�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V=g@W¸[KbWXY"R\D@T_VUTZbUQ@GXRUb·v

� | � �"? $?(����-7-;���� $67�k:~�

°9T4QSbUT_Re¢�F�BZFHVUPkFHVE[�J8FHV&R\D@WXb�b\RUQ@xSd �MRUD@T � T�Q@RUTZVUb pUnHnSl$sOoB�FOGcGXT�BZRUWXFHY�[)Y@x�RUDST,�.® AC`�^ 7 ��BZFHGXGXT�B�RUWXFOYiv� D@T � T�Q@R\T�VUb2Y@T�¢&b2bUR\FHV\d9B�FHGXGXT�B�R\WcFOY´WXb_BZFHN"N/FHY@GXd/Q@bUT�xB�FOVUPkFHV�[.WXY_R\T��CR»B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOY_VUTZbUT$[KVUBED´Î l$o h l h nSl h l$Ò h oZÏD v � DST�VUT�[)VUT nSl h ��mOt x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb_WXY±RUD@T2J8QSGcG=B�FOGXGcTZB�RUWXFHY-*GXT�bUb�R\D�[)YDk[)GºJ�F)J�R\D@T_x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb.D�[·aHT_DCQ@N�[)Y[)b\bUWX]HYST�xRUFOP@WXB_G¸[)gkT�GXb$v�°9T�Q@bUTZx´FOY@GXdwRUD@FObUT2x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R\b&RUD�[KR4D�[Kx[)RwGXT$[KbURwFOY@T�RUFHPSWcBOh�xSWcaCWXx@T�x¯V�[KY@x@FHN/GXd´WXYCRUF9[±RUVE[)WXY@WXY@]bUTZR�FKJ � h ÒSl$t [)Y@x9[/RUT�b\R�b\T�R�FKJ o h ÒHÒHn x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb$v � D@WXbP�[KVURUWXR\WcFOY"WXb�bUWXN"WXG¸[)V=RUF2RUDk[)R&T�N/P@GXF)dHT�xwWXY´Î l\Ï hOg@Q@R&x@Wº³IT�VUbJ8V\FHN Î l$oZÏ ¢&DSF9Q@bUT�RUDST"J;Q@GXG&B�FHGXGXT�B�R\WcFOY�WXY@B�GXQ@xSWcYS]´Q@YSG½[ p

.+/1032�465'798:2�;�<'=+2�>?;@2)8:=�<'AB0DCE0�F@GH2)5'7JIK2:L�M+2)8:=�NPORQ�S�T�U�CV<'=F�;�FB<W5'FBX�5'2YM�Z�8:A�L�[�ZEZ�M+M�\^] _�_�4`4K4a 8:2�=+2�F�8:b�ZDa F@M+M�a b�A�GY_)c5'2�46<'=�a

Page 5: 0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

gkT�GXGcTZx9x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R\b ­ v � D@TwbUR\FHV\WcTZb_D�[·aHT"[/N/T$[)Y±GXT�Y@]HR\DF)J �Ht v Ò ¢�FOVUx@b�¢&WXRUD±bURE[)Y@x�[KVUx±x@T�aCW¸[)R\WcFOY �@l v Ò v�°9T2B�FHY pbUWXx@TZVUT�x±RUD@T �Hn B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b�RUDk[)R [KP@PkT$[)V�[)R4GXT$[KbUR�FHYSB�T_WXYRUDSTRUVE[)WXY@WXY@]±bUT�R·v � D@T�b\TB$[KRUT�]OFHVUWXT�b/B�F)aHTZV"RUFOP@WXB�bwbUQSB�D[)b�B�FON"N/F�xSWcR\WXT�b$hSWcYCR\T�VUT�b\R�VE[)R\T�b$h=[)Y@xÀJ8FOVUT�WX]HY±T��CBED�[)YS]HTHv°ÂD@WXGXT2bUFHN/Twx@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb_D�[·aOTwQ@P9RUF«J8FHQ@V\RUT�TZY,[)b\bUWX]HYST�xB$[KRUT�]OFHVUWXT�b·hkRUD@T_N/T$[)Y/WXb&FHY@GXd l v n)� B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b4PkT�V�x@FCB�Q pN"TZY�R·v � D@T�J8V\T�¥CQ@T�Y@BZdwF)JIF�BZB�Q@VUV\T�Y@B�T�aH[)VUWXT�b=]OVUT$[KRUGXd_J;VUFHNB$[KRUT�]OFHVUd9R\FB$[KRUT�]OFHVUd * � � (���� ���R��h�J8FOV_T��@[)N/P@GXTHhi[)PSP�T$[KVUbWXY�V\FHQ@]OD@GXd oHtH¼ FKJ RUDST>xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR\b$h�¢&D@WXGXT���� � ��� ��� WXb[)b\bUWX]HYST�x�R\F´FOY@GXd¹�aOT"R\V�[)WXY@WXY@]Àx@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R\b$v � D@T�V\T´[)V\Tl$Ò h tHoH� QSY@WX¥�QST�R\T�VUN/biWXY�R\D@T�B�FHGXGXT�B�R\WcFOY"¦8[qJ8RUTZV»PkT�VrJ8FHV\N"WXY@]WXY54�T�BZRUWXFHY�[KG�b\RUT�N/N"WXY@]kh�bUR\FHP/¢�FOVUxwVUTZN"F)aH[)Geh)[)YSx"B�FOY�aOT�V pbUWXFOY>R\F�GXF)¢�T�V&B$[KbUT$§Zv�.® AC`�^ 7 � Wcb�[_g@WXg@GXWXFH]OV�[KP@D@WXB$[)GSx@FCB�Q@N"TZY�RMB�FHGXGXT�B�R\WcFOY��Hhx@T�aOT�GXFHPkT�xÌgCd�°ÂWXGcGXW¸[)N¡®.T�VUb\D�[)Y@x B�FHGXGXT$[)]OQ@T�b9[)R±RUD@T�.VUT�]OFHYÌ®4T·[)GXRUDÌACB�WXT�Y@B�TZb,`.Y@WXaHT�V\bUWXRedCv¡�eR´WXb9[{bUQ@gSbUT�RF)J2RUD@T9^ 7 ��ÔI� � 7 x�[KR�[)gk[)bUTOÎ �qÏ h&B�FHYSbUWXbUR\WcYS]�F)J o)��� h mHÒHÒVUT'J8T�VUTZY@B�T�b�J;VUFHN nHsOt N/T�x@WXB$[KGÊ�EFOQ@VUYk[)GXb2J8VUFONØR\D@T�dHT$[KVUbl$�O�Hs RUF l$�H�Sl v j GXG&F)J_RUDSTVUTEJ;T�VUT�YSB�T�b±D�[·aHT�RUWXR\GcTZb$h&g@QSRFHYSGcd nHoOo h �H�Cm FKJ"RUD@T�N D�[·aHT�[Kg@bUR\V�[)BZRUb$v °9T¯VUTEJ8TZV´R\FRUDST�RUWXR\GcT¯P@GXQ@b´[Kg@bUR\V�[)BZR�[)b´[�x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR$v � DST�x@FCB�Q pN"TZY�R\b�¢�T�VUT�N>[KYCQ�[)GXGXd�WcYSx@T��CT�x"QSbUWXY@]2bUQ@gH�ETZB�R&B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b¦8^«T�x@WXB$[)GiA�Q@gH�ET�B�R&®.T$[)xSWcYS]Hb$hCFOVÑ^«T$AC® §�WXY/RUD@T � [)R\WXFHY�[KGÔIWXg@VE[)V\d,FKJ�^�T�xSWcBZWcYSTHv � D@TZVUT�[)V\T¾[Kg�FOQ@R l·� h tHtOt B$[)R\T p]HFOVUWXT�b&x@T'¹�Y@T�x�WXY>^�T·AC®�hk[)Y@x l�� h oOn@l B$[KRUT�]OFHV\WcTZb&P@VUT�b\T�YCRWXYRUDST,�.® AC`�^ 7 �Ìx@FCB�QSN"T�YCR&B�FOGcGXT�BZRUWXFHYiv °9T QSbUT�x±RUD@Tl$�O�Ht x@FCB�QSN"T�YCRUb_[Kb [wR\V�[KWcYSWcYS]"bUTZR![KY@xR\D@T l·�H�Sl x@FCB�Q pN"TZY�R\b [Kb R\D@TwRUTZbUR_b\T�R_WXYRUDSWcb�b\RUQ@x@dCv � DST�VUT"[KVUT sHn h tHsHÒQ@Y@WX¥CQ@T2RUT�V\N"b.WcY±RUDST�R\V�[)WXY@WXY@]/bUT�R·v � D@T�[·aOT�V�[K]HT2GXT�Y@]HR\DF)J"[�x@FCB�QSN"T�YCR�WXb l$ÒOs ¢�FHV\x@b$v �.Y�[·aHT�VE[)]OT l$n B$[)R\T p]HFOVUWXT�b_[)V\T"[)b\bUWX]HY@TZx´R\F>T·[)BED9x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR$v2�eY´b\FHN/T_bUT�YSbUTRUDST �.® A�` ^ 7 � B�FOVUP@QSb WXb.N"FHV\T�x@WºË"B�Q@GXR4R\D�[)Y � T�Q@R\T�VUbgkT�B$[)QSbUT{RUD@T�x�[KR�[�[)V\T�N"FHV\T�×\Y@FHWXbUdCÙkv � D�[KR9WXb$h2RUD@T¢�FHVUx �)B$[KRUT�]OFHVUd�B�FHV\VUT�b\P�FOY@x@T�Y@BZT�b�[)V\T´N/FHVUT�×eJ8Q@�Z��dCÙ�WXY�.® AC`�^ 7 �2v�L�FOY@bUTZ¥�QST�YCRUGXd�hCR\D@T�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY/Wcb�N"FOVUTx@WºË"B�Q@GXR�RUFwGXT$[KVUY/J8FHV&[2B�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V·v

� ����� ÉU�SÉU�I� ��� � � ÉUÇ4���@ÉUÆ Å

��|�� }4�C�*!��k�)79?@:&�)�w79�C?��+�=�)���°9T"[)PSP@GXdJ8T·[)RUQSVUT�bUT�GXT�BZRUWXFHY¯RUF±x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R\b�WXY9R\D@T"P@V\T pP@V\F�BZT�bUb\WcYS]9F)J ¶ �3� [KY@x,Ô�ÔiA@ �v � D@T�TE³ÊTZB�RUWXaHTZY@T�bUb�FKJ [J8T$[KRUQ@V\T4b\T�GXT�B�RUWXFOYwN"T�R\D@FCx�WXb�T�aH[KGXQ�[)R\T�x�QSbUWXY@]_R\D@T4PkT�VeJ;FHV pN>[KY@B�TwFKJ4¶ �3� [KY@x�ÔiÔ�A@ {FHY¯RUD@T/P@VUTZP@VUFCB�T�b\bUT�x{x@FCB�Q pN"TZY�R\b$v=ACWXY@B�T�gkFHRUD�¶ �\� [)YSx«Ô�ÔiA@ ±b\B�FHV\T_B$[KRUT�]OFHVUWXT�b&FOY[/P�TZV p x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R�g�[KbUWXb$h¤¢�T2Q@bUTwR\D@T2bUR�[KY@x�[KVUx±x@TE¹�Y@WXR\WcFOY��� Z32)8:2Z�F@= X 2�2)0 FY=+2)8+<'ABL3=K\�8:ABX�5'2�G <W0EL3=�<W03[VM�Z�<'= b�A�5W5'2�b)N

M�<'AB0�� AB8,M+2��RMYb�F�M+2�[�AB8+<���F�M�<'AB0 2�;�FB5WL3F�M�<'A�0^a � Z�F@MH<'=�C F 5'F�8:[�2\�8:AB\�A�8:M�<'AB0 A�� M�Z�2>�ARb)L3GH2)0�M+=6<W0EM�Z32M+2�=+M6=+2�M6FB8:2 <W03b�AB8+8:2�b�M�5'7L�0�5'F�X�2)5W5'2�>^a � Z�<'=`GHF�� 2�=`M�Z�22�;�F�5WL�F@M�<'AB0 8:2�=�L�5'M+=`Z�<'[�Z�5'7! �L�2�=�NM�<'AB03FBX�5'2VA�80�A�0�N <W0�M+2)8+\�8:2�M+F�X�5'2VL�0�5'2�=+= M�Z32�=+2 L�0�5'F�X�2)5W5 2�> >�ARb)NL3GH2)0�M+= F�8:2> <'=+b�FB8:>�2�>#C�F@=`FB03FB5'7"��2�>E<W0$# O�%�&$a')(+*-,/.10�243 <'=?F�;�FB<W5'F�X�5'2;�<'F F�0�A�0�7RGHABL3=5� M�\6� 8:A@G

GH2�>R<W8�a ABZ3=�L^a 2�>RL <W0 M�Z32> <W8:2�b�M+AB8:7 _�\�L�X _BA�Z�=�L3GH2�>�a

F)J=VUT�B·[)GXG»[KY@x�P@VUT�BZWcb\WXFHY[)b&PkT�VeJ;FHVUN�[)Y@BZT N/T$[)b\Q@VUTZb �

VUTZB$[)GXG�H B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b J8FHQ@YSx>[)YSx>BZFHVUV\T�B�RRUFHRE[)GIB$[KRUT�]OFHV\WcTZb4B�FOVUVUTZB�R

P@V\T�B�WXbUWXFOY�H B$[KRUT�]OFHV\WcTZb&J8FOQ@Y@x>[KY@x�B�FHV\VUT�BZRR\FHR�[KGIB$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b J8FHQ@YSx

¢&D@T�V\T�×UB$[KRUT�]OFHV\WcTZbwJ8FOQ@Y@x@Ù¯N"T$[KY@b"R\D�[)R/RUD@T±B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b[)V\T_[)gkF)aHT [2]OWXaHT�Y/bUB�FOVUT_R\D@VUT�b\D@FHGXxiv�ª�WXaHT�Y�[_xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR·hJ8FOV_VUT�B·[)GXG�R\D@VUTZbUD@FOGcxSb�FKJ tO¼ h l·tH¼ h nOtH¼ h�vcvXv l·tHtO¼ hIRUD@TbUdCb\RUT�N [KbUbUWX]OY@b&WXY>xST�B�VUT·[)bUWXY@]�b\B�FHV\T_FHV\x@T�V [Kb&N>[KY�dwB·[)R pT�]OFHVUWXT�b_[Kb4Y@T�TZx@T�x±Q@YCRUWXG»[�]HWXaHT�Y�V\T�B$[)GXG=WXb [KB�DSWcTZaHT�xihI[KY@xB�FON"P@Q@R\T�b2RUD@T/P@VUT�BZWcb\WXFHY�aH[)GXQ@T"[KR�R\D�[)R2P�FOWXY�R·Î l$�ZÏ v � D@TVUTZbUQ@GXRUWXY@] lHl P�FOWXY�R�P@VUT�BZWcb\WXFHY9aH[)GXQ@TZb�[)V\TwRUD@T�Y�[·aHT�VE[)]OT�xRUFÀFHg@RE[)WXY�[�bUWXY@]OGXT p YCQ@NwgkT�V�N"T·[)bUQSVUT"FKJÑb\dCbURUTZNØPkT�VeJ;FHV pN>[KY@B�T�FHYwR\D�[)R�xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR·v» SFHV�[�R\T�bUR�b\T�R�F)Jix@FCB�Q@N/T�YCRUb·hRUDST>[·aHTZV�[)]OT"P@V\T�B�WXbUWXFOY9aH[)GXQ@T�b2F)J4WXY@x@WXaCWXx@Q�[KG»xSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR\b[)V\T�J8Q@V\RUD@T�V&[·aHTZV�[)]OT�x2RUF_FOg@R�[KWcYw[.]HGXFHgk[)GCN"T$[KbUQ@V\T�FKJibUdCb pRUTZN²PkT�VeJ;FHVUN�[)Y@BZT F)aOT�V&RUDST TZY�R\WXVUT_b\T�R$vM�eY>R\[email protected])¢&WXY@]�hQ@Y@GXT�b\b�FORUD@TZVU¢&WXbUT�bUPkT�B�Wº¹�TZxih�¢�T"¢&WXGXG=Q@bUT�×UPSVUT�B�WXb\WcFOY@ÙFOV× j�� ª f Ù.RUF�VUTEJ;T�V=RUF4R\D@T lHlEp PkFHWXYCR»[·aHTZV�[)]OT�P@V\T�B�WXbUWXFHY2F)aHTZV[2bUTZR&F)J�RUT�b\R4x@FCB�QSN"T�YCRUb·v

��| � 798;: �C�)6;79��:� $? -~�Z�5 ·6;:»<I�Ð�TEJ8FHV\T,[KP@P@GXdCWcYS]9J8T$[KRUQ@V\T�b\T�GXT�B�RUWXFOY�RUF�x@FCB�QSN"T�YCRUb·h_¢�TVUTZN"F)aHTZx�RUDST>¢�FHV\x@bwWXY,[±b\R�[)YSx�[)V\x,b\RUFOP,¢�FHV\x�GXWXbUR·Î l·�ZÏ v� D@T�Y�T$[KBED,FKJ R\D@T/¹�aHT/J8T$[KRUQ@V\T�bUT�GXT�B�R\WXFHY�N"T�R\D@FCx@b2¢Ñ[KbT�aH[KGcQk[)RUTZx�¢&WXRUDÌ[{Y�QSNwg�T�V±F)J"xSWÓ³IT�V\T�YCR�RUTZVUN p VUTZN"F)aH[)GRUDSVUT�b\D@FHGXx@b·v j R>[9DSWc]OD�RUD@V\T�bUD@FOGXxih4WXR/Wcb/P�FObUb\WcgSGcTÀRUD�[KR[)GXG=RUDST�R\T�VUN/b WXY´[�x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR![KVUT2g�TZGcF)¢�R\D@TwRUDSVUT�b\D@FHGXxiv� F�[·aOFHWXxwVUTZN"F)aCWXY@]_[)GXGIRUD@T�R\T�VUN/b�J8V\FHN²[�x@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR$hC¢�T[)xSx@T�xÂ[N/T�R�[«VUQ@GXT�RUF±RUD@T�P@V\FCB�T�bUb·v � D�[KR�WXb·hÑ[KP@P@GXd9[RUDSVUT�b\D@FHGXx�RUF�[±x@FCB�QSN"T�YCR2FHY@GXd9WºJ WXR2VUT�b\Q@GXRUb"WXYÂ[ÀY@FHY pT�N/P@Redwx@FCB�Q@N/T�YCR@*@FORUD@TZVU¢&WXbUTHhI[KP@P@GXd"R\D@T_B�GXFHb\T�bUR�R\D@VUT�b\D pFHGXx/¢&D@WXB�D�V\T�bUQ@GXR\b4WXY>[2Y@FOY p T�N"P@RedwxSF�BZQ@N"T�YCR·v°9T_[)GXbUFwQSbUT�xR\D@T�A@^ j �=� b\dCbURUTZN0Î l·�ZÏ J8FOV&Q@Y@Wº¹�T�x�P@V\T pP@V\F�BZT�bUb\WcYS]�J;FHGXGXF)¢�T�x J8T$[KRUQ@V\TbUT�GXT�BZRUWXFHYih.¢&D@WXBED�WcYSB�GXQ@x@T�b¢�FHVUx�b\RUT�N/N"WXY@]w[)Y@x�¢�T�WX]HDCRUWXY@]kv�°9T�RUV\WcTZxbUT�aOT�V�[KG�RUTZVUN¢�T�WX]HDCRUWXY@]wFOP@RUWXFHYSb�¦�×\GXRUB�Ùkh�×E[)R\B�Ù�h�×UGXY@BZÙ´h�×Ug@YSY@Ù"T�R\BHv�WXYA@^ j��=�=< bIY@FHRE[)R\WcFOY�§k¢&D@WXBED_B�FONwg@WXY@TiR\D@T�R\T�VUN{J;VUT�¥CQ@T�YSB�d¦ �  =§.N"T·[)bUQSVUT�[KY@xRUDST��eYCaHTZVURUTZx¾�.FCB�Q@N/T�YCR  SVUT�¥CQ@T�YSB�d¦¸�U�� =§&N/T$[)b\Q@VUT2WXY´[waH[KVUWXT�Red�F)J�¢&[·dCb$v � D@T�gkT�b\R_VUT�b\Q@GXRUb¦¸¢&WXR\D>QSbUWXY@]±×UGXRUB�ÙC§&[)V\T V\T�PkFHVUR\T�x±WcY/RUD@T�Y@T��CR&bUT�BZRUWXFHYiv

��| � }��)6879?S�='´�)�@�+� -7 )� �WX]HQ@V\T l x@WXb\P@G¸[·d�b.RUD@T2PkT�VeJ8FOVUN�[)Y@B�T�B�Q@VUaOT�b.J8FHV.¶ �\� FOY� TZQ@RUT�V\b&¦ � h ÒSl$t RUVE[)WXY@WXY@]&x@FCB�QSN"T�YCRUb·h)[)Y@x o h ÒHÒHn R\T�bUR=x@FCB pQ@N/T�YCRUb�§�[·J8R\T�V=RUT�V\N�b\T�GXT�B�RUWXFOY�Q@b\WXY@]��Uªwh$�� �h � AIhH^��i[KY@xL�®4�MRUD@V\T�bUD@FOGXx@WXY@]�hCV\T�bUPkT�B�R\WcaOT�GXd�vM°9T&RUT�b\RUT�xÀRUD@T�Re¢�F_FHP pRUWXFOY@b$h � !>�±[)YSx? � �ÀWXY¨^��w[)Y@x{L�®4��h�[KY@xÂR\D@TgkT�RUR\T�VVUTZbUQ@GXRUb�[)V\T V\T�P@V\T�bUT�YCR\T�x9WXY"RUDST�¹�]HQSVUTHv �WX]HQ@V\T n x@WXb\P@G¸[·d�b&R\D@T2P�T�VrJ8FHV\N>[KY@B�T_B�QSVUaHTZb FKJ�ÔiÔiAS �FOY� TZQ@RUT�V\b$v�ACWXY@B�T_R\D@T�RUV�[KWXY@WXY@]�Pk[)VUR.F)J�ÔiÔiAS 9WXb&V�[KRUD@T�V&V\T pbUFOQ@VUBZT BZFHY@b\Q@N"WXY@]kh)¢�T.Q@bUTZx>[)Y"[KP@P@V\F)��WXN�[)RUWXFOY_F)J»Ô�ÔiA@ 

Page 6: 0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

0.65

0.7

0.75

0.8

0.85

0.9

0.95

0200040006000800010000120001400016000

11-p

t ave

rage

pre

cisi

on

Number of features (unique words)

Figure 1. Average precision of kNN vs. unique word count

IGDFTS

CHI.maxMI.max

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

0.65

0.7

0.75

0.8

0.85

0.9

0.95

0200040006000800010000120001400016000

11-p

t ave

rage

pre

cisi

on

Number of features (unique words)

Figure 2. Average precision of LLSF vs. unique word count

IGDFTS

CHI.maxMI.max

WXY@bUR\T$[)x�F)J�R\D@TB�FON"P@GXT�R\TbUFOGcQSRUWXFHY�RUF¯b�[·aOTbUFON"T�B�FHN pP@Q@RE[)R\WcFOY�VUT�b\FHQ@V\B�T�b±WcY�R\D@T´TZ��PkT�V\WcN/T�YCRUb·v � D�[)R/WXb$h&¢�TB�FON"P@Q@R\T�x9FHYSGcd nHtOt G¸[)V\]HT�b\R�b\WcYS]HQ@G¸[)V�aH[)GXQ@T�b2WXY9bUFHGXaCWXY@]ÔiÔ�A@ �h»[KGXRUD@FOQ@]HD9R\D@T�g�T�b\RwVUT�b\Q@GXRUb¦©¢&D@WXB�D¯WXb�b\WcN/WXG½[KV4R\FRUDSTP�TZVeJ8FOVUN>[KY@B�T�F)J_¶ �\� §"[KP@P�T·[)VUTZx¨¢&WXRUD�Q@b\WXY@] l$tOtHtbUWXY@]OQ@G¸[)V=aH[)GXQ@TZb$Î n)�·Ï v � T�aOT�VUR\D@T�GXT�bUb·h@R\D@WXb�bUWXN"PSGcWº¹�B·[)RUWXFOY_F)JÔiÔ�A@ ÀbUD@FOQ@GXx�Y@FOR=WcYCaH[KGcWXx�[KRUT�R\D@T&T��@[)N/WXY�[)R\WcFOY�F)JkJ8T$[)R\Q@VUTbUTZGcTZB�RUWXFHYÀ¢&D@WXB�D/WXb&RUD@T�J;F�BZQ@b&F)J=RUD@T_TZ��PkT�V\WcN/T�YCRUb·vj Y/FHg@b\T�VUaH[KRUWXFHYwN/T�VU]OT�b=J8V\FHNÌRUDST4B$[KRUT�]OFHVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY/VUT�b\Q@GXRUbF)J&¶ �\� [KY@x�ÔiÔ�A@ �FHY � TZQ@RUT�V\b$v � D�[KR_WXb$h��UªwhI�� ¨[KY@xL�®4�2RUDSVUT�b\D@FHGXx@WXY@]¯D�[·aHT�bUWXN/WcG¸[KV T'³ÊT�BZRUbFOY,R\D@TPkT�VeJ;FHV pN>[KY@B�TFKJ_RUD@T±B�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V\b$v j GXG4F)J2RUD@T�N¡B·[)Y{T�GXWcN/WXY�[)R\TQ@P�RUF �OtH¼ FOVwN"FOVUT"FKJ_RUD@T�Q@Y@WX¥CQ@TR\T�VUN/b�¢&WXR\D,TZWcR\D@T�V[)YÀWcN/P@VUF)aOT�NwT�YCR�FHV4YSFwGcFObUb.WcY�B$[KRUT�]OFHV\Wc�·[)RUWXFOY´[)B�BZQ@V�[KB�d¦8[Kb4N/T$[)b\Q@VUT�x�gCd>[·aOT�V�[K]HT_PSVUT�B�WXb\WcFOY�§�v�`.bUWXY@]"�Uª R\D@VUT�b\D pFHGXx@WXY@]kh�J8FHVwTZ��[KN"P@GXTHh=R\D@T�aHFCB$[Kg@Q@G¸[)V\d�WXb�V\T�x@Q@BZT�xÂJ;VUFHNl$Ò h tHoH� RUT�V\N"b=RUF oHn@l ¦;[ �H�O¼ VUT�x@QSB�RUWXFHYk§�h@[)YSx�R\D@T j�� ª fF)J�¶ �\� Wcb2WXN"P@V\F)aHT�xÀJ8V\FHN �Os v �H¼ RUF �H� v nO¼ v¾L�®.�_D�[KbT�aOT�Y�g�T�R\RUT�V/B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY¯VUT�b\Q@GXRUb"TZ��BZT�P@R"R\D�[)Rw[)RwTZ� pRUV\T�N"TZGcd±[)]H]OVUT�b\bUWXaHTwR\D@VUTZbUD@FOGcxSb_�Uª�WXb_gkT�R\RUT�V·v � A±D�[Kb_[B�FON"P�[KV�[)gSGcT=PkT�VeJ;FHVUN�[)Y@BZT�¢&WXRUD�Q@P p RUF mOtH¼ R\T�VUN VUT�N/F)aH[)GWXY�¶ �3� hk[)Y@x[)gkFHQSR ÒHtH¼ RUTZVUN£VUTZN"F)aH[)GkWXYÔiÔiAS �vS°ÂWXRUD

0.0001

0.001

0.01

0.1

1

1 10 100 1000 10000

IG

DF

Figure 3. Correlation between DF and IG values of words in Reuters

DF-IG plots

1e-05

0.0001

0.001

0.01

0.1

1

1 10 100 1000 10000

CH

I

DF

Figure 4. Correlation between DF and CHI values of words in Reuters

DF-CHI plots

N"FOVUT[)]O]HV\T�bUb\WcaOTRUDSVUT�b\D@FHGXx@b·h&WXRUb"PkT�VrJ8FHV\N>[)YSB�T�x@T�B�GXWXY@T�bNwQ@BED/JÁ[)b\RUT�V.RUD�[KY�UªwhkL�®4�&[)Y@x´�� �v�^«�&x@FCT�b4Y@FOR4D�[·aOTB�FON"P�[KV�[)gSGcT&PkT�VrJ8FHV\N>[)YSB�T4R\F�[KY�d2F)[email protected]\D@T�V&N"TZRUD@FCx@b·v

��|�� [�k�)�)�5-8?$ ·67��:�� � �5 ��_�C�C: �10�� 6*9 ?@:�� �! 6� D@T2bUWXN"WXG¸[)V&PkT�VrJ8FHV\N>[)YSB�T�FKJ��UªwhI�� �[)Y@x9L�®4�.WcY±RUTZVUNbUTZGcTZB�RUWXFHYwWXb�V�[)R\D@T�V�b\Q@VUPSVUWXbUWXY@]�gkT�B$[)QSbUT4YSF b\Q@BED"[)Y_FOg@bUTZV paH[)R\WXFHY�D�[)b.P@VUTZa�WXFOQ@bUGXd�g�TZT�Y´V\T�PkFHVUR\T�xiv j Y�[KRUQ@VE[)Gi¥CQ@TZb pRUWXFOYRUD@TZVUTEJ8FOVUTwWXb4¢&DST�RUD@TZV R\D@T�b\TwRUD@V\T�TwB�FHV\P@Q@b�bURE[)R\Wcb\RUWXB�b[)V\T�B�FHV\VUT�G¸[)R\T�xiv �WX]HQ@V\T o PSGcFORUb�R\D@T&aH[)GXQ@TZb»FKJ»�� [)Y@xw�Uª�]HWXaOT�Y�[.R\T�VUNÌWXYRUDST � T�Q@R\T�VUb�B�FOGcGXT�BZRUWXFHYiv= �WX]HQ@V\T � PSGcFORUb�R\D@T&aH[)GXQ@TZb»FKJ¤�� [)YSx«L�®.� ����� B�FOVUVUTZbUPkFHY@x@WXY@]OGXd�v�L�GXT$[KVUGXdwRUD@TZVUT�[KVUT�WXY@x@T�T�xaHTZVUd"b\RUV\FHY@]wB�FOVUV\T�G¸[)RUWXFOY@b&g�TZRe¢�T�TZYRUD@T_�� �hC�Uª�[KY@xL�®4�aH[)GXQ@TZb»FKJÊ[&R\T�VUN±v» �WX]HQSVUT�b m [)Y@x Ò b\D@F)¢&b=RUD@T&V\T�bUQSGcR\b�F)JI[B�V\FHbUb p BZFHGXGXT�B�RUWXFOY>TZ��[KN"WXY�[KRUWXFHYiv j bURUV\FHY@]wBZFHVUV\T�G¸[)R\WcFOY"gkT pRe¢�T�T�Y9�  �[KY@x�Uª WXb [)GXb\F"FHgSbUT�V\aHT�x±WXYRUD@TV�4®�AC` ^ 7 �B�FOGcGXT�BZRUWXFHYiv � D@TwP�TZVeJ8FOVUN>[KY@B�TwB�QSVUaHTZb�FKJѶ �\� ¢&WcR\D¾�� aHTZVUbUQSb_�Uª�[)V\T�WXx@TZY�R\WXB$[)G=FHY±RUDSWcb�B�FOGXGcTZB�RUWXFHY�v � D@T�FOg@bUTZV paH[)R\WXFHY@b=FHY � T�Q@R\T�VUb&[)Y@x2FHY �.®�AC` ^ 7 �¨[KVUT&D@WX]HDSGcd�B�FHY pbUWXb\RUT�YCR$vwª�WXaOT�YRUDSTwaHT�V\dx@Wº³ÊTZVUT�YCR�[KP@P@GXWXB$[)R\WcFOYx@FON>[)WXY@b

Page 7: 0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

0.0001

0.001

0.01

0.1

1

1 10 100 1000 10000 100000

IG

DF

Figure 5. DF-IG correlation in OHSUMED’90

DF-IG plots

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

020406080100

11-p

t avg

p

Percentage of features (unique words)

Figure 5. Feature selection and the performance of kNN on two collections

IG.ReutersDF.Reuters

IG.OHSUMEDDF.OHSUMED

F)[email protected]¢�F2B�FOVUP@Q@b·h@¢�T [KVUT�B�FHYCaCWXY@B�T�x�R\D�[)R�RUD@T�FOg@bUT�V\aHT�xTE³IT�B�R\bwF)J �� ¨[KY@x±�Uª RUD@V\T�bUD@FOGXx@WXY@]´[)V\T"]OT�Y@T�VE[)G�V�[)R\D@T�VRUDk[)Y�B�FHV\P@Q@b p x@TZP�T�YSx@T�YCR$v

� �ÂÉU�C�IÈ4�C�CÉUÆ Å

°ÂD�[KR4[)V\T_RUD@T�VUT$[KbUFHYSb&J8FOV&]HFCFCx>FOV&g�[)x�PkT�VeJ;FHVUN�[)Y@BZT_F)JJ8T$[KRUQ@V\T_bUTZGcTZB�RUWXFHY�WXY�RUT��CR&B$[KRUT�]OFHV\Wc�·[)RUWXFOY>RE[)b\¶�b/� � [)g@GXT lB�FON"P�[KVUT�b&R\D@T.¹�aHT�B�V\WcR\T�VUW¸[�J8V\FHN�b\T�aHTZV�[)G�[KY@]HGXT�b*�

� JÁ[·aOFHV\WcYS]_B�FHN/N"FOY�R\T�VUN/b&FHV&V�[KVUT�RUTZVUN"b·h� RE[)bU¶ p bUT�YSbUWXRUWXaHT¿¦¸QSbUWXY@] B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\d0WXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHYk§ÂFOVRE[)bU¶ p J8VUTZTHh

� Q@b\WXY@]wRUT�V\N [)g@b\T�Y@B�T2RUF/P@VUTZx@WXB�R4R\D@T_B$[KRUT�]OFHVUd�P@V\FHg p[Kg@WXGcWXRedCh�Wev THvXh�Q@b\WXY@]�R\D@T´� p BZT�GXG4F)J_R\D@T´BZFHYCRUWXY@]OT�Y@B�dRE[)g@GXTHh@[KY@x

� R\D@T´PkT�VrJ8FHV\N>[)YSB�TF)J_¶ �\� [KY@x¨ÔiÔ�A@  FHY � T�Q@R\T�VUb[KY@x �4®�AC` ^ 7 �2v

 SVUFHN � [)gSGcT l h=R\D@T"N/T�RUDSF�xSb_¢&WXRUD�[)Y�×\T��CB�T�GXGXT�YCRUÙ±P�TZV pJ8FOVUN>[KY@B�T�bUDk[)VUT2RUDST_b�[KN"T�g@W¸[)b·h@Wev THvXh@bUBZFHVUWXY@]/WXY�JÁ[·aHFOV&F)JB�FON"N"FOY_RUTZVUN"b�F)aHTZV&V�[)V\T�RUT�V\N"b$v � D@WXb�g@W¸[)b�Wcb�FHgCaCWXFHQ@b\GXdWXY"R\D@T��� ±B�VUWXR\T�VUWXFHY�v=�eR&Wcb&YSFHR�Y@T�B�T�b\b�[KVUWXGXd>R\VUQ@T�WcY/�Uª�FOVL�®4�=gCd_x@T'¹�Y@WXRUWXFHY��iWXY2RUD@T�FOVUdCh�[.B�FON"N/FHY�RUT�V\NÌB$[)YwD�[·aOT[w�ZT�VUF p aH[KGcQST�x´WXYCJ;FHVUN�[)R\WcFOYw]�[KWcY�FOV ¬ ­ bUBZFHVUTOv_®4F)¢�T�aOT�V$hWXR�WXb&b\R�[)R\WXbURUWXB$[KGXGcdwR\VUQ@T�g�[KbUT�xÀFHY"R\D@T_b\RUVUFOY@]wB�FOVUVUTZG½[KRUWXFHYSbgkT�Re¢�TZT�YRUDST!�� �hC�Uª�[KY@xL�®4��aH[KGXQ@T�b$v � DST!^«��N/T�RUD@FCxD�[Kb"[)Y�FOP@PkFHbUWXR\T>gSW½[Kb$h�[)bwB$[KY,gkT�bUT�TZYÂWXY�RUDST�J8FHV\NwQ@G¸[� ¦CE�<Z§&HÂGXFO] L�M ¦CE P <�§�I´GXFH] L�M ¦GE�§�v � DSWcb�g@W¸[)b&gkT�B�FON"T�b&TZ� pRUV\T�N"T/¢&D@T�Y L�M ¦GE�§2WXb2Y@T$[KVw��T�VUFkv � A¯x@FCT�bwYSFHR2D�[·aHT�[B�GXT$[KVwg@W¸[)bwWXY�R\D@WXbwbUT�Y@b\THh.WÁv THvXh=gkFHR\D,BZFHN"N/FHY�[KY@x�VE[)VUTRUTZVUN"b&B·[)Y�D�[·aHT.D@WX]HD�bUR\VUT�YS]HRUD�v� D@T�T��CB�T�GXGXT�YCRwPkT�VeJ8FOVUN�[)Y@B�T/F)J �� �h=�Uª [KY@x,L�®.�_WXY@x@W pB$[KRUT�bwR\D�[)R2B�FHN/N"FOYRUT�V\N"bw[)V\T"WXY@x@T�TZx,WXYCJ;FHVUN�[)R\WcaOT�J8FOVRUTZ��R&B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOY"RE[)bU¶Cb·v��;J»b\WX]HY@Wº¹�B$[KYCRÑ[KN"FHQSY�R\b�F)J=WXY pJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHY±¢�T�VUT�GXFHb\R"[)R2D@WX]HD�GXT�aOT�GXb>¦©THv ]�v �H�O¼ §_FKJ aHF pB$[Kg@Q@G¸[)V\d´V\T�x@Q@B�R\WXFHY9WXR_¢�FHQ@GXx±Y@FHR_gkTwPkFHbUb\WXg@GXT2J8FHV_¶ �3�FHV=ÔiÔ�A@ �RUF.D�[·aHTMWcN/P@VUF)aOT�x�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY_PSVUTEJ8FOVUN�[)Y@B�TOv� F"gkT�N/FHV\T PSVUT�B�WXb\THhiWXYR\D@T�FOVUdCh��Uª N"T$[KbUQ@V\T�b�RUD@T2YCQ@N pgkT�V�F)J�g@WXR\b>FKJ_WcY�J8FHV\N>[)R\WXFHY�FOg@R�[KWXY@T�xÂgCd�¶CY@F)¢&WXY@]9RUD@TP@V\T�bUT�YSB�T9FHV�[)g@b\T�Y@B�T±F)J�[±RUTZVUN¡WXYÂ[±x@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R·v � D@TbUR\VUFOY@]�   p �U ¯B�FHV\VUT�G¸[)R\WXFHY@b�N"T·[)[email protected]�[KR4B�FON"N"FOY"R\T�VUN/b[)V\TwF)J8R\T�Y9WXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXaHTOhÊ[KY@x±a�WXB�T/aHT�V\b�[9¦©RUD@WXb_b\R�[KRUT�N/T�YCRF)J=B�FHQSVUbUT�x@FCT�b&YSFHR�T��CRUT�Y@x�R\F�b\RUFHP�¢�FHV\x@b�§Zv � D@WXb�WXb�B�FHY pRUVE[)V\d9RUF9[�¢&WXx@T�GXd´DST�GXx�gkT�GXWcT'J WXY9WXYCJ8FHV\N>[KRUWXFHYV\T�RUV\WXT�aH[)GRUDk[)R�B�FHN/N"FOY>R\T�VUN/b [KVUTwY@FOY p WXYCJ;FHVUN�[)R\WcaOTHvH�4QSV_T��CP�TZV pWXN"T�YCR\b_bUD@F)¢µRUD�[KR�R\D@WXb"[)bUb\Q@N"PSRUWXFHY±N>[·d±Y@FHRw[)PSP@GXd´R\FRUTZ��R&B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOYivj YSFHRUDST�V�WXYCRUT�V\T�bUR\WcYS] PkFHWXYCR=WXY � [)gSGcT l WXb=RUDk[)R=Q@bUWXY@].B$[)R\T p]HFOVUd_WXYCJ;FHVUN�[)R\WcFOY&J8FOV�J8T$[)R\Q@VUT&b\T�GXT�B�R\WcFOYwx@FCT�b�Y@FOR=bUT�T�NÌR\FgkT�B�V\Q@B�W¸[)G~J8FHV.T��CB�T�GXGXT�YCR_P�TZVeJ8FOVUN>[KY@B�THv_�� ¯WXb�R�[)b\¶ p J8V\T�THhWev THvXh�WXRwx@FCT�b/Q@bUTÀB$[)R\T�]HFOVUd�WXYCJ8FHV\N>[KRUWXFHY9P@V\T�bUTZY�R�WXY�RUD@TRUVE[)WXY@WXY@]2bUT�R·hkg@Q@R4Dk[)b4[2PkT�VeJ8FOVUN�[)Y@B�T�b\WcN/WXG½[KV�RUFw�UªÌ[KY@xL�®4�=¢&D@WXBED"[)V\T&R�[KbU¶ p b\T�Y@b\WcR\WXaHTHv�^��=WXb=R�[KbU¶ p b\T�Y@b\WcR\WXaHTHhCg@QSRbUWX]OY@Wº¹�B$[)YCR\Gcd9QSY@x@T�V p PkT�VeJ;FHVUN/bwg�FORUD � A�[)Y@x��� �¢&D@WXBED[)V\T�R�[)b\¶ p J8V\T�THv� D@T/P�FCFHV�P�T�VrJ8FHV\N>[KY@B�TwF)J4^���WXb�[)GXb\F>WXYCJ;FHVUN�[)R\WcaOTHv2�eRUbg@W¸[)bwR\F)¢Ñ[KVUx@b2GXF)¢ÌJ8V\T�¥CQ@T�Y@B�d�RUT�V\N"b2Wcbw¶CY@F)¢&Y{¦8ACTZB�RUWXFHYn §ZhigSQ@R_¢&D@T�R\D@T�V2FHV_YSFHR�RUD@WXb_R\D@T�FOVUT�R\WcB·[)G&¢�T$[)¶CY@T�b\b_¢&WXGXGB$[KQ@bUT�bUWX]OY@Wº¹�B$[)YCRw[)B�BZQ@V�[KB�d�GcFObUb2WXY�RUTZ��RwB·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOYD�[Kb4Y@FOR4gkT�T�Y9T�N/P@WXVUWXB$[)GXGXd2T��@[)N"WXY@TZxiv �.Q@V�T��CP�TZVUWXN"T�YCR\b¥CQ�[)YCR\WcRE[)R\WcaOT�GXd�[Kx@x@V\T�bUb.RUD@WXb�Wcb\bUQ@T�Q@b\WXY@]"[_BZVUFHb\b p N"T�R\D@FCxB�FON"P�[KVUWXbUFOY¾[KY@x,[�BZVUFHb\b p B�G¸[)b\bUWº¹�T�V/aH[)GXWXx�[)R\WcFOYiv�Ð�T�dHFOY@xRUDSWcb9gSW½[Kb$h"^«�´b\T�T�N"b9R\F�D�[·aHTÂ[�N"FOVUT�b\T�VUWXFOQ@b�P@V\FHg pGXT�N£WXYWXRUb.bUT�Y@b\WXRUWXaCWcRed�R\F>PSVUFHgk[)g@WXGXWXRedwT�bUR\WcN�[)R\WcFOY�T�VUV\FHVUb·v� D�[KR´WXb$h2R\D@T�bUT�B�FOY@xÌRUT�V\N WXY�R\D@T¯J8FHV\NwQ@G¸[ � ¦GE/<�§ HGXFH] L�M ¦CE P <�§,I�GXFO] L�M ¦CE�§.N>[)¶OT�b4R\D@T2bUB�FOVUTwT��CRUV\T�N"TZGcd�b\T�Y pbUWXR\WcaOT�RUF2T�bUR\WcN�[)R\WcFOY"T�V\VUFOVUb4¢&DST�Y L�M ¦GE�§�WXb&Y@T$[KV&��T�VUFkv SFHV4R\D@T�FOVUT�R\WcB·[)G�WXYCRUT�V\T�bUR·hiWXR.Wcb�¢�FHV\RUD´[KY�[)GXdC��WXY@]"R\D@T2x@WºJ pJ8T�V\T�Y@B�T.g�TZRe¢�T�TZY"WXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHY.]�[KWcY2[)Y@x2NwQ@RUQk[)GCWXYCJ8FHV\N>[ pRUWXFOYivi�Uª B$[KY�g�T�P@V\F)aHT�YTZ¥�QSWcaH[KGXT�YCR�R\F��

Fw¦CE�§ H ��������� ���

� ����������

L�M ¦��5���§CGXFO] L�M ¦��5���§L�M ¦��§ L�M ¦���§

Page 8: 0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

� [)g@GXT l v�L�VUWXR\T�VUW¸[2[)Y@x�PkT�VeJ8FOVUN�[)Y@B�T�FKJiJ8T$[KRUQ@V\T_bUTZGcTZB�RUWXFHY�N/T�RUD@FCx@b&WXY/¶ �3� Õ�Ô�ÔiA@ ^�TZRUD@FCx ��  �Uª L�®4� ^«� � AJÁ[·aOFHV\WcYS]_B�FHN/N"FOY�R\T�VUN/b Ö Ö Ö � Ö � �Q@b\WXY@]wB$[)R\T�]HFOVUWXT�b � Ö Ö Ö �Q@b\WXY@]wRUT�V\N [Kg@bUTZY@B�T � Ö Ö � �PkT�VeJ;FHVUN�[)Y@BZT WXY/¶ �3� �OÔiÔiAS  TZ��BZT�GXGcTZY�R T��CB�TZGcGXT�YCR T��CB�T�GXGXT�YCR PkFCFHV FH¶

H��>�B�D

L M ¦GE/</>e§ � ¦GE/</>Á§ O��>�B�D

L M ¦ RE/</>8§ � ¦ RE /</>8§

� D@T�b\TÂJ;FHVUNwQSG½[Kb´b\D@F)¢ R\D�[)R¯WXYCJ8FHV\N>[KRUWXFHY�]C[)WXYÌWcb¯RUD@T¢�T�WX]HDCRUT�xw[·aHTZV�[)]OT&F)J�R\D@T&NwQ@R\Q�[)GOWcY�J8FHV\N>[)R\WXFHY � ¦CE�<�§=[KY@x� ¦SRE /<�§�h�¢&D@TZVUT±RUD@T±¢�TZWc]ODCRUb"[)V\T´R\D@T��EFOWXY�RwPSVUFHgk[)g@WXGXWXRUWXT�bL�M ¦GE/<�§&[KY@x L�M ¦SRE�<�§ZhCVUT�b\P�TZB�RUWXaHTZGcdCv�A�FwWcY�J8FHV\N>[)R\WXFHY2]�[)WXYWXb�[)GXbUF.B$[)GXGXT�x � !��@( � ��� �3� � � �D����&���(� � �$� ���@Î sZÏ v � D@TZVUT4[)V\TRe¢�F±J8Q@Y@x�[KN"T�YCRE[)G�x@Wº³ÊT�V\T�Y@B�TZb>gkT�Re¢�T�T�Y{�Uª [KY@xÂ^��Q� l §�Uª N>[K¶HT�b&[2Q@bUT2F)J�WXYCJ8FOVUN�[)RUWXFOY�[Kg�FOQ@R4R\T�VUN£[)g@b\T�Y@B�T2WXYRUDST4J;FHVUNÌFKJ � ¦ RE /<�§�hO¢&D@WXGXT ^��MWc]OY@FHV\T�b�bUQ@BED�WXYCJ8FHV\N>[KRUWXFHY *[)YSx n §��Uª£YSFHVUN�[)GXWX��T�b2RUD@T�NwQ@R\Q�[)GMWcY�J8FHV\N>[)R\WXFHYb\B�FHV\T�bQ@b\WcYS]9RUD@T��'FHWXYCRwP@VUFOg�[)g@WXGXWXRUWXT�b2¢&D@WXGXT«^«�wQ@bUT�b/RUD@TÀY@FHY pY@FOVUN>[KGXWc�ZT�xwbUB�FOVUT�b·v

� � Æ Å � � È4�CÉUÆ Å

� D@WXb_WXb_[)Y9T�aH[KGXQ�[)R\WcFOY´FKJ�J;T$[)R\Q@VUTwb\T�GXT�B�RUWXFOY�N"TZRUD@FCx@b�WXYx@WXN"TZY@bUWXFHYk[)GXWXRed_VUT�xSQ@B�RUWXFOY�J8FHV&R\T��CR&B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY[)R4[KGXGRUDSTwVUT�x@QSB�RUWXFHY9GXT�aOT�GXb�F)JÑ[K]H]HV\T�bUb\WXaHT�Y@TZbUb$h�J;VUFHN£QSbUWXY@]�RUD@TJ8Q@GXGwaOF�B·[)g@Q@G¸[KVUd�¦¸TZ��BZT�P@R�b\RUFOP�¢�FOVUx@bE§9[)b9R\D@T¯J8T$[)R\Q@VUTbUPk[)B�THhORUF.VUT�N/F)aCWcYS] �H�H¼ F)JkRUD@T�Q@Y@WX¥CQ@T�RUT�V\N"b$v¤°9T=J8FHQSY@x�Uª�[KY@xL�®4��N/FHb\R�TE³IT�B�R\WXaHT_WXY>[K]H]OVUT�b\bUWXaHT�RUTZVUN VUT�N/F)aH[)G¢&WXRUD@FOQ@R�GXFHbUWXY@]�B$[KRUT�]OFHV\Wc�·[)RUWXFOY¾[KB�B�Q@VE[)B�d9WXY±FHQ@V�T��CPkT�VUW pN"TZY�R\b�¢&WXR\D"¶ �\� [KY@xÔiÔiAS �v@�� ±R\D@VUT�b\D@FHGXx@WXY@]wWXbMJ8FHQSY@xB�FON"P�[KV�[)gSGcTMRUF4R\D@T&PkT�VeJ8FOVUN�[)Y@B�T�F)Jk�Uª¨[KY@x�L�®4��¢&WXRUD2Q@PRUF �HtO¼ R\T�VUN�V\T�N"F)aH[KGeh)¢&D@WXGXT � AwWXb�B�FON"P�[KV�[)gSGcT�¢&WXRUD/Q@PRUF mOt·pUÒHtH¼ R\T�VUNÌV\T�N"F)aH[KGÁvI^�QSRUQ�[KG@WXYCJ8FHV\N>[KRUWXFHY.D�[)b=WXYCJ8T pVUWXFOV4PkT�VeJ8FOVUN�[)Y@B�T�B�FON"P�[KVUT�x�R\F"RUDST�FORUD@T�V.N"T�R\D@FCx@b&x@Q@TRUF[�g@W¸[)b.JÁ[·aHFOVUWXY@]wVE[)VUT2RUTZVUN"b_[KY@x¾[�bUR\VUFHYS]>b\T�Y@b\WcR\WXa�WXRedRUFwPSVUFHgk[)g@WXGXWXRed�T�b\RUWXN>[KRUWXFHYwTZVUVUFOVUb·v°9Twx@WXbUBZF)aHT�V\T�x�RUD�[KR�R\D@T>�� �hi�Uª£[KY@x�L�®4��bUB�FOVUT�bwFKJ [RUTZVUN [)V\T´b\RUVUFOY@]HGXdÂBZFHVUV\T�G¸[)R\T�xih_V\T�aHT·[)GXWXY@],[¯P@V\T�aCWcFOQ@bUGXdQ@Y@¶CY@F)¢&Y2Je[)B�R&[)gkFHQ@R�RUDST4WXN"PkFHV\R�[)YSB�T&F)JiB�FON"N/FHY_R\T�VUN/bWXYÂRUTZ��R�B$[KRUT�]OFHV\Wc�·[)RUWXFOYiv � D@WXb�bUQ@]O]HT�b\RUbR\D�[)R�RUDk[)R>�� RUDSVUT�b\D@FHGXx@WXY@]¯Wcb/Y@FHR_�EQSbUR>[KY¨[)x�D@FCB¾[KP@P@VUFC[)BEDÂR\F�WXN pP@V\F)aHTwTEË"B�WXT�YSB�d¦8[Kb�WXR�D�[)b2gkT�T�Y,[KbUb\Q@N"T�x9WXY±RUD@T/GXWcR\T�V p[)R\Q@VUT2F)J�RUT��CR4B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOY¾[KY@xV\T�RUV\WcTZaH[)G¸§�hkg@Q@R�[wV\T�GXW p[)gSGcT�N"T$[KbUQ@V\T�J8FHV.bUT�GXT�R\WXY@]"WXYCJ8FOVUN�[)RUWXaOT&J8T$[KRUQ@V\T�b$v��eR�B$[KYgkTwQ@bUT�x9WXY@b\RUT$[Kx9F)J&�Uª�FOV_L�®4��¢&D@T�Y9R\D@TwB�FHN/P@Q@RE[)RUWXFOY¦¸¥CQ�[Kx@V�[KRUWXB$§�F)J4R\D@T�bUTÀN"T$[KbUQ@V\T�b�WXb2RUFCFT��CPkT�Y@b\WcaOTHv � D@T[·aH[)WXG¸[)gSWcGXWºRed_F)J�[_b\WcN/P@GXT&g@Q@R&TE³IT�B�R\WXaHT_N/T$[)Y@bMJ8FOVÑ[K]H]HV\T�b pbUWXaOT&J8T$[KRUQ@V\T4b\P�[)B�T�V\T�x@Q@B�R\WXFHY�N>[·d_b\WX]HY@Wº¹�B$[KYCRUGXd�T·[)bUT.RUD@T[)PSP@GXWcB·[)RUWXFOY"F)J�N/FHVUT�PkF)¢�TZVeJ8Q@G=[)Y@x�B�FON"P@QSR�[)R\WXFHY�[KGcGXd2WXY pRUTZY@bUWXaHT�GcT·[)VUYSWcYS]wN"T�R\D@FCx@b$hCb\Q@BED¾[Kb&Y@T�Q@VE[)GiYST�Re¢�FOVU¶Cb$hkR\FaHTZVUdwG¸[)V\]HT�RUT��CR�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[)R\WXFHYwP@V\FHg@GXT�N/b»¢&DSWcBED�[)VUT&FORUD pT�V\¢&Wcb\T_WXYCRUV�[KB�R�[Kg@GXTHv

�����I:,� � -;����<k�C79��:�

°9T9¢�FHQ@GXx�GXWX¶HT9RUF�RUD�[KY@¶���[KWcN/T¾L&[KVUgkFHY@TZGcGw[)YSx � [)GºJÐ�VUF)¢&Y¨[KR"L&^�` J8FHVwPkFHWXYCRUWXY@]±FHQSR"[)Y�WXN"P@GXT�N/T�YCR�[)R\WXFHYT�V\VUFHV�WXY�R\D@T&B�FON"P@Q@RE[)R\WcFOY_F)JIWXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHY�]C[)WXYihH[KY@x�PSVUF paCWXx@WXY@]RUDST"B�FOVUVUTZB�R"B�FCx@TOv9°9T>[KGcb\FGXWX¶HTwRUF±RUDk[)Y@¶ � FHN^�WXRUBED@TZGcG�[KY@x´DSWcb�N�[)BED@WXY@T�GXT$[)V\Y@WXY@]"]OVUFHQSP¾[KR L&^�` J8FOVRUDST"J;VUQ@WXReJ;Q@G�xSWcb\B�Q@b\bUWXFHY@bwR\D�[)R2B�G¸[)V\WºJ8d´R\D@T�x@TE¹�YSWcR\WXFHY@b2F)JWXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHYw]C[)WXY>[KY@xNwQ@R\Q�[)GkWXYCJ8FOVUN>[KRUWXFHYwWXY�RUDST_GXWcR\T�V p[)R\Q@VUTOv

� � � iÅ � �

Î l'Ï L�v j P@R\THh_ �v&� [KN"T�VE[)Qih.[)Y@x¨A¤v&°9T�WXbUb·v � F)¢&[)V\x@bG¸[)Y@]OQ�[)]OT&WXY@x@T�PkT�Y@x@TZY�R4[KQ@RUFON>[KRUT�xwGXT$[KVUY@WXY@]_FKJiRUT��CRB$[KRUT�]OFHVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY�N/F�xST�GXb$vI�eY�(:�� ���� ��� � � � �)&H���#����������H����� � �������������! "�$# �����&���(:���� ��$h l$�H�K� v

Î nqÏ&% T�Y@Y@TZRUD°�[KVUx"L�DCQ@VUBED[)YSx f [)R\VUWXBE¶w® [)YS¶�b·vi°9FOVUx[)b\bUFCB�W¸[)R\WXFHY9Y@FOVUN"b·hiNwQSRUQ�[KG»WXYCJ;FHVUN�[)R\WcFOY[)Y@x9GXT��CW pB�FO]HV�[KP@DCd�vC�eY'()�@ ���� ��� � � � �:&(����)+*,��hKP�[)]OT�b sHÒ.-��Oo h� [KY@B�FHQSaHT�V·h�L&[)Yk[)x�[Sh l$�H�O� v

Î oqÏ °ÂWXGXGXW½[KN²° vÊL�FOD@T�Y9[)Y@x Ö FOV�[)N A�WcYS]HT�V·v�L�FOYCRUT��CR pbUTZY@bUWXRUWXaOT�GXT$[KVUY@WXY@]wN/T�RUFCx@b�J8FOV&RUT��CR�B$[KRUT�]OFHVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY�v�eY����� /�0#21 35456"(:�� ����7��� � � � �:& ���#�8�93������H����� � �:����%���@(�� � ��� ��� � �,�����;���� /�0#<�`����&B�@()�@�� ��V����#�B��� � (: �� ����=��@!���� ���;,����� � ������&���(� � �$� ���'#�@��(�� ��! � �ch l$�O�HÒ voHtOs·pUo@l·m v

Î �KÏ!� v ®2v@L�VUT�T�BZd�hSÐ v ^9v@^[Kb�[KY@xih@AIv ��v@A�N"WXRUDihO[)Y@x���v ÔMv°�[)GXR\�Hv � VE[)x@WXY@]wN/WXP@bÑ[KY@xN/T�N"FOVUd�J8FHV&¶CY@F)¢&GXT�x@]OTT�Y@]OWXY@T�T�V\WcYS]���B�G¸[)bUb\WºJ8dCWcYS]�B�TZY@bUQ@bMVUT�R\Q@VUY@b=FOY_RUD@TMB�FHY pY@T�BZRUWXFHYN�[)BED@WXY@THv>�`� 8?������±h oOm � ���.-�ÒHo h l$�O�Hn v

Î mqÏ AIvi�.T�TZVU¢�T�bUR\T�V$h�AIv � vi�.Q@N>[KWcb·h�ªwv °�vI SQ@VUYk[)b$h � v % vÔi[KY@x�[KQ@T�V$hI[KY@x � vS® [KVUbUDSN>[)Y�v��eY@x@TZ��WXY@]/gCd"G¸[)R\T�YCRbUTZN>[)YCR\WcB�[)Y�[KGXd�b\WXb$v±�eYA@B� ,��('�D�� �����&��D @�C�.D84HhP�[K]HT�b oH�@lE-��CtHs h l$�H�Ot v

Î ÒqÏ � v 7 vi�.Q@Y@YSWcYS]�v j B�B�Q@VE[)R\T"N"TZRUD@FCx@b J8FHV�RUDSTwbUR�[KRUWXb pRUWXB�b=FKJ�bUQ@V\P@VUWXb\T4[)Y@x_BZFHWXY@B�WXx@T�YSB�THvC�eYB�`� � ��� � �$����� � �)`��� � ��� ����� B�'hCaOFHGXQ@N/T l$� � l hCP�[)]OT�b Ò@lE-�s)� h l·�H�Oo v

Î sqÏ!� v� k[)Y@FkvGF^( � ���)V� ���������?�:&H����&���(� � �$� ���@v¡^�� �f V\T�bUb·hÊL&[KNwg@VUWXx@]OTHhC^ j h l$�HÒSl v

Î �qÏ[� v� @Q@DSV$hiAIv¤® [)V\RUN�[)Y@Y�[ShIªwvIÔIQ@b\RUWX]�hi^ vÊA�B�DC¢&[)YCR pY@T�V·h�[)Y@x % v � ��T�VE[)b$v j WXV>�K� p [«VUQ@GXT p g�[)b\T�x9NwQ@GXRUW pbURE[)]OT WXY@xST��CWcYS]_bUdCbUR\T�N"bMJ8FOV�G¸[)VU]OT4b\Q@gH�ET�B�R�¹kT�GXx@b$v��eYÒHtOÒ·pUÒHnOo hOT�x@WXRUFOV$hI (:�� ���� ����� �R�H�:&J#K�0��L'1 3M�Kh l$�O�@l v

Page 9: 0 122 $34 $courses.ischool.berkeley.edu/i256/f06/papers/yang97...0 122 $34 $ ... RUDST \

Î �qÏ °�vk®4TZVUbUD�h»L�vkÐ�Q@BE¶�GXT�dCh � v ��vIÔ¤T�FHY@TOh»[KY@x´�2vk®4WXBE¶ pN>[KYiv?�.D@bUQ@N/T�x��9[)Y�WcYCR\T�V�[KB�RUWXaHTÀVUT�R\VUWXT�aH[)G�T�aH[KGXQ p[)R\WXFHY�[)YSx9Y@T�¢ÌG¸[)VU]OTwRUT��CR2B�FHGXGXT�B�R\WXFHY±J8FOV_VUT�b\T$[)V\BEDiv�eY ������� �H�#� �����(�����;���! "�$# �`����&B�@()�@�� ��E��� #�B%��� � (: � � ���C=Y��!@��� � � V�@���K� �'����&���(� � �$� ���'#�@��(�� ��! � �� ���! "�0#�1 3����KhkP�[K]HT�b l·�Hn.-�nHtSl h l·�H�K� v

Î l$tqÏ �2v % FOGXGcTZV»[)YSx�^9v)A@[)Dk[)N"Wev � F)¢Ñ[KVUx�FHPSRUWXN>[KG·J8T$[)R\Q@VUTbUTZGcTZB�RUWXFHY�v&�eY (:�� ���� ��� � � �,�:&Y����� F:�#� (������@���������#�$��(�%� � �$� ��� � � �`����&���(:���� ��Y����� � ��� ���C)-� � (��#� � �Oh l$�H�OÒ v

Î lHl'Ï&% vHÔi[KY@]�v � TZ¢&bU¢�T�T�x@T�V*��Ô¤T$[)V\Y@WXY@]�RUF.¹�GXRUT�V=Y@TZRUY@T�¢&b·v�eY (:�� ���� ��� � � �,�:&V���#� F��`��� &����������$��(�� � �$����� � � �`����%&���(:���� ��,��� � � ��� �#�C) � � (B��� � �Oh l·�H�Hm v

Î l$nqÏ ��[·aCWcx{��v�ÔIT�¢&WXb·h � FHgkT�VUR 7 v&ACBED�[KP@WXVUTHhK��[KN"T�b f vL&[)GXG¸[)Y�h�[)YSx � FHY f [)PS¶H[@v � VE[)WXY@WXY@]"[KGc]OFHV\WcR\D@N"bMJ8FOVGXWXY@T$[)V�R\T��CR´B�G¸[KbUbUWº¹�TZVUb$v �eY ���! "�$# 1 354 6A()�@ ���� �R%� � � � �:& ����� � 3���� �H����� � �K�������@(B� � ��� ��� � �/����� ���:% "�$# �`����&���(:���� ��H���8# ����� � () 7� � ���C=Y��!��)� ��� V�����6� ����B&���() � ��� ��� #���$(����@! � �Xh l$�H�OÒ v nH�O�·pUoHtHÒ v

Î l$oqÏ �2v ��v&Ô¤T�¢&WXb«[KY@x�^9v � WXY@]HQST�RUR\THv£L�FHN"Pk[)VUWXb\FHY�F)JRe¢�F�GXT$[)V\Y@WXY@]�[)GX]OFHVUWXR\D@N"b�J8FHV/RUT��CR�B$[KRUT�]OFHVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY�v�eYA()�@ ���� ��� ���R�"�)& ����� F:����( � �H����� � �&���"9���R��� ����'=��@ �,����� �H� � ������ � � ��������&���(� � �$� ���'#�@��(�� ��! � �� �M= � �0#�1 3����Hh l·�H�K� v

Î l��KÏ � FHN ^�WXR\B�DST�GXGÁvC� � 7�#� ���8)-� � (��#� � �Ov�^�B$L�VE[·¢�®.WcGXGehl$�O�HÒ v

Î l$mqÏ ��v�^�FHQ@GXWXY@WXT�V·v �ebGXT$[KVUY@WXY@]�g@W¸[)b´[KY�Wcb\bUQ@T9FOY�RUD@TRUTZ��RÀB$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[)R\WXFHYÂP@V\FHg@GXT�N1� �eY F^�� ����� � � ()��%����(�� D�)���>L(#K�$�H% ) �$ 4 D � �#� !@��(���� ��� � (�� ���:�EhCP�[)]OT¦¸R\F"[)P@PkT$[KV�§�h l$�O�Hs v

Î l$ÒqÏ ��vI^�FHQSGcWXY@WXT�V·h�ªwv � [KbU¶CWXY@WXb$h@[)YSx ��vIª_[KY�[)b\B�W¸[@v � T��CRB$[KRUT�]OFHVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY���[2bUdCNwgkFHGXWXB4[)P@PSVUF�[KBEDiv��eY ()�@ ���� �R%� � � ��:&������ � &���� �H����� � ����" � � ��� � ���C=��@ �,������H� � ������� � � ��������&���(� � �$� ���'#�@��(�� ��! � �ch l·�H�OÒ v

Î l$sqÏ ��v � v��4QSWcYSG½[KYiv±�eY@x@Q@BZRUWXFHY�F)J4xST�B�WXbUWXFHY�R\VUT�T�b·v � � % ��� ���C)-� � (��#� � �Oh l ¦ l §Q� �@lE-Êl·tHÒ h l$�H�OÒ v

Î l$�qÏ ªwv"AS[)GXRUFOYiv � ����� � ��� F^����� (:�� ��B����� � � 6 F:���F^( � ��� &���() � ��� ��� DI�H� � ������ � D � ���C#�@��(�� ��! � �D�)&"����&���(�% � ��� �������B�`� � �����@(Zv j x@x@WXbUFOY p °9T�bUGXT�dCh � T·[)x@WXY@]khf T�Y@Y@b\dCGcaH[KY@W¸[@h l·�H�H� v

Î l$�qÏ ®�v.ACBED��Q@RU�ZTHhw��v j v�®.Q@GXGeh [KY@x���vW�2v f T�x@T�V\bUT�Y�v jB�FON"P�[KVUWXbUFOY"F)J�B�G¸[KbUbUWº¹�TZVUb_[)Y@xÀx@FCB�Q@N"TZY�R&V\T�P@V\T�bUT�Y pR�[KRUWXFHYSb�J8FHVÀRUD@T9V\FHQ@R\WcYS]ÂP@VUFOg@GXT�N´v �eY ���3��� �H������#�,����� ���� /�0# �`����&���(:���� �� ����# ����� � () 7� � ���C=Y�B%!��)� ��� V�����,��� ����&���() � �$����� # �@��(�� ��! � � � ���! "�$#�1 3����HhP�[K]HT�b nHnH�.-�nOoHs h l$�H�Om v

Î nHtqÏ&% v � ��T�VE[)b�[KY@x9AIvk® [)V\RUN�[)Yiv j Q@RUFON>[)R\WXB_WXY@x@T��CWXY@]g�[KbUT�x{FHYÂgk[·dHT�b\W½[KYÂWXYCJ8T�V\T�Y@B�T9YST�Re¢�FOVU¶Cb$v �eYA()�@ �94������H�#�����#� ����� ���! "�$# �`����&B�@()�@�� �� ����#�B%��� � (: � � ���C=Y��!@��� � � V�@���K� �'����&���(� � �$� ���'#�@��(�� ��! � �� ���! "�0#�1 3����KhkP�[K]HT�b nOn�-@o)� h l$�O�Ho v

Î n@l'Ï 7 v�°ÂWXT�Y@T�V·h'��vW�2v f T�x@TZVUbUTZYih[)Y@x j v A¤v�°9T�WX]HT�Y@x�vj YST�Q@V�[KG�Y@T�Re¢�FHVU¶�[KP@P@VUFC[)BED�R\F�RUFOP@WXB�bUPkFHRUR\WXY@]�v�eY ()�@ ���� ��� � � �E�:&E����� -� ��(����B�H����� � �(���"9���R��� �

���'=��@ �,����� �H� � ������ � � ��������&���(� � �$� ���'#�@��(�� ��! � �� �M= � �0#�1 3��!�Hh l·�H�Om v

Î nHnqÏ ��v °�v.°ÂWXGXg@Q@V[)YSx % v�ACWXVUFORU¶CWXYiv � D@T,[KQ@RUFON>[)R\WXBWXx@T�YCRUWº¹�B·[)RUWXFOY_F)J�b\RUFOP�¢�FHV\x@b$v:@ ?�����& ?�^ @� ?©h l$� � �Cm�-@mHm hl$�O�Hn v

Î nHoqÏ4Ö v Ö [KY@]�v 7 �CP�TZVUR�Y@T�Re¢�FHV\¶ � 7 ³IT�B�R\WXaHTw[)Y@x�TEË"B�WXT�YCRGXT$[)V\Y@WXY@]�J8V\FHNÌDCQ@N>[KY_x@T�BZWcb\WXFHY@b�WXYwRUT��CR�B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[ pRUWXFOY [KY@x�VUT�R\VUWXT�aH[KGÁv �eY ������� �H��� ����������� ���:% "�$# �`����&���(:���� ��H���8# ����� � () 7� � ���C=Y��!��)� ��� V�����6� ����B&���() � ��� ��� #���$(����@! � � � ���� /�0#�1 3����Hh�Pk[)]HTZb l$o.-�nOn hl$�O�)� v

Î n)�KÏ4Ö v Ö [)Y@]kv � FHWXbUT�V\T�x@Q@B�R\WXFHYÌWXY�[Âb\R�[)R\WXbURUWXB$[KG"[)P pP@V\F�[)BED¯RUFR\T��CR_B$[)R\T�]HFOVUWX�$[KRUWXFHYiv��eY (:�� ���� ����� �R� �)&�����8���3���'�H���������:����� ���� /�0#<�`����&B�@()�@�� ��H���'#�B%��� � (: � � ���C=Y��!@��� � � V�@���K� �'����&���(� � �$� ���'#�@��(�� ��! � �� ���! "�0#�1 3��!�KhkP�[K]HT�b nOmHÒ.-�nHÒOo h l·�H�Om v

Î nHmqÏ4Ö v Ö [)Y@]kv�A@[)N/P@GXWXY@]�bURUVE[)R\T�]HWXT�b�[)Y@x¯GcT·[)VUYSWcYS]´TEË pB�WXT�Y@BZd¨WXYÂR\T��CR>B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOYivÌ�eYA�K�J� ���"� (�� � ����" � � ��� �1����� � 7�#� ���C)-� � (������ � � ������&���(� � �$� ���� � ��B���'hCPk[)]HTZb �H�.-��Om h l$�H�OÒ v

Î nHÒqÏ4Ö v Ö [)YS]�v j Y�T�aH[KGXQ�[)R\WcFOY�FKJ bURE[)R\Wcb\RUWXB$[KG [)PSP@VUFC[)BEDRUF¿R\T��CRÍB·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOYiv �eY F^�� ���#� � �+# � ����(�����"� % � ��% 3��%7�.*,� D �`��9�;�3����("�D @���@�� �� =Y� � � (�� ,����� D� � (B��� ��� � � �)� � ���#� ��� !���(���� �$�)h l·�H�Os v

Î nHsqÏ4Ö v Ö [)Y@]�[)Y@xÌL�v ªwv L�DCQ@R\THv j YÍTZ��[KN"P@GXT p g�[KbUT�xN>[KP@P@WXY@]/N"T�R\D@FCx±J8FHV_R\T��CR�B·[)RUTZ]HFHV\WX�$[)R\WcFOY�[)Y@x9V\T pRUV\WXT�aH[)GevA����� F^( � ��� � ��$����� ��� ����&���(� � �$� ��� ������%��� �� � F"L"� ���HhCP�[)]OT�b nHmOo�-�nOsHs h l·�H�)� v

Î nH�qÏ4Ö v Ö [)Y@]�[)Y@x2°�v ��vK°ÂWXGcgSQ@V$vO`4b\WcYS] BZFHVUPSQ@b�bURE[)R\Wcb\RUWXB�bRUF.VUT�N/F)aHT�V\T�x@Q@YSx�[)YCR=¢�FOVUx@b�WXY_RUT��CR=B$[KRUT�]OFHVUWX�$[KRUWXFHY�v�eY @'� ,��(K�D�@ ���B& �D ��¸h l·�H�HÒ v